General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNY-16: The Most Endangered Democrat in America Jamaal Bowman might lose his job over Israel.
The work is daunting. Bowman, less than two months from the June 25 primary, is one of the most endangered Democratic incumbents in America. This is in spite of or because of his charisma and budding celebrity, his ability to slash through the noise of 435 House members and command attention on a scale only one or two levels removed from Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. A former public-school principal and self-described hip-hop head, Bowman marries her online savvy with a deft working-class touch. Burly and boisterous, with a knack for whipping up crowds, it is not hard to imagine him as a future presidential candidate, storming through South Carolina with a pack of reporters hanging on his every word.
But first he needs to win. And Latimer, the sitting Westchester County executive, has outraised him in the primary, thanks in part to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) the conservative, ardently pro-Israel political powerhouse that is seeking to crush the pro-Palestinian movement and the left itself. They do not want any critique, they do not want any accountability, and so what it looks like to people in my district and around the country is that Israel can do whatever it wants even though, to people on the outside looking in, it looks completely wrong and horrible, Bowman says of AIPAC. One, it doesnt represent all the Jews. It doesnt represent all the Jews in Israel!
If Israel represents all the Jews, Bowman continues, revving up now, and if Israel is doing bad things without accountability, some idiot in the street just makes the connection that, Oh, Jews must be bad because Israel is bad. Thats fucking excuse my language thats effing scary, man, and dangerous. And as we fight antisemitism, that has to include accountability for Israel.
There was a time, not very long ago, when no member of Congress would speak this way. The Israeli governments response that has starved out Gaza and killed thousands of civilians has catalyzed a new era though. Mass protests have flooded the streets and rocked college campuses, including two, Columbia and City College, that are only a short drive from Westchester. Bowman has been an AIPAC target for his support of conditioning military aid to Israel and his willingness to label the military campaign in Gaza a genocide, among other criticism lodged at the Jewish state. AIPAC is one of the most powerful lobbies in America. Well you know what we have got to say to AIPAC? Bring it on, he said at his campaign kickoff earlier this year. AIPAC, bring it on. We are not scared of none of that. Im from the streets of New York.
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/jamaal-bowman-george-latimer-primary-israel.html
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)...making the most of dividing the left, aren't they.
FalloutShelter
(14,465 posts)atreides1
(16,799 posts)Has no interest in American democracy and never has!
brooklynite
(96,882 posts)Perhaps they're not as perceptive as you are?
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)I'm just making an observation.
brooklynite
(96,882 posts)along with Democratic Whip Katherine Clark, Caucus Chair Pete Aguilar, Jim Clyburn, Stony Hoyer.....
None of them have renounced their support.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)...in any case, AIPAC, which is a known "conservative" organization (ie; rightwingers) as mentioned in the OP article, sure is working hard to cause division among the Left.
brooklynite
(96,882 posts)They're looking for, and supporting, candidates of either Party who support Israel.
A not unknown occurrence among mainstream Democrats, even today.
In the case of Bowman, they're supporting another pro-Biden Democrat.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)...by getting involved in a Leftwing race when they are purely rightwingers.
As rightwingers, it's safe to assume that their priorities are only for themselves and they will do anything they can to stir up trouble on the left.
It's simple.
Nixie
(17,984 posts)anti-Israel. Just like the busy defunder crowd, they are free to support their own priorities, which is Israel.
Splitting the left isn't just done by RWers. Some even say they want a party revolution and they stir up their own trouble.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)Or even anti-netanyahu with anti-Israel?
To be honest, the damage that netanyahu has done to Israel now on the world stage breaks my heart.
Nixie
(17,984 posts)to do with your post about a pro-Israel organization dividing the left, and they have nothing to do with my response.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)Your response brought up politicians who are anti-Israel, I asked if you're confusing anti-Israel with pro-Palestine.
Simple stuff, really.
Nixie
(17,984 posts)nefarious connotations about dividing the left. It seems like you have no acknowledgement or answer as to what other political types cause divisions on the left. Then you bring up Palestine and "confusion." Seems really convoluted.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)...I responded to that response by asking if you might be confusing anti-Isreali with pro-Palestinian.
