General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSCOTUS just quietly slashed your Sixth Amendment rights
(TheHill) The Supreme Courts recent assault on our rights has gone far beyond Roe and Dobbs. The Supreme Court quietly issued a 6-3 ruling recently on Shinn v. Martinez Ramirez, siding against two Arizonans on death row who sought to challenge their convictions in federal court after receiving shoddy legal support. The majoritys rationale, which was based on a 1996 federal law, was that state sovereignty and legal expediency must be protected at all costs.
Unfortunately, those costs are clear. The Courts ruling slashed Americans constitutional right to effective counsel by eviscerating the life-saving accountability mechanism that allows people to appeal unjust rulings. The six conservative justices have plainly prioritized the legal systems power to convict and kill over our human right to live.
What is less clear is why, in a nation where folks will literally risk childrens lives to maintain their Second Amendment rights, Americans seem perfectly happy to hand over their Sixth Amendment rights with hardly a thought. The silence on social media and in our public discourse about this ruling is alarming we should be very scared and very, very angry.
snip
We live in a world where innocent people are prosecuted every day. This ruling erodes protections for any American who might at any time be perceived guilty of any sort of wrongdoing. Whether it be the person in the midst of a miscarriage who is accused of committing an abortion in a red state, or the person who rented a car to visit family and was accused of stealing it despite a complete lack of evidence. It truly could be any of us at any time. All it takes is running into the wrong cop or prosecutor at the wrong time. And after Dobbs, it might take as little as a bad pregnancy outcome, whatever the cause.
Read More: https://thehill.com/opinion/judiciary/3541102-scotus-just-quietly-slashed-your-sixth-amendment-rights/
In It to Win It
(8,248 posts)disappointing. If there was any case that depletes all the confident you have in courts, it's this one.
katmondoo
(6,457 posts)with their rulings.
Thomas Hurt
(13,903 posts)States rights will be making a comeback, individual liberties pared down so the red states can become proper christofascist theocracies.
I was calling this move the Christian Republic of the US. I think we are going to The Christian Confederate States of America now.
We won't have states secede, the extremists on the SC are going to weaken the federal gov't so that won't be necessary.
sarcasmo
(23,968 posts)AllaN01Bear
(18,191 posts)calimary
(81,238 posts)Excellent summary! WELL-worth remembering.
These a holes won't be content until we are at parity with the Articles of Confederation.
States rights will be making a comeback, individual liberties pared down so the red states can become proper christofascist theocracies.
I was calling this move the Christian Republic of the US. I think we are going to The Christian Confederate States of America now.
We won't have states secede, the extremists on the SC are going to weaken the federal gov't so that won't be necessary.
SergeStorms
(19,199 posts)a disproportionate amount of the blue states' tax dollars. Socialism is still acceptable when it benefits them.
canuckledragger
(1,636 posts)They want to make sure there is NO escape, legal or otherwise for those they plan on demonizing and turning into criminals under the new christofacist regime.
ancianita
(36,053 posts)state abortion laws? And they'll sustain their ruling through this clause of the 13th Amendment?
Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
Dark n Stormy Knight
(9,760 posts)for "duly convicted."
I've been saying for years that Rs are evil, and I've been told to settle down. That it's not that terrible.
The M$M has been helping spread the lie that both parties are the same, or even that Dems are worse.} So, Rs now have massive power & are now doing just what they've always wanted to do. And we are all are royally screwed.
Traildogbob
(8,731 posts)Now this. The brown shirts are coming for you. After they take full control, be damn sure they will come to get your precious guns when you realize youve lost all rights and your votes are as useful as Russian or North Korea votes. You will not be allowed to take away their power with those finally WOKE The FUCK UP militias.
Farmer-Rick
(10,163 posts)They worship money more than a magical sky daddy. Money was always their favorite god.
So, if you ain't got enough of that magical money that Jesus so loves , you get NO justice. Maybe they'll streamline it and just allow the filthy rich to pay a judge directly for a favorable ruling. Why even bother with a court or jurry?
