Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Beastly Boy

(13,283 posts)
Wed Dec 6, 2023, 03:00 PM Dec 2023

IDF finds one of the largest Gaza weapons stockpiles ever near school, hospital

The IDF said that it had found one of the largest weapons stockpiles in the history of its operations in Gaza, an arsenal containing hundreds of missiles, launchers, long-range rockets, anti-tank missiles, UAVs, and explosives.

The massive weapons cache was located near a hospital and a school, the IDF reported.

Who stores RPG missiles, anti-tank missiles, explosive devices, long-range missiles, grenades and UAVs at a school and a medical facility in Gaza? The answer: Hamas.Hamas doesn’t hide their terrorism. Stop excusing it. pic.twitter.com/az4Es0Vh5v
— Israel Defense Forces (@IDF) December 6, 2023


The terror munitions were discovered by the 50th battalion of the 460th brigade. The IDF said that some of the munitions were detonated on site while others were sent for further investigation.

https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/defense-news/article-776786
70 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
IDF finds one of the largest Gaza weapons stockpiles ever near school, hospital (Original Post) Beastly Boy Dec 2023 OP
This is why it is so difficult JohnSJ Dec 2023 #1
It's even more difficult when the IDF reports weapons found "NEAR " a school and hospital sjr2323 Dec 2023 #53
and without explicitly saying it, that is exactly what I was saying. Thanks JohnSJ Dec 2023 #56
Good job. Proves my point. Ground forces/special forces are the way to ferret out Hamas. brush Dec 2023 #2
Ground Forces Go In Once Air Power Creates A Permissive Environment The Magistrate Dec 2023 #3
I don't recall you advocating ground forces in the vicinity of schools and hospitals. Beastly Boy Dec 2023 #6
All you have to do is reseach my posts before our recent tangles. I've been advocating ground/special forces... brush Dec 2023 #9
There will be no less crying if there is armor and artillery instead of airstrikes TheKentuckian Dec 2023 #12
That's not my perception. Ground forces have tanks, Javelins, Himars guided rockets etc, and artillery, way more... brush Dec 2023 #14
Well sign up and go to the front. Swede Dec 2023 #21
No one with any sense thinks it'll be easy, but for your information, that's what the IDF is doing right now. brush Dec 2023 #28
40 IDF soldiers have died in Gaza since. Swede Dec 2023 #35
And so would the number of innocent Palestinians be too, now 16,000 and counting. brush Dec 2023 #38
In war you pound your enemy with artillery or bombs to weaken them. Swede Dec 2023 #41
No matter how many innocent non-combatants are killed, huh, with nowhere to go but where... brush Dec 2023 #48
You're not getting it. Israel is in a war with Hamas. Swede Dec 2023 #58
"..innocent Palestinians be too, now 16,000 and counting" wow, so now they are all innocent, zero Hamas deaths? EX500rider Dec 2023 #59
Of the 16,000 dead (probably many more buried in the rubble... brush Dec 2023 #68
Why would I "read it & weep"? I didn't vote for Likud & don't even live in Israel EX500rider Dec 2023 #70
Looks like Hamas is hiding with civilians again: yagotme Dec 2023 #67
Fair enough. All that gear will also bring down buildings TheKentuckian Dec 2023 #62
Ok, old friend, I've long advocated for ground forces to be the ones to root out Hamas from their tunnels. brush Dec 2023 #37
Ok, if this is a challenge, as it appears to be, I will bite. Beastly Boy Dec 2023 #39
Oh, man, you're disappointing me. The ground forces have the Hamas mastermind cournered... brush Dec 2023 #40
Are YOU hearing what you are saying? You are not even pretending to respond to what I posted. Beastly Boy Dec 2023 #43
Forget it. As I said, I've advocated ground forces to ferret out Hamas and they're doing that now... brush Dec 2023 #47
You've advocated ground forces to ferret Hamas out of the tunnels, Beastly Boy Dec 2023 #51
Hopeless. Take no care to not just kill innocent non-combatants in the airstrikes. Hopeless. brush Dec 2023 #55
Yep, US military agrees (link) uponit7771 Dec 2023 #15
It's not a one or the other situation.... Happy Hoosier Dec 2023 #23
