General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsFacebook Photo Of Woman At Tomb Of The Unknowns Sparks Outrage
I wonder what her username here is?

Lindsey Stone was visiting the Tomb of the Unknowns last month on a business trip when she posed for a picture next to a sign that reads silence and respect.
In the photo, Stone is pretending to yell and shes showing her middle finger.
The photo, taken by a co-worker, went viral and sparked thousands of angry comments.
Some of those comments were posted on the Facebook page of their employer, Living Independently Forever, Inc.,(LIFE) a non-profit organization in Hyannis that helps adults with disabilities on Cape Cod.
More... http://boston.cbslocal.com/2012/11/20/facebook-photo-of-plymouth-woman-at-tomb-of-the-unknowns-sparks-outrage/
Moral of the story... don't do stupid shit and upload it to FaceBook unless you want to suffer the consequences.
Better yet... stay off FaceBook altogether.

seabeyond
(110,159 posts)dmr
(28,705 posts)-..__...
(7,776 posts)wasn't that long ago that some here were mocking the "Old Guard" at Arlington National Cemetery.
LanternWaste
(37,748 posts)I suppose a simple mind would extrapolate from that the OP is indeed a picture of a DUer... and believe themselves not merely clever.
I imagine we all advertise our character in unintended ways.
obamanut2012
(29,126 posts)CreekDog
(46,192 posts)in order to make him look like a stereotype.
JustAnotherGen
(37,475 posts)Didn't he/she? Thanks for the reminder. Now I know what I'm dealing with.
CreekDog
(46,192 posts)Blue_Tires
(57,596 posts)since the "narrative" isn't playing out as he thought it would...
But I told him back then I'd have my day before it was all over...
liberalmuse
(18,881 posts)There are many DUer's here who have served in the military. I served. There are many DUers who support the military even though they don't support trumped up wars. To insinuate this stupid woman is a member of our community is beyond the pale.
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Why?
Electric Monk
(13,869 posts)He enjoyed defending Zimmerman for awhile and loves disparaging Rachel Maddow too.
Anyone else see a pattern of behavior?
The jury went 3-3 on his latest OP so expect this thread to stink up the place for awhile.
-..__...
(7,776 posts)Link?
Electric Monk
(13,869 posts)nt
rDigital
(2,239 posts)Electric Monk
(13,869 posts)NYC_SKP
(68,644 posts)In yer subthread!
dixiegrrrrl
(60,140 posts)thankfully.
Cali_Democrat
(30,439 posts)very obvious.
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,608 posts)JustAnotherGen
(37,475 posts)get the red out
(13,938 posts)A place where cute pet pictures are best.
Barack_America
(28,876 posts)Lest we forget, the Democratic party actually honors veterans.
aquart
(69,014 posts)Girl needs a dictionary.
gollygee
(22,336 posts)It is certainly not obvious by a long shot that she meant no disrespect. It looks incredibly disrespectful to me.
TheMadMonk
(6,187 posts)...thing that some people think is clever, and generally sinks like a stone on Cheezburger, because what might have been worth a mild chuckle first time around is hair tearingly annoying after the 30th or 40th copycat.
Atman
(31,464 posts)And would have broadcast on national tv as a comedy sketch.
.
Swamp Lover
(431 posts)crass is crass
sadbear
(4,340 posts)Smelling salt sales are skyrocketing. Along with fainting couches.
closeupready
(29,503 posts)Sheez. Journalists today just seem to lazily pick ever-lower hanging fruit for inspiration.
patrice
(47,992 posts)Count me in the last group.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)i wish i could remember this one for everytime i hear it.
perfect.
the same to you, woman.
patrice
(47,992 posts)seabeyond
(110,159 posts)and they refuse to believe.
i believe....
thank you.
snooper2
(30,151 posts)when people put your wipers up?
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Internet tough guys are funny.
patrice
(47,992 posts)I'm not playing in any high school popularity contest here, so I don't have to stop and think about who will/won't approve, like some others may do, before if I step into something on someone else's behalf.
sekha68
(36 posts)Honeycombe8
(37,648 posts)and posted it on FB for laughs, you probably would take that seriously.
Some things ARE serious.
You don't think that's a big deal? That's your right. It's also the right of her employer not to want someone like that working for him. If someone is that callous toward others, no telling what they will end up doing in the work place.
sadbear
(4,340 posts)She wasn't yelling (it's obvious from the picture) either.
Get over it. It was just a silly picture.
If that's disrespect, WTF are we doing supporting President Obama right now. And you know what I'm talking about. If that's disrespect, he's doing more to disrespect that cemetery than anyone else right now.
(And since I don't think it's disrespect, I can support President Obama with a clear conscience. Can you?)
Honeycombe8
(37,648 posts)The amount of time isn't the issue.
It's showing disrespect for the tomb of someone whose remains couldn't be identified. Yeah, that's real funny. It also shows disrespect to those who revere the tomb.
It's very disrespectful and very juvenile. Not someone I'd want working for me. Not mature enough to be trusted with business matters or the complicated social relations necessary in the work place.
It's silly to YOU. But what it means to YOU isn't really teh whole point, is it? It's that it is not silly to most others. It's not just about you.
