General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsRoberts attempting to defend the SCOTUS behavior(s) is an admission that they are damaged as
an institution.
If he thinks his credibility is just fine he is living in screwball land. This business of right wingers denying reality is getting shamefully old and tiresome.
The Roberts court caused more damage to democracy, and America as an idea, than almost any other court.
If he had any sense of duty or honor left he would resign.
Diamond_Dog
(40,579 posts)Tell the newbies who got special favor that you dont overturn a 50 yr. precedent which takes away human rights. And Tell Clarence that he needs to resign. Remind them what separation of church and state means.
PJMcK
(25,048 posts)The Chief Justice has no control over the Associate Justices. All of them have lifetime appointments.
What would you say?
Diamond_Dog
(40,579 posts)I guess I was just venting.
PJMcK
(25,048 posts)The frustration is palpable.
Enjoy your weekend, DD.
dchill
(42,660 posts)Well, there's an utter fantasy!
jimfields33
(19,382 posts)I suspect that will mostly continue.
dchill
(42,660 posts)Hermit-The-Prog
(36,631 posts)Faux pas
(16,357 posts)know it's hard to be humble when you're perfect in every way..."
I hope you all know this is
czarjak
(13,639 posts)really don't think roberts is qualified in any way, shape or form.
RANDYWILDMAN
(3,163 posts)she is coming for you like a tsunami and your name is poop after all this and forever more
Joinfortmill
(21,169 posts)usaf-vet
(7,811 posts)..... POTUS ever, and he KILLED the Roberts' Court and made it lose any hope of being considered a judicial shining light.
The history books will tell the story of the court that was stacked with unqualified extremists and how they did all they could to take away freedoms from Americans that have existed for decades.
The good news is that the decisions of the current Roberts court will likely be responsible for the Blue Wave that is building to give Democrats control of both houses of congress in 2022.
Joinfortmill
(21,169 posts)NullTuples
(6,017 posts)Remember Citizens United was his, too. And election rulings galore that allowed Republicans to take power by cheating.
He helped build this monster & now that it's become clear it is out of control he is trying to play the part of Captain Renault in Casablanca in order to protect his "reputation".
I say his reputation is quite clear.
cstanleytech
(28,473 posts)Roberts court seems to be trying to top them.
Snackshack
(2,587 posts)Will go down as the worst CJ ever, even eclipsing Roger B Taney who IMO was formerly the worse CJ ever (Taney will still hold the spot for the most creepy looking CJs ever) but in terms of damage done to the court and the country Roberts has excelled. Citizens United was disastrous, his wallflower act at the 1st impeachment, letting the clock run out on the Emoluments crimes and his allowing the GOP to use and turn his court into a branch of the GOP for bias political rulings is the final nail in the once non bias arbiter known as the Supreme Court.
leftieNanner
(16,159 posts)Gutting the Voting Rights Act.
PufPuf23
(9,861 posts)specific individuals and institutions that have bought the courts, and spend the remainder of life advocating for egalitarian court without corruption. Roberts would say today which USSC Justices do not have the skills or philosophy to be on the court and also call out the recent Justices (plus Thomas) regards the irregularities in their appointments.
NQAS
(10,749 posts)The problem is that they - RWers in any job any education, any class - believe that they are in the right. Which is why they dont resign but rather double down. IMHO it is sickness and a moral failing.
jaxexpat
(7,794 posts)lindysalsagal
(22,915 posts)But at least he's on the defensive. Glad to know that.
BlueIdaho
(13,582 posts)Roberts has been a horrible Chief Justice and he along with his trained monkeys have ruined the courts reputation.
Bush - by far the most authoritarian U.S. President until Cheeto - didn't just pick him out of thin air.
He - or rather, his Rasputins - knew exactly who they'd be shoving into such a strategic post for the next 30-40 years.
Yes, Roberts has gone off-script here and there - but in general, he's little better than all those "mainstream conservative" judges who, without being Nazis themselves, enabled Hitler and his abuses.
Texin
(2,851 posts)Does it seem plausible at this point, that McConnell and his lockstep Nazi repuke senate would allow Biden to nominate a replacement?
Lasher
(29,577 posts)And the Democratically controlled Senate would confirm him or her.
Lonestarblue
(13,480 posts)The fly in the ointment is the Senate Judiciary Committee, which has 11 Democratic members and 11 Republican members. If the committee deadlocks on moving a nominee to the full Senate, it can slow things down quite a bit. Biden nominated a black woman for the 11th Circuit in January, but her nomination still has not gone to the full Senate. Republicans are refusing her because she once worked for the ACLU.
That said, neither Roberts nor any of the other right-wing extremists on the Court will resign. Theyre enjoying their power to remake US laws according to their biases too much.