General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNorth Korea is reportedly in talks to send 100,000 soldiers to fight in Ukraine:
Link to tweet
cilla4progress
(26,525 posts)Eom
Bayard
(29,701 posts)An army of soldiers from one of the worlds most authoritarian nations could be sent to bolster Vladimir Putins forces fighting in Ukraine.
Up to 100,000 North Korean soldiers could be sent to bolster Vladimir Putins forces fighting Ukraine, according to Russian reports.
A leading defence expert in Moscow, reserve colonel Igor Korotchenko, told state TV: We shouldnt be shy in accepting the hand extended to us by Kim Jong-un.
North Korea has made it clear through diplomatic channels that as well as providing builders to repair war damage, it is ready to supply a vast fighting force, reported Regnum news agency.
They would be deployed to the forces of the separatist pro-Putin Donetsk Peoples Republic [DPR] and Luhansk Peoples Republic [LPR], both of which Kim has recently recognised as independent countries.
The country is ready to transfer up to 100,000 of its soldiers to Donbas, said the report by the pro-Kremlin news agency.
Pyongyang will be able to transfer its tactical units to Donbas.
In return, grain and energy would be supplied to Kims stricken economy.
https://www.news.com.au/world/europe/100000-north-korean-soldiers-could-be-sent-to-bolster-putins-forces-fighting-ukraine/news-story/1126782c8c5e6fe08a8ad2d9fa38dff0
Not good at all. Desperate people do desperate things. And with China mad as hell at us now, we could get sucked into this after all.
Response to Bayard (Reply #2)
PortTack This message was self-deleted by its author.
brush
(61,033 posts)this an intervention by outside forces and won't intervene itself. I think that would be another of Putin's bonehead decisions.
IMO it would be just a matter of time before other nations enter that war.
Trueblue1968
(19,251 posts)tinrobot
(12,062 posts)Since it's being reported by Russian state TV, you have to take this with a big grain of salt. I doubt the real numbers will be anywhere near what they're stating.
mahatmakanejeeves
(69,854 posts)North Korean troops are to be sent some place where crops are grown?
murielm99
(32,988 posts)TheBlackAdder
(29,981 posts).
I'm sure they will select troops who have families, and they will get killed if there's a defection.
.
EndlessWire
(8,103 posts)They're not going to get interviewed on TV. Some of them will defect no matter what. Lil Kim will just get additional sanctions on his country.
TheBlackAdder
(29,981 posts)PortTack
(35,820 posts)That would indeed be bad, but russia isnt going to be able to arm them or give them heavy military hardware to use, they dont have enough for the current soldiers deployed. Are they going to bring their own tanks, howitzers, planes how?
TheBlackAdder
(29,981 posts)Bucky
(55,334 posts)I mean, it's also about shortening Russia's border defense lines too.
It's strategic madness. That's what you get when one guy holds all the power for too long. You should thank the universe every morning that you don't live in Asia
muriel_volestrangler
(106,212 posts)Easy to transport anything that can fit on a railcar.
PortTack
(35,820 posts)Lines. Ukraine has already severely weakened the russian military machine, they are currently unable to mount any successful offenses. By the time the NK arrive, it may be too late for them
muriel_volestrangler
(106,212 posts)and I don't think any military analyst thinks that either. Being unable to mount new offences does not mean "unable to defend, too". There's a lot of territory for Ukraine to retake, and they'll have to do it while holding the line in some places. The Russians wouldn't need to wait for all North Korean men and equipment to arrive before using some of them, either.
I think the problem with this might be more that Kim needs his army to maintain control over his country. And it's not actually an army experienced in fighting.
BootinUp
(51,325 posts)former9thward
(33,424 posts)Russia is a huge food exporter with the EU their #1 customer. They have no problem feeding their own people and many other countries as well.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1238548/russia-leading-food-export-partner-countries/
Response to former9thward (Reply #32)
WarGamer This message was self-deleted by its author.
Novara
(6,115 posts)Sounds fucking familiar. If you don't win, burn it all down.
Bluethroughu
(7,215 posts)blue-wave
(5,135 posts)Pooty the baby is sitting around in his diaper crying that he's not getting his way.
Im not sure what to do but the US should not stand for that. NK and Russia share a border so there is no way to stop the troops without landing in NK or Russia.
But if this is allowed to happen it will be complete genocide in Ukraine.
PortTack
(35,820 posts)The Ukrainian forces were hamstrung until the heavy equipment from the west arrived. 100,000 soldiers without military heavy equipment? Not in this war.