But she should have known better. Sure there are too many people with corn ears up their crack, but there is also too many people like her who are totally clueless of the culture they are in.
Oh noes!
closeupready
(29,503 posts)it was the pizza delivery guy peeing on the front door of the woman who stiffed him out of his tip.
Today, it's some crazy photo that gets posted to Facebook, and suddenly, it's national news.
I mean, how lazy are journalists today that instead of getting out there and actually reporting about worthy subjects, modern journalism now is like 12-year-old's tattling on teacher's pet to mommy? Seriously.
This is a complete non-story.
stuntcat
(12,022 posts)ALL the REAL terrible things going on in the world, but this kinda stuff is what my fellow citizens bother about.
closeupready
(29,503 posts)for merit-worthy journalism and hardhitting news, IMO. Maybe Der Spiegel, too.
Brickbat
(19,339 posts)than go through the latest documents at city hall. And many editors don't have a clue. (I can say that; I was one.) "Face Book, you say? Thousands of people, you say? Why get down there, my boy!"
Chiyo-chichi
(3,927 posts)You're free to go if you don't like the company here.
2ndAmForComputers
(3,527 posts)is obvious.
bluestate10
(10,942 posts)MADem
(135,425 posts)people at a lower wage. That "LIFE" outfit is one of the worst going. They are abusive towards their employees and the parents who pay for their special needs kids to get a leg up in the world are getting fleeced by that shitty organization. Real bottom feeders running that joint...turnover, even in this tough economy, is way OTT.
GermanSmoker
(91 posts)I think the picture is funny. And the outrage about it just shows that too many people in the USA idolize the military.
glacierbay
(2,477 posts)and it's not idolizing the military, it's about respecting veterans of the military who served their country.
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Just because someone was in the military doesn't mean they are better then others.
Elitist and snobish is what it is.
glacierbay
(2,477 posts)It is not about idolizing, it's about respect.
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Anyone I ever respected was able to take a joke and never thought they were above the next person because of deeds done.
FBaggins
(28,613 posts)So why would anyone care if they had earned it?
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Should we all talk in hushed tones when we speak of the king?
Union Scribe
(7,099 posts)Yeah yeah, jury stone me. But what you call "silly guidlines" most civilized people call common decency. If you're not 6 years old, you have no excuse for not getting how to behave in a cemetery. You think you're exposing something about others, but all you're exposing is your own unimaginable ignorance. I have rarely been as disgusted by the attitudes of a DUer as I am with yours in this thread.
xfundy
(5,105 posts)I was on the jury for this post.
Poster needs to understand that the origin of the word "cretin" derived from "christian."
Nuff said.
pinboy3niner
(53,339 posts)And those of us who have friends or family buried there can hardly be mockingly dismissed as just being "dainty."
ronnie624
(5,764 posts)Are all cemeteries off-limits to jokes, in your opinion, or just the ones where military personnel are buried?
onenote
(45,963 posts)would you defend them?
ronnie624
(5,764 posts)It is also irrelevant to whether or not the corpses of military people are more deserving of reverence than the cadavers of the general public.
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,608 posts)ronnie624
(5,764 posts)People have been laughing about death for a very long time. We've just been conditioned by propaganda to take the deaths of soldiers much more seriously. Perhaps the exaggerated solemnity assists the elites in the manufacture of consent for their wars.
marions ghost
(19,841 posts)Firing her was stupid. Just fanned the flames. A warning was in order perhaps, but firing was way overkill.
Re. the reaction to it: Silencing someone over a stupid spontaneous gesture (which harmed nobody) is dangerous.
Do people around here not see how this is tied to silencing any dissonant expression you don't happen to agree with?
pinboy3niner
(53,339 posts)The question is, why are YOU introducing it?
I've never seen a post from you yet that I've disagreed with. Thanks for being here.
cordelia
(2,174 posts)rDigital
(2,239 posts)theHandpuppet
(19,964 posts)Thank you.
tabasco
(22,974 posts)A completely deserved and well-executed smackdown.
EPIC.
FBaggins
(28,613 posts)You obviously share a civility blind spot with the idiot in the picture.
AlexSatan
(535 posts)Yet, you should still still show appropriate respect.
underoath
(269 posts)patrice
(47,992 posts)How very very paternalistic of you.
Perhaps you should consider asking a few people what their reactions to this picture are and what their thoughts about US military are, that is, ****IF**** you're interested in the truth and not just trolling for hurt and outrage.
F- all bigots!
Have a nice day.
JoeyT
(6,785 posts)that didn't involve the military in any way, do you think the reaction to this picture would be the same?
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)glacierbay
(2,477 posts)It doesn't matter whether it's a military cemetary or a civilian cemetary, it's all the same to me.
JoeyT
(6,785 posts)I almost added a "To many of us I think it would be the same" at the end of the other post, but I could think of too many ways it could be taken badly.
ret5hd
(22,123 posts)Rex
(65,616 posts)and I am guessing global humiliation via the WWW has to sting some. People do stupid shit all the time, I'm not going to get all mad...as a matter of fact at one time I defended her right to do just what she is doing. No matter how stupid it looks. She has that right, that people died by the thousands indirectly so she could act like a clown on camera in a free country.
The employer is the one stuck in the middle. Hey what can they do? Some people have no class.
