Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
122 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
It's pretty disgusting how many people are minimizing murder, torture, rape, and kidnapping. (Original Post) BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 OP
Not surprising to me. The target was a Jewish state. Marius25 Oct 2023 #1
It is not claudette Oct 2023 #10
They were offered a 2 state solution since before Israel existed Marius25 Oct 2023 #11
I'm not that familiar claudette Oct 2023 #14
Why bring that up now? BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #20
+100 Mossfern Oct 2023 #31
This is such horsesh*t. Jirel Oct 2023 #21
Lol, no they aren't. Marius25 Oct 2023 #33
So, Israel's government can never, ever be criticized because Bettie Oct 2023 #68
This. onecaliberal Oct 2023 #88
The amount of criticism is completely out of proportion Mosby Oct 2023 #100
I think Netanyahu is a right wing criminal and a piece of shit. Sky Jewels Oct 2023 #107
+1 MorbidButterflyTat Oct 2023 #110
Totally agree with you. All who favors Starbucks should be aware that a percentage of each cup akbacchus_BC Oct 2023 #118
If your criticize Starbucks you're anti-coffee! maxrandb Oct 2023 #120
This is an interesting post. GhostHunter22 Oct 2023 #113
You're proving my point. Nothing Israel has done is as bad as Iran or Russia or North Korea Marius25 Oct 2023 #114
All criticism of Israel is necessarily antisemitic? That's convenient. Bok_Tukalo Oct 2023 #35
I didn't say all criticism is Antisemitic, I'm saying the Anti-Israel hate Marius25 Oct 2023 #39
here's what you said - cab67 Oct 2023 #89
Please define anti-semitism when Palestinians are semites and cally Oct 2023 #76
Agreed MayReasonRule Oct 2023 #83
Antisemitism exclusively refers to hate and discrimination against Jews. Marius25 Oct 2023 #85
Here is the State Department definition sarisataka Oct 2023 #98
an absolute "no" on this. cab67 Oct 2023 #84
I've got the same family arrangement. Ligyron Oct 2023 #96
Not yet - she's 7. cab67 Oct 2023 #101
Not minimizing Mossfern Oct 2023 #2
We're all against it LiberaBlueDem Oct 2023 #3
I'm not surprised. roamer65 Oct 2023 #4
It's one of those sad reminders that anti-Semitism infects both the right and left tritsofme Oct 2023 #5
I don't see claudette Oct 2023 #6
I see justification Mossfern Oct 2023 #7
Deflection and both-siderism in this thread already AZSkiffyGeek Oct 2023 #8
Sometimes claudette Oct 2023 #12
It's in the context Mossfern Oct 2023 #27
What? claudette Oct 2023 #34
That poster said NOTHING like what you are acussing them of obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #52
I must have totally missed their point Mossfern Oct 2023 #56
I am NOT Hamas. I have compassion for ALL INNOCENT people. I can't control your comprehension onecaliberal Oct 2023 #90
Wait, what? Mossfern Oct 2023 #94
Hamas has just murdered hundreds in cold blood out of hatred. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #28
I was watching the BBC DemocratSinceBirth Oct 2023 #15
Me neither. Emile Oct 2023 #9
Exactly BuddhaGirl Oct 2023 #17
Also ignoring MorbidButterflyTat Oct 2023 #74
Thank you for making this point. It can't be said enough. onecaliberal Oct 2023 #92
YW MorbidButterflyTat Oct 2023 #111
I've seen it here many times in the last few days mcar Oct 2023 #22
Can you provide links to them? Emile Oct 2023 #23
No, I don't have time mcar Oct 2023 #24
This message was self-deleted by its author Emile Oct 2023 #25
Call outs are against the DU TOS. former9thward Oct 2023 #48
I'm not negatively calling out anyone. Emile Oct 2023 #58
You're asking other people to violate the TOS with call outs Marius25 Oct 2023 #59
You are forgetting the word negatively. Emile Oct 2023 #60
Cute. former9thward Oct 2023 #65
You asking another poster to do so. former9thward Oct 2023 #64
People post links to other DU discussions all the time MorbidButterflyTat Oct 2023 #75
The poster I was replying to asks for specific call outs. former9thward Oct 2023 #77
Don't bully me MorbidButterflyTat Oct 2023 #112
I see a straw man being assaulted! The minimizing if any is of those slaughtered in Gaza! Alexander Of Assyria Oct 2023 #79
Bibi LIHOP tenderfoot Oct 2023 #13
The Israeli government deliberately allowed Hamas to murder and kidnap innocent women and children? AZSkiffyGeek Oct 2023 #18
Post removed Post removed Oct 2023 #29