NATO and western allies have indicated they have their lines that will not be crossed too, they just dont bluster and threaten. the bottom line remains unmoved, especially for the EU- that is Poopin must be stopped or they will have another continent wide European war. Their very way of life will be threatened if Ukraine falls.
nuxvomica
(14,092 posts)If NK sends 100K, I wonder how many will end up at the destination.
ColinC
(11,098 posts)NCjack
(10,297 posts)land stolen from them by Russia.
Bucky
(55,334 posts)And China is using Russia both for (1) cheap oil, which China needs lots of, & (2) a distracting the west from their aggression in the South China Sea.
So, no, no one's taking land from Russia this week
Crunchy Frog
(28,280 posts)and eventually holding referendums to unite with China.
Bucky
(55,334 posts)Do you have any reason to believe the Russians are inclined to be giving up territory in the east?
Read more and opine less
Crunchy Frog
(28,280 posts)also opine all I want. If you find my opining offensive, you are free to put me on ignore.
Bucky
(55,334 posts)It's random and irrelevant, but please feel free to opine away, my friend.
Crunchy Frog
(28,280 posts)He's been relying on ethnic minorities, Russian dregs from the impoverished provinces, and forcibly conscripted men from the separatist "republics". He evidently doesn't think he can politically survive true mass consumption and lots of body bags coming into Moscow and St Petersburg. He wants to fight a major war using only garbage people who no one important will miss.
Mr.Bill
(24,906 posts)South Korea and the US to ratchet-up some military exercises on and around the Korean peninsula. You know, stuff that was already scheduled.
NCjack
(10,297 posts)Bluethroughu
(7,215 posts)ripcord
(5,553 posts)They will send soldiers with families left behind so they have hostages.
Bluethroughu
(7,215 posts)We are talking about people banished from reality, when they see it, their natural instincts will take over and they will try to run away from danger.
The propaganda wars of today outshine those of yesteryear....
tblue37
(68,436 posts)Alhena
(3,076 posts)I seriously doubt they would allow 100k of their troops to go to an uncontrolled environment and report back to the people at home that even a poor country like Ukraine is vastly better than their own.
Response to Alhena (Reply #19)
PortTack This message was self-deleted by its author.
thucythucy
(9,103 posts)except you are so much more succinct.
My post #20 is a long-winded agreement with yours.
Bluethroughu
(7,215 posts)It will only destabilize NK more. It would not be in their best interest to get involved.
thucythucy
(9,103 posts)Allowing a hundred thousand soldiers access to the outside world could totally destabilize North Korea,
Even in a war, many of these soldiers will be exposed to standards of living they probably can't even imagine. This happened to a certain extent to Soviet troops during WWII once they crossed the border first into Poland and then into Germany. People who had never before seen a flush toilet and indoor plumbing, or houses wired for electricity, or networks of paved road, were simply astounded at the western standard of living. The result then was in large part to make Soviet soldiers even more pissed at Germans--"These people are so unbelievably well off, why did they have to invade us?" Even so, returning POWs were usually sent straight to the Gulag, since what they saw even as prisoners was enough to make the regime doubt their continued loyalty to Stalin.
For North Koreans there might be a similar reaction, compounded by the fact that they're not defending their homeland or retaliating for an attack on their native country, but instead are basically being used as mercenaries. Add to this there is an option available to North Koreans unavailable to Soviets in 1945: they can defect and end up in South Korea. A nation where they speak the language, know the culture--to an extent--and may even have family.
"We were told we were the best country on earth. We were told we were the envy of the world. We were told Westerners were savage animals. All of it was a lie?"
Even being stationed in Russia, which has a standard of living below that of Ukraine, there might be such a reaction. Add to all this access to the outside internet, even to broadcast TV, and the culture shock is going to be intense.
Some of these soldiers will inevitably defect. Others will return home in a state of intense dissatisfaction and cognitive dissonance. Even if most of the soldiers hang onto their imposed world view, enough of them will be affected to be a truly destabilizing factor.