MadrasT
(7,237 posts)If narcissistic idiots are going to take pictures of themselves doing stupid shit and plaster it on Facebook for attention... well, enjoy the attention I guess.
underoath
(269 posts)Initech
(107,219 posts)Don't post pictures of you doing stupid shit on a public domain everyone can read. It's that simple.
patrice
(47,992 posts)bayareamike
(602 posts)She should've known that there is a huge difference between smoking under a no smoking sign and being disrespectful in a place that represents thousands of people who gave their lives for this country.
TorchTheWitch
(11,065 posts)It's why she did it.
trumad
(41,692 posts)She was making fun of the fucking sign.
I remember seeing a sign in San Fran that said "Hill". It was on a massive Hill.
Someone wrote "No Shit" on it.
Like I said---what the fuck is wrong with this Country?
patrice
(47,992 posts)FBaggins
(28,613 posts)Obviously there is little need for a sign that says "hill" on what is clearly a hill.
But just as obviously, there is a need for a sign reminding people to act in a respectful fashion... since this idiot felt that it was an appropriate place to take photos making fun of a sign. Quod erat demonstrandum
patrice
(47,992 posts)trumad
(41,692 posts)Fucking insane
FBaggins
(28,613 posts)Nobody egged her house or beat her up.
She just lost the ability to convince her employer that she was worth keeping around (and likely convinced many of her "friends" that she wasn't worth having as a friend).
MADem
(135,425 posts)It's kind of ironic...
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Should we put a no yelling sign at the Grand Canyon?
Echos of voices are disrespectful to the piece and quiet of nature.
FBaggins
(28,613 posts)If you're old enough to post online, you should be mature enough to tell the difference.
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Maybe the blind reverence is affecting your vision.
pinboy3niner
(53,339 posts)It's not just a "tourist site" like the Grand Canyon. Grieving families and friends come there every day to visit the graves of their loved ones or to attend new burials.
Some of my friends are buried there, including a best friend whose war trauma eventually led to suicide, and a roommate who was awarded the Medal of Honor posthumously after he sacrificed his life to save the lives of others.
I don't think a little respect for the dead and sensitivity to the feelings of their living families and friends is too much to ask.
coalition_unwilling
(14,180 posts)pre-Civil War plantation of Robert E. Lee. Confiscated as contraband of war by the Army of the Potomac soon after Virginia seceded. That has always struck me as deeply moving and deeply fitting.
pinboy3niner
(53,339 posts)When I first went to D.C. in '77 on a "D.C. Semester" program from USC, the Custis-Lee mansion was one of our first field trips. I ended up living near there for 16 years--shopping at the Ft. Myer PX and commissary, attending events there, visiting Arlington National Cemetery (and attending one interment of a friend there following his memorial service at a chapel on-post).
One of my Army Infantry OCS classmates was assigned to the Old Guard when he was commissioned, before he went to Vietnam. And the federal agency I worked for had its annual staff picnic at Ft. Myer once. (That was the time my young son, on being introduced to the head of my agency, told him he looked like Boss Hogg--and I suddenly saw my career flash before my eyes.
)
Yet for all my time there, I suspect you're more up on the detailed history of that place.
onenote
(45,963 posts)Just another fun loving jokester or behavior that is validly subject to criticism?
marions ghost
(19,841 posts)People have all kinds of opinions I disagree with. I don't feel it necessary to stifle them.
I save my energy for the real criminals and abusers in high places.
Union Scribe
(7,099 posts)I dunno, people who can't discern the time or place for obvious trite "humor"?
trumad
(41,692 posts)FBaggins
(28,613 posts)It isn't the sign that's stupid.
Union Scribe
(7,099 posts)One would hope the sign wouldn't even be necessary, but with the idiot in that picture and everyone like her I suppose it is.
NCTraveler
(30,481 posts)But this idiot makes it clear as to why the sign is necessary. Some people have no class.
a la izquierda
(12,224 posts)My grandfather served in WWII, and I'm married to a man whose family has had at least one male serve in every generation since the Revolution.
bluedigger
(17,382 posts)The hell with her.
patrice
(47,992 posts)clique.
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Lighten the fuck up, Francis'.
Military is above comedy. Bow before their superior being.
And before you crybabies start in on me, piss off, I have served.
LanternWaste
(37,748 posts)"military idolators clutching their pearls...."
I imagine when we have no argument other than criticism, we are often forced to attribute sentiments to others that are simply not there...
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)Better call for more whaaaambulances.
So many, I haz sads.
dawg
(10,777 posts)Even if you don't respect the military, at least respect the memory of those who were ground up in the wheels of war far before their time.
LP2K12
(885 posts)No.
We're all just human. Stupid happens.
Kingofalldems
(40,012 posts)freshwest
(53,661 posts)quinnox
(20,600 posts)the first amendment is the foundation of our country.
FBaggins
(28,613 posts)Amazing how few people understand that foundation. "Free speech" does not mean "no consequences for any kind for your personal expression"
Other residents of our free country are free to express their dissatisfaction with her behavior... including her employer.
quinnox
(20,600 posts)and sue their stupid asses to kingdom come.
FBaggins
(28,613 posts)You act as if she has a right to continued employement absent violating some law. In reality she has no grounds for a lawsuit unless she had a contract (or the company had employment policies) significantly more ammenable to such behavior than most of the state.
