Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Cyrano

(15,388 posts)
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:17 PM Jul 2023

Enough b.s. about UFOs. Here's the reality.

There are many millions of planets in our Milky Way galaxy on which there is intelligent life.

The inhabitants of a few million of these planets have unified to create a broad, interstellar, sane society.

They engage in trade, peaceful relations, and the exchange of their countless art forms.

There are occasional minor disagreements that are settled through a direct voting process.

This interstellar community constantly monitors younger planets, (such as ours), as candidates to join them.

Occasionally, they come across a planet on which madness and war among the inhabitants is the norm.

Such planets are considered to be a danger to themselves and inevitably self-destruct.

But some of these planets, somehow, achieve space travel and are, accordingly, viewed as a virus.

And, therein, lies the answer to why UFOs are occasionally seen.

They are here to monitor us. They are here to issue any needed alerts to the interstellar society.

Yet, they know they need not be concerned with our early attempts at gaining access to them, or infecting them.

They know we will destroy ourselves before we can spread the virus that infects us.

To repeat, UFOs are here for the sole purpose of monitoring us. Nothing more.

(Please don't ask me how I know this. Just grant me a bit of trust here.)

124 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Enough b.s. about UFOs. Here's the reality. (Original Post) Cyrano Jul 2023 OP
makes sense to me. We crazy ZonkerHarris Jul 2023 #1
Sad, but true. peppertree Jul 2023 #75
Well said!!! n/t RKP5637 Jul 2023 #2
Ahhhh wuz wonderin who changed awww dem trump votes to biden Fullduplexxx Jul 2023 #3
No sane aliens Pantagruel Jul 2023 #4
SANE ALIENS ???? Would they have 2 legs or four ??? Trueblue1968 Jul 2023 #32
+1 progressoid Jul 2023 #39
Alien - the short version. paleotn Jul 2023 #57
CATS ARE ALIENS ;;;; LOLOL Trueblue1968 Jul 2023 #64
Dogs have their points, as well.... nt DemocraticPatriot Jul 2023 #100
Maybe we are just average in terms of wretchedness Shermann Jul 2023 #5
Aliens passing by Danascot Jul 2023 #52
+1 n/t area51 Jul 2023 #77
I Know Your Tongue Is In Your Cheek, But... ProfessorGAC Jul 2023 #6
I see you've visited 41 countries. Cyrano Jul 2023 #7
That's Up To Them! ProfessorGAC Jul 2023 #8
OK, that is where I put my foot down...They don't understand Golf? Shame on them...Now, seriously Escurumbele Jul 2023 #40
i REALLY WONDER if they are not just TIME TRAVELERS YoshidaYui Jul 2023 #50
You're gonna love this! Marthe48 Jul 2023 #93
Half of us on earth do not understand that, either.... DemocraticPatriot Jul 2023 #101
Not necessarily. intheflow Jul 2023 #9
Because You Can't Crash At 5 Million Miles Away? ProfessorGAC Jul 2023 #10
Can they crash? intheflow Jul 2023 #12
Don't anthropomorphize an alien species. paleotn Jul 2023 #60
As I understand, atmospheric visits are needed to release the pidgins sanatanadharma Jul 2023 #13
Wouldn't They Had To Have... ProfessorGAC Jul 2023 #31
Perhaps they don't need to travel here to treestar Jul 2023 #33
Best Explanation So Far! ProfessorGAC Jul 2023 #34
Yeah, That's My Question Beetwasher. Jul 2023 #45
Could they just beam us up I_UndergroundPanther Jul 2023 #111
OR (just spitballing) the distances between us and likely inhabitable planets is too far for travel brooklynite Jul 2023 #11
It used to take a couple weeks to cross the Atlantic. Who woudda thought we could fly someday? rickford66 Jul 2023 #16
I'm looking MorbidButterflyTat Jul 2023 #21
Unless you've found a way to exceed the speed of light (Star Trek notwithstanding).... brooklynite Jul 2023 #27
I suppose MorbidButterflyTat Jul 2023 #38
"Quantum Leap" was one of my favorite shows.... Remember "Ziggy"??? DemocraticPatriot Jul 2023 #106
The Universe is what it is anyway... WheelWalker Jul 2023 #86
Extraordinarily bad analogy. paleotn Jul 2023 #69
The one thing we should be mindful of is that we don't know what we don't know. Renew Deal Jul 2023 #97
"We don't know everything" doesn't lead to "anything in possible". brooklynite Jul 2023 #104
This assumes that another civilization perceives or experiences time the way we do. Renew Deal Jul 2023 #107
Believing something is true and THEN looking for evidence is equally flawed thinking. brooklynite Jul 2023 #109
Technologically, we've only just begun.... DemocraticPatriot Jul 2023 #105
And it's possible we're getting attention because they've started picking up on our radio signals. Renew Deal Jul 2023 #108
That's as good a solution as any to the Fermi Paradox paleotn Jul 2023 #73
Until physicists can show a way to travel faster than the speed of light, this is doubtful. Quixote1818 Jul 2023 #14
You are talking about OUR physicists. edisdead Jul 2023 #18
And yet they are crashing here on earth millions of years ahead of us? Quixote1818 Jul 2023 #22
They are? edisdead Jul 2023 #82
Also do us a favor edisdead Jul 2023 #83