The North Korean regime is playing with fire in more ways than one. Hopefully they will take all this into consideration before they make decisions that can't be undone.
former9thward
(33,424 posts)Where are you getting your info? Russia's standard of living is three times that of Ukraine. Ukraine is the poorest country in Europe. Russia GNP per capita is $10,127. Ukraine's is $3727.
https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/poorest-countries-in-europe
BeyondGeography
(41,101 posts)Then what do you have? Poor Russians are fighting and the rich kids are staying home. All of the troops are from the hinterlands where people are indeed poorer than the average Ukrainian. Why do you think they steal everything that isnt nailed down?
former9thward
(33,424 posts)Just that they "steal everything". Factor out Kyiv and Odessa and the rest of Ukraine is dirt poor. I provided a link for my opinions. Maybe you can do the same.
BeyondGeography
(41,101 posts)I salute you.
This is like every other war; poor kids are the ones fighting and dying.
https://amp.france24.com/en/live-news/20220517-young-poor-and-from-minorities-the-russian-troops-killed-in-ukraine
thucythucy
(9,103 posts)I'd prefer St. P. to Moscow.
But I wouldn't want to live in either as long as Putin is in power.
thucythucy
(9,103 posts)Per capital GNP being one of the most misleading ways to judge standard of living.
Russia has an economy based primarily on energy exports, control of which, and the benefits of which accrue to a very small percentage of the population.
Other measures are more ambiguous.
https://www.mylifeelsewhere.com/compare/ukraine/russia
So mortality during infancy is higher in Ukraine, but life expectancy in Russia is lower. And though wages are higher in Russia, the percentage of the population living in poverty is also higher.
The Russian Federation is more than just European Russia. Standards of living for various minority groups: Uzbeks, Kazaks, Tartars etc. are also lower, on average, than for European Russians.
I admit though it's a debatable point, especially since official figures for both nations--but especially Russia--must be taken with many grains of salt.
PSPS
(15,322 posts)former9thward
(33,424 posts)It just a figure you are throwing out there with no evidence.
PSPS
(15,322 posts)From: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/24/opinion/russia-ukraine-sanctions-offshore-accounts.html
PortTack
(35,820 posts)The supposed once thought 2nd most powerful military in the world is a worn out paper tiger. Yes, they have thousands of tanks, ones that sat in open fields since the 70s. Their howitzers have had so little maintenance that the barrels are melting or exploding on site with the rocket inside. The orcs are using rifles from the 40s. The initial fighting force had no food, no ammo. They were cannon fodder..and still are because russia hasnt invested anything in their force.
former9thward
(33,424 posts)The article you linked is almost six months old and is paywalled so I have no idea what it says.
It has been almost 6 months since Russia invaded Ukraine. It has been about 8 YEARS since Russia invaded the Crimean section of Ukraine. Sanctions both times. Is it really that hard to find 85% of Russia's GNP with all the resources the U.S. has? How come that has not been seized?
PSPS
(15,322 posts)That's the real question here instead of parroting a pro-kremlin argument.
Our sanctions are full of exemptions, presumably to protect the highest oligarchs & kleptocrats from their effect. The holes aren't as big as those in the UK, but they're still way too big. I can agree with you on that. But you can't equate russia's GDP figures with that of any other country because they're known not to reflect the living standard of its citizens. Very little of russia's GDP sees its way to the citizens. Almost all of it lines the pockets of putin and his buddies.
muriel_volestrangler
(106,212 posts)This is like saying a household has a $100,000/year income, and one member has $85,000 in a secret bank account. That doesn't mean that 85% of the income is siphoned off each year.
SheltieLover
(80,484 posts)Bucky
(55,334 posts)Although I guess the survivors will have combat experience. This serves Kim's interest two different ways. Troops with combat experience and fewer mouths to feed
OnDoutside
(20,868 posts)Turbineguy
(40,077 posts)Unless it turns out that their only training has been goose-stepping in parades
A re-run of Napoleon's "Sans Culottes"?
A little music to go with that?
tblue37
(68,436 posts)EX500rider
(12,583 posts)Turbineguy
(40,077 posts)They'll fit right in with the Russians then.
EX500rider
(12,583 posts)Torchlight
(6,830 posts)Moscow's attempt at military reform has failed to shape a modern force structure as the endemic, massive corruption (CATO has suggested that a fifth of the defense budget is defrauded every year) had hampered Putin's attempted modernization of the military. Russian command failed to ensure air superiority, came up short on command and control, and has been suffering considerable attrition of senior officers, including generals and admirals killed in Ukrainian strikes.
Two months ago, Russian military command sought to compensate for battlefield losses by bringing tanks out of storage, but discovered that in many cases vital hi-tech equipment like gyros and target finders had been stripped. Entire engine blocks had been removed. I also think it revealing that Russias largest maker of tanks has ceased operations due to a lack of components.