The employer is under no obligation to employ a person whose behavior (whether at work or off) damages the company's reputation.
She made the choice to put this out on FB. It was her actions alone that created a terrible situation for her employer - especially considering her line of work. If I were her employer I would terminate her as well.
If someone had taken a picture of her and her co-worker while they were taking the photo - and then posted it online - I would have some sympathy for her. That could at least be construed as a private moment. This was her to choice to broadcast this image of her to the world
WeekendWarrior
(1,437 posts)I agree that she's being an idiot and disrespectful, but the mob-like reaction is just as bad, to my mind. Unfriend her or ignore her. But demand she be fired? Ridiculous.
RedCappedBandit
(5,514 posts)She shouldn't lose her job.
MadHound
(34,179 posts)You could take pictures of yourself doing stupid stuff and nobody would care, much less see them. Now, in our brave new digital all connected world, your pictures of stupid stuff(or even not so stupid stuff), winds up on FB, being spread across the world, costing you your job or worse.
As for your comment about wondering which DUer this is, again, you were probably better off before the internet, where nobody could see the stupid shit you write.
well played
coalition_unwilling
(14,180 posts)ramapo
(4,772 posts)Yes this woman was obnoxious and very stupid. Why people post anything and everything to Facebook beyond me. But her job is her job and her life is her life. It is a scary place that this society is racing towards when your employment is based upon what you do when you are not in work.
Luminous Animal
(27,310 posts)-..__...
(7,776 posts)and the pic was taken by the CEO.
Regardless... once something like this goes viral, and the general public goes after the offender and that persons employer, the employers hand is forced to take some sort of action.
FBaggins
(28,613 posts)Of course it does.
This is a nonprofit organization that deals with adults with various mental disabilities. They specifically advertise that their staff provides a "nurturing and caring environment". Who they choose to employ certainly impacts the public's view of their ability to provide this nurturing/caring environment.
"Obnoxious and very stupid" doesn't fit that need. They absolutely could lose business because of her actions.
They're under no obligation to continue her employment.
"It is a scary place that this society is racing towards" the belief that you can do whatever you want and the rest of society has to enable that behavior.
PavePusher
(15,374 posts)22+ years USAF. So cry me a freakin' river.
glacierbay
(2,477 posts)30 years LE.
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)It is one thing to act a certain way on your own but when you are told what to do is totally different, the next thing they do is tell what to think, then what to say.
That is why I told the military to kiss my ass years ago and left.
PavePusher
(15,374 posts)TeeYiYi
(8,028 posts)... to be loud AND disrespectful in front of a sign that requests the opposite. She's being a non conformist. She doesn't deserve to lose her job over it.
I did drugs once next to a sign that said Drug Free Zone. It happened quite by accident but my friend laughed her ass off.
TYY
Blue_Tires
(57,596 posts)right up until the moment you actually do it
And I've had a *lot* of those moments in my life, since I find a lot of things funny that most average people don't (luckily those moments were before the age of social media)
But this just seems immature and juvenile--I don't know how old the woman is, but it's hard to image this behavior from anyone past high school...FWIW, if I was a high-schooler on a field trip or something, I could easily see myself pulling this stunt or something similar (along with almost any of my friends from that time)
TeeYiYi
(8,028 posts)...but I still don't believe she should lose her job over it.
Facebook is scary.
TYY
Blue_Tires
(57,596 posts)but on a business trip where you're representing your employer? Not smart...
TeeYiYi
(8,028 posts)Are you really suggesting that the company somehow owns her every waking moment of that trip? I disagree.
Also, did she reference the company in the post to her own facebook page? I'm not sure. I'm asking...
TYY
On Edit: I went back to the OP and found this: "Some of those comments were posted on the Facebook page of their employer..." That does seem to change a few things; that and the fact that a co-worker took the pic. I still don't think she should be fired but her biggest problem seems to be facebook.
patrice
(47,992 posts)Skip Intro
(19,768 posts)Yeah, obviously....
ProudToBeBlueInRhody
(16,399 posts)MOST people from the Bay State are fine, but some take pride in being obnoxious, boorish d-bags for some reason. It's gotten worse since they started winning shit in sports and having every other movie about mobsters and low lifes set in Boston, Charlestown, Lowell, etc....
I deal with them on an almost daily basis, it ain't fun.
Jennicut
(25,415 posts)Cross that state line from Connecticut to Mass and boom, the honking starts. Just kidding, sort of. Massholes.
MADem
(135,425 posts)And you're carping about someone using that kind of "lumping language?"
What does that say about you?
Irony is alive, well and living in RI?
ProudToBeBlueInRhody
(16,399 posts)Wouldn't want you to miss out on a big heaping helping of outrage! Hope you enjoyed it! Cheers!
MADem
(135,425 posts)All your griping about sports is just stupid and has nothing to do with people from the Bay State in particular--most New Englanders support the Boston-based teams. It's not like RI or CT or NH can field a competitive franchise, anyway. There are noxious Bruins, Celtics, Sox and Patriot fans from other NE states, too--in case you weren't clear on that. It's not a characteristic of sports fans that stops at the Commonwealth's borders.
That subject line of yours sucks, and I stand by my comments--yours were out of line.
