General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Supreme Court's Corruption Scandal Isn't About Ethical N
By David Kurtz June 23, 2023 9:08 a.m.
The Rot Is Deep
At the risk of participating in the overuse of Michael Kinsleys rule of scandals The scandal isnt whats illegal, the scandal is whats legal. lets take another look at the way the Supreme Courts influence-peddling scandal is being portrayed.
The ostensible sin of Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito is failure to report gifts and freebies from wealthy GOP donors. That leads to an entirely unhelpful debate mired in semantics, legal technicalities, and line-drawing over disclosure requirements. Its not that the reporting requirements are meaningless or useless or of no value (though probably less value than you think), its that theyre tripwires at best, an alert system.
Put it this way: If Thomas and Alito had disclosed these gifts, it would not have been okay! Or rather, in the norms of DC it would have been okay, but definitely should not have been okay
https://talkingpointsmemo.com/morning-memo/supreme-court-corruption-scandal-ethics
-snip-
The issue is Leonard Leo and the Federalist Society and a couple of generations of leading lawyers on the right exerting enormous influence over the composition of the judiciary. You dont fix that or reform the judiciary with nickel-and-dime financial disclosure rules alone.
Quote : from Dahlia Lithwick ...... Leonard Leo........Travel Agent
Sheldon Whitehouse......
The Unmitigated Gall
(4,710 posts)Feel like I'm taking crazy pills here. That these gifts/favors happened AT ALL is sickening, whether they were declared or not.
crickets
(26,168 posts)Dahlia Lithwick's article: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2023/06/justice-alito-fishing-trip-real-prize.html
Sheldon Whitehouse has been on this issue for years now. Love him! More reading:
This member of Congress wants everyone to know about the 'dark money scheme' that's 'captured' the Supreme Court | Nov 20, 2021
https://www.businessinsider.com/sheldon-whitehouse-fighting-to-end-dark-money-at-supreme-court-2021-11
https://archive.ph/QMyIg
"The rule of the court purports to say that you can't hide behind a front group. There's almost no other situation in court where somebody is allowed to come in and not identify themselves, and yet there is conspicuous non-enforcement of that rule, and it deprives the public of seeing the coordination among the phony front groups," Whitehouse said, adding that he doesn't "understand why the court doesn't clean that up itself."
In the current term, hundreds of briefs tied to a slew of contentious cases have been filed to the Supreme Court. One highly-watched case, concerning a Mississippi law that bans abortion after 15 weeks of pregnancy, has attracted dozens of briefs that express support for or opposition to the law.
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse Wants You to Know Why SCOTUS Is FUBAR | Feb 22, 2022
https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2022/02/sheldon-whitehouse-scheme-scotus-supreme-court-right-wing-conservative-capture-influence/
Whitehouse chose his title carefully. It implies that this is not random, he says. This is not just, Oh, were conservatives, and so were going to appoint conservative thinking judges, which is the veneer. They would like to maintain this is just conservatives being conservatives.
He suggests that the model of agency capture, when an administrative agency is co-opted to serve the interests of a minor constituency, was applied to the supreme court. Once youre over that threshold of indecency, it actually turned out to be a pretty easy target. The other construct to bear in mind is covert operations, because essentially whats happened is that a bunch of fossil fuel billionaires have run a massive covert operation in and against their own country. And thats a scheme.
Who Is Leonard Leos Mysterious Dark Money King? | May 16, 2023
America needs to know who Barre Seid is, what kind of country he wantsand just how massive an impact a gift of that size can have on our political discourse.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonard_Leo
https://newrepublic.com/article/172480/barre-seid-leonard-leo-dark-money-king
https://archive.ph/FEdNK