No, it isn't -- just like saying the Bush Administration did the same about 9/11 isn't Anti American obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #54
My BIL asserts Pres Johnson LIHOPPED the Tet Offensive Torchlight Oct 2023 #41
I'm sick of the conspiracy theories. Cha Oct 2023 #115
No one is doing that obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #16
+1 Celerity Oct 2023 #26
If they're not to be conflated... BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #30
Of course, that is logical obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #42
When someone is discussing topic A and someone else brings up topic B... BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #49
You would have to ask the conflators what their motivation is. Celerity Oct 2023 #72
You are in Sweden, right? obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #45
Yes, in Sweden, and I grew up in London, after being born in Los Angeles and my parents then Celerity Oct 2023 #61
That's not my impression. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #32
He is a fascist, and he had intel this would happen and let it happen anyway obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #46
So let me understand this. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #53
Thank you for proving my point obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #55
No, I don't think I proved your point. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #57
I think you and I Mossfern Oct 2023 #62
Thank you. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #70
This! MN2theMax Oct 2023 #36
I VERY rarely comment on I/P issues, because I always get called anti semitic or it is implied I am obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #50
Funny, Mossfern Oct 2023 #67
I think we are all desensitized by what we watch on tv Tree Lady Oct 2023 #19
I'm not.. I don't have a tv.. Cha Oct 2023 #51
I care too especially because I have a friend Tree Lady Oct 2023 #73
Just wait till you see the justification for ethnic cleansing and genocide. Bok_Tukalo Oct 2023 #37
And utilizing methods that make Plausible Deniability kid's play. Torchlight Oct 2023 #38
There are some Jeremy Corbyn types, unfortunately. BannonsLiver Oct 2023 #40
Christians apologizing for their Bible? Stardust Mirror Oct 2023 #43
For the record, I'm not calling anyone anti-Semitic. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #44
It's not that simple inthewind21 Oct 2023 #95
Why is "deliberately killing civilians is bad" not that simple? BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #104
It Sure As Hell Is. It's Sickening. Cha Oct 2023 #47
Message auto-removed Name removed Oct 2023 #81
Gee, I haven't seen that. Fiendish Thingy Oct 2023 #63
it's pretty disgusting that Israel's leaders have kept their people at war since 1967 GenXer47 Oct 2023 #66
This is exactly what I'm talking about. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #69
Wow! Mossfern Oct 2023 #71
Israel kept their people at war since 1967?? onenote Oct 2023 #91
Very glib responses you will see. boston bean Oct 2023 #99
Yes, it is. I dont think Israel is innocent by any means but.. honest.abe Oct 2023 #78
I don't think anyone is for rape and murder. I also don't think anyone is for a nation being ZonkerHarris Oct 2023 #80
So you are against the creation and existence of the state of Israel. onenote Oct 2023 #93
Good catch. The use of 75 (1948) and not something that would have meant 1967 is telling. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #108
This comment is exactly what I'm talking about. BlueCheeseAgain Oct 2023 #105
What nation was occupied for 75 years? AZSkiffyGeek Oct 2023 #106
Yeah it's pretty disgusting. boston bean Oct 2023 #82
Exactly obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #86
+1 MorbidButterflyTat Oct 2023 #97
Wow those are some heavy accusations. edisdead Oct 2023 #87
There are none obamanut2012 Oct 2023 #109
Anti-Semitism is a universal evil. nt LexVegas Oct 2023 #102
Explaining or contextualizing is not minimizing or justifying terror. maxsolomon Oct 2023 #103
You can always tell one of those responses ripcord Oct 2023 #116
Why? ExWhoDoesntCare Oct 2023 #117
It's pretty disgusting how any discussion of the thousand year history of the Israel/Palestine issu maxrandb Oct 2023 #119
This thread is worthless without you posting examples of DUers maxrandb Oct 2023 #121
i hate netanyahu with my entire being moonshinegnomie Oct 2023 #122
 