ProudToBeBlueInRhody
(16,399 posts)Christ, are you still going?
Hope Brady doesn't tear his ACL going for another touchdown up 70-3.
MADem
(135,425 posts)I pay attention during the advertisements.
Yawn, indeed...
But do double down on your commentary; by your own snarking words we know you!
valerief
(53,235 posts)Jersey Devil
(10,722 posts)If I saw something like that I am sure it would be pretty hard not to smack her across the face.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)Jersey Devil
(10,722 posts)I said it would be pretty hard not to do it, not that I would do it.
Puregonzo1188
(1,948 posts)WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)And I say this as a devoted monthly donor to the PVA and VFW.
Mugu
(2,888 posts)WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)gollygee
(22,336 posts)If she were arrested over it, then it would be a freedom of speech issue. She has the right to do this and can't be arrested for it.
She doesn't have the right to avoid any consequences for her immaturity and lack of judgement.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)gollygee
(22,336 posts)whether something she did off the job that was legal is a fair reason to fire her. I think it's at best questionable, even though she was disrespectful. But it isn't a freedom of speech issue.
AlexSatan
(535 posts)(and many other examples I could produce)
JI7
(93,111 posts)doing opposite of what it asks .
they were still stupid to show the pics like that, but i dont think they should get fired over it.
former-republican
(2,163 posts)demosincebirth
(12,810 posts)Enrique
(27,461 posts)so at least it makes some sense that her company might discipline her. Before I saw that fact, it made no sense to me.
rrneck
(17,671 posts)Doubly stupid to advertise the fact.
Soldiering is hard dangerous work in peacetime, much less when some fucker's shooting at you. Those soldiers died in service to their country and they deserve respect. They fucking earned it. They didn't die to give some asshole a funny photo op.
ETA:
Implying that she's a DUer is some pretty rude shit.
apocalypsehow
(12,751 posts)or unobjectionable is probably a better word, if the poster removed that one sentence. The vast, vast majority of DU'ers from all sides of the progressive spectrum DO NOT approve of the person's actions (whether it's a free speech issue is another question).
Blue_Tires
(57,596 posts)Besides, the only time I see the "Which DUer was this?" meme is in the lounge when someone posts "news of the weird"...
at least that's the only time i use it
coalition_unwilling
(14,180 posts)and felt I should disqualify myself this time round.
However, as I have now read through the thread, I would have voted to suppress for this reason:
The OP insinuates that this sentiment is one that would find approbation here on DU by one or more DUers. Thus the OP is insinuating that DU hates the military and does not respect those who have given the last, full measure of devotion. That is a vicious slur of the DU membership, akin to the slur that the antiwar movement spat upon returning Vietnam Vets many years ago. There's no point suppressing any posts if we're not going to suppress vicious slurs.
Response to -..__... (Original post)
Post removed
PavePusher
(15,374 posts)Response to -..__... (Original post)
Tuesday Afternoon This message was self-deleted by its author.
HereSince1628
(36,063 posts)in these jingoistic times.
I visited the site back in 1974, near the end of my active duty service that earned me Vietnam Service and Vietnam Campaign Ribbons, without other distinction.
What I saw wasn't respect on the part of the guards.
What I saw was theater, absolute embarrassing fucking theater.
I can't imagine ANY veteran expecting such embarrassing attention to stupidity.
I don't REALLY think that a dying veteran would expect a person to guard their grave with a spotless silver butt-plate on a weapon that is entirely for show.
Nor do I think a dying veteran really gives a fuck about guards wearing footprints into a rubber mat on the marble.
I think those dying vets cared about failing their squad members, and not being able to see their families again EVER.
I think those dying vets knew fear and pain.
Do their deaths in the service of civilian leaders deserve respect? Yes.
But just WHO gets to define RESPECT?
Arctic Dave
(13,812 posts)NickB79
(20,218 posts)Whether you agree with what she's saying in this photo or not is irrelevant.
Jeff In Milwaukee
(13,992 posts)Freedom of Speech refers to freedom to speak one's mind without molestation by the government. If this young woman were arrested and charged with a crime for expressing an opinion, I would be the first to defend her.
But Freedom of Speech does NOT mean you can say whatever dumb-ass, hateful thing you want without suffering the fall-out in other ways. You CAN lose your job, you CAN lose your standing in the community, you CAN be shunned by your friends and family.
Life has consequences.
SidDithers
(44,333 posts)Well said.
Sid
muriel_volestrangler
(105,473 posts)I don't think "fire at will" is a popular concept on DU; and there should be limits for how much an employer can control what you do with your private life, eg on Facebook.
Jeff In Milwaukee
(13,992 posts)But the fact is that unless you have a contract or are otherwise protected from termination, an employer can fire you for bad public behavior. And one could certainly argue that there is nothing "private" about something posted on Facebook.
But my larger point is that this is not a First Amendment issue.
marions ghost
(19,841 posts)...it was silly.
What about the hate being directed at her for a thoughtless stupid act? Have we not all done something stupid?
The over-reaction to this is amazing.
Jeff In Milwaukee
(13,992 posts)I suppose that to some right-wing asshole, burning a cross isn't hateful either, but to anybody who isn't a fucking moron, it most certainly is.
