General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIn hindsight, "Stand Back and Stand By" does not sound quite the same as the first time...
...I heard it in the debate?
It sounds more intentional.
It sounds more planned.
It sounds more threatening.
It sounds more like orders were being given.
It sounds more like seditious conspiracy.
Novara
(6,115 posts)It was instruction. It was telling them to be patent because shit was coming down and he'd tell them what to do.
Walleye
(44,807 posts)Just like Putin knew what Trump meant when he said Russia if youre listening. You got to think racketeering with these guys not politics
mucifer
(25,667 posts)Arkansas Granny
(32,265 posts)Sunsky
(1,876 posts)Yep, plain to see and easily understood.
arthritisR_US
(7,810 posts)Alexander Of Assyria
(7,839 posts)Hortensis
(58,785 posts)to journalism and journalists, and they know it. tRump often spoke about closing down newspapers and arresting reporters, and of course every year many journalists are arrested, "disappeared," murdered in lawless, authoritarian nations.
Then there was/is the whole QAnon thing, with people expecting tRump to use the national emergency broadcast system, or some such thing, to alert them personally that it was time to attack and take over the nation, arresting and holding people for execution. All of them supposedly just waiting eagerly for tRump's orders for where to go and who to attack.
PLUS, many of tRump's MAGAs. This was the context within which he made many statements like this.
he reason WE know this is the free press.
Alexander Of Assyria
(7,839 posts)the assembled media protests were meek, at best the dots never connected to fascism even still!
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)Last edited Sat Jul 9, 2022, 06:05 PM - Edit history (1)
as experts are watching it take form in modern contexts that have changed dramatically since 1930s Europe.
Much of what the Republicans have been up to is so far more definitively indicative of OTHER types of vicious, anti-freedom RW extremism, which don't require characteristics that define fascism be present.
The WH press corps mostly reports news coming out of the WH. In-depth interpretation is for other sections of newspapers and journals, and that's where informative articles about rising RW (and LW) extremism, and signs of fascism, are published. After all, how would many of us have been aware years ago of the increasing threat of RW takeovers of the WH, SCOTUS, and congress if journalists hadn't been informing us of signs and analysts hadn't been warning us of what they were pointing to?
Btw, hostility toward the free press is a poison that's been spread by RW enemies of democracy to make people discredit truthand to prepare them to accept, even support, losing it. Of course they've had great success on the right and are extremely pleased with signs of success on the left.
After all, a free press so critical to democracy that it's protected right along along with freedom of speech and religion in the Constitution. We're the must-save-it party, the Republicans the must-destroy-it party.
AntiFascist
(13,751 posts)some MAGAts want to teach "both sides" regarding the Holocaust. Do they want to teach the Holocaust denier side, or do they want to go further than that, touching on certain conspiracy theories promulgated by Hitler?
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)Last edited Sat Jul 9, 2022, 07:35 PM - Edit history (1)
by far-right white supremacists to keep MAGAs dazzled and distracted. Definitely fascist or just some more run-of-the-mill far-right racism manipulator?
As you obviously know, Hitler did heavily employ conspiracism, German mythology, and occultism, along with of course giant, massive lies, to draw vulnerable sorts to his new ideology, but are those elements unique to fascism?
We do know that mythology, occultism, and conspiracism have all been and are used by leaders of other ideologies, including socialist and theocratic, on both left and right. Especially "charismatic" leaders who draw people less concerned with provable truth and science-based answers than the thrill of finding great truths unknown to most in a "great" leader and "great" cause. Some tRumpists, of course, 8 feet deep in it, but some on the left admired both Bernie Sanders and Marianne Williamson and some eventually migrated to the right as anti-vaxxers etcetera and likely more than a few eventually as Q-nuts running the spectrum.
(Liberal democratic leaders find them least useful in drawing and manipulating support and most likely to repel their larger proportion of more sober, self-honest, reality-grounded voters. Moderate conservative leaders used to have much the same problem, but not with what they'd have to work with these days if they ran.)