Marius25

(3,213 posts)
1. Not surprising to me. The target was a Jewish state.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:46 PM
Oct 2023

This always goes back to Antisemitism. It doesn't matter how much people deny it, their criticism of Israel is always grounded in Antisemitism. The fact that Jews have to get enhanced police protection in the US and Europe right now proves that. Jews in the US and Europe are not Israeli and have nothing to do with Palestinians.

 

claudette

(5,455 posts)
10. It is not
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:55 PM
Oct 2023

Antisemitism to express compassion for innocents who die in a war that they did not choose. Just as Jews (many flesh and blood in my own family) have nothing to do with Palestinians, there are many innocent Palestinians who have nothing to do with Israel.

Hamas is a terrorist group. A two-state solution might have prevented this horrible outcome of hatred by those who feel oppressed.

 

Marius25

(3,213 posts)
11. They were offered a 2 state solution since before Israel existed
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:56 PM
Oct 2023

and Arabs/Palestinians always reject it. So it was never going to happen when only one side has ever supported it.

 

claudette

(5,455 posts)
14. I'm not that familiar
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:59 PM
Oct 2023

with all the meetings they had about it, but I do recall that President Clinton worked hard at that. It's just so sad.

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
20. Why bring that up now?
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:05 PM
Oct 2023

Why can't people denounce terroristic crimes without bringing up something else? Why, when hundreds of innocent civilians have just been murdered in cold blood, do people have to bring up offenses carried out by somebody else entirely?

Most of my Jewish and Israeli friends can't stand Netanyahu. Is it okay to kill them because of something their government did?

Jirel

(2,369 posts)
21. This is such horsesh*t.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:05 PM
Oct 2023

There is no state that is beyond criticism. There are many religious states in the world, though only one is Jewish. Those states are criticized by many for good reason. There are also people who criticize those states because of religious bigotry alone or in part. It is not anti-Islamic to criticize the horrifying treatment received by women in Afghanistan. It is not antisemitic to criticize the very real oppression of Palestinians in their homeland by Israel. It is, however, intellectually dishonest to equate criticism of Israeli political and military choices with being anti-Jewish or blaming Jews for the actions of distinct government actors. It’s as stupid as MAGAts claiming that anyone who doesn’t support unlimited gun rights is anti-American.

 

Marius25

(3,213 posts)
33. Lol, no they aren't.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:13 PM
Oct 2023

The UN has put more resolutions against Israel than every other country on Earth combined, including Russia, North Korea, Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, etc.

Arabs have something like 20 ethnostates under their control, but the only one that ever gets complained about is the tiny little Jewish state surrounded by enemies.

The anti-Jewish bias is so freakin obvious, and all Jews see it for what it is.

Bettie

(19,704 posts)
68. So, Israel's government can never, ever be criticized because
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:48 PM
Oct 2023

um, reasons.

It sure isn't because all of their actions are beyond reproach.

 

Mosby

(19,491 posts)
100. The amount of criticism is completely out of proportion
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 06:09 PM
Oct 2023

There are more reporters and NGOs in Israel per capita than any other country in the world. There is an entire industry of websites that demonize Israel. The UN passed 16 anti-israel resolutions last year, Russia was second with 6. How can that be explained other than antisemitism?

 

Sky Jewels

(9,148 posts)
107. I think Netanyahu is a right wing criminal and a piece of shit.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 06:43 PM
Oct 2023

That doesn't make me anti-Semitic.

akbacchus_BC

(5,830 posts)
118. Totally agree with you. All who favors Starbucks should be aware that a percentage of each cup
Tue Oct 10, 2023, 06:24 AM
Oct 2023

sold goes to Israel. Netanyahu is taking advantage of Russia's invasion of Ukraine as the focus is on Ukraine. Netanyahu is bent on destroying Palestine by continuing to occupy its land. I sometimes wonder what is the purpose of the UN?

 

GhostHunter22

(95 posts)
113. This is an interesting post.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 08:45 PM
Oct 2023

Curiously “the UN has put more resolutions against Israel than every other country on Earth combined”, and the “…tiny little Jewish state surrounded by enemies” is the only ones complained about.

Gosh, I wonder why. It couldn’t possibly be their decades long habit of stealing land and/or killing and subjugating countless innocent Palestinian civilians over multiple generations.

Nope - gotta be anti-semitism.

Not a single American tax dollar should go to Israel for military reasons, and it sickens me that we enable them and allow them to get away with literal murder - while any (righteous) attack on them is met with ‘they have the absolute right to defend themselves’.

I stand with the innocents lost to the Israelis - and my surname name ends in stein. My (half) Jewishness does not blind me to the blood thirst that permeates the ‘Jewish’ state.

If that adds up to my somehow being anti-semitic, then so be it.

 

Marius25

(3,213 posts)
114. You're proving my point. Nothing Israel has done is as bad as Iran or Russia or North Korea
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 08:46 PM
Oct 2023

Also you're literally defending ISIS-level terrorists attacking Israel right now. What Hamas did has zero justification. Absolutely none.