So you're advocating to keep blasting innocent non-combatants to smithereens with bombs ? brush Dec 2023 #25
I'm saying it's necessary to take Hamas off the board. Happy Hoosier Dec 2023 #31
FYI: I advocated that ground forces/special forces be deploy to root out Hamas from their tunnels... brush Dec 2023 #34
Yes, they are doing now that the battlefield is prepped. Happy Hoosier Dec 2023 #42
Properly prepped against who, the innocent civilians, 65 percent or more women and children... brush Dec 2023 #44
Having empathy for the less fortunate... Happy Hoosier Dec 2023 #52
Didn't I just write in my post (NOT HAMAS, MIND YOU), and in my other posts on this thread I've said... brush Dec 2023 #54
Okay... fair enough, but.... Happy Hoosier Dec 2023 #57
Read it and weep: Netanyahu/Likud incompetence. brush Dec 2023 #66
I see little evidence urban ground warfare is any kinder to civilians or infrastructure EX500rider Dec 2023 #60
Perhaps. The text below is from this link. brush Dec 2023 #65
Haven't Been So Shocked, Sir, Since The Sun Rose In The EAST This Morning The Magistrate Dec 2023 #4
Good on IDF.. Less Weapons for Butchers of HAMAS to Cha Dec 2023 #5
As I peruse the internet, I'm sure it won't be long before I start reading conspiracy theories * Oopsie Daisy Dec 2023 #7
Rec.. TY Cha Dec 2023 #8
All of this! ShazzieB Dec 2023 #10
Such as: False claims dead Palestinian baby was 'a doll' go viral on social media in the Israel-Hamas disinformation war Celerity Dec 2023 #16
They properly retracted the story. Yet people still harp on it while ignoring Hamas' propaganda efforts * Oopsie Daisy Dec 2023 #17
disinfo in war is almost always a 2 way street Celerity Dec 2023 #18
LOL Oopsie Daisy Dec 2023 #19
nothing in that post was gish-gallop Celerity Dec 2023 #20
LOL! As I said, I'm not blind... nor am I stupid. Oopsie Daisy Dec 2023 #22
this is not a rebuttal: Celerity Dec 2023 #24
LOL! Thanks for proving and illustrating my previous points. Oopsie Daisy Dec 2023 #26
petitio principii Celerity Dec 2023 #30
LOL! Oopsie Daisy Dec 2023 #32
I Confess, Ma'am, That Often I Do Skim Your Lengthier Comments The Magistrate Dec 2023 #45
What in this post is gish galloping? obamanut2012 Dec 2023 #46
Stick around. Watch closely. You'll see. Oopsie Daisy Dec 2023 #49
At this point, I even wonder if it matters. Behind the Aegis Dec 2023 #11
Thats Israel's fault. nt LexVegas Dec 2023 #13
Any information on who is supplying these weapons? thucythucy Dec 2023 #27
From manufacturers of the worlds arms Kennah Dec 2023 #36
Please let there be video. redqueen Dec 2023 #29
Great news! .. Think. Again. Dec 2023 #33
Well, that's bad but mcar Dec 2023 #50
Gazas population density is similar to Londons... ExciteBike66 Dec 2023 #61
And then the local government would make civilians subject to Articles 28 and 29 of the 4th Geneva Convention Beastly Boy Dec 2023 #63
If That Government Neither Levied War Against Israel, Nor Tolerated 'Private Enterprise' In That Line The Magistrate Dec 2023 #64
See all the white areas? countryside EX500rider Dec 2023 #69
 

sjr2323

(28 posts)
53. It's even more difficult when the IDF reports weapons found "NEAR " a school and hospital
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 03:49 PM
Dec 2023

and a response says: Who stores RPG missiles, anti-tank missiles, explosive devices, long-range missiles, grenades and UAVs at a school and a medical facility in Gaza?

It may seem a small grammatical nitpick but one could with so many military bases all around this nation that weapons are stored or stockpiled NEAR a school or hospital. Imprecision is the stuff by which wars are prolonged. I am sure that in my home state of Delaware this is the case.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
2. Good job. Proves my point. Ground forces/special forces are the way to ferret out Hamas.
Wed Dec 6, 2023, 03:10 PM
Dec 2023

The air strikes just keep blowing civilian non-combatants to smithereens and creating piles of rubble with bodies buried in them.

I say get on with it and finish this war to eliminated both Hamas and Bibi's corrupt ass from power and to jail.

