General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsF Brian Williams
So maybe you heard Brian Williams's signoff the other day, but if you didn't, then it's posted below. But I say fuck you Brian Williams because the ambiguity of his statement has allowed both sides to claim he was speaking of them, or was condemning the "other side" with a stark and scary warning. Honestly, Brian, this is no time for subtlety. Trumpy members of my own family have taken his words to mean the Biden administration is trying to burn things down from the inside. I am so pissed.
Ocelot II
(130,536 posts)where he stands on Trump and the general state of things. I don't know how anyone could interpret his comments as ambiguous in the slightest - just because he didn't scream and use swear words?
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)I am not lying when I say that members of my family have taken his words to be a warning against the current administration. So it's fine for you to say that you didn't misinterpret his comments, but you probably haven't been living in the twisted world of QAnon for the last five years. All I'm saying is NO MORE AMBIGUITY.
PTWB
(4,131 posts)Crazy people are going to hear what they want to hear.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)he didn't name names or point fingers. Now some may say that shows professionalism, class or elegance. But this is not the time for even the slightest ambiguity.
PTWB
(4,131 posts)We all know exactly what he was saying, what he was talking about, and who he was talking about. The only people pretending they don't are the conspiracy theorists whose brains have turned to mush after years of cognitive dissonance. Nothing he could have said would have reached them. They're lost to reality .
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)who are killing democracy -- and people -- with their insanity. All I'm asking is that when public speakers speak out, they do so in a way that leaves no room for misinterpretation.
PTWB
(4,131 posts)oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)did you hear me?
PTWB
(4,131 posts)It seems like the issue here is not that Brian Williams was ambiguous but that crazy conspiracy theorists are crazy.
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)But many of these eejits believe the virus is a hoax.
XanaDUer2
(15,772 posts)Of Willy Wonka with whatever words fit the narrative of one side or the other.
Casady1
(2,133 posts)I thought it was really well done. I am going to miss him. Utterly professional.
Raine
(31,179 posts)Response to oldtime dfl_er (Original post)
Chin music This message was self-deleted by its author.
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Haggard Celine
(17,821 posts)to rule the USA at the side of Trump. Their judgement is suspect, to say the least. BW wasn't being ambiguous. If you watch him, you have no doubts about where he stands.
skylucy
(4,024 posts)will always deny reality. That's not Mr. Williams' fault.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)Because he began by saying "I'm not a Democrat or a Republican". I say NO MORE AMBIGUITY, NUANCE or SUBTLETY.
iemanja
(57,757 posts)Because you don't seem to have many agreeing with you.
ETA: Sorry, meant to reply to your other post. However, it's not his job to be a Democratic booster. You shouldn't be looking to journalists for that.
SharonClark
(10,497 posts)He said he was neither a liberal nor a conservative, hes a institutionalist. If youre going to attack someone, at least quote them correctly.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts).
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Naw, thats the other side that gets by on lying all the time.
Im still gobsmacked any trumpers would be watching MSNBC. Do they watch Maddow too?
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts).
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Are you being serious here?
You post an OP saying F Brian Williams, a media figure that many of us here respect, and dont expect pushback?
I simply said I cant believe your trumpian relatives watch MSNBC.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)"So you want him to lie about his political beliefs?"
No, I did not say that.
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)The only attacking here is your implied obscenity toward a figure many of us respect.
We heard his warning. We hope many did and that all will head it.
You have a good night now.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)I am actually quite distraught over this, and nobody seems to agree with me. I suppose I could just shut up and go away but I can't.
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Dont take it personally.
Were all on the same side.
2naSalit
(102,793 posts)I didn't interpret it that way at all.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)but many do.
Tommymac
(7,334 posts)Links, other web sites, tweets, etc.
Don't make blanket statements without proof or they are just opinion. Basic debating 101.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)I'm not the enemy here. I'm merely asking for clarity from people who have a platform to speak.
Raine
(31,179 posts)Bayard
(29,693 posts)The whole evening lineup is definitely pro-Dem.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)I am only saying that some Trumpers -- some that I KNOW PERSONALLY -- are interpreting his statement as a warning against the current administration. Sure, they're crazy. They think crazy things. They DO crazy things. And that is exactly WHY a person who has a platform must speak clearly and without ambiguity. I'm getting pilloried here for thinking this, but I think it nonetheless. Why be ambiguous? Why not SAY EXACTLY WHAT YOU MEAN, when the times are as crazy as they are.
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)I dont even see how you can think that.
As far as trumpers thinking that, well we know theyre not known for their great thinking skills.
niyad
(132,440 posts)WHO is attacking the school boards. Hint: it is NOT liberals, Antifa(scists) or BLM, but the insane reichwingnutjobs.
Brian was VERY clear.
2 Meow Momma
(6,876 posts)His sharp wit was always aimed at repubs ridiculousness.
Your trumpy relatives obviously didnt watch the show and are spinning the comments from a world in which the sky is not blue.
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Even his words went over their heads, at least theyre watching.
There was nothing ambiguous about what he said. Nothing.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)They don't watch MSNBC. This tiny snippet made the rounds and got picked up by some of them who know nothing of the man. Their interpretation is OUT OF CONTEXT and INSANE. That's the point I am laboring to make. IF THERE IS AN IOTA OF AMBIGUITY THEY WILL MISINTERPRET. There was nothing ambiguous in what he said IF YOU HAVE WATCHED HIM REGULARLY. THEY DO NOT.
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Williams warning was not for them.
oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)They have guns. These are the people who are gearing up to take away democracy. They will use every tool at their disposal. We need to be awake. We should all care.
oasis
(53,693 posts)oldtime dfl_er
(7,176 posts)I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did. I didn't say they did.