LoisB
(7,203 posts)gab13by13
(21,323 posts)The Pro Life court my ass.
jaxexpat
(6,820 posts)eliminate appellate courts.
The irony is how these people aren't smart enough to appreciate the use of caution about what they wish for.
TeamProg
(6,124 posts)Auggie
(31,167 posts)Caliman73
(11,736 posts)The media focuses on the 1st, the 2nd, and at times the 4th and 5th. I would wager that even those Amendments are not that familiar to the average American, let alone the 6th Amendment.
This is a problem of our education system and the focus on celebrity, sports, and sensationalism rather than on the laws, customs and traditions that affect our everyday lives.
at140
(6,110 posts)nowforever
(302 posts)It seems the judicial branch is now calling all the shots. When the final arbiter of everything resides with 6 justices who are strict right wingers how can there be any balance. Every decision is based on there own personal views of what they feel is right and moral. I feel like we are hostages to their very conservative moralistic opinions and desires...this is not justice.
ultralite001
(894 posts)and start over???
That is all...
3825-87867
(844 posts)A Congress that can't really act on anything let alone repeal anything the Six Horses Asses do means the Federalists can pretty much make the Supine Court their bitch, not that this court for the most part minds being one. A president who has turncoats in the Democratic Senate and some in the House.
This is almost too good to be true for Republicans or rather 21st Century Stalinists. I'd almost believe it's been scripted.
Could anyone have written this?
ShazamIam
(2,570 posts)dlk
(11,561 posts)There is no code of ethics and, essentially, no accountability. We are watching the conservative justices arbitrarily rescinding Constitutional rights and freedoms, not based on the Constitution or precedent, but on personal religious and political whims. This is not how a democracy thrives or even survives.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)federal, state, local and military governments to enforce.
Congress legislates and can pass new laws or parts of laws to replace or mitigate damage from what SCOTUS rules against. This is a big main one, with this court's power over the electorate highly dependent on Repubs being able to block Democrats' ability to pass these laws.
Congress can make various changes to the court, including impeaching justices for cause. And probably at least 4 have given cause. Also, congress can change the high court's jurisdiction in some ways I've never understood but could probably be targeted to help foil an insidious plot or two.
Congress already created a bunch of courts inferior to SCOTUS, but no doubt could add more.
Congress can investigate SCOTUS.
Congress holds the purse for SCOTUS, as well as the rest of the government. Although the constitution prevents expressing disapproval of their behavior by cutting their compensation, we could refuse to pay for water and power or personnel to clean the bathrooms.
Must be more. Really, the other branches have tools. The big problem is the subversives who discourage people from voting in the Democratic majorities needed to wield them.
dlk
(11,561 posts)And with Republican opposition, it will be very difficult to counter SCOTUS legislating from the bench.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)will decide the balance of power in congress and the state governments for the next two years. The more power the Democratic Party has, the less the Republicans have.
What the various governmental and private organizations can do to counter and mitigate damage from this SCOTUS is undoubtedly far more than amateurs can guess at, however. All one has to do is click on a newspaper or activist site to read about what some are doing about something.
dlk
(11,561 posts)Its happening but together we can turn back this storm slashing burning anything that promotes a more fair and just country.
In It to Win It
(8,248 posts)went to the store for cigarettes and never came back.
Response to FM123 (Original post)
Post removed
Pepsidog
(6,254 posts)due to limited knowledge and/or resources to put up an effective defense. However, if your rich then you can buy all the Justice you can. Terrible blow to our system that prides itself on the idea that better 10 people go free than 1 person be wrongly convicted. This is a plain and simple attack on the poor and vulnerable. Shame on SCOTUS.
NullTuples
(6,017 posts)Meaning, anything except guns and god. Because you know, textualism.
Alice Kramden
(2,166 posts)"Its a gruesome conclusion from a court that seems bent on increasing the suffering of the American people."
Too true.
llashram
(6,265 posts)Lifetime appointment, no accountability, led by a nazi along with 5 more nazi fascists. What can be done? Outside of expanding the Supreme Court. Legislatively, no remedy except ...what?