Nixie
(17,984 posts)that is the subject of this thread. It explains clearly what the subject matter is.
edit From the article:
ardently pro-Israel political powerhouse
edit: From the article:
They do not want any critique, they do not want any accountability, and so what it looks like to people in my district and around the country is that Israel can do whatever it wants even though, to people on the outside looking in, it looks completely wrong and horrible, Bowman says of AIPAC.
The article is discussing Bowman's anti-Israel response. The title of this thread is that his anti-Israel positions might cost him his job.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)Nixie
(17,984 posts)about the thread content or about my response to your connotations about what other political types also divide the left.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)Nixie
(17,984 posts)distractions.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)brooklynite
(96,882 posts)Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)brooklynite
(96,882 posts)AIPAC has been a supporter of Israel since long before the Gaza conflict started.
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)I, myself, am pro-Israel, and pro-Palestine.
I am also very much anti-netanyahu.
Edit to add (to avoid any confusion) I am also VERY MUCH anti-hamas.
AND, whether anyone WANTS to believe it, I'm not antisemitic.
The Magistrate
(96,043 posts)Right wing figures around the world support 'Palestinian resistance'.
The dictator of Russia is certainly a right winger, the clerics ruling Iran certainly are, so is the leader of China. The fighting arms of Palestine are themselves right wing: surely you don't imagine Hamas a part of the left, or that the PA is in any sense a liberal, leftist, or progressive body. If you do, well...think again, harder this time. I won't go into the sort of neo nazis who, while they hate Muslims, are quite happy to see the, kill Jews, and cheer them on.
There is nothing whatever inherently left about support for Arab Palestine, never was, never will be, at least not on the current lines of Arab Palestine as a culture and polity.
"Travel broadens the mind."
Think. Again.
(22,456 posts)I was thinking of American rightwingers.
Celerity
(54,407 posts)and dumped in millions to get them elected is not a good look IMHO.
When I see MAGA and RW billionaires getting involved with our primaries, my suspicions go up, and AIPAC places fealty to the ultra RW fascist, racist, homophobic Netanyahu coalition government above American democracy by their very actions in American politics.
In 2022, AIPAC endorsed 109 Rethug traitors who refused to certify Biden, almost of whom still push the Big Lie Including
the christofash Speaker of the House Mike Johnson
Gym Jordan
ultra MAGAt Elise Stefanik
Kevin McCarthy
the crazed gunhumper Greg Steube
Ronny 'Trump's drunk Dr Feelgood' Jackson
Joe 'you lie!' Wilson
John 'I am a racist, climate change denying MAGAt, but look!, Henry Cuellar campaigns and fundraises for me so it's all good' Carter, Troy Nehls,
etc etc
much more here:
https://www.democraticunderground.com/100218940616#post6


kelly1mm
(5,756 posts)returned the contributions? If not, why not?
I seem to remember the last two Democratic House Leaders are proud of the support APAIC gives them? Seems strange if APAIC is a 'right wing organization', no?
Celerity
(54,407 posts)despite their supporting some Democrats.
You cannot wash away the stench of support for RW christofascists and white nationalists (Jim Jordan for example, who AIPAC endorsed) just because you also support some Democrats.
Just because there is overlap between the 2 parties in terms of who AIPAC supports (and again, they are funded to a very significant degree by RW billionaires) does not excuse them from being a threat to American democracy, due to their support for RW politicians who are, by both their natures and their actions, threats to our democracy.
AIPAC plays both sides against each other. They are most definitely, on balance, not a Democratic party ally.
AIPAC's RW billionaires go after progressives who they see as a threat to their RW economic agenda. It is a 2-for-1 deal, as they use Israel (and thus by extension AIPAC engages in support for the fascist RW Netanyahu coalition, as that is who is in power there) as cover to go after their American economic ideological enemies.
kelly1mm
(5,756 posts)Pelosi, both who have said they are proud to be supported by AIPAC, as giving back those 'right wing' contributions .....
Bonus points for knowing the US Senator who got the most AIPAC money combined from 1990-2024? Hint is that he currently lives at 1600 Pennsylvania Ave.