Bok_Tukalo

(4,540 posts)
35. All criticism of Israel is necessarily antisemitic? That's convenient.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:14 PM
Oct 2023

Makes it easier to marginalize anyone who may take issue with that nation's actions.

 

Marius25

(3,213 posts)
39. I didn't say all criticism is Antisemitic, I'm saying the Anti-Israel hate
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:18 PM
Oct 2023

is rooted in Antisemitism.

Saying the Israel government is oppressive and does bad things isn't Antisemitic.

Saying "Palestine should be free from river to sea" is, because it means the destruction of Israel and Jews living there. Or saying Israel is a bunch of European colonizers oppressing the native people is Antisemitic.

cab67

(3,749 posts)
89. here's what you said -
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:44 PM
Oct 2023

" It doesn't matter how much people deny it, their criticism of Israel is always grounded in Antisemitism."

If we're overreacting, it's because it really did look like you said any criticism of Israel reflects antisemitism.

I do apologize if I overreacted. But hopefully, you can see why some of us might have had reason to do so.


cally

(21,868 posts)
76. Please define anti-semitism when Palestinians are semites and
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 04:53 PM
Oct 2023

Have almost identical DNA. I am not anti-Jew but I am disgusted by the apartheid practiced by Israel. I am also disgusted by Hamas and their atrocities.

 

Marius25

(3,213 posts)
85. Antisemitism exclusively refers to hate and discrimination against Jews.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:16 PM
Oct 2023

That's how languages work.

Palestinians practice apartheid too. As does Egypt. The only reason Israel gets so much crap over everyone else is because it's mostly Jews.

cab67

(3,749 posts)
84. an absolute "no" on this.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:14 PM
Oct 2023

A lot of us criticize US policy. That doesn't make us anti-american.

Israel, like any other country, has made policy errors. That's because its leaders have been error-prone human beings.

I acknowledge that the current situation was started by Hamas, and that Hamas must be destroyed. I happen to think cutting power to Gaza will backfire, not because the Gaza population somehow deserves power, but because antagonizing a community is a good way to bolster support for the wrong people. I am thus capable of supporting Israel in its current struggle while disputing some of the tactics its government is deploying in that effort.

For what little it's worth - I was raised Catholic, but my wife is Jewish, and we're raising our daughter in that tradition. (This isn't "I've got Jewish friends, so I can't be anti-semitic;" I'm explaining that Judaism is a very important part of my life.) I thus take personal exception whenever a criticism I might level against Israeli policy is boiled down to antisemitism.


Ligyron

(8,006 posts)
96. I've got the same family arrangement.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 06:04 PM
Oct 2023

Raising the kids as Jews was the deal agreed to allowing us to marry and her to have a Jewish marriage ceremony at the temple. Which was a lot of fun btw, with dinner and a great band!

Jewish weddings tended to be a much bigger affair than the many Christian weddings I've attended.

Done a Bat Mitzah yet?

cab67

(3,749 posts)
101. Not yet - she's 7.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 06:13 PM
Oct 2023

I attended multiple bar/bat mitzvahs in junior high (lived in northern New Jersey at the time), and several in recent years for my wife’s extended family.

She’s not our biological child and is of Mexican heritage. So she’ll have both a bat mitzvah and quinceneanera.

LiberaBlueDem

(1,167 posts)
3. We're all against it
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:47 PM
Oct 2023

Especially Russian activities for the last 18 months.

Just republicans who are minimizing it

tritsofme

(19,900 posts)
5. It's one of those sad reminders that anti-Semitism infects both the right and left
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:50 PM
Oct 2023

in American politics.

 

claudette

(5,455 posts)
12. Sometimes
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:57 PM
Oct 2023

I think people mistake compassion for innocents as "justification" for the what the terrorist group does to those they hate. I don't understand why it's not clear.

Mossfern

(4,716 posts)
27. It's in the context
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:08 PM
Oct 2023

So Hamas has compassion for innocents?
I'm not understanding this.

Compassion for Palestinians justifies Hamas actions?
Innocent people are tortured and killed by Hamas because Hamas has compassion for Palestinains?
Do you know how Hamas treats some Palestinians?

 

claudette

(5,455 posts)
34. What?
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:14 PM
Oct 2023

I never said that compassion for innocent Palestinians justifies ANY horrible actions of Hamas. So you're saying innocent Palestinians don't deserve compassion because of how Hamas treats them?