The Magistrate

(96,043 posts)
3. Ground Forces Go In Once Air Power Creates A Permissive Environment
Wed Dec 6, 2023, 03:13 PM
Dec 2023

When they have to create their own, there's little to choose in death and destruction between the two.

 

Beastly Boy

(13,283 posts)
6. I don't recall you advocating ground forces in the vicinity of schools and hospitals.
Wed Dec 6, 2023, 03:20 PM
Dec 2023

Or accepting the fact that Hamas hides their military assets there.

Before long, you might be telling us that using civilians as human shields is a bad thing...

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
9. All you have to do is reseach my posts before our recent tangles. I've been advocating ground/special forces...
Wed Dec 6, 2023, 03:47 PM
Dec 2023

Last edited Thu Dec 7, 2023, 11:08 AM - Edit history (1)

from the jump, along with my impartiality in acknowledging innocent civilians on both sides, while calling for stopping the air strikes from just blowing civilians to smithereens and creating piles of rubble with bodies buried under them (yes there's nuance to advocacy. It's not just about blowing innocent Palestinians away to get one or two terrorists while they're at it).

You might learn from that.

 

TheKentuckian

(26,314 posts)
12. There will be no less crying if there is armor and artillery instead of airstrikes
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 01:46 AM
Dec 2023

If the misconceptions is units will be fed into a meat grinder with rifles then that is delusional and is marching up to the line of a demand to maximize the Israeli body count.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
14. That's not my perception. Ground forces have tanks, Javelins, Himars guided rockets etc, and artillery, way more...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 02:10 AM
Dec 2023

way more superiority in weapons than what Hamas has with their hand-made rockets with no guidance systems. Israel has the latest in US weapons and Hamas has no match for them. Hamas will be the ones in the meat grinder.

Plus Israel and especially special forces have agility and the training needed to perform a job that just has to be done. Even if every structure in Gaza obliterated, the side with the weapons advantage then wins.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
28. No one with any sense thinks it'll be easy, but for your information, that's what the IDF is doing right now.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 11:06 AM
Dec 2023

Blasting civilian housing to rubble might satisfy Netanyahu's guilt over his failure in not detecting the Oct. 7 attack, but it doesn't actually destroy Hamas operatives hiding in their tunnels, or does it get back the over 100 hostages still in captivity.

Swede

(39,495 posts)
35. 40 IDF soldiers have died in Gaza since.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 12:07 PM
Dec 2023

If they hadn't bombed, the numbers would be far greater.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
38. And so would the number of innocent Palestinians be too, now 16,000 and counting.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 12:28 PM
Dec 2023

It's apparent that impartiality is a foreign concept to you, as is empathy for innocent civilian lives.

And fYI: It's just been reported that IDF ground forces think they've cornered the Hamas mastermind of the Oct. 7 attack in Khan Younis, a city in the southern part of Gaza.

And as I've said, ilots in jets overhead with bombs certainly can't do that. They can bomb the shit out of a lot of innocents told to go there by the IDF though.

Swede

(39,495 posts)
41. In war you pound your enemy with artillery or bombs to weaken them.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 02:43 PM
Dec 2023

Then your side does not get higher casualties. That's the way wars are fought. Don't accuse me of lack of empathy of impartiality.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
48. No matter how many innocent non-combatants are killed, huh, with nowhere to go but where...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 03:13 PM
Dec 2023

the IDF told them to go for safety?

Swede

(39,495 posts)
58. You're not getting it. Israel is in a war with Hamas.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 04:38 PM
Dec 2023

In a war you pound your enemies til they are weak, then you attack. This saves the lives of your soldiers. It's war.
Hiroshima and Nagasaki might stir your memory of war.

EX500rider

(12,583 posts)
59. "..innocent Palestinians be too, now 16,000 and counting" wow, so now they are all innocent, zero Hamas deaths?
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 04:41 PM
Dec 2023
 

brush

(61,033 posts)
68. Of the 16,000 dead (probably many more buried in the rubble...
Fri Dec 8, 2023, 04:41 PM
Dec 2023

how many do you estimate to be Hamas terrorists?

Or are they most likely hiding in their tunnels?

The point being that the vast majority of the dead are women, children and non-combat-aged old men.

