Historian Seth Cotlar: The power of Trump's accusers saying they'd still vote for him

[Nevilledog]

Link to tweet

Unrolled thread here
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1539677549826953217.html

I would feel more sympathy for Bowers if he hadn’t basically nullified his powerful testimony yesterday by immediately telling a journalist he’d totally vote for Trump again 2024.

Prepare for this to be a Trump ad in 2024 should he run. “If January 6 was such a big deal, then why did one of the supposed critics and victims of it say he’d vote for Trump again?”

GOP strategists are smart enough to know that the voters they need to keep on board are not the ultra-MAGA type who think Jan 6 was awesome, but the generally apolitical but "patriotic" folks who vote on gas prices or inflation, & need permission to vote for the coup guy again.

A good number of potential Trump voters will be people who, if they watch the footage of Jan 6, will find it disturbing, disqualifying even. The GOP needs to set up a permission structure that says "your concerns are understandable, but trust us, this won't happen again."

Nothing says "trust us, this won't happen again" more forcefully than having the vast majority of Republicans who testified before the Jan 6 Commission (like Bowers, Raffensperger, Sterling, etc.) endorse Trump in 2024, which I fully expect they will if he runs.

Bowers' seeming reverence for the Constitution is, ironically, the very thing that enables him to absolve his party (and his 2024 Trump-voting self) of any responsibility. "The divine will sort it out, fallible men can only do so much."

A hallmark feature of modern conservatism is its profoundly anti-sociological, anti-structural, and hyper-individualistic understanding of historical causality. History is made by individuals, not movements or broader social forces. Individual virtue, a la Rusty, will win out.

No need to talk about the county and state level GOP officials with ties to white nationalists and far right militias. No need to talk about the far right media ecosystem that inspires stochastic terrorists and acts of vigilante intimidation like Bowers' family experienced.

Another hallmark feature of modern conservatism is its hyperbolic obsession with "the dangerous left that wants to destroy America as we know it." This also gives people like Bowers reason to minimize or explain away what Trump and his movement did to him, because "the left..."

Instead of structural understandings of historical causality, what the political culture of the US Right offers are a range of conspiracy theories. "The Hollywood elites" or "Soros" or "the liberal media" want you to care about Jan 6, but that's because they're out to get you.

Nothing would give more credence to these Jan 6 minimizing mechanisms on the right than having a parade of testimonials from Republicans who testified before the Jan 6 Commission endorse Trump or a Trump-approved candidate.

Here it is, the 2024 messaging already in place. "Far from being a party that empowered & enabled a coup plotter, the GOP is filled with Trump-supporting politicians who quietly did their jobs in a virtuous manner. Don't worry, you can keep voting for us."

• • •

[BigmanPigman]

1. I lost respect for him when he said he voted for tRump twice,

no with this new info I have lost all respect for him.

He reminds me of the FBI during Watergate voting for Nixon a second time because he is a straight Republican voter, despite already knowing Nixon was a crook.