I'm outta this conversation. Some people just cannot understand that one can walk and chew gum at the same time. Despise what Hamas did to innocent Israelis and feel compassion for the innocent Palestinians who will now suffer because of it. bye

obamanut2012

(29,369 posts)
52. That poster said NOTHING like what you are acussing them of
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:28 PM
Oct 2023

You literally just proved their point. Well done!

Mossfern

(4,716 posts)
56. I must have totally missed their point
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:33 PM
Oct 2023

Can you explain?

The OP is bemoaning the minimization of the terrorists actions - I replied that it was justification more than minimizing and the poster spoke about expressing compassion.

Compassion for whom?

 

onecaliberal

(36,594 posts)
90. I am NOT Hamas. I have compassion for ALL INNOCENT people. I can't control your comprehension
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:46 PM
Oct 2023

of things that are not black and white.

Mossfern

(4,716 posts)
94. Wait, what?
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:55 PM
Oct 2023

Did I claim that you're Hamas?
Please do not attack me personally, I have not attacked you at all.

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
28. Hamas has just murdered hundreds in cold blood out of hatred.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:08 PM
Oct 2023

And you bring up compassion for another group of people entirely. Of course people will think you're minimizing or justifying their actions. Why else would you bring it up now? Why don't you express compassion for how Native Americans were treated by white settlers? Or how the Japanese Americans were interned by the federal government in World War II?

DemocratSinceBirth

(101,852 posts)
15. I was watching the BBC
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:59 PM
Oct 2023

And a former minister, I forget of what, said there is action and context with action being Hamas's barbarism and the context being the unresolved conflict. He said now is the time to focus on the action. I thought that was a great way of putting it.

BuddhaGirl

(3,708 posts)
17. Exactly
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:01 PM
Oct 2023

What Hamas has done is horrific, no one is minimizing it or justifying it.

But to some unfortunately, it's a black and white issue, ignoring the historical perspective. That is sad. And to bring it up is somehow seen as "justifying" or "minimizing" or "both-siderism."

MorbidButterflyTat

(4,512 posts)
74. Also ignoring
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 04:49 PM
Oct 2023

the human perspective.

Hamas does not represent Palestinians.

Like MAGAts do not represent Americans.

Response to mcar (Reply #24)

MorbidButterflyTat

(4,512 posts)
112. Don't bully me
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 07:52 PM
Oct 2023

The post to which you are referring must have been deleted.

So post thread links instead of bullying posters with DU TOS.

23. Can you provide links to them?



That was the original request. You don't have to slam it down the poster's throat.
 

tenderfoot

(8,982 posts)
13. Bibi LIHOP
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 02:58 PM
Oct 2023

My personal opinion is not Anti-Semetic or Anti-Israel or Anti-Jewish State.

It is however very Anti-Benjamin Netanyahu. He's had a hard on for this for decades.

AZSkiffyGeek

(12,744 posts)
18. The Israeli government deliberately allowed Hamas to murder and kidnap innocent women and children?
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:03 PM
Oct 2023

And that's not anti-Semitic

Response to AZSkiffyGeek (Reply #18)

obamanut2012

(29,369 posts)
54. No, it isn't -- just like saying the Bush Administration did the same about 9/11 isn't Anti American
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:31 PM
Oct 2023

Several countries have stated they gave Bibi INTEL about this.

Torchlight

(6,830 posts)
41. My BIL asserts Pres Johnson LIHOPPED the Tet Offensive
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:20 PM
Oct 2023

and Roosevelt Pearl Harbor, and Eisenhower Wacht am Rhein. He tells me that since they're only opinions (as "I think apples are delicious" are only opinions) it requires zero evidence to support the assertions.

Celerity

(54,408 posts)
26. +1
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:08 PM
Oct 2023

There is a concerted effort by some to conflate supporting Palestinians and/or criticising Israeli actions against them (the illegal settlements/land theft in the West Bank for example) with support of Hamas and its horrific actions.

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
30. If they're not to be conflated...
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:11 PM
Oct 2023

Then why are they bringing it up now? Was anyone expressing this at anywhere near the same level last week? If not, then bringing it up now is specifically because of Hamas's attack.

obamanut2012

(29,369 posts)
42. Of course, that is logical
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:21 PM
Oct 2023

Why would we talk about I/P issues randomly in GD?

Why are YOU accusing folks of conflating it is the actual question, when we are not.

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
49. When someone is discussing topic A and someone else brings up topic B...
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:27 PM
Oct 2023

One naturally assumes that that person thinks A and B are related.