Oh, and btw: Read it and weep: Netanyahu/Likud incompetence.
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=18511654

"Is Israel’s eagerness to shatter Gaza a product of the same incompetence that led to the massive failure of the Israeli military to counter Hamas’s attack on October 7, the plans for which ended up in the hands of Israeli military and intelligence officials more than a year earlier?"

EX500rider

(12,583 posts)
70. Why would I "read it & weep"? I didn't vote for Likud & don't even live in Israel
Fri Dec 8, 2023, 04:52 PM
Dec 2023

And as I have said before, we have zero idea how many dead are Hamas since they count their dead as civilians and I trust their number even less, the US couldn't give you up to date war dead in a active war zone in the US, I highly doubt Hamas is super efficient and could.

yagotme

(4,135 posts)
67. Looks like Hamas is hiding with civilians again:
Fri Dec 8, 2023, 03:47 PM
Dec 2023
And fYI: It's just been reported that IDF ground forces think they've cornered the Hamas mastermind of the Oct. 7 attack in Khan Younis, a city in the southern part of Gaza.


Why is this cretin in the south? Weren't CIVILIANS told to go south? Hamas was supposed to stay in the north to be killed. Oh, wait a minute. Human shields.
 

TheKentuckian

(26,314 posts)
62. Fair enough. All that gear will also bring down buildings
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 05:32 PM
Dec 2023

just the same, all this does is slacken the pace.

I don't see the point and believe the handwringing will be exactly the same.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
37. Ok, old friend, I've long advocated for ground forces to be the ones to root out Hamas from their tunnels.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 12:23 PM
Dec 2023

I think you know as well as I do that bomb strikes won't do that. Pilots in jets overhead can bomb the shit out of a lot of innocents told to go there by the IDF though.

Now back to ground forces, you may have heardby now it's just been reported that IDF ground troops think they've cornered the Hamas mastermind of the Oct. 7 attack in Khan Younis, a city in the southern part of Gaza. That's probably the only way to get to them in the tunnels

As far as using civilians as human shields by Hamas, come on, that's a definite NO. What I'm against is bombing the shit out of buildings/hospitals/housing to maybe get a terrorist who ventured outside of his tunnel hideout.

You probably also know Israeli hostage families blasted Netanyahu yesterday for concentrating on just getting Hamas instead of negotiating to get the over 100 hostages back. They're furious with Netanyahu for suggesting flooding the tunnels with sea water to get Hamas out. Can you believe that?

He must be going a little nuts with his guilt for his intel failure on the Oct. 7 attack/subsequent revenge and over-retaliation motive. Israel needs to ditch him asap, even before the war is over.

What say you?


 

Beastly Boy

(13,283 posts)
39. Ok, if this is a challenge, as it appears to be, I will bite.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 02:02 PM
Dec 2023

No, I don't think I know as well as you do that ground forces are to be the ones to root out Hamas from their tunnels. In fact what I know is exactly the opposite of what you think you know.

I don't think you know as well as I do that any sane military doctrine calls for air strikes prior to ground offensives against fortified enemy positions.

I don't think you know as well as I do that a good portion of Hamas casualties, including their top commanders, as well as much of their military infrastructure were destroyed in air strikes, not ground offensives.

I don't think you know as well as I do that IDF rarely sends soldiers into the tunnels to drive Hamas out. In fact, they destroy most of the shafts they find above ground that lead into tunnels, to keep Hamas in.

I don't think you know as well as I do that Hamas militants were escaping the tunnels at the time of cease fire, when IDF took no action against them.

And, if you are referring to Sinwar as Hamas mastermind of the Oct. 7 attack, there is no indication that he is hiding in the tunnels, only that IDF knows where he is. It is just as likely that he will be taken out by air strike as not.

And by now not even you can delude yourself with fantasies of random terrorists hiding in schools and hospitals: https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/defense-news/article-776786

You must be better friends with Netanyahi than I am, though. I have no effing clue about him going a little nuts, or his guilt trip. However, I don't think anyone in Israel cares about what you think Israel needs to do.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
40. Oh, man, you're disappointing me. The ground forces have the Hamas mastermind cournered...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 02:33 PM
Dec 2023

in Khan Younis but you keep up with the conventional old thinking of blast the shit out of innocent civilian targets.