oh yeah. It is difficult to capture an airplane or a chopper even with the best phone ecstatic Jul 2023 #113
exactly! edisdead Jul 2023 #118
Maybe the flight to Earth took 15+ years or thousands of years ecstatic Jul 2023 #121
We are a product of our time and place. Irish_Dem Jul 2023 #25
Unfortunately some find it Disaffected Jul 2023 #51
Post removed Post removed Jul 2023 #94
John Titor is that you? edisdead Jul 2023 #15
Timetravel_0 (2009) Celerity Jul 2023 #84
hahaha yep! edisdead Jul 2023 #96
Interesting hypothesis.... anciano Jul 2023 #17
Why do we assume that "intelligent life" cyclonefence Jul 2023 #19
We cannot get beyond being human centric, earth centric. Irish_Dem Jul 2023 #61
There are theorists Danascot Jul 2023 #110
Who is assuming that? brooklynite Jul 2023 #102
It's just that phrase "intelligent life-forms" cyclonefence Jul 2023 #117
If true, that would blow the big bang theory out the window ecstatic Jul 2023 #114
Nailed it! MOMFUDSKI Jul 2023 #20
Do you have kids? Rafi Jul 2023 #36
I don't think anyone here thinks Disaffected Jul 2023 #53
And all this time I thought the monitoring was because Mars needs women. Xavier Breath Jul 2023 #23
The rest of the Universe put yellow police tape around our solar system. Irish_Dem Jul 2023 #24
Occasionally seen? There are tens of thousands of reports every year in the US. Rafi Jul 2023 #26
Amusing that someone living in Israel MOMFUDSKI Jul 2023 #30
WOW, must be a full moon tonight. nt Disaffected Jul 2023 #59
For the last time, Mork, you are messing up our control group! Beastly Boy Jul 2023 #28
Thread winner! AKwannabe Aug 2023 #122
And they love beef....... Goonch Jul 2023 #29
You didn't address the most important question sarisataka Jul 2023 #35
We are the Junkyard Dog nocoincidences Jul 2023 #37
To solve the alien debate once and for all, we could launch several enormous rockets into allegorical oracle Jul 2023 #41
Actually, Demobrat Jul 2023 #42
Hey, it's your fantasy, so have at it. n/t elocs Jul 2023 #43
This is probably the reason we don't all have flying cars. They were promised sixty years ago. JustABozoOnThisBus Jul 2023 #44
Klaatu barada nicto nolabear Jul 2023 #46
Makes sense Wild blueberry Jul 2023 #47
I bet when they fly past us they roll up their windows and lock their doors. n/t Mr.Bill Jul 2023 #48
Nice theory but it collapses at the first sentence. Disaffected Jul 2023 #49
link? orleans Jul 2023 #54
They've done enough already. Marcuse Jul 2023 #55
To a species that's figured out how to traverse interstellar space... paleotn Jul 2023 #56
Most humans wouldn't recognize an alien intelligence if it bit them on the ass. hunter Jul 2023 #58
Big Star Trek/Sci-Fi fan here Martin Eden Jul 2023 #62
Makes Sense Jazz Jon Jul 2023 #63
NOT NEW...A MOVIE WAS MADE IN THE EARLY 50S..."DAY THE EARTH STOOD STILL" Stuart G Jul 2023 #65
Michael Rennie was ill the day the earth stood still... Duncan Grant Jul 2023 #115
Maybe. moniss Jul 2023 #66
I wholeheartedly agree. Snackshack Jul 2023 #67
I'm guessing we've been very closely monitored ever since we detonated nuclear bombs. OMGWTF Jul 2023 #68
I can live with this reality. Meantime, ancianita Jul 2023 #70
I loved that book. Supposed to be making it into a movie. A bit of a tease - this is *not* your... electric_blue68 Jul 2023 #87
Me, too. It would be an amazing film if Hollywood could do it. ancianita Jul 2023 #90
Definitely a whole lotta computing power for that alien! ... electric_blue68 Jul 2023 #91
Found this. Glad that Matt Damon is the lead, since his mom was a teacher. ancianita Jul 2023 #92
I always hoped this was a documentary: Pinback Jul 2023 #71
Our species orangecrush Jul 2023 #72
KR NT ProudProgressiveNow Jul 2023 #74
We are the aliens, my friends. nt chowder66 Jul 2023 #76
Klaatu barada nikto. nt AndyS Jul 2023 #78
This message was self-deleted by its author Wednesdays Jul 2023 #85
Or you can take the Stephen Hawking POV on aliens Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Jul 2023 #79
Have you seen Battleship? AKwannabe Aug 2023 #123
Man's tryin' to keep us down..... Red Mountain Jul 2023 #80
Got to thinking about this. If they are watching us then they would have killed Trump off. LOL Quixote1818 Jul 2023 #81
I know this is for shits and giggles...but... Xolodno Jul 2023 #88
It is VERY risky for them to make contact. Renew Deal Jul 2023 #98
Precisely. Xolodno Jul 2023 #120
They are here to probe our asses Kaleva Jul 2023 #89
That is one of the theories. Renew Deal Jul 2023 #95
I guess you're a "Trekkie" ??? DemocraticPatriot Jul 2023 #99
First sentence, numbers are wrong Snooper9 Jul 2023 #103
lol. I would not have asked how you know this, but now I have to ecstatic Jul 2023 #112
Dayum, I thought they were coming to save the world from right-wing dipshits. raccoon Jul 2023 #116
I think they are here to teach us how to think in quantum physics terms as a population. librechik Jul 2023 #119
I had so much fun reading in this OP! AKwannabe Aug 2023 #124

paleotn

(22,218 posts)
57. Alien - the short version.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:35 PM
Jul 2023

That's just too good. And probably what would happen if Jones's momma taught him how to hunt.