Celerity

(54,408 posts)
72. You would have to ask the conflators what their motivation is.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 04:11 PM
Oct 2023

Many times in my life (not speaking about DU and much of this happened in the US whilst I was attending uni there, although some of it happened in London and elsewhere as well, including here in Stockholm) I have run into people who try to deny that the West Bank settlements are illegal, that is was anti semitic to say they were illegal, and that basically 100% (or damn close) of any evil action in the greater Israel area was all done or caused by the Palestinians, that the Israelis did little to nothing wrong, and even if the Israelis did do something that many outsiders said was wrong, that they (the Israelis) had the right to do basically anything if they said it was self-defence and/or was in order to fulfil extreme interpretations of Zionist manifest destiny.

You will find that type of thought (and even more extreme manifestations of it) amongst many parts of the Netanyahu coalition in Israel and the overall Jewish diaspora, but it is not strictly limited to just the Likudniks and their allies.

obamanut2012

(29,369 posts)
45. You are in Sweden, right?
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:22 PM
Oct 2023

Folks in the US do not understand how differently the I/P issues are duiscussed in news outside of teh US bubble. I was really surprised the first time I realized this when I was in London.

Your post is well said.

Celerity

(54,408 posts)
61. Yes, in Sweden, and I grew up in London, after being born in Los Angeles and my parents then
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:42 PM
Oct 2023

moving back to London when I was less than 2 years old. I did live in the US again for several years whilst I read for my MBA in Los Angeles. After that was over, we (my now wife and I) returned to London, and then moved to Stockholm a short time before I joined DU in summer 2018.

I am racially mixed to an extreme degree, with ancestry that includes Swedish (from my father) and then from my Bajan (Barbados) mother: black African, English, Scottish, Chinese, East Indian, Sephardic Portuguese Jewish, and Lebanese.

I am basically WWIII (minus Russian ancestry) on a genetic level, lolol, although I prefer to look at it as world peace via a blending of many major human backgrounds.

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
32. That's not my impression.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:13 PM
Oct 2023

Personally, I can't stand Netanyahu. But I don't see why bringing him up in the hours after hundreds of innocents were slaughtered at point blank rage in cold blood is really necessary.

obamanut2012

(29,369 posts)
46. He is a fascist, and he had intel this would happen and let it happen anyway
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:24 PM
Oct 2023

What he has done to Israelis AND Palestinians is beyond troubling.

He is the leader of Israel, of course people are bringing him up.

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
53. So let me understand this.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:29 PM
Oct 2023

Person A: "Hamas invaded Israel and killed hundreds of civilians."

Person B: "Netanyahu has done bad things."

What do you conclude from what Person B said? That they were just changing the subject? Or that they think what Netanyahu has done is somehow related to what happened?

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
57. No, I don't think I proved your point.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:35 PM
Oct 2023

Unless I'm completely misunderstanding what your point is.

Is your point that people talking about the Israeli government now are in fact connecting it to the murders of innocent Israeli civilians? Because that's my point. That for some reason, these people can't condemn murder without casting blame elsewhere.

Mossfern

(4,716 posts)
62. I think you and I
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:42 PM
Oct 2023

think and speak a different language than some people here. I understand your point completely and am also wondering if I've misunderstood something.

Yes people can have compassion for several different things at once, but I don't see how that is the point of this thread.
I thought it was about a brutal and inhumane in your face torture with a grin event.

MN2theMax

(2,257 posts)
36. This!
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:16 PM
Oct 2023

There is a lot of dividing going on around this issue, feels like it is being exploited by those who would like to divide us. Most folks on DU seem pretty like-minded, so accusations about antisemitism and other name calling and nastiness is out of place here. Just my opinion.

obamanut2012

(29,369 posts)
50. I VERY rarely comment on I/P issues, because I always get called anti semitic or it is implied I am
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:27 PM
Oct 2023

Just because I loathe the leadership of Israel as much as I do Trump and Modi, and believe Palestinians deserve more civil rights. That somehow makes me pro-Hamas and anti Israel.

Mossfern

(4,716 posts)
67. Funny,
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:47 PM
Oct 2023

I abhor the same people and wish the Palestinian people a peaceful and fruitful resolution. I'm Jewish and born the same year as Israel. I was a Rabin supporter and wept hot tears when he was assassinated by a Right Wing Orthodox nut job.

So I, for one will not label you as antisemitic.

Tree Lady

(13,282 posts)
19. I think we are all desensitized by what we watch on tv
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:04 PM
Oct 2023

and read and the fact that in our lifetime its not here in America where we live except 9-11.

Cha

(319,076 posts)
51. I'm not.. I don't have a tv..
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:27 PM
Oct 2023

and I'm very sensitive to what I read that's happening to Israelis being Attacked by the fucking HAMAS Terroist Org.