AntiFascist
(13,751 posts)marching through streets carrying torches and chanting "Jews will not replace us,"
showing up at a LGBTQ+ Pride event in riot gear,
calling the free press "the enemy of the American people"
and most obviously the Jan. 6th riot with echoes of the Reichstag Fire:
trying to blame the riot on Antifa and BLM (considered by the far right to be leftist communists),
arresting or executing the elected officials obstructing Trump,
then planning to enact martial law and redoing the election the "right" way.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)of the harnessing of aggressively anti-elite, anti-establishment nasty-negative emotions that is populism. Yes, Hitler presented as a populist leader, as did tRump, but so did many other power-seekers espousing almost all ideologies. Brazil's Bolsonaro, Venezuela's Maduro, France's Marine Le Pen, Hungary's Orban, UK's Boris Johnson, Israel's Netanyahu, on and on.
If you're a nasty, dangerous creep who can't hold a job and responsible political kingmakers wouldn't let you enter the house to deliver groceries, much less put you in high office, populism can still be a means to power.
I don't think anyone doubts tRump and his special supporters have studied Hitler's techniques, but there are many, many others, successful in today's world, to study and seek advice from. Populist leader Putin for another. All would tell their followers to stand by for their call to lawlessness.
AntiFascist
(13,751 posts)Julius Caesar, with no less than a direct descendant of the family of the Julii as his primary Counsel, enacting Constitutional reforms to increase his powers and suppress the blue states, establishing a Praetorian Guard of Oath Keepers, ...
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)the trumpist war against the deep state illuminati. Who's the purported Julii descendant in tRump's government?
No doubt many pleasing zero-reality implications could be spun for trumpists from a descendant of the family of Julius Caesar advising tRump. I'm a bit of a JC fan, and to my mind some dirty tRump associate might not be exactly flattering to him, but if even I find the thought of Julii descendants fun how about tRump and his 74M fellow antitruth addicts?
This all reminds me that without the electoral college, the Republican Party would already have collapsed into some stagnant backwater for bitter irredeemables. And to thank goodness for the majority with sensible, reality-based expectations for a democratic government that maintains a healthy, prosperous and stable nation for everyone to pursue their happiness in. We really need to hurry the irredeemables along, though.
AntiFascist
(13,751 posts)but the Giuliani family name does seem to be concentrated around Rome, also both names derive from the same root.
https://www.italianames.com/italian-last-names-maps/GIULIANI
What is also a bit scarey when you think about it are all the Roman symbols in Washington DC and government: the Greco-Roman architecture all over the place (how many columns were really necessary for the Supreme Court building?), the eagle as an imperial symbol, and there are even 'fasces' in the House of Representatives!!
https://uschs.wordpress.com/2011/10/21/what-does-that-mean/
One can only wonder what delusional thinking goes into wanting Trump to take over our government.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)Apparently Caesar's adopted son Octavius (Augustus Caesar) may have many living descendants. That'd be fun for some to someday "discover," though apparently genetic testing that far back would miss a lot, even most of who actually were.
Warping of heavy Roman classicism was apparently very popular with Hitler and Mussolini fascists, though from what I've read the big building binge of that general era in DC mostly lost out on the special fascistic imprint. Thank goodness. Lots of that pretty neoclassicical though.
As for that last, I've just assumed surrendering to all of one's worst character traits as required by The Leader, or just team as available, must require suspension of thinking. How else to explain them? All in service to The Leader and his great cause of course.
I'll never know such happiness.
AntiFascist
(13,751 posts)There may be some young National Guard captains facing some very, very tough choices in the next 48 hours, read one message posted by the group on Jan. 4.
...
Made up largely of Special Forces veterans and former intelligence officials, 1AP was founded in September 2020 to protect Trump supporters from harassment at rallies and to safeguard free speech rights from tyrannical, Marxist subversive groups, Mr. Lewis wrote in a thread of tweets announcing the creation of the group. In a video attached to the thread, he said it would be a tactical mistake to discuss how many members 1AP had, noting only that it was several times more than the dozen in a standard Special Forces operational unit.
...