Shermann

(9,062 posts)
5. Maybe we are just average in terms of wretchedness
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:25 PM
Jul 2023

So, half of the alien species out there are more wretched than we are.

ProfessorGAC

(76,706 posts)
6. I Know Your Tongue Is In Your Cheek, But...
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:25 PM
Jul 2023

...if they have the theoretical knowledge & technology to star travel wouldn't they be able to monitor us from a few million miles out while being 100% stealthy, given our state of technology?
Why would they have to do atmospheric level flights at their tremendous technological sophistication?
Nobody who is convinced we've been visited has ever given a good answer to those questions?

Cyrano

(15,388 posts)
7. I see you've visited 41 countries.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:31 PM
Jul 2023

Those who have visited 41 thousand planets would never question the reason for atmospheric-level observations.

By the way, golf is a huge mystery to them. They don't know why some chase a little ball around grassy surfaces.

Escurumbele

(4,094 posts)
40. OK, that is where I put my foot down...They don't understand Golf? Shame on them...Now, seriously
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:56 PM
Jul 2023

your post makes for a very good hypothesis of why some UFOs have been seen around our earthly sky. I also read a book that says that we actually come from aliens who inhabited the earth for many years, then they went back to their respective planets.

So many theories out there but so far, none can be corroborated.

YoshidaYui

(45,415 posts)
50. i REALLY WONDER if they are not just TIME TRAVELERS
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:20 PM
Jul 2023

Coming back from the future to see how our civilization survived this period in time. Aliens maybe, but I think many of them are futuristic humans coming back to check on us.

Marthe48

(23,175 posts)
93. You're gonna love this!
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 09:36 PM
Jul 2023

I never forgot it lol

I can't get the link to work.

B.C. Comic: It is daylight. Grace (aka Cute Chick) has a golf club, and is saying to B.C. "Let me get this straight. The less I hit the ball, the better I am doing." B.C. says, "That's right." And Grace says, "Then why do it at all?" Last panel is B.C. in the same spot with the moon shining. He is holding a golf club, staring at a teed ball, saying, "Why....do it....at....all...."

 

DemocraticPatriot

(5,410 posts)
101. Half of us on earth do not understand that, either....
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:09 PM
Jul 2023

NOR WHY it is broadcasted on television....

:::changing channels::::


My dad loved to golf, and watch the golf shows on TV...
but I was never any good at it

(except for putting, my dad thought I was 'one hell of a putter' lol)

intheflow

(30,179 posts)
9. Not necessarily.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:36 PM
Jul 2023

When I see pictures or movies of places I’ve never visit and them visit them later, I gather much more information from being there than I ever had from travel guides. They may feel the same, and honestly, why hide yourself when you’ve got shields that can easily deflect our worst weapons?

ProfessorGAC

(76,706 posts)
10. Because You Can't Crash At 5 Million Miles Away?
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:38 PM
Jul 2023

In addition, that answer doesn't address why they'd interact with the subject of their observations.
I also don't think your reading about/visiting analogy applies well to a species so much more advanced.
You'd learn nothing extra about bees by going into a hive and you can't get stung reading it in a book.

intheflow

(30,179 posts)
12. Can they crash?
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:43 PM
Jul 2023

What if their tech allows the ships to bounce off Earth and immediately return home for repairs, like a cross between a bounce house and pneumatic tubes? No proof of crashed alien vehicles has ever been verified. 👽

sanatanadharma

(4,089 posts)
13. As I understand, atmospheric visits are needed to release the pidgins
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:43 PM
Jul 2023

As I understand, atmospheric visits are needed to release the pidgins; the robots can fly but not in thin air.

treestar

(82,383 posts)
33. Perhaps they don't need to travel here to
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:46 PM
Jul 2023

observe us, but they like to send vehicles here to see how we react to them.

They might be graduate students studying us like anthropologists, and it is research for their thesis.



Beetwasher.

(3,178 posts)
45. Yeah, That's My Question
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:10 PM
Jul 2023

How did they crash and allow us to capture and/or kill them? And why would the aliens take any risk at all? I mean even WE use satellites, telescopes, drones, robots and more instead of actually going places. Doesn’t make sense.

I_UndergroundPanther

(13,369 posts)
111. Could they just beam us up
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 01:15 AM
Jul 2023

And leave all the psychopaths ,narcissists ,republicans and christian nationalists, evangelical control freaks here? Rapture them away to a rocky dead planet with no technology to fight each other until extinction.

A lot of people here could do just fine in a kind ,just compassionate,cooperative society,we even wish it could happen here. I dont think these kind folks should be abandoned here.

 

brooklynite

(96,882 posts)
11. OR (just spitballing) the distances between us and likely inhabitable planets is too far for travel
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:41 PM
Jul 2023

Doesn't make for nearly as interesting as Sci Fi story, but.....

rickford66

(6,065 posts)
16. It used to take a couple weeks to cross the Atlantic. Who woudda thought we could fly someday?
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:51 PM
Jul 2023
 

brooklynite

(96,882 posts)
27. Unless you've found a way to exceed the speed of light (Star Trek notwithstanding)....
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:28 PM
Jul 2023

...its just not practical to travel multiple years if not generations...and certainly not in something the apparent size of the UFO blobs we keep being shown in photos.

