Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Septua

(2,957 posts)
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 06:55 PM Feb 2024

Well, Trump can't pull us out of NATO...I didn't know that till just now.

Most recently, the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2024, enacted on December 22, 2023, prohibits the President from unilaterally withdrawing from NATO without approval of a two-third Senate super-majority or an act of Congress.


This bill was a response to Donald Trump's repeated expressions of interest in withdrawing from the organization.



https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_from_NATO#:~:text=United%20States,-The%20United%20States&text=Most%20recently%2C%20the%20National%20Defense,or%20an%20act%20of%20Congress.
42 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Well, Trump can't pull us out of NATO...I didn't know that till just now. (Original Post) Septua Feb 2024 OP
That's better than nothing, but still carries risk. Turbineguy Feb 2024 #1
TY! I don't suppose the fucking mediaW****** are talking about this? Cha Feb 2024 #2
Some in the media are. I just read about it in the last couple days. nt pnwmom Feb 2024 #9
Good! TY!! Cha Feb 2024 #12
First of all, Trump wouldn't care about the law Silent3 Feb 2024 #3
Discussed on NPR this morning. President is commander in chief, Congress has no authority RandomNumbers Feb 2024 #30
"half this country" intrepidity Feb 2024 #38
True, but RandomNumbers Feb 2024 #42
Pulling out vs not supporting... getagrip_already Feb 2024 #4
A valid point Septua Feb 2024 #18
Too bad COL Mustard Feb 2024 #24
Legally, no, but we're talking about Donnie here Retrograde Feb 2024 #5
He can still a great deal of damage. Irish_Dem Feb 2024 #6
I 💓 you for bringing this to our attention... Kudos hlthe2b Feb 2024 #7
He doesn't have to. Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #8
So happy to know this. Thanks for posting. n/t iluvtennis Feb 2024 #10
What he would do Warpy Feb 2024 #11
Other legislation passed post-Trump was change to election certification rules wishstar Feb 2024 #13
All about getting attention on Superbowl Sunday JoseBalow Feb 2024 #14
..wait a minute.. thomski64 Feb 2024 #33
Oh that's right! Thx for reminding those of us who had a lapse in memory about that recently passed law PortTack Feb 2024 #15
He can just refuse to help Diraven Feb 2024 #16
I'd be a bit concerned, if trump takes the chair again, slightlv Feb 2024 #17
That assumes he cares about laws relayerbob Feb 2024 #19
If the crazy fool gets reelected and fills the Cabinet... Septua Feb 2024 #21
If the TFA get re-elected he will ignore these laws and be the dictator he dreams of being kimbutgar Feb 2024 #20
Isn't he just placating putin for assistance this cycle? SleeplessinSoCal Feb 2024 #22
Thanks for bdamomma Feb 2024 #23
Dictators don't care... hurple Feb 2024 #25
Won't matter if he declares himself a dictator. He''ll do whatever he wants and then stand on Hotler Feb 2024 #26
Didn't they release HInkley from prison, or are about to do so? DemocraticPatriot Feb 2024 #28
This bill was 'superfluous' --- Presidents did not have any power DemocraticPatriot Feb 2024 #27
He wouldn't have to Qutzupalotl Feb 2024 #29
Trump wins by ignoring laws--who can force him? kiri Feb 2024 #31
He would just unilaterally pull the troops out of Europe. kairos12 Feb 2024 #32
No, Trump can't unilaterally pull the US out of NATO, but we've already seen the mischief he can cause as Martin68 Feb 2024 #34
Congress overwhelmingly passed a bipartisan law in December to prevent presidents from leaving NATO. LetMyPeopleVote Feb 2024 #35
He can set the ball in motion. mzmolly Feb 2024 #36
Maybe someone should tell Putin. appleannie1 Feb 2024 #37
That law doesn't alter the fact that in an emergency, Trump could stand around with his arms folded. flashman13 Feb 2024 #39
All of his properties in NATO countries should be seized the moment he tries to leave NATO. usaf-vet Feb 2024 #40
He can't withdraw us unilaterally Mad_Machine76 Feb 2024 #41

Turbineguy

(40,040 posts)
1. That's better than nothing, but still carries risk.
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 06:58 PM
Feb 2024

Since republicans compete to kiss trumps ass.