Come on, are you hearing what I'm saying, IDF ground forces have the Hamas mastermind cournered. Ground forces. Haven't you heard this? You've got fo adjust your thinking. Where's your empathy for innocent civilians and hostage families?

Even the Israeli hostage families want emphasis on getting the hostages back instead of bombing every building in Gaza to smithereens. They want Bibi and his tactics out and their relatives back through concentration on negotiations/prisoner exchange.

You disappoint me in thinking this is a challenge. It's seeking a solution, not body counts.

 

Beastly Boy

(13,283 posts)
43. Are YOU hearing what you are saying? You are not even pretending to respond to what I posted.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 02:49 PM
Dec 2023

Ground forces have the mastermind's home surrounded. What the hell is all the babble about innocent civilians? And what the hell does it have to do with ground forces driving Hamas out of the tunnels? And what the hell does this have to do with adjusting my thinking or my empathy with the hostages?

Just try reading this word salad aloud to yourself when your mind clears up a bit. You would be embarrassed.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
47. Forget it. As I said, I've advocated ground forces to ferret out Hamas and they're doing that now...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 03:09 PM
Dec 2023

and have the mastermind cornered, but you're not getting it. They did their job, what they're trained and paid for, what I've advocated for instead of wholesale bombings.

But you still seem to be about just turning Gaza into rubble, no matter how many non-combatants are killed?

Hopeless.

 

Beastly Boy

(13,283 posts)
51. You've advocated ground forces to ferret Hamas out of the tunnels,
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 03:39 PM
Dec 2023

forsaking the air strikes. A totally ridiculous advocacy that betrays ignorance of well established tactics of engaging entrenched enemy. Now you are trying to weasel out of what you actually said, and then falling back on some wild speculations of what I seem to be about, without an iota of a basis to show for it.

And I am the one not getting it? No, I am getting it allright!

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
55. Hopeless. Take no care to not just kill innocent non-combatants in the airstrikes. Hopeless.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 04:10 PM
Dec 2023

The Biden admin has cautioned Netanyahu to take care to limit as much as possible civiiian casualties, as has the UN, it's Sec'y General calling for a Security Council resolution to such an effect.

You however, think differently. Again, Palestinian non-combatants and Hamas terrorists are not the same.

Happy Hoosier

(9,535 posts)
23. It's not a one or the other situation....
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 09:53 AM
Dec 2023

If you send ground forces into an area not prepped by airstrikes and artillery, they are walking in to a meat grinder. This is ESPECIALLY true in urban conflicts.

Combined arms is the foundation of a modern military offensive.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
25. So you're advocating to keep blasting innocent non-combatants to smithereens with bombs ?
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 10:57 AM
Dec 2023

That's the best possible solution? Thinking human beings can't come up with something that doesn't take as many innocent lives than that?

And btw, on "Morning Joe" today an Isreali couple whose son is a hostage are outraged at Netanyahu for his obvious over-retaliation/guilt/failure complex in not stopping the Oct. 7 attack, that he can't concentrate on anything but getting Hamas instead of doing everything/negotiating to get the over 100 hostages back.

This was this morning. and echoes what happened yesterday when Israeli citizen yelled at Bibi for not getting the hostages back. Also they're still outraged that the his government took hours to respond to the Oct 7 attack...literally hours and nothing was done whil they hid in safe rooms and closets.

Happy Hoosier

(9,535 posts)
31. I'm saying it's necessary to take Hamas off the board.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 11:30 AM
Dec 2023

I'm saying that I think any solution which leaves Hamas in power is not viable. Hamas has said what they want... to repeat Oct 7 over and over again until every Jew in "Palestine" is dead or driven into the sea.

I mean, even in your own post, you're not offering a real alternative. I understand the compassion and even outrage. But I think people must understand that Oct 7 means Hamas cannot remain.

Hamas will not release all the hostages, IMO. They lose what leverage they have.

And make no mistake... this kind of horror was always Hamas's best defense. By embedding themselves in the civilian population and infrastructure, they have always planned on this kind of reaction ensuring their resiliance. The question is, are we willing to let them succeed?

That's not to say I think Israel can do whatever it wants. I think the US should continue to pressure Israel to allow more aid in, to be more focused in their efforts, and to make it clear we will not accept permanent relocation of the Palestinian population.