MorbidButterflyTat

(4,513 posts)
38. I suppose
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:52 PM
Jul 2023

you've never heard of time travel?

It wouldn't necessarily take multiple years or generations.

 

DemocraticPatriot

(5,410 posts)
106. "Quantum Leap" was one of my favorite shows.... Remember "Ziggy"???
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:23 PM
Jul 2023

The handheld computer which 'Al' used???


Back then, 30 years ago, it was total science fiction...


but today most of us have a 'Ziggy' in our pocket, the smartphone....

It is impossible to imagine the technological advance we may make in the next 100 years--
but I think we should devote more resources to our space program...


WheelWalker

(9,402 posts)
86. The Universe is what it is anyway...
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 08:17 PM
Jul 2023

We might conclude that the universe is a stranger place than we have sometimes been led to suspect and that the amount and type of strangeness each of us can tolerate depends, to some extent, on prior commitments. But the universe is what it is anyway.

paleotn

(22,218 posts)
69. Extraordinarily bad analogy.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:57 PM
Jul 2023

We've been crossing the Atlantic since Leif Ericson's crappy travel brochures. Even today, it takes decades to get a spacecraft just outside our stellar bubble.

Most of us really can't comprehend the distance from here to Proxima Centauri, currently our closest stellar neighbor, and the amount of energy needed to move an object from here to there in a reasonable amount of time. Even if you could harness that much energy, the General Theory of Relativity kicks in, i.e. everyone you've ever known has been dead for centuries before you get back. Bend space time? Well now you're talking a huge number of solar masses combined. Good luck with that.

It may simply be impossible, like traveling faster than light or going back in time. As good an answer as any for the Fermi Paradox.

Renew Deal

(85,168 posts)
97. The one thing we should be mindful of is that we don't know what we don't know.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 09:57 PM
Jul 2023

Other civilizations may be ahead of ours for a few reasons.

Longer time in existence
Different physical resources that are more efficient than anything known on earth
Different environmental and scientific conditions that make solving the problem of long distance travel easier
Completely different understanding of physics that are not yet known on earth (and maybe never will be without contact)
Different preservation methods that make things like hibernation possible for them

 

brooklynite

(96,882 posts)
104. "We don't know everything" doesn't lead to "anything in possible".
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:15 PM
Jul 2023

If nobody here can establish a premise upon which FTL or multi-generational travel is possible, I won't be wasting my time dreaming about it.

Renew Deal

(85,168 posts)
107. This assumes that another civilization perceives or experiences time the way we do.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:25 PM
Jul 2023

The 24 hour day is a human concept limited to earth. Lifespans for creatures on earth vary greatly.

Anything is possible. Everything isn't probable. But limiting our thoughts of what's possible solely on what we currently know would be a mistake.

 

brooklynite

(96,882 posts)
109. Believing something is true and THEN looking for evidence is equally flawed thinking.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 11:00 PM
Jul 2023
 

DemocraticPatriot

(5,410 posts)
105. Technologically, we've only just begun....
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:19 PM
Jul 2023

We only began to fly 120-some years ago.... about the same time with radio electronics, out of our thousands of years of existence here...


Yes, it is quite likely that there are other civilizations that are more advanced than we are,
although they may be very, VERY far away...



"God hope" they are more benevolent than we are...

Renew Deal

(85,168 posts)
108. And it's possible we're getting attention because they've started picking up on our radio signals.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:28 PM
Jul 2023

We certainly try to narrow down signals that originate off earth. It's logical that they would do the same thing.

paleotn

(22,218 posts)
73. That's as good a solution as any to the Fermi Paradox
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 07:07 PM
Jul 2023

And one I tend to lean towards. Or intelligent life might be overrated, extraordinarily rare and spread across stretches of space and time too vast for us to comprehend. The most common forms of life may just be bacterial goo. That's earth for the vast majority of its existence.

Quixote1818

(31,155 posts)
14. Until physicists can show a way to travel faster than the speed of light, this is doubtful.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:50 PM
Jul 2023

Distances are just too far for regular visits as Carl Sagan explains. It's possible a few very advanced civilizations have sent out millions of drones to explore the universe but even if they find us, it would take tens of thousands of years to find out about us, then tens of thousands of years to reach us. It's possible the Earth was found millions of years ago and is being visited by these aliens for the second or third round but for that to occur at this moment in time is very low probability. My main issue is that we now have billions of cell phone cameras ready to film them and no one can get a good image? Why is it always some lousy infrared military image that pilots say was going super fast but when the numbers on the camera are plugged in it was going a regular rate of speed?

edisdead

(3,396 posts)
18. You are talking about OUR physicists.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:53 PM
Jul 2023

Our Physicists could be children compared to theirs.

Quixote1818

(31,155 posts)
22. And yet they are crashing here on earth millions of years ahead of us?
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:04 PM
Jul 2023

We can't have it both ways. If they are as advanced as you say, we won't know they are here at all which I think is the most likely possibility. Not these bogus fuzzy images we keep getting shown.

edisdead

(3,396 posts)
83. Also do us a favor
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 07:56 PM
Jul 2023

Next time there is an airplane flying over head go outside and take a picture of it and post it here.

