General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsStop calling it "The Ukraine"
The country is called "Ukraine," not "the Ukraine"
Thanks
themaguffin
(5,003 posts)USALiberal
(10,877 posts)multigraincracker
(37,184 posts)Here we go to the hospital, in England they go to hospital.
Ocelot II
(129,743 posts)multigraincracker
(37,184 posts)the Russia.
Thanks.
Cha
(317,730 posts)Ms. Toad
(38,410 posts)We're traveling to the UK, the United States, the Ukraine, etc. It just sounds weird without "the," in the same way "going to hospital" sounds weird to me.
TheBlackAdder
(29,981 posts)bucolic_frolic
(54,498 posts)SoonerPride
(12,286 posts)Also you are not the boss of me
USALiberal
(10,877 posts)W_HAMILTON
(10,240 posts)Because calling it "the Ukraine" is doing just that.
Oneironaut
(6,246 posts)Ukraine is a country rather than a region, so, the Ukraine sounds a bit wrong.
We go to The Caribbean. We dont go to The Cuba. However, there are exceptions, such as The Dominican Republic. Also, we use The United States. I am going to United States sounds weird (probably because states is plural). English is weird.
lagomorph777
(30,613 posts)He uses language the way Reptilians do in the US, to manipulate and frame the discussion.
When we call it "the Ukraine" we are tacitly implying that it's just a region, not a nation, and we're helping Putin.
Ocelot II
(129,743 posts)It is no longer a region; it's a country. "The Ukraine" is basically Russian propaganda.
TheRealNorth
(9,647 posts)Failing to mention Russian involvement in Ukraine goes back much farther then the USSR (or is it just "USSR"
. Ukraine had been part of Tsarist Russia for at least 200 years prior to the Bolsheviks, and had been fought over and been divided between Russia, the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, the Ottoman Empire, and the Crimean Khanate and the Golden Horde for the past 700 years.
In some ways, Ukraine is similar to Yugoslavia and some of the other countries that were created at the end of WW I. Only except that it's independence was short-lived.
While I think we need to defend Ukraine against Russia, it kind of pisses me off that people refuse to acknowledge that had we not supported a coup in Ukraine, we probably wouldn't be in this mess.
mathematic
(1,605 posts)I can't wait to see it spread throughout the internet.
What next, deny that Greeks are a people because they were part of Rome then Byzantium then the Ottoman Empire?
DFW
(59,877 posts)Or to The Hague, once they make it there.
PoliticAverse
(26,366 posts)Why do some country names have 'the'?
http://bbc.com/news/magazine-18233844
Polybius
(21,634 posts)Is it wrong to just say Bronx?
PoliticAverse
(26,366 posts)Like:
Bronx Borough President
I'm going to Queens.
I'm going to Manhattan.
I'm going to Brooklyn
I'm going to Staten Island
I'm going to the Bronx.
Adjective:
I went to a new Bronx restaurant.
Noun:
I went to a new restaurant in the Bronx.
Polybius
(21,634 posts)Why isn't it ever Im going to The Staten Island?
PoliticAverse
(26,366 posts)NYC rivers have 'the'.
The Harlem river.
The East River.
The Hudson river.
Why is it called "The Bronx'...
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/other/why-is-it-called-the-bronx-instead-of-just-bronx/ar-AAQcwuY
Sneederbunk
(17,353 posts)BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Ive pointed that out a number of times, and it seems many prefer to use Putins terminology.
SharonClark
(10,497 posts)Why is Ukraine called the Ukraine?
It was used for the middle Dnieper territory controlled by the Cossacks. The people of Ukraina were called Ukrainians (українці, ukrayintsi, or українники, ukrayinnyky). Later, the term Ukraine was used for the Hetmanate lands on both sides of the Dnieper although it didn't become the official name of the state.
I graduated university in 1975 with a minor in Russian History and language. It took me a while to drop the "the" after 1991.
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Very odd.
Wounded Bear
(63,986 posts)Think of it that way. Ukrainians think of it as an insult. So do Russians.
msfiddlestix
(8,170 posts)I haven't heard that reference. Guess cuz I don't watch Cable News?
BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Putin and trump say it that way too.
Makes me wonder about those here who somehow cant wrap their head around the correct appellation.
msfiddlestix
(8,170 posts)I do know that I've mispronounced Kyiv (not Kiev)... because our media taught me incorrectly. Now having learned from actual Ukrainian, how we've pronounced and spelled the name was from Russian linguistic orientation.
But I've missed "THE Ukraine" .... seems quite Putinesque.
Paladin
(32,354 posts)I'm hanging tough on the pronunciation of "Kiev, " however. It remains "Kee-EHEV," rather than "Keev." I first heard Mussorgsky's "Great Great Gate At Kiev" over 60 years ago, from his marvelous "Pictures At An Exhibition." It remains one of my favorite pieces of classical music, and I'm sticking with the pronunciation of the city as I originally heard it. Subject to future political developments.
RobinA
(10,476 posts)I never heard of Keev until this current situation. I have always heard Kee-ehev and have always used that, thinking it was correct. I didnt even realize what Keev was until about the third time I heard it.