I also think the U.S. needs to begin public efforts for organizing and supporting post-conflict recovery and reonstruction efforts.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
34. FYI: I advocated that ground forces/special forces be deploy to root out Hamas from their tunnels...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 12:01 PM
Dec 2023

which btw, the IDF is doing right now. It's just reported that they think they've cornered the Hamas mastermind of the Oct. 7 attack in Khan Younis, a city in the southern part of Gaza.

Pilots in jets overhead with bombs certainly can't do that. They can bomb the shit out of a lot of innocents told to go there by the IDF though.

Happy Hoosier

(9,535 posts)
42. Yes, they are doing now that the battlefield is prepped.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 02:46 PM
Dec 2023

Sending ground and Special forces inbto a zone that hasn;t been properly prepped is a very bad idea. They tried it in Gaza before and failed.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
44. Properly prepped against who, the innocent civilians, 65 percent or more women and children...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 02:58 PM
Dec 2023

with hardly any shelter? What the hell has happened to DU? I once thought of this place as a haven for progressives of like minds who had empathy for the less fortunate...like maybe innocent Palestinian civilians (NOT HAMAS, MIND YOU), but no, that is no longer the case here.

There's little impartiality here, it's all about blast the shit out of Gaza and to hell in any innocents in the way. In areas where they were told to go by the IDF by the way.

Happy Hoosier

(9,535 posts)
52. Having empathy for the less fortunate...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 03:46 PM
Dec 2023

... does not mean we can't see through the Hamas tactics.

And kindly stop telling me what I think, or passive aggressively strawmanning me.

Your screed does not represent my thinking AT ALL.
NO, it's NOT about just blasting Gaza to shit.

Let me ask this and save us some time:

Are you willing to to allow Hamas to remain in power in Gaza in order to reduce civilain casualties?

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
54. Didn't I just write in my post (NOT HAMAS, MIND YOU), and in my other posts on this thread I've said...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 04:04 PM
Dec 2023

Hamas must be eliiminated? Scroll thru and see for yourself. Eliminating Hamas doesn't have to include thousands of innocent non-combatants...so far 16,000 or so and counting.

Happy Hoosier

(9,535 posts)
57. Okay... fair enough, but....
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 04:33 PM
Dec 2023

... I simply do not buy your claim that you can just send in ground forces and Special Forces and root out Hamas.

Check out the Israeli experience 2014. This was a much more limited operation intened to target Hamas capability while limiting civilian casualties.

It failed, of course.

I agree that limiting civilian casualties is important. I also acknowledge that any urban operation of this scale will result in heavy civilian casualties.

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
66. Read it and weep: Netanyahu/Likud incompetence.
Fri Dec 8, 2023, 03:20 PM
Dec 2023
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=18511654

"Is Israel’s eagerness to shatter Gaza a product of the same incompetence that led to the massive failure of the Israeli military to counter Hamas’s attack on October 7, the plans for which ended up in the hands of Israeli military and intelligence officials more than a year earlier?"

EX500rider

(12,583 posts)
60. I see little evidence urban ground warfare is any kinder to civilians or infrastructure
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 04:48 PM
Dec 2023

I am sure the civilians of Stalingrad, Grozny, Fallujah, Mariupol, Taiz, etc would agree

Urban ground combat:

Stalingrad


Battle of Grozny-1999


Second Battle of Fallujah-2004


Popasna-Ukraine


Battle of Mariupol-Ukraine


Taiz-Yemen

 

brush

(61,033 posts)
65. Perhaps. The text below is from this link.
Fri Dec 8, 2023, 03:16 PM
Dec 2023
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=18511654

"Is Israel’s eagerness to shatter Gaza a product of the same incompetence that led to the massive failure of the Israeli military to counter Hamas’s attack on October 7, the plans for which ended up in the hands of Israeli military and intelligence officials more than a year earlier?"

Cha

(319,077 posts)
5. Good on IDF.. Less Weapons for Butchers of HAMAS to
Wed Dec 6, 2023, 03:17 PM
Dec 2023

to lob at Israel.

And, of Course the Sadistic Murderers have their weapons near schools and hospitals.. that's what has been Reported All Along.

Oopsie Daisy

(6,670 posts)
7. As I peruse the internet, I'm sure it won't be long before I start reading conspiracy theories *
Wed Dec 6, 2023, 03:32 PM
Dec 2023

* and other unfounded accusations. (ie: fake photos, planted evidence, photos from a different place, etc.)