Additionally, go take a picture of the skyline at night awith your cellphone and post that. See how those photos turn out.

ecstatic

(35,075 posts)
113. oh yeah. It is difficult to capture an airplane or a chopper even with the best phone
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 01:46 AM
Jul 2023

I was trying to make a mini movie at the beach. The chopper was flying super low but on my phone it was like a tiny spec so I couldn't do it. I think a UFO would have to hover over an outdoor movie set where filming is in progress in order for the world to FINALLY get a good visual.

edisdead

(3,396 posts)
118. exactly!
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 01:46 PM
Jul 2023

Now I am not trying to say ufo’s are real (alien ines anyway) or not, but people think that iphones or even consumer dslr cameras could just capture an object in the sky at full clarity.

Doesn’t work that way.

ecstatic

(35,075 posts)
121. Maybe the flight to Earth took 15+ years or thousands of years
Mon Jul 31, 2023, 10:49 AM
Jul 2023

Depending on which planet they were coming from. Earlier today I looked up how long it would take to get to the hypothetical planet 9 / planet x and one of the estimates was 20 years. So perhaps, just like we're vigorously looking for information on a potential "Planet 9," the inhabitants of that planet have been desperately trying to find out about us? Or, if the UFO was from Proxima B, perhaps their flight here took 70,000+ years.

Assuming they're more advanced, but not advanced enough to travel using teleportation / wormholes, they sent off their astronauts a long time ago. This might explain a potential crash. Perhaps the astronauts were already dead due to some sort of malfunction on the ship (cryo malfunction)??

Maybe only one ship crashed, but they've had multiple successful landings thousands of years ago (which could explain the "ancient alien" phenomena). Maybe we are their descendants. 😮🤔🤯

Irish_Dem

(81,277 posts)
25. We are a product of our time and place.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:17 PM
Jul 2023

It is hard for humans to think outside of our constraints and limitations.

Disaffected

(6,408 posts)
51. Unfortunately some find it
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:23 PM
Jul 2023

all too easy. Such is one of the geneses of irrational belief.

Response to Quixote1818 (Reply #14)

Irish_Dem

(81,277 posts)
61. We cannot get beyond being human centric, earth centric.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:39 PM
Jul 2023

All intelligent life will be in humanoid form.
All livable planets for sentient life forms will be like Earth.

Danascot

(5,232 posts)
110. There are theorists
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 11:14 PM
Jul 2023

who propose that machine intelligence may be the dominant 'life' form in the universe. Look at where we are now with AI, and where it could go in the future.

 

brooklynite

(96,882 posts)
102. Who is assuming that?
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:12 PM
Jul 2023

Nobody is questioning the TYPE of alien life; they're questioning the ability to transcend the laws of physics in a practical way.

cyclonefence

(5,151 posts)
117. It's just that phrase "intelligent life-forms"
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 08:02 AM
Jul 2023

puzzles me.

Maybe two hundred years ago--before we understood about dolphins, elephants, trees, even fungi and viruses--we considered ourselves the only forms of intelligent life on earth. We have learned that every life form we investigate here seems to communicate, form attachments, feel pain and other "human" emotions--I just wonder what other senses, etc.--things we are unable to imagine--exist in the endless boundaries of space. I think it's presumptuous of humans that we imagine ourselves as the standards by which to judge "intelligent life" when our imaginations are so limited that when we imagine alien beings, they are basically humanoid in form with their superior intellects merely exaggerations of what we know about our own brains and emotions.

ecstatic

(35,075 posts)
114. If true, that would blow the big bang theory out the window
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 01:49 AM
Jul 2023

There's no fucking way for a big bang to be duplicated with the same end result on multiple planets. lol. No way. Actually, it would disrupt a lot of theories of how things came to be.

 

MOMFUDSKI

(7,080 posts)
20. Nailed it!
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:58 PM
Jul 2023

We can’t be so presumptuous as to think our planet is the only one with life on it in this vast universe. They will communicate when we are worthy. Thanks for your common sense.

Disaffected

(6,408 posts)
53. I don't think anyone here thinks
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:29 PM
Jul 2023

our planet is the only one with life on it in this vast universe. The actual issue is whether or not such possible life has been detected and, for now at least, the answer is a resounding No (blurry blobs on cockpit screens and anecdotal "evidence" not withstanding).

Irish_Dem

(81,277 posts)
24. The rest of the Universe put yellow police tape around our solar system.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:15 PM
Jul 2023

Active crime scene.

Rafi

(281 posts)
26. Occasionally seen? There are tens of thousands of reports every year in the US.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:17 PM
Jul 2023

If you count sightings worldwide it increases to hundreds of thousands. No doubt they are monitoring us, but there is a evidence that it is much more than that.

It's not a chance happening that the number of sightings increased exponentially after we exploded nuclear weapons. It is also a fact, and the files are open, because of FOIA requests, that UFOs have shutdown our nuclear weapons while hovering above them. This has also happened in the old Soviet union and in one case made the missiles ready to launch. All of this is documented for anyone to read.

Anyone claiming to have the entire truth regarding this phenomenon is guaranteed to be blowing smoke.

Make of this what you will. An article from The Jerusalem Post.:

Has the State of Israel made contact with aliens?