 

Silent3

(15,909 posts)
3. First of all, Trump wouldn't care about the law
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 07:01 PM
Feb 2024

Second, even as a nominal member, he would do everything possible to make the US such a bad partner that the rest of NATO would want to get rid of us.

RandomNumbers

(19,151 posts)
30. Discussed on NPR this morning. President is commander in chief, Congress has no authority
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 09:35 AM
Feb 2024

to deploy troops.

Even if TSF couldn't officially withdraw from the treaty, he could just refuse to authorize the deployment of troops, effectively abrogating the U.S. commitment under the treaty. Putin of course knows this.

And TSF's sick minions would support him in this despicable action.

What the f*ck is wrong with half this country!

getagrip_already

(17,802 posts)
4. Pulling out vs not supporting...
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 07:02 PM
Feb 2024

Not a huge difference.

If a potus refused to participate in nato activities, pulled troops and prepositioned armor and ammo, and then sat back during an attack, what's the real difference?

Septua

(2,957 posts)
18. A valid point
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 08:52 PM
Feb 2024

Even with Congressional majorities passing legislation to fund assistance, he could veto it. And most likely would out of spite.

Retrograde

(11,416 posts)
5. Legally, no, but we're talking about Donnie here
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 07:06 PM
Feb 2024

No one tells Donnie what to do. No one ever has, and no one ever will. As long as we have a toothless judicial system he'll continue to get away with all his illegal actions.

It's telling that the only prosecutions that seem to be going forward are civil ones - and he's losing those. The criminal proceedings seem to get hung up in delay after delay.

Irish_Dem

(81,143 posts)
6. He can still a great deal of damage.
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 07:08 PM
Feb 2024

Letting our allies know the US is not trustworthy, doesn't keep the agreements it makes, and emboldens
dangerous psychopath leaders.

Warpy

(114,592 posts)
11. What he would do
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 07:43 PM
Feb 2024

Of course he'd issue some sort of imperial fiat pulling us out, only to be smacked down by the courts. Again.

He would also try to defund NATO and might be somewhat more successful at that. He'd sell it as forcing European countries to pay their fair share. Given the generosity to Ukraine, I'd say they are paying their fair share these days.

He'd suck up to Putin full time, not sure how well that would go over. MAGAts aren't the only violent ones out there.

The best idea is to keep him the hell out of office forever.

wishstar

(5,828 posts)
13. Other legislation passed post-Trump was change to election certification rules
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 07:49 PM
Feb 2024
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/congress-approves-new-election-certification-rules-in-response-to-jan-6

Although we almost certainly never had to worry about a Dem Pres and Dem VP scheming to disrupt the process.

thomski64

(930 posts)
33. ..wait a minute..
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 03:55 PM
Feb 2024

..his beef with our NATO Allies is that they don't pay their bills? What did they do bankrupt a casino? Stiff their creditors? Not pay their lawyers?

PortTack

(35,820 posts)
15. Oh that's right! Thx for reminding those of us who had a lapse in memory about that recently passed law
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 07:54 PM
Feb 2024


On edit: how is what he what he said not giving aide and comfort to our enemy??!! F..KING TRAITOR!

Diraven

(1,892 posts)
16. He can just refuse to help
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 08:09 PM
Feb 2024

Since he would still be Commander in Chief he could just refuse to give orders to send any help to a NATO partner who is attacked.

slightlv

(7,784 posts)
17. I'd be a bit concerned, if trump takes the chair again,
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 08:45 PM
Feb 2024

(since it's not an office and he's not an officer!), that we could find ourselves treated the way Russia, China, N Korea, etc., are treated today, and have been for decades. A military campaign for "regime change" wouldn't be beyond imagination, at least in my head.

relayerbob

(7,422 posts)
19. That assumes he cares about laws
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 08:56 PM
Feb 2024

If Russia attacks, he can either: just not do anything at all and ignore the screaming; arrest all dissenting congress people and rewrite the law; join Russia and attack NATO. The ONLY thing that would be able to stop him is a military absolutely refusing to follow his orders

Septua

(2,957 posts)
21. If the crazy fool gets reelected and fills the Cabinet...
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 09:12 PM
Feb 2024

..with cronies, as has been suggested, you are correct. It'll take the rank and file to stop him. And hell, he could replace all the rank and file with white supremacists.

kimbutgar

(27,235 posts)
20. If the TFA get re-elected he will ignore these laws and be the dictator he dreams of being
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 09:11 PM
Feb 2024

And his weak assed lap dog repukes will follow his lead!

