General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Tomb of the Unknown Soldier was guarded by an all-woman team for the first time ever
Link to tweet
MLAA
(19,745 posts)James48
(5,215 posts)Since the military began collecting DNA samples of every enlistee in the 1990s, if there is now a remain, it will be able to be identified. Thats why there isnt an unknown from Iraq or Afghanistan, or any other battle since Vietnam.
Angleae
(4,801 posts)TFRD
(205 posts)Demovictory9
(37,113 posts)Rhiannon12866
(255,567 posts)I've witnessed the changing of the guard at the Tomb of the Unknown and it's very solemn and moving. And it's long past time that our female service members were allowed to participate.
brer cat
(27,588 posts)I have witnessed it also, and it always brought tears. The gender of the guards should not be an issue.
3catwoman3
(29,406 posts)of the all female retinue.
James48
(5,215 posts)That is them.
3catwoman3
(29,406 posts)
in appearance, IMO.
(No tomatoes or rocks, please)
WhiskeyGrinder
(26,956 posts)Withywindle
(9,989 posts)Seriously, what was the point of this?
obamanut2012
(29,369 posts)Rhiannon12866
(255,567 posts)And I've actually seen the guards at the tomb in person.
3catwoman3
(29,406 posts)
appreciate you being willing to say so here. I truly thought it was an old picture from the all male days.
My observation was not intended critically, and I attempted to word it as neutrally as possible, but, of course, some did not see it that way.
Rhiannon12866
(255,567 posts)And like I said, I've been there and seen them. But I have to say it's long past time that female service members got the honor of participating. It's been far too long.
WhiskeyGrinder
(26,956 posts)It feels a little weird to say "it doesn't matter" about a photo with a news article touting the first all-female team, but whatever you think about how they look truly does not matter and is something better kept to yourself.
melm00se
(5,161 posts)meant to look like, well, guards.
IIRC, there are very specific physical requirements (height, weight, inseam length and the like) so of course they are going to look like every other 3rd US Infantry Regiment guard.
druidity33
(6,915 posts)really has a shitload of medals. Nonee of which i can identify, but it looks like a lot.
Aristus
(72,188 posts)She's a Sergeant First Class.
Her top row of medals include, from left to right, the Army Commendation Medal, the National Defense Service Medal, and the Meritorious Service Medal.
druidity33
(6,915 posts)when i looked up NCO it says it stands for Non Commissioned Officer. So i'm not sure i understand you... unless you mean she's a "Numerically Controlled Oscillator" or a "National Cyber Olympiad".
Aristus
(72,188 posts)in a country's armed forces, and is empowered with command, and the issuing of direct orders.
A Non-Commissioned Officer, especially in the United States Armed Forces, is a lower-level leader, squad, platoon, and company, in charge of training, day-to-day discipline and morale. An NCO will tell you emphatically that he or she is not an 'officer', meaning a commissioned officer, and will often follow that by saying "I work for a living!", implying, somewhat unjustly, that an officer's commission is a prestige position and carries with it very little responsibility. The U.S. Army NCO Corps proudly boasts its non-commissioned status, and thinks of themselves as the backbone of the professional armed forces.
I earned the (admittedly low-level) rank of Sergeant when I was in the Army. Nowhere near being a commissioned officer.
The Guards at the Tomb of the Unknowns at Arlington are all entirely non-commissioned officers. Only the Sergeant of the Guard wears rank insignia, however. The actual Guards walking the post at the Tomb never wear rank insignia, so as not to outrank the honored dead.
druidity33
(6,915 posts)to non-military people. If you were wanting to distinguish between the two, maybe you should have said she's a non-commissioned officer and told me the difference? Because to be honest, to me, if it's in your title, that's what you are. And NCO clearly has officer in the acronym. I work in a grocery store. The Maintenance Manager is a manager as much as the Store Manager is. It's just that one reports to the other.
Aristus
(72,188 posts)And that distinction is what I was referring to from the beginning...
druidity33
(6,915 posts)Military Intelligence? Because Calling someone an Officer and then saying "But they're not an officer!" is just plain stupid if you ask me. How many people in this country have served or would know the distinction you refer to? My guess is less than 10%. Why did you choose to correct me when, like i said, it is a meaningless distinction unless you're in the military? I guess it's nice to learn something new though, so thanks for that...
JustABozoOnThisBus
(24,681 posts)... they look like a Bronze Star and a Meritorious Service Medal. And they're sitting under what looks like a Combat Infantryman Badge.
I'm guessing she has earned the honor of guarding the Tomb of the Unknowns, and recognizes what an honor and solemn duty it is. I'm also guessing she is counting the days until she can get back into a unit that's more mud and dust and less spit-shine and creases. I don't think I met anyone who truly enjoys guard duty.
Aristus
(72,188 posts)take immense pride in their duty, and do not consider it a distraction from combat training. In fact, all Guards must maintain full combat duty qualification while serving their tours as Guards.
In fact, a soldiers status as a Guard at the Tomb of the Unknowns can be rescinded, not only after their tours at the Tomb, but also after they have returned to civilian life, if their personal conduct in any way brings dishonor to the Guard Corps.
TomSlick
(13,014 posts)The SFC is a combat veteran and has earned the honor of being a tomb guard.
Kid Berwyn
(24,399 posts)One medal looks like a Bronze Star, awarded for gallantry in combat.

TomSlick
(13,014 posts)If the award is for valor, it has a "V" device on the ribbon. I can't tell if the SFC's Bronze Star has a "V" device. Either way, she also has the Combat Action Badge, so she's seen combat.
have been in for a minimum of 15 years (a friend of mine just retired as one after 26 years) so many of them have been there and done that.