Tree Lady

(13,282 posts)
73. I care too especially because I have a friend
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 04:48 PM
Oct 2023

who lives in Jerusalum. I was talking about a lot of people don't care unless it's happening to them.

Bok_Tukalo

(4,540 posts)
37. Just wait till you see the justification for ethnic cleansing and genocide.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:17 PM
Oct 2023

Although I get the feeling you already have.

Torchlight

(6,830 posts)
38. And utilizing methods that make Plausible Deniability kid's play.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:17 PM
Oct 2023

I'd use the specific word, 'rationalization' to characterize the handful I've come across today (not necessarily here).

Stardust Mirror

(685 posts)
43. Christians apologizing for their Bible?
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:22 PM
Oct 2023

what a basis for morality, amirite?

(I know that's not what you were referring to, but if the shoe fits..)

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
44. For the record, I'm not calling anyone anti-Semitic.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:22 PM
Oct 2023

It's fine to criticize Israeli government policy. The people I know who dislike the Netanyahu government the most are Israelis themselves. (Just like the people who hated Trump the most are Americans.)

I just don't understand why we can't condemn murder without any conditions. Why we can't condemn Hamas's killing of children without adding a "but... " at the end. The people killed weren't soldiers. They weren't even "collateral damage." They were shot at point blank range by people deliberately. It can't be that hard to condemn that, without saying "but their government ...".

 

inthewind21

(4,616 posts)
95. It's not that simple
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:59 PM
Oct 2023

and not that black and white. My what short memories people have. Every perceived slight against the US is followed by a landslide of "but, but but" as justification at the end for countless reactions and even waging full blow wars.

Response to Cha (Reply #47)

Fiendish Thingy

(23,236 posts)
63. Gee, I haven't seen that.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:42 PM
Oct 2023

Of course, I’m not looking for it either.

Sadness and outrage, that’s what I’m seeing.

 

GenXer47

(1,204 posts)
66. it's pretty disgusting that Israel's leaders have kept their people at war since 1967
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:46 PM
Oct 2023

Don't you ever wonder why Israel's leaders, who hold all the cards, likes to remain in a state of perpetual war?
And for that matter, why it continues to lie about its nuclear weapons (which are everybody's business).
So who's really minimizing murder, torture, and kidnapping? These actions are the vocabulary of war. Israel's leaders have never seemed too worried about it, and even today, they still aren't.
I don't know the reasons for these decisions but it's a good guess that the fascist threads running through Israel would rather keep some sort of card to play - a casus belli - for a total annihilation of their neighbors. This is their big chance!
And while a few DU'ers tolerate the scolding and accusations of racism, Israel flattens whole buildings, kills scores of families in the blink of an eye, and starves children unlucky enough to be born in the world's largest open air prison.
Disgusting, indeed.

BlueCheeseAgain

(1,983 posts)
69. This is exactly what I'm talking about.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 03:50 PM
Oct 2023

Excusing the deliberate slaughter of civilians because of the actions of other people.

onenote

(46,142 posts)
91. Israel kept their people at war since 1967??
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:47 PM
Oct 2023

What do you think Israel should have done so that its people weren't "in a state of perpetual war"?

Some facts: Between 1948 and 1967, there were dozens of state-sponsored terror attacks against Israelis. Should Israel have surrendered to prevent the 1967 War? And when the 1967 War happened, should Israel have surrendered and ceased to exist in order to prevent their people from being kept at war?

And after the 1967 War, those state sponsored attacks on Israel continued leading up to the 1973 Yom Kippur War, launched against Israel by Egypt and Syria among others. Should Israel have surrendered so as to prevent their people from being kept at war?

And in 2005, Israel removed its Defense Force installations from Gaza and evicted over 9000 Israelis from settlements in Gaza. Two years later, Hamas took over the Gaza Strip from the Palestinian Authority. Consistent with their stated desire to destroy Israel, Hamas began launching rockets and engaging in other terror attacks on Israeli civilians. Israel responded not by invading and re-taking control of Gaza, but by a defensive maneuver -- blockading Gaza. Did Gazans respond by trying to evict Hamas? Did Hamas respond by moderating its behavior? No. But somehow, it is Israel's fault that it has been attacked by others for the entirety of its 75 year history.

boston bean

(36,931 posts)
99. Very glib responses you will see.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 06:07 PM
Oct 2023

They act like they know the history but actually know bupkiss.

A lot of ignorance masquerading as righteousness running rampant.