According to retired Israeli officer and current professor Haim Eshed, the answer is yes, but this has been kept a secret because "humanity isn't ready."
Speaking in an interview to Yediot Aharonot, Eshed – who served as the head of Israel's space program for nearly 30 years and is a three-time recipient of the Israel Security Award – explained that Israel and the US have both been dealing with aliens for years.
And this by no means refers to immigrants, with Eshed clarifying the existence of a "Galactic Federation."
The 87-year-old former head of the Defense Ministry's Space Division gave further descriptions about exactly what sort of agreements have been made between the aliens and the US, which ostensibly have been made because they wish to research and understand "the fabric of the universe." This cooperation includes a secret underground base on Mars, where there are American and alien representatives.
If true, this would coincide with US President Donald Trump's creation of the Space Force as the fifth branch of the US armed forces, though it is unclear how long this sort of relationship, if any, has been going on between the US and its reported extraterrestrial allies.
But Eshed insists that Trump is aware of them, and that he was "on the verge" of disclosing their existence. However, the Galactic Federation reportedly stopped him from doing so, saying they wished to prevent mass hysteria since they felt humanity needed to "evolve and reach a stage where we will... understand what space and spaceships are," Yediot Aharonot reported.
As for why he's chosen to reveal this information now, Eshed explained that the timing was simply due to how much the academic landscape has changed, and how respected he is in academia.
"If I had come up with what I’m saying today five years ago, I would have been hospitalized," he explained to Yediot.
He added that "today, they’re already talking differently. I have nothing to lose. I’ve received my degrees and awards; I am respected in universities abroad, where the trend is also changing.

 

MOMFUDSKI

(7,080 posts)
30. Amusing that someone living in Israel
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:32 PM
Jul 2023

would speak in terms of "federation". But then I do have a very weird sense of humor.

Disaffected

(6,408 posts)
59. WOW, must be a full moon tonight. nt
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:37 PM
Jul 2023

BTW, the simple fact that something is "documented" goes nowhere in demonstrating its authenticity or factuality.

Another example would be astrology - it is also well documented for anyone to read but never-the-less is demonstrable nonsense. There are many others...

 

Beastly Boy

(13,283 posts)
28. For the last time, Mork, you are messing up our control group!
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:29 PM
Jul 2023

And putting the whole experiment in jeopardy.

Keep your ego in check and quit your intrusive ramblings on anonymous boards, before you create irreparable damage to the 50 million year undertaking so many of your colleagues staked their reputations on! Or else I will have to fire you.

- Orson

-

nocoincidences

(2,489 posts)
37. We are the Junkyard Dog
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:51 PM
Jul 2023

of the Milky Way.

No way are they letting us out of this Solar System.There was a message in 2010 Space Odyssey. Be happy where you are!

allegorical oracle

(6,480 posts)
41. To solve the alien debate once and for all, we could launch several enormous rockets into
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 05:57 PM
Jul 2023

space loaded with tons of Earth's plastic garbage on them. We might get a quick response if there are any aliens keeping an eye on what we're doing.

Demobrat

(10,299 posts)
42. Actually,
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:04 PM
Jul 2023

the UFOs are alien children daring each other to knock on the spook house door

JustABozoOnThisBus

(24,681 posts)
44. This is probably the reason we don't all have flying cars. They were promised sixty years ago.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:05 PM
Jul 2023

I think the rest of the galaxy is safe, as long as we don't invent warp drive. So far, we use all our dilithium crystals in vape pens.

Disaffected

(6,408 posts)
49. Nice theory but it collapses at the first sentence.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:20 PM
Jul 2023

&quot Please don't ask me how I know this. Just grant me a bit of trust here.)"

Nah. How do you know this?

paleotn

(22,218 posts)
56. To a species that's figured out how to traverse interstellar space...
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:32 PM
Jul 2023

much less intergalactic space, to them we'd be not better than our view of Homo habilis. Intelligent? Well...sorta. They might not be all that interested in us.

hunter

(40,691 posts)
58. Most humans wouldn't recognize an alien intelligence if it bit them on the ass.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:36 PM
Jul 2023

In any case, I'm pretty sure the speed of light is absolute. Faster-than-light travel and time travel, which would be two aspects of the same thing, are simply impossible in this universe.

That puts a severe limit on the kinds of trouble any spacefaring species could get into and that's okay.

Star Trek is fantasy, not science fiction.

End of story.

Believing that space aliens are visiting earth is no more rational than believing angels or demons walk among us. (This is of course exactly something a demon such as myself would say...)

Be that as it may, when I look up at the Milky Way on a clear night away from any city I don't have any urge to populate it with imaginary beings. It's wonderful as it is.

Martin Eden

(15,629 posts)
62. Big Star Trek/Sci-Fi fan here
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:41 PM
Jul 2023

Star Trek offers a hopeful vision of a more advanced human civilization which for the most part has outgrown the worst aspects of human nature that plagued our history, which is one of the reasons why I like it so much. However, I know the storylines with alien species who are almost always humanoids who understand each other (with a universal translator) are pure fiction. In the vastness of our galaxy, I suspect intelligent life is much more diverse not only in terms of physical form but psychological and societal structures as well. Concepts, values, motives, etc. among spacefaring species could make it impossible for intragalactic agreements and cooperative efforts. They may have outgrown the kind of internecine conflicts which threaten our own survival, but interactions with totally alien species are fraught with suspicion, misunderstanding, and potential violence.

I **trust** you reached your conclusions via honest deductive logic, but I think you are anthropomorphizing a bit. I'm not suggesting you necessarily believe in the Star Trek model of humanoids who can readily communicate, but diversity spans a broad spectrum that includes behavior.