Flipping off dead soldiers at a shrine created in their memory is hateful, and you'd have to be a complete blithering idiot to not understand why people might, just might, be offended by it.
marions ghost
(19,841 posts)call me personally --a "complete blithering idiot" --
I am SURE that this gal did not intend to give the finger to the unknown soldier.
No, I don't understand why people are so defensive and thin-skinned they can't just scoff at a spontaneous naughty gesture in response to a very imperious SIGN. Scoff and move on. This need not be an insult to anyone, unless you trump it up and make it so.
Now where did I put that blood pressure cuff? Give me your wrist.
Jeff In Milwaukee
(13,992 posts)If you think she did that accidently, then I am absolutely calling you a complete blithering idiot.
And if I should I call someone a rat-fucking shithead, you're telling me that it "need not be an insult to anyone" unless they trump it up and make it so.
Interesting...
marions ghost
(19,841 posts)...just because I disagree with you. Naughty naughty --remember the rules.
"This post is disruptive, hurtful, rude, insensitive, over-the-top, or otherwise inappropriate." (See Community Standards.)
But just as I would suggest not getting incensed about this woman's dumb gesture in reacting to a sign-- this is how I react to you and your verbal taunts.........................
Jeff In Milwaukee
(13,992 posts)You're confessing to being a blithering idiot by not understanding that someone might be justifiably upset about "disruptive, hurtful, rude, insensitive, over-the-top, or otherwise inappropriate" behavior directed toward the tomb of a dead soldier in Arlington National Cemetary.
You see, if flipping off a man who died protecting his country is not offensive (by DU rules), then suggesting that some one might be a blithering idiot, or might even be a rat-fucking shithead, should certainly not be any less offensive. How could it be?
What you're basically suggesting here is that there's is no such thing as a community standard for one's public behavior, and that only, as you put it, "defensive and thin-skinned" people take offense to other people's actions. So I shouldn't be offended by the neo-klansmen who hanged racist effigies of Barack Obama during the last election. I'm just being "defensive and thin-skinned" because nobody should ever take offense at the guy who paints a swastika on the door of the local synagogue.
If this woman is too fucking stupid to understand that her behaviour might have been offensive, and if she's furthermore so fucking stupid that she posted it on Facebook for the whole world to see, then she's too fucking stupid to hold a job.
marions ghost
(19,841 posts)Real soldiers have bigger battles to fight than this little nothing prank you want to elevate to the level of cross-burnings. Whole lotta pent-up hate goin' on in your post. I'm sure there's a reason for that. OK, if it makes you feel better, I am a blithering idiot and she's too fucking stupid to hold a job. There--feel better?
It's only words on a page (and pix on FB). Suggest to save it for the real battles.
Cya
Jeff In Milwaukee
(13,992 posts)Now that you're shared with me your level of cognition, it's easy for me to understand why you don't get this.
When Westboro Baptist Church pickets soldiers funerals, they're assholes with a fucked-up sense of morality. When the woman in the picture flips the bird to a dead soldier, she's an asshole with a fucked-up sense of humor.
And I find it really curious that what you refer to as "pent-up hate" is what most normal people would consider "common decency."
bigwillq
(72,790 posts)She would've been rich.
Response to -..__... (Original post)
devilgrrl This message was self-deleted by its author.
Raine
(31,072 posts)HappyMe
(20,277 posts)piece of shit.
When my stepson that is stationed in Afghanistan as a sniper comes home in January, I'll make sure to show him this stupid cb*&^%$ and ask him what he thinks of her.
Stupid fucking bitch. I really don't care if she thought it wa 'funny' or 'ironic' or whatever this bc)*&^% thinks.
I am sorry, but my gut reaction to this crap is not pc at fucking all. In light of my family, where can I line up top punch her?
Response to HappyMe (Reply #134)
Post removed
Response to Post removed (Reply #138)
Post removed
Odin2005
(53,521 posts)H2O Man
(78,497 posts)often rely upon far more "offensive" humor than this.
Renew Deal
(84,641 posts)ZombieHorde
(29,047 posts)LanternWaste
(37,748 posts)I knew a simple soldier boy
Who grinned at life in empty joy,
Slept soundly through the lonesome dark,
And whistled early with the lark.
In winter trenches, cowed and glum,
With crumps and lice and lack of rum,
He put a bullet through his brain.
No one spoke of him again.
You smug-faced crowds with kindling eye
Who cheer when soldier lads march by,
Sneak home and pray you'll never know
The hell where youth and laughter go.
~ Sigfried Sasson ~
coalition_unwilling
(14,180 posts)'Dulce et Decorum Est':
Bent double, like old beggars under sacks,
Knock-kneed, coughing like hags, we cursed through sludge,
Till on the haunting flares we turned our backs,
And towards our distant rest began to trudge.
Men marched asleep. Many had lost their boots,
But limped on, blood-shod. All went lame, all blind;
Drunk with fatigue; deaf even to the hoots
Of gas-shells dropping softly behind.
Gas! GAS! Quick, boys! -- An ecstasy of fumbling
Fitting the clumsy helmets just in time,
But someone still was yelling out and stumbling
And flound'ring like a man in fire or lime. --
Dim through the misty panes and thick green light,
As under a green sea, I saw him drowning.