 

honest.abe

(9,238 posts)
78. Yes, it is. I dont think Israel is innocent by any means but..
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:09 PM
Oct 2023

I would never ever condone the things Hamas is doing no matter how wrong Israel has been. The slaughter of innocent people, women, children, elderly and kidnapping, rape, torture.. its completely barbaric.

 

ZonkerHarris

(25,577 posts)
80. I don't think anyone is for rape and murder. I also don't think anyone is for a nation being
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:11 PM
Oct 2023

Occupied by a foreign power for 75 years

onenote

(46,142 posts)
93. So you are against the creation and existence of the state of Israel.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:48 PM
Oct 2023

Just come out and say it directly. Not everyone will understand your math.

boston bean

(36,931 posts)
82. Yeah it's pretty disgusting.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 05:13 PM
Oct 2023

They are conflating Hamas terrorism with the plight of innocent Palestinians.

It is ignorant and wrong.

maxsolomon

(38,728 posts)
103. Explaining or contextualizing is not minimizing or justifying terror.
Mon Oct 9, 2023, 06:21 PM
Oct 2023

Hamas' atrocities were DESIGNED to outrage, DESIGNED to spark this exact recrimination-filled debate in the West.

They mean to provoke an Israeli over-reaction in Gaza, to provoke widespread unrest in the West Bank, and to provoke a Palestinian death toll in the 1,000s if not 10s of 1,000s.

They're likely to succeed. Look what Al Qaeda accomplished w/ 9/11.

 

ExWhoDoesntCare

(4,741 posts)
117. Why?
Tue Oct 10, 2023, 04:11 AM
Oct 2023

The abrahamic religions do far worse than minimizing those things; they support them. Have you not read the books they follow?

Even the supposed "nice" demigod advocates not only torture--but also *permanent* torture of those who disagree with him. He only discusses it multiple times. Furthermore, he supports the laws saying it's okay to rape women and children captured in war. He supports the murder of witches, homosexuals and disobedient children. He said so--in Matthew 5:18, when he declared all of those laws to be in existence until the end of the earth. Which is still here, in case you hadn't noticed.

And I've seen people right here on this forum celebrating their demigod using violence over a non-violent offense (moneylenders at the temple), and wishing to send people to receive permanent torture. It's like they don't comprehend the level of utter sadism and cruelty it takes to torture someone ten minutes, never mind forever. They certainly haven't cared enough to think through that it's what hell really means--endless sadism and cruelty,

For a thought crime, no less.

So why be surprised when the majority in this country adhering to such religions don't have a problem with murder, torture, rape and kidnapping? Why do you expect anything different? Me, I expect people who follow books promoting those things to be okay with all of it, enough to minimize it. If they weren't okay with it, they wouldn't belong to any group that has any of those books as its "moral" foundation.

QEbloodyD.

maxrandb

(17,428 posts)
119. It's pretty disgusting how any discussion of the thousand year history of the Israel/Palestine issu
Tue Oct 10, 2023, 08:36 AM
Oct 2023

Gets you labeled as "minimizing murder, torture, rape and kidnapping".

Kind of reminds me how after 9/11, if a group were discussing how we should "turn the Middle East into glass", and someone said; "hey, there may be some unintended consequences to that", they were labeled "terrorist supporters".

I mean, I guess we could point out the fact that there are no posts minimizing murder, torture, rape and kidnapping, but that would be like trying to convince a MAGAt that Donnie Dipshit lost the election.

"Minimizing murder, torture, rape and kidnapping"?

Is that you Vlad?

maxrandb

(17,428 posts)
121. This thread is worthless without you posting examples of DUers
Tue Oct 10, 2023, 08:52 AM
Oct 2023

"minimizing murder, torture, rape and kidnapping"

Would be interesting to see just what type of "specific" posts meet your definition of "minimizing murder, torture, rape and kidnapping"?

If you can't find "specific" posts that meet your definition, you should delete this post and apologize.

I am really interested, because if posters are minimizing "murder, torture, rape and kidnapping", they should lose site access.

Let me know so I can report these posts "minimizing murder, torture, rape and kidnapping" to the moderators.

moonshinegnomie

(4,022 posts)
122. i hate netanyahu with my entire being
Tue Oct 10, 2023, 09:03 AM
Oct 2023

and how the israelis treat palestinians is horrible.


but this attack by hamas is so over the line that as far as im concerned if israel levels gaza to eliminate hamas im not opposed it it.
hamas is nothing more than a terrorist organization. the people in tha gaza strip also support them and were then one to first elect them. so I really cant feel sorry for them.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»It's pretty disgusting ho...