As the war drags on, the Kremlin is forced to withdraw whatever troops can be harvested from other deployments, other actors are likely to be emboldened. Azerbaijan has already resumed its own offensive. Georgia is currently eyeing the recapture of South Ossetia and Abkhazia, and Moldova could decide to tackle the breakaway Transnistria. And after the humiliation in Ukraine of the Chechen strongman Ramzan Kadyrov, Russia might even be drawn into a third Chechen war.
BeyondGeography
(41,101 posts)This noble reclamation of Russias natural cultural borders brought to you by Kim Jong-un!
Aristus
(72,188 posts)sixty years...

David__77
(24,728 posts)lindysalsagal
(22,915 posts)interpreters from south Korea to assist with 100,000 male Korean immigrants.
EndlessWire
(8,103 posts)lpbk2713
(43,273 posts)BOOM!
Crunchy Frog
(28,280 posts)And let's not go wetting the bed over their handful of "nukes" either. It would be insanity to allow that shithole to hold the rest of the world hostage.
roamer65
(37,953 posts)purr-rat beauty
(1,257 posts)100,000 defectors
Stinky The Clown
(68,952 posts)Ukraine is being harmed in so many horrible ways by a bully in the person of one Vladimir Putin. That harm is affecting the entire planet in the form of millions of displaced persons and the direct burden of accepting them in places not prepared for the migration. It also takes the form of inflation, food shortages and starvation in the Third World, and global energy shortages. The bullying is far beyond Ukraine's borders and impacts millions, perhaps billions of people having NOTHING to do with Russia or Ukraine.
Bullies get differential treatment from their victims. Putin continues in office, seemingly immune to threats to his power.
Among the latest insults to the Body Humanity is the war crime of killing prisoners of war. The UN is investigating. That investigation will go nowhere because Russia and China sit on the Security Council with the absolute right to veto whatever they wish, no matter how self-serving.
I recognize there is a threat of thermonuclear obliteration in suggesting this, but it is time to act. it is time for the world to end its tolerance of bullies. It is time to stop the Russian aggression in Ukraine. Allow Ukraine into NATO and if not that, then go it alone.
Issue the ultimatum to Putin.
If ignored, go in and end it. This is a GLOBAL threat.
I know this is unpopular. I know many (most?) of you who read this will find it unthinkable. So be it.
I think standing up to any bully is the right thing to do, even if never done. Standing up to a civilization-threatening global bully is necessary.
WE ARE BEING TESTED
Should this prove accurate and Putin tries it, such action cannot be allowed.
Maybe the answer is to assassinate the bully(ies)
PortTack
(35,820 posts)With more heavy artillery and weapons and now talk of training Ukrainian pilots to fly our F15s. It must be a terrible fine line to walk especially for those in the EU..how much, when.
Listening to Jen Stoltenberg NATOs Secretary General I dont believe the EU and NATO will let Ukraine fall. Their very way of existence will be threatened just as Ukraines is now.
Crunchy Frog
(28,280 posts)The risk of giving in to nuclear blackmail is incalculably higher IMO.
arthritisR_US
(7,810 posts)they want to avoid a world war. North Korea doing this would escalate this war into a world war. This proposition is extremely dangerous.
Lettuce Be
(2,355 posts)Freedom!
Crunchy Frog
(28,280 posts)and it's not like they're not going to be on an extremely tight leash.
Ukraine needs to be given the tools to obliterate the fuck out of them, preferably before they enter Ukrainian territory. We need to get over this idiotic policy of forbidding them from striking military targets inside russian territory.
2naSalit
(102,803 posts)they never got there.
Bettie
(19,704 posts)NK runs on xenophobia, isolation, and repression (suppression?). If they get even a glimpse of the world, it will change some of the troops they would send in a way that is not necessarily friendly to the current government.
But, Vlad must be desperate.
Kaleva
(40,365 posts)Life in a UKR POW camp would be bliss compared to living in NK
Response to tblue37 (Original post)
WarGamer This message was self-deleted by its author.
MarineCombatEngineer
(18,060 posts)they have no combat experience and will be going toe to toe with combat experienced Ukr. forces, plus they're equipment is far inferior to the western systems and munitions flooding into Ukraine.
DFW
(60,186 posts)Sounds like Russia is in dire need of a new leader.
Should enough highly-placed Russians come to the same conclusion, theyll get one, too.