General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAna and the intentional fallacy of the hasty generalization.
The tweet:
"I'm a woman. Please don't ever refer to me as a person with a uterus, birthing person, or person who menstruates. How do people not realize how degrading this is? You can support the transgender community without doing this shit."
The informal fallacy of generalizing from the particular (aka 'the hasty generalization') is a standard HORSESHIT TECHNIQUE for scoring rhetorical points. The HORSESHITTER picks a particular example, devoid of context, and then proceeds to claim it is now the general condition.
A simple example. An unusually cold day in June happens. The paid PR agents of the fossil fuel industry, in unison, claim that this proves global warming is a hoax. They've just generalized from the particular.
In the case of Kasparian, she chose a particular situation, a reference to 'pregnant people' instead of 'pregnant women' in specific medical contexts, to infer that Kasparian, and all women, are now being referred to, in general, as 'a person with a uterus'. This is a deliberate bad faith argument, she is lying and she knows she is lying.
The only real issue here is why she chose to do this. The follow on issue is why the flying fork do we keep falling for this sort of vile nonsense.
Walleye
(31,017 posts)Straw man is an old technique that is being revived
Voltaire2
(13,027 posts)The bag of rhetorical tricks is lined with straw and filled with horseshit. The thing is, when you find yourself emotionally outraged by something some 'influencer' has said, it is frequently A Very Good Idea (tm) to step back and examine what was actually said, why it has triggered an emotional response, and how it might be intentionally misleading.
GenXer47
(1,204 posts)You're correct, the medical context here is crucial.
I remember one medical report attributing an "increased risk of death" to something, probably smoking.
Don't we all have a 100% risk of death?
It's a mistake to listen to doctors with the same ear as a regular person.