Hamas is getting exactly what they wanted, and exactly what they deserve. Hamas doesn't care about civilian deaths. If they did, they wouldn't have attacked on the 7th. They wouldn't have broken the ceasefire. They wouldn't have hidden stockpiles of ammo near schools and hospitals. They wouldn't garrison with civilians.

They wouldn't rape, gang-rape, mutilate and murder-while-raping women.

Hamas = Isis = Taliban. They all need to be wiped from the face of the earth.

ShazzieB

(22,590 posts)
10. All of this!
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 01:09 AM
Dec 2023

From what I've read, Hamas is actually pleased when there are high civilian death tolls, because they can use that info to make Israel look bad.

I'm convinced that these murdering bastards truly don't give a good goddamn about how much suffering they cause for Palestinian civilians. They're the kind of zealots who only care about their "cause," which is to wipe out all the Jews in Israel and reclaim every square inch of the country for Palestine. They don't care how many Palestinians are killed, maimed, or subjected to hardship in the process.

Celerity

(54,409 posts)
16. Such as: False claims dead Palestinian baby was 'a doll' go viral on social media in the Israel-Hamas disinformation war
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 08:00 AM
Dec 2023



and earlier, this, another similar incident:

17/OCT/2023

Fact Check: Israel Govt Falsely Claims Photos of Slain 4-Year-Old in Gaza Are of a Doll

The claim by the state of Israel’s official X handle that the dead child shown in the viral videos/images is actually a doll is false.

https://thewire.in/world/fact-check-israel-govt-falsely-claims-photos-of-slain-4-year-old-in-gaza-are-of-a-doll













Oopsie Daisy

(6,670 posts)
17. They properly retracted the story. Yet people still harp on it while ignoring Hamas' propaganda efforts *
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 08:36 AM
Dec 2023

* and how Hamas has intentionally put innocent civilians, in harms way by staging in and under and around hospitals, by storing their weapons in/under/around schools and other public places, by bivouacking in/with and hiding among civilians. It seems that they're getting exactly what they wanted. Why no outrage about that? Hamas = Taliban = Isis and they could end this TODAY if they wanted to, they simply don't want to, do they?

FYI: Gish-gallop posts are a waste of my time and do not fool me. Beyond the subject line, I ignore needlessly long posts with multiple links and that contain images with oversized screen captures and text that's too small to read.

Celerity

(54,409 posts)
18. disinfo in war is almost always a 2 way street
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 08:52 AM
Dec 2023

and you apparently do not understand the term gish-gallop

I only posted 2 links, 1 each for 2 articles

I posted no text from either article, just the title and the sub title

and the screenshots can be easily read via the most utterly basic of computer skills: right click and then select 'open image in new tab'

Celerity

(54,409 posts)
20. nothing in that post was gish-gallop
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 09:24 AM
Dec 2023
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop

During a Gish gallop, a debater confronts an opponent with a rapid series of many specious arguments, half-truths, misrepresentations, and outright lies in a short space of time, which makes it impossible for the opponent to refute all of them within the format of a formal debate.


In the past (most definitely not in this case however), I have posted some long replies that thoroughly laid out the case I was making at the time.

That said, none of the parts (which I provided links for with which to verify) of those long replies were 'specious arguments, half-truths, misrepresentations, and outright lies'.

Whilst those past replies were sometime copious in terms of the amount of individual components and information imparted, those components were integral and logically linked to the overarching point(s) I was making at that time.

Ergo, they were not gish-gallop,

Oopsie Daisy

(6,670 posts)
22. LOL! As I said, I'm not blind... nor am I stupid.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 09:41 AM
Dec 2023

I should also point out that pedantic posts do nothing to advance the discussion. I'll generally ignore those as well. It's been my observation that excessive pedantry (or any other attempt to monopolize or dominate by trying to create an impression of superior knowledge) can actually hinder effective communication and in the end, not contribute positively to the overall discussion. On a personal level, whether online or in person, I take less seriously individuals who use such tactics.

Celerity

(54,409 posts)
24. this is not a rebuttal:
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 10:57 AM
Dec 2023
LOL! As I said, I'm not blind... nor am I stupid.