SleeplessinSoCal

(10,411 posts)
22. Isn't he just placating putin for assistance this cycle?
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 09:21 PM
Feb 2024

That's what it sounds Ike to me. He's a brazen traitor.

bdamomma

(69,527 posts)
23. Thanks for
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 09:23 PM
Feb 2024

posting.

All the more reason why that POS can't get near the WH. VOTE VOTE VOTE.

Anything can happen between now and November.

hurple

(1,359 posts)
25. Dictators don't care...
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 09:50 PM
Feb 2024

What indicators have there been, any time in the orange shitgibbons life that he gives a flying fuck about laws, rules, regulations, policy... whatever?

He will do what he wants and bully and threaten anyone who dares try yo say no.

Hotler

(13,747 posts)
26. Won't matter if he declares himself a dictator. He''ll do whatever he wants and then stand on
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 11:06 PM
Feb 2024

the balcony of the White House tell us if we don't like it to come get him. You can bet if he/the right take power the Christian evangelicals will be our rulers.

 

DemocraticPatriot

(5,410 posts)
28. Didn't they release HInkley from prison, or are about to do so?
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 12:01 AM
Feb 2024

I hear tell that Drumph wants to sleep with Jodie Foster, and has been persecuting her...


 

DemocraticPatriot

(5,410 posts)
27. This bill was 'superfluous' --- Presidents did not have any power
Sun Feb 11, 2024, 11:58 PM
Feb 2024

to cancel international treaties which were passed by 2/3s of the US Senate in the FIRST place...
(such as the NATO alliance)

That new act only emphasized a point which was already true.... but I'm glad they did it.


kiri

(967 posts)
31. Trump wins by ignoring laws--who can force him?
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 02:18 PM
Feb 2024

You miss what Trump can do--ignore the law. He can refuse to appoint an ambassador to NATO or any military representatives. As CiC he can block any and all military actions. He can withdraw every bit of our military 'cooperartion/liason' with NATO. And block all US weapons from NATO.

He consistently wins by generating chaos, confusion, distrust. We have no real tools to deal with this.


kairos12

(13,574 posts)
32. He would just unilaterally pull the troops out of Europe.
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 02:20 PM
Feb 2024

Make it a hollow alliance. He pulled troops from Germany before.

That law means nothing.

Martin68

(27,677 posts)
34. No, Trump can't unilaterally pull the US out of NATO, but we've already seen the mischief he can cause as
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 03:59 PM
Feb 2024

president, lending comfort an aid to his Russian friends. If the president of the US is against NATO, it weakens the alliance significantly.

LetMyPeopleVote

(179,523 posts)
35. Congress overwhelmingly passed a bipartisan law in December to prevent presidents from leaving NATO.
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 04:06 PM
Feb 2024

mzmolly

(52,790 posts)
36. He can set the ball in motion.
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 04:12 PM
Feb 2024

“Act of Congress” his lemmings do whatever he asks.

flashman13

(2,378 posts)
39. That law doesn't alter the fact that in an emergency, Trump could stand around with his arms folded.
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 06:07 PM
Feb 2024

Just like what we saw on J6.

usaf-vet

(7,803 posts)
40. All of his properties in NATO countries should be seized the moment he tries to leave NATO.
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 06:12 PM
Feb 2024

And held until HELL FREEZES over. Or the sick SOB has a spot next to his wife buried on the golf course.

Mad_Machine76

(24,951 posts)
41. He can't withdraw us unilaterally
Mon Feb 12, 2024, 06:39 PM
Feb 2024

Given his recent statements, if he wins, I would be surprised if we weren’t kicked out

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Well, Trump can't pull us...