In the interview, Mr. Rhodes described how the two groups worked together at the rally. He then urged Mr. Trump to wage war against traitors at home by imposing martial law. That was the same message that Ms. Powell, Mr. Flynn and others in their orbit were advising at the time.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/03/us/politics/first-amendment-praetorian-trump-jan-6.html
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)Thanks for pointing them out. Likely largely bombast, but.... And National Guard captains? The name alone suggests they need to be drowned at birth.
In looking up this group, I saw this on Esquire. Seems like a valid alternate working definition of the fascism developing around tRump:
by obsessive preoccupation with community decline, humiliation, or victimhood, in which a mass-based party of committed nationalist militants, working in uneasy but effective collaboration with traditional elites, abandons democratic liberties and pursues with redemptive violence and without ethical or legal constraints goals of internal cleansing and external expansion.
A lot of what Paxton describes has evolved into instinctual behavior in our present politics. These elements of fascism are already here. Its vocabulary and syntax have long been an important part of our national dialogue. They simply have not yet fully coalesced. God help us if they do.
I hope this group, also gathering at the Willard Hotel, ends up as some obscure names in a long list of people convicted and serving time after the nation's mostly moved on.
THIS one mentioned in Mother Jones as one of a bunch, for instance.
You always record what everybody says, and you put shit out there, and you follow people around and take pictures, Michael Kenny, a member of 1st Amendment Praetorian, or 1AP, a shadowy group of former military members that has worked with former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn, told Staci Burk on the March 1 call. You talk a lot publicly, and thats what makes you a target. Burk is onetime Republican activist who is now studying for her law degree. There was a number of people, you ruffled their feathers, Kenny said moments later. If you put anybody in jeopardy of prison time, or you know, if you might hurt them financially or whatever, people get edgy, you know? People dont think clearly. You need to think about the easy way.
She considered it a death threat and initially pulled back from talking to the J6 committtee, then resumed.
AntiFascist
(13,751 posts)thanks so much for pointing this out. Flynn definitely belongs in prison, even if it requires new indictments and convictions.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)Caliman73
(11,767 posts)Trump is not the "genius" he proclaims to be. He does speak intentionally however. When he isn't saying the stupidest shit imaginable, like "hamberder" or Covefefee (or however it is spelled), he us using language like mobsters use.
"Hey, this guy is a friend of ours" (he's a mafioso like us) OR "I want you to pay Jimmy Hands a visit and make it short" (I want you to kill Jimmy Hands today).
Trump knows the phrase when you want someone to stop everything they are doing is "Stand Down". When you order someone to "Stand Down" you are telling them STOP. When you say, "Stand back and stand by" you are telling them "wait till you hear from me again".
The Proud Boys and other hate groups knew exactly what Trump was saying.
sop
(18,624 posts)Maeve
(43,457 posts)They turned it into tee shirts and a rally cry.
By the way--anyone know if it is true that "proud boy" is a rancher's term for a gelding that acts like it still has balls?
TheRickles
(3,386 posts)IANAR (I am not a rancher), but "proud boys" seems to be a variant of this term.
Maeve
(43,457 posts)The devil hates for people to laugh at him.
live love laugh
(16,383 posts)IronLionZion
(51,269 posts)Most of it was him deflecting blame to the left, Antifa, BLM, etc. and refusing to condemn white supremacists. Moderator Chris Wallace asked him to tell his white supremacist supporters to stand down.
Solomon
(12,644 posts)ProfessorGAC
(76,706 posts)There's a huge difference between standing down & standing by.
My only doubt comes from my belief that TFG wouldn't know those terms meant different things.
After all, he is a babbling idiot.
Dorian Gray
(13,850 posts)I thought it was Suss at the time!
niyad
(132,440 posts)JT45242
(4,043 posts)Sounded like a thinly veiled threat to attack all non-MAGA
bucolic_frolic
(55,141 posts)Worthy of a man who thinks the public is as dumb as they were in 1925
keithbvadu2
(40,915 posts)yardwork
(69,364 posts)kentuck
(115,407 posts)No one knew at the time how deep the Proud Boys and OathKeepers were going to be involved with January 6th insurrection.
But it could have been anticipated.
electric_blue68
(26,856 posts)H2O Man
(79,053 posts)And it sounded horrible at the time. But it sounds worse now, and exactly as you say, a seditious conspiracy taking form.