In all my dreams before my helpless sight
He plunges at me, guttering, choking, drowning.
If in some smothering dreams, you too could pace
Behind the wagon that we flung him in,
And watch the white eyes writhing in his face,
His hanging face, like a devil's sick of sin,
If you could hear, at every jolt, the blood
Come gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs
Bitter as the cud
Of vile, incurable sores on innocent tongues, --
My friend, you would not tell with such high zest
To children ardent for some desperate glory,
The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est
Pro patria mori.
http://www.everypoet.com/archive/poetry/Wilfred_Owen/wilfred_owen_dulce_et_decorum_est.htm
Jasana
(490 posts)Classy no? But she's not vandalizing graves or something horrid like that. With everything that's going on in our country now, this is what we get outraged about? Come on!
Macoy51
(239 posts)While I feel what the woman did was stupid, and disgusting, I am disturbed by the growing trend for employers to fire workers over what they do in their own time. I saw nothing to link the woman with her employer, so claiming she discredited the company she worked for doesnt hold water.
Again, I am in no way supporting what the DB did, I am just uneasy at her employer firing her over it. What is next, being fired because you served as a escort at an abortion clinic and your boss is pro-life?
Macoy
Jasana
(490 posts)...this trend troubles me. Everybody does something stupid in life at least once. She isn't doing anything illegal and she's not the CIA Director. No way she should lose her job over this. A heartfelt apology should be all that is necessary here.
rainbow4321
(9,974 posts)From what I could tell by looking at her employer's facebook, they help physically or mentally challenged individuals live more independently.
This was not done during a DC visit on her own private time...she was there in the role of a worker with a group of people who use the services of her employer...and the picture of her was taken by a co worker who was also on the trip
So I'm thinking that the employer has every right to discipline/fire her.
alp227
(33,093 posts)Then I read the full article. Turns out this was a business trip. And according to her dad, the woman's facebook is private. So a friend might have snitched on her, the only way it took her employer to learn about the incident A MONTH LATER. Do you think employers have the right to be thought police and monitor employees' social media even if the facebook etc are set to private?
Jasana
(490 posts)Somewhere I missed the part that she was on a business trip. I just saw the picture and thought she was doing something rude while on vacation.
As a former union rep I would say...
1) If she was on a work trip and a co-worker complained about her behaving this way in front of others who would be distressed by this behavior which also reflected poorly on the employer then the employer would have a right to discipline her - not fire her - unless she had been disciplined before.
2) No I don't think employers should be able to monitor an employee's private social media but somebody did a "whistleblower" on her doing something inappropriate on a business trip. I would say that gives her employer the right to discipline her... again not fire her unless she had been disciplined before.
But the truth is, if you're not in a union shop, you can get fired for almost anything and if you can't prove it's because of race, gender, religion, disability - then you are screwed.
quinnox
(20,600 posts)an employer firing her for her exercising her 1st amendment rights. The constitution is a hell of a thing to have in your corner. I would think the ACLU would be very interested to take up this case and I hope they do so.
Lightbulb_on
(315 posts).. And her actions have made it more difficult for her to do her job.
Employer has every right to fire her and replace her with someone who has less baggage.
MADem
(135,425 posts)life. The old man seemed like a nice fellow, for whatever that is worth. He was on the teevee this evening.
I don't think what she did was smart, but I think it's ironic that a worker unfriendly place that treats their workers like disposable pieces of shit is suddenly so "affronted" that they fired her. She was probably making too much anyway, and they wanted someone to do her job at a few bucks less an hour.
Her employer is so scuzzy they make her look like a saint--really. I've known people who have labored under that yoke and the conditions are hellish and the workplace environment is probably best described as dog-eat-dog.
She's probably better off to be moving on from that organization.
My POV on what she did? Stupid, but not "fire-worthy." And I'm retired military, with both friends and relatives buried at Arlington. I worked close to that cemetery for years, too, so I'm quite familiar with it. I really feel like one of the things we defend as we serve in uniform is our way of life, and that includes our free speech rights.
To see an employer that routinely fires people for the tiniest of infractions leap to unload this kid makes me wonder if she got one too many raises and this is a handy excuse for them to jettison her. They've kept people on with DUIs and personal misconduct between employees...but they'll fire a kid over this? Hmmm.
Methinks they doth protest too much...
Tikki
(15,010 posts)How this young lady thought this was funny is beyond my grasp.
Should she get fired? NO. But WOW.
Tikki
MADem
(135,425 posts)He said his daughter has a quirky view of life, and she's been taking crazy pictures since she was small. He said she feels bad, and that she's a good kid. I believe him.
The place where she works is a horrid place--they find any excuse to fire employees who either make too much through longevity raises, or who refuse to take "management" positions (read, salary instead of hourly wages, so they can be exploited for longer periods of time).
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)MADem
(135,425 posts)I will believe her father. He came across as very credible.
Also, her employer, that fired her, has a nasty and longstanding reputation for treating their employees like shit and firing them after they've had to give the workers a pay raise too many. Then they hire untrained people at rock bottom wages and start the cycle anew. They don't deserve "praise" for using any old excuse to get rid of a twelve bucks an hour employee in exchange for someone working for eight.