Of course, this is all speculation. It's entirely possible that a coalition of species with superior technology and wisdom have suppressed threats by hostile spacefarers and have been monitoring Earth for the reasons you posit.

I think it's fairly obvious that aliens who achieved interstellar travel could destroy us if they wanted. I'm not skeptical that such things are possible. We may perceive the speed of light as an impermeable barrier but our science and technology is still in its infancy, given our first powered flight occurred a mere 120 years ago. If we don't destroy ourselves, where might we be 12,000 years from now?

What I am a bit skeptical about are the ostensible errors made by highly advanced aliens with technology beyond our ken resulting in sightings, crashes, and their own corpses being found. I'm not entirely ruling out sightings and possible abductions (the need for specimens to examine) but I think most of the reports are hokum.

However, I do lean toward Fox Mulder's belief:

We are not alone.

Jazz Jon

(159 posts)
63. Makes Sense
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:41 PM
Jul 2023

That scenario sounds reasonable.

I want to say my peace here, however:

Thousands of people have come foward over the past 75 years telling their stories of UFO sightings. They have picked up physical evidence only to have it confiscated, followed by threats to stay silent or else.
Good photographic evidence still exists, like the many photos taken by many people of the lights hovering over Washington in the1960's. (Did i get the year right?)

There are three preferreed methods that people interested in keeping this secret use to keep us in the dark

Denial - "It was a weather balloon or the planet Venus." OK, so a large silent black colored triangular craft hovering 100 feet overhead was the planet Venus viewed at dusk!

Misinformation- Very badly done hoaxes and the most nonsensical outlandish stories, and films, some made by charlatans, but others planted on Purpose to "show" us how stupid it all sounds... to smear the actual good evidence.

The blanket moronic starement: "There is no evidence" That one is just a lie. Lookup the term " coverup" in the dictionary. Somebody perpetrating a coverup is not going to give you the evidence. There are thousands of eyewitness statements instead.

We have been visited by extraterrestrials. Just face it.

Duncan Grant

(8,920 posts)
115. Michael Rennie was ill the day the earth stood still...
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 03:13 AM
Jul 2023

But he told us where we stand.
And Flash Gordon was there
In silver underwear.
Claude Raines was the invisible man…

moniss

(9,056 posts)
66. Maybe.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:49 PM
Jul 2023

But one of the failings of humans is to think that in order for something to exist it must be detectable by our senses or limited detection methods/hardware. We keep listening for electronic signals, radio waves etc. because that is what we know. Well humans there are planets and systems far older than Earth and to look at our own evolution as beings over many thousands of years and not think that "beings" evolving over many millions or billions of years wouldn't be way past radio waves for example is the height of stupidity and hubris. We keep talking about looking for "communication" or "contact" but expect to experience it by our own definitions. There may have been all kinds of "communications" coming our way but we don't have the ability for now to perceive them. Look at how little we knew or were capable of discerning 200 years ago compared to now.

So because our capabilities currently limit us to being conveyed in a vehicle or ship we assume that other intelligent life would do the same. Maybe. But by limiting our thinking/perception in the way I've described we may well miss what in fact has already happened and the irony is that somewhere there may well be some other intelligent form of life that is trying to communicate with us by methods they know and understand but that we do not perceive as such. It may be as perplexing and frustrating for them to receive no response from us just as we listen in vain to radio waves etc. without result. But as sure as you can count on a Republican to be stupid you can also count on the idea that 200 years from now (should we survive) our descendants will look back and marvel at how little we knew compared to them. Hopefully any of those trying to contact us will understand and keep trying despite our seeming to be "deaf and blind". But we need to open our minds to developing not just better "receivers" for means we already use for perception but to open our minds to the possibilities of more than light, electricity and radio waves.

At least that's what they told me the last time they visited.

Snackshack

(2,587 posts)
67. I wholeheartedly agree.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 06:50 PM
Jul 2023

They came when all we had were basically sticks and stones to throw at them.

Weapons grade fissile material changed all that.

Now they stand back and watch. Every now and then they need a little closer inspection e.g. the “Tic Tac” incident.

That’s it. They don’t give 2 💩’s about us as great grandma used to say (she had no filter). They just don’t want us to spread.

electric_blue68

(26,856 posts)
87. I loved that book. Supposed to be making it into a movie. A bit of a tease - this is *not* your...
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 08:59 PM
Jul 2023

average humanoid intelligence. Very interestingly thought out. 👍

ancianita

(43,307 posts)
90. Me, too. It would be an amazing film if Hollywood could do it.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 09:14 PM
Jul 2023

But then came Jackson, who stayed true to the details, spirit and epic sweep of the Lord of the Rings. CGI has done a lot for sci fi. But to portray the alien in Project Hail Mary? that would take some doing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Hail_Mary


electric_blue68

(26,856 posts)
91. Definitely a whole lotta computing power for that alien! ...
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 09:19 PM
Jul 2023

I read LOTR at around 12 yrs old after one of my favorite aunt's gifted me The Hobbit.


I loved Peter J's LOTR films! Got see them all on the big screen more than once. Esp the last one in Imax! 👍🧡

ancianita

(43,307 posts)
92. Found this. Glad that Matt Damon is the lead, since his mom was a teacher.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 09:29 PM
Jul 2023

Or Ryan Gosling, as the case may be.
Just the idea of us being able to go to Tau Ceti, the how and why, and the alien he meets, is amazing.




orangecrush

(30,261 posts)
72. Our species
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 07:05 PM
Jul 2023

Are imprisoned and chained to this planet.