Jeesh, Im barely recovered from learning to say Omicron instead of Omnicron.
Paladin
(32,354 posts)If Ukraine becomes our next Vietnam, I may have to re-evaluate things.
Raine
(31,121 posts)the History of Russia and the USSR and the teacher stressed pronouncing Russian names correctly. Kiev was pronounced Kee-ehev, he was very exacting about it. That was Russian though so I see Ukrainian's have a different spelling and pronunciation.
Tommy Carcetti
(44,449 posts)When I visited in 2019, I remember the first thing our local tour guide said to us: "Welcome to Keev!"
However, some of my relatives have an alternate pronunciation, which is rather unorthodox (no pun intended). It's more akin to "Key-you" and dispenses with the "v" sound altogether.
Also, as to the city of Lviv in the west of Ukraine, it's not "La-viv" as you might think, but more like "Le-view."
Kharkiv in the east has a silent "K" and is "Hark-you."
msfiddlestix
(8,170 posts)Ukrainian language preferred when it comes to the spelling and pronunciation :
Kyiv spelling (not Kiev) pronounced Keeve.
Link:
KyivNotKiev
sarisataka
(22,359 posts)In 1993 the Ukrainian government explicitly requested that, in linguistic agreement with countries and not regions,[34] the Russian preposition в be used instead of на,[35] and in 2012 the Ukrainian embassy in London further clarified that it is politically and grammatically incorrect to use a definite article with Ukraine.[1] Use of Ukraine without the definite article has since become commonplace in journalism and diplomacy
Putin continues to refer to it as "the" Ukraine as a reminder that he does not consider Ukraine a "real country". He is indicating it is a region of Russia.
cachukis
(3,751 posts)insisted he was Ukraine, not Ukranian. That was imposed, again, as a pejorative.
He was my cousin's beau, and exhibited tremendous pride in his heritage, especially free from the SSR delineation.
Coventina
(29,442 posts)BlackSkimmer
(51,308 posts)Strange, but there it is.
Firestorm49
(4,519 posts)ColinC
(11,098 posts)NightWatcher
(39,376 posts)Stinky The Clown
(68,939 posts)The Revolution
(885 posts)don't even have definite articles as far as I know. So it's an issue of what the country is called in a non-native language.
I wonder if there are any languages that require definite articles for country names. I know Spanish uses them in places we don't in English (el Señor Garcia, for example).
I've always wondered why languages often call countries by different names than the natives do. We say Germany (from Latin Germania) instead of Deutschland, but English is a Germanic language and its own country of origin is called 'England', which obviously got its name the same way 'Deutschland' did
DFW
(59,877 posts)No one can know what is "correct" or not because Slavic languages DON'T HAVE ARTICLES. In most cases, translators are left to figure from context. In German, for example MANY countries are named with a definite article. Turkey is "Die Türkei," Switzerland is "Die Schweiz," and the Czech republic is "Die Tschechei." Not to mention "Die Ukraine," which is used by our resident Ukrainian friend when he discusses his homeland with my wife (his German is excellent). French goes even further with Le Luxembourg, L'Espagne, l'Allemagne, La Russie, le Finlande, etc etc (not to mention La France).
The very name means "out of (У
the edge (of the national territory)," the edge (Край
being the Russian border. Україна in Ukrainian, Украина in Russian. "The" is in the ear of the listener, so to speak. "I am the walrus" in Russian would be "I Walrus" because they have no articles or present tense of the verb "to be." If you want to get technical, go check with Moose and Squirrel.
The Revolution
(885 posts)This is what I think of when I hear 'the Ukraine'. The Ukrainian man uses the correct term though
. Maybe since his English grammar is a little off (dropping the indefinite article), people thought that was incorrect?
Cha
(317,730 posts)ago.. I haven't seen that being said but, of course, I don't read every post or even close to it.
But, yeah.. TY
ETA~ I don't even know where it started.. the wrong way to say it.
Patton French
(1,823 posts)The Ukraine region of the USSR. Old naming conventions die hard.
Vinca
(53,567 posts)of a brutal invasion and, apparently, the problem is the word "the." That part of the world has been sliced and diced so many times, many think of it as a region, thus "the."
ColinC
(11,098 posts)Ukraine is no longer a region of the USSR. It has been it's own sovereign country for nearly 30 years.
Vinca
(53,567 posts)ColinC
(11,098 posts)Not all we can do
I'm only asking for a modicum of respect for a country going through a crisis. Sure there is more that can be done, but showing some respect goes further than so many might realize.
Vinca
(53,567 posts)Good lord . . . get a grip.
ColinC
(11,098 posts)Calling a country by the wrong name is disrespectful. It baffles me so many people cannot comprehend this simple fact.
Response to ColinC (Reply #57)
Post removed
ColinC
(11,098 posts)Getting bent out of shape because most people don't want us to refer to a country by the wrong name. It is too bad.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)and suggesting we could use his "peacekeeping" tactic to grab a chunk of Mexico.
Amusingly, he corrected himself immediately, so obviously his staff have made some progress over the years in getting him to drop the "The."