I spent decades in the military. I have friends and relatives buried at Arlington. I think what this kid--and she's a kid, to my mind--did was dumb and certainly ill-advised but she doesn't deserve death threats or poutrage or hyperbolic hyperventilations about how this is the Worst Possible Thing Ever. If Sarah Silverman did it, or Katt Williams, people would call it "edgy humor." Because an unknown does it, it's suddenly the crime of the century and Everyone Has To Be Very, VERY Upset About This Serious and Outrageous Affront.
The people who rest in Arlington died to defend our "freedoms" including the freedom to make an ass of oneself. I think some folks are getting just a bit too sanctimonious about this matter to suit me, and I'm an old fart who, in general, favors a certain amount of decorum.
1-Old-Man
(2,667 posts)As far as I'm concerned that child's stunt should bring her all the scorn that can be heaped upon her; and if she got fired over it I am much pleased.
onenote
(45,963 posts)Last edited Thu Nov 22, 2012, 12:55 PM - Edit history (1)
even if the arena in which they show such poor judgment is unrelated to their job. I wouldn't want someone working for me if I couldn't trust them not to behave in a way that the overwhelming majority of people would find offensive and in exceptionally poor taste.
Its one thing to spontaneously pose for and take the picture. I can understand that. But posting it on facebook is not a spontaneous act and it suggests that the person doesn't comprehend or care about the consequences of what they do "publicly." And that is not a quality I would want in an employee.
Logical
(22,457 posts)onenote
(45,963 posts)Logical
(22,457 posts)onenote
(45,963 posts)Response to Logical (Reply #187)
Logical This message was self-deleted by its author.
Vattel
(9,289 posts)We all do dumb stuff once in a while. It is no big deal. She should keep her job.
The statue was pretty hot, btw.
Skittles
(169,196 posts)but I read their apology and it seems very sincere (statement, not the panicked one on Facebook)......my guess is this will help them grow up, a lesson hard-learned.
Catherine Vincent
(34,596 posts)Skittles
(169,196 posts)she was on a company-sponsored trip, which makes her decision even more reckless. She is not a bad person but certainly she needs to grow up, and I think her sincere apology is a big start.
obamanut2012
(29,126 posts)It was ridiculous she was fired for this, and I am someone with relatives who are disabled combat vets, and who had relatives die in Vietnam.
Comrade_McKenzie
(2,526 posts)By other symbols we have deemed vulgar...
THE HORROR!
tabasco
(22,974 posts)The employer has freedom to hire and fire whom he wants.
valerief
(53,235 posts)sadbear
(4,340 posts)a lot of people here would be less outraged.
TrueBlueinCO
(86 posts)Hint, it's not that you can't be fired for acting like a jackass.
Puregonzo1188
(1,948 posts)Yes, this woman is an idiot, but it hardly warrants attention.
RetroLounge
(37,250 posts)This OP
or the pearl-clutchers below.
RL
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,608 posts)RetroLounge
(37,250 posts)RL
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,608 posts)If I had an office mate who was Hindu and I made of point of ostentatiously eating hamburgers in her presence I bet you would think that was asshole and Freeper like behavior.
See where I'm going with this.
RetroLounge
(37,250 posts)RL
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,608 posts)RetroLounge
(37,250 posts)RL
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,608 posts)RetroLounge
(37,250 posts)RL
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,608 posts)RetroLounge
(37,250 posts)You love me, you really do!
RL
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,608 posts)I love everybody, I really do!
SimplyMarie
(15 posts)I mean..what is she..? Twelve years old? I don't understand why a grown woman would feel the impulse to do something this disrespectful...but then to post it on Facebook for all the world to see? I'm not surprised she got fired. That lack of judgement in her line of work is a dangerous liability to any employer.
Laura PourMeADrink
(42,770 posts)TrueBlueinCO
(86 posts)She wasn't censored by the government in any way. The First Amendment doesn't guarantee that there won't be any consequences of speech. She acted like a jackass on the job and got fired for it. It's hardly a free speech issue.
Laura PourMeADrink
(42,770 posts)TrueBlueinCO
(86 posts)marions ghost
(19,841 posts)without that job. Innocent if juvenile, fun. Dumb to put it on FB.
Everybody wants to criticise...
Public Flogging
SimplyMarie
(15 posts)For me it's not about criticism. It's about determining what level of disrespect we will tolerate as a society. I mean...what is the purpose of flipping off a sign at the Tomb of the Unknown soldier? Is she just anti-authority in general? If yes..then that is not a person I want in charge of my at risk friend or relative.
Actions have consequences. In this case the company was right. She was ..after all..on a company funded trip.
marions ghost
(19,841 posts)since it was just dumb and crass I wouldn't blink an eyelash. Yawn.
The company was equally stupid. She's better off out of that job.
Taverner
(55,476 posts)AldoLeopold
(617 posts)When will people learn that Facebook is insane? How many lives do it or its elder brother Myspace have to destroy? She was obviously being stupid and disrespectful - but why do people keep putting this crap on Facebook when the consequences are sometimes so severe?
Chances she loses her job over this? 100%
Skidmore
(37,364 posts)participate in whipped up outrage over a picture some idiot making a fool of herself? I'm so sick of seeing this thread. If you take personal offense with every idiotic stunt in the world, you never get anything done.