Our biological composition makes interplanetary travel impossible for us. (Except perhaps to Mars).

Was there an alien race that was so warlike and murderous, that they were defeated, and marooned here, or perhaps had their DNA spliced to primates knowing we would evolve, and our only hope is to grow out of our violent, selfish ways?

That's another interesting thing about AI.

Machines, thinking machines can be made that will be capable of interplanetary travel.

Perhaps even a biological human brain/machine hybrid, that can be constantly renewed by a similar process used now to create meat from animals without killing them. The brain would never die.

The trouble is, by the time the thousands of light years have passed for such a craft to reach its destination, we will have brought about our own extinction.

Response to AndyS (Reply #78)

Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin

(135,729 posts)
79. Or you can take the Stephen Hawking POV on aliens
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 07:28 PM
Jul 2023
Stephen Hawking Warns Us to Stop Reaching Out to Aliens Before It's Too Late

When the potential of intelligent alien civilisations comes up in conversation, it's usually about the search. How will we find them? Where are they? Are they there at all? What actions should we take if – or when – we find them, or they find us?

Well, according to physicist Stephen Hawking, we should probably stop trying to contact them at all, because reaching out to advanced civilisations could put humanity and Earth in a pretty risky situation. And the bad news is, we've already been broadcasting our location to the Universe for years.

Hawking's warning comes in a new online film called Stephen Hawking's Favourite Places, which shows the famed scientist in a CGI spacecraft called the SS Hawking exploring his favourite places in the Universe.

-snip-

Despite Hawking's extraordinary effort to find intelligent life in the Universe, he is one of the most outspoken critics of actually trying to communicate with them, an act that he says would potentially endanger humanity, because a distant alien civilisation might view us as inferior, weak, and perfect to conquer.

https://www.sciencealert.com/stephen-hawking-warns-that-we-might-not-want-to-reach-out-to-aliens

Can't say he didn't have a point. Look how we treated less advanced civilizations on our planet.

Red Mountain

(2,344 posts)
80. Man's tryin' to keep us down.....
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 07:41 PM
Jul 2023

Not to worry. We have a secret weapon....

This is a documentary.




Quixote1818

(31,155 posts)
81. Got to thinking about this. If they are watching us then they would have killed Trump off. LOL
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 07:42 PM
Jul 2023

Xolodno

(7,350 posts)
88. I know this is for shits and giggles...but...
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 09:00 PM
Jul 2023

...its actually a pretty good hypothesis. Watching us from afar to see if we get our act together or destroy ourselves and they turn the planet into a space archeological dig. Perhaps rehabilitate the planet for the remaining plant and animal life, minus us of course.

And I think its down right naive to think they use propulsion technology to traverse long distances. They would probably use some sort of "folding space" or some sort of version of what we call teleportation to travel. Our minds just haven't just imagined it yet or we haven't advanced far enough to understand the capability.

Renew Deal

(85,168 posts)
98. It is VERY risky for them to make contact.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:01 PM
Jul 2023

Because we will instantly want to know how they did it and if we solve that problem, we are a threat.

Xolodno

(7,350 posts)
120. Precisely.
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 06:23 PM
Jul 2023

The first thing we would probably build would be warships. We are way too war like.

Renew Deal

(85,168 posts)
95. That is one of the theories.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 09:51 PM
Jul 2023

The theory is that we're too dumb to deal with them. The theory is that to them we are basically the equivalent of ants to humans.

 

DemocraticPatriot

(5,410 posts)
99. I guess you're a "Trekkie" ???
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:05 PM
Jul 2023

LOL "The Next Generation" and all the rest...

Which movie was that, where we achieved a particular speed of rocket travel,
which forced them to recognize and contact us? lol


From what I saw of the UFO shows on the History Channel,
it now seems somewhat plausible to me
that we were "planted" here by them--

and mistook them for gods....


Personally, I am rather disappointed how we have lost momentum in the exploration of space,
since the Kennedy challenge got us to the moon before the end of the 60s
(when I was a small child)

Oh well...





 

Snooper9

(484 posts)
103. First sentence, numbers are wrong
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 10:13 PM
Jul 2023

Billions not Millions- Everything after that is a false dichotomy.

you should listen to this though while drinking a (drink of choice)

ecstatic

(35,075 posts)
112. lol. I would not have asked how you know this, but now I have to
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 01:35 AM
Jul 2023

because of the last line in your OP. Are you from another planet?

ETA: Don't bother answering because your answer won't be believed regardless. lol

librechik

(30,957 posts)
119. I think they are here to teach us how to think in quantum physics terms as a population.
Sun Jul 30, 2023, 01:56 PM
Jul 2023

Like learning a foreign language to the point where you are dreaming in that language. If we could do what they do, we could also travel the universe.

Yes, I saw "Arrival." That's the story, more or less.

AKwannabe

(6,890 posts)
124. I had so much fun reading in this OP!
Fri Aug 25, 2023, 03:56 PM
Aug 2023

Hilarious and worth the time I spent with over a hundred replies.



You have had some DUzzzy! OPs the last few days. Can’t believe I missed this one July 29 but then I remembered was traveling.

Be safe out there! 😉

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Enough b.s. about UFOs. H...