It is just repetition of a previously made positing in support of your false claim that I engaged in gish-gallop in my first reply to you. My initial reply to you contained none of the elements of gish-gallop.

As for the rest, it is ironic that you chose to inject the concept of pedantry into the colloquy, when actual pedantry has been one of the more oft-used tactics employed by the same small group of posters with whom I most often have engaged in contentious debate with over my years here.

pedantry:

excessive concern with minor details and rules


My lengthy posts in the past were making big picture points, thoroughly fleshed out with hard evidence, and were not at all reliant on an obsession with minor (and often non-germane) details. Those replies of mine were often met with actual pedantry, obscurantism, and thread-based misdirection/water-muddying. A veritable cornucopia of sophistry, sometimes interspersed with ad hominem for added spiciness.

you said:

trying to create an impression of superior knowledge


Again, that is pejorative slanting of posts that simply contained a lot of factual evidence. I made no claims of superiority, I just laid out my case in a logical and documented manner. If my (at times) thoroughness of reply is a modus operandi that you take issue with, do realise that taking issue with that in no way is an actually effect rebuttal. It is just your personal opinion about style, and an attempt at diminishment of evidence that you may not like, done via the logical fallacy of an appeal to your personal feelings.

you said

On a personal level, whether online or in person, I take less seriously individuals who use such tactics.


That is your clear right to do so, but it is not of concern to me. I am not interacting with you in an attempt to curry favour from you, nor does your stance have the slightest effect on how I have, how I do, and how I will construct my posts and conduct myself on this board.

Oopsie Daisy

(6,670 posts)
26. LOL! Thanks for proving and illustrating my previous points.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 11:03 AM
Dec 2023

Perfect timing. I couldn't have done it better myself. That saved me a lot of time.

The Magistrate

(96,043 posts)
45. I Confess, Ma'am, That Often I Do Skim Your Lengthier Comments
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 03:00 PM
Dec 2023

I feel safe in doing so because you have shown yourself knowledgeable as you are industrious, and honest in your citations and representations.

Behind the Aegis

(56,108 posts)
11. At this point, I even wonder if it matters.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 01:22 AM
Dec 2023

Hamas could open a YouTube page and post videos of their deeds against women and children, and we would still see "but, Israel!" They could announce, "We have a nuke!" and still we would see, "Well, you can't oppress people and not expect this kind of response (actually written here in regard to Oct. 7th). They could take out ad space in the NY Times and, especially their mouthpiece propaganda news source, Al Jazeera Media Network, "We won't stop until all Israeli Jews are dead and gone, then global Jewry will be eradicated too", and still we would see excuses and "but, Israel".

Of course, my favorite are all the lies about how the world and the people supported Israel after Oct. 7th and those silly...um, er, Israelis "squandered" the world's good will.

redqueen

(115,186 posts)
29. Please let there be video.
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 11:06 AM
Dec 2023

All the mocking from young people of the footage from under the hospital could do with a responding dose of reality.

 

Think. Again.

(22,456 posts)
33. Great news! ..
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 11:33 AM
Dec 2023

...ground forces really are the best way to locate and ferret out substantial weapons caches while also limiting any civilian harm and structural damage to more focused targets, although I did think modern weaponry was more precise than what we've seen, I'm certainly not an expert on such things.

ExciteBike66

(2,700 posts)
61. Gazas population density is similar to Londons...
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 05:06 PM
Dec 2023

Even if hamas didn't exist, the local government would have to store weapons near all sorts of civilian infrastructure...

 

Beastly Boy

(13,283 posts)
63. And then the local government would make civilians subject to Articles 28 and 29 of the 4th Geneva Convention
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 07:17 PM
Dec 2023
ART. 28. — The presence of a protected person may not be used
to render certain points or areas immune from military operations.

ART. 29. — The Party to the conflict in whose hands protected
persons may be, is responsible for the treatment accorded to them
by its agents, irrespective of any individual responsibility which may
be incurred

https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/documents/atrocity-crimes/Doc.33_GC-IV-EN.pdf

That is assuming they don't use their civilians as human shields.

The Magistrate

(96,043 posts)
64. If That Government Neither Levied War Against Israel, Nor Tolerated 'Private Enterprise' In That Line
Thu Dec 7, 2023, 07:28 PM
Dec 2023

They could store the weapons anywhere without the least risk to civilians....

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»IDF finds one of the larg...