Celerity
(54,407 posts)RandySF
(84,274 posts)He had a Youtube channel that delves into topics such as "the Illuminati". .
DinahMoeHum
(23,606 posts)He's already been under attack for promoting the 9/11 ones.
Cha
(319,074 posts)the Primary! A Pres Biden
Happy Hoosier
(9,535 posts)Once again, it seems like the opinion of some here is it is always the Jew's fault.
Bowman dug his own hole.
Cha
(319,074 posts)dalton99a
(94,115 posts)comradebillyboy
(10,955 posts)Doc Sportello
(7,964 posts)Sorry about your sad.
Wednesdays
(22,602 posts)It's one thing for him to be primaried (is that still possible?), a whole 'nuther thing for him to lose his seat to a MAGAt.
DinahMoeHum
(23,606 posts)Trust me. I live in this district - and while it's liberal, it ain't leftist.
Methinks Bowman is going to learn the hard way that this area is NOT a northern suburban version of AOC's district.
A liberal community and a leftist community are NOT the same thing.
Happy Hoosier
(9,535 posts)until they start spouting bullshit.
"progressives" are far too often their own worst enemy.
jimfields33
(19,382 posts)I dont think it will be sad at all if the challenger wins the primary.
Cha
(319,074 posts)Doc Sportello
(7,964 posts)Other than the money from AIPAC, which gives 10s of millions to dozens of repubs who support trump, and another group, nothing is provided in the way of polls or anything else to prove this claim. There is a list of his opponents' job titles which show he is a lifelong politician. Some demographic factors are listed, which may or may not show Bowman is on his way out. Hyperbole seems to be the reason. And what happens if Bowman wins again. How will that be spun?
brooklynite
(96,882 posts)No, they don't.
First, as a PAC they can only give $5,000 to a candidate committee.
Second, they give almost as much support to Democrats, including leadership like Nancy Pelosi and Hakeem Jeffries.
Doc Sportello
(7,964 posts)Meant overall obviously. A TOTAL. Sheesh, it isn't that hard to understand. Use more thought and less emotion tied
to false 'gotchas"and you won't have to make this kind of post.
From AIPAC;s own website "We supported 365 pro-Israel Democratic and Republican candidates in 2022 with more than $17 million in direct support through AIPAC."
And no, I don't care that a one-issue organization also gives money to Democrats when it supports anti-democracy candidates.
unc70
(6,501 posts)I'm "sure" someone will be along explain this discrepancy to us.
Doc Sportello
(7,964 posts)So you'll need to ask them to "explain" it.
mjvpi
(1,931 posts)Celerity
(54,407 posts)United Democracy Project backing Sarah Elfreth, even with Harry Dunn, former US capitol officer, as fellow Democrat in House race
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/article/2024/may/10/pro-israel-pac-funding-maryland-primary-sarah-elfreth
A pro-Israel lobby group has dropped millions into a Maryland congressional race as tensions remain high over the war in Gaza. The primary race in the third congressional district, which will be held on Tuesday, has attracted national interest thanks to the candidacy of one Democrat in particular: Harry Dunn.
A former US Capitol police officer, Dunn and his colleagues won praise for their actions defending lawmakers against a violent mob of Donald Trumps supporters on January 6. In his New York Times bestselling memoir, Standing My Ground, Dunn recounted how the insurrectionists repeatedly used the N-word as they attacked him and other Black officers.

Dunn announced his bid to replace retiring Democratic congressman John Sarbanes on the third anniversary of January 6, marking his first formal foray into electoral politics. Despite Dunns high name recognition, the group United Democracy Project, a Super Pac affiliated with the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (Aipac), has thrown its support behind another primary candidate.
According to documents filed with the Federal Election Commission, UDP has spent over $4.2m supporting state senator Sarah Elfreth. UDPs investment comes after the group spent $4.6m on its failed effort to block the Democratic congressional candidate Dave Min from advancing to the general election in Californias 47th district.
Building on a successful playbook from 2022, AIPAC and other aligned groups are picking their targets many more of them this time.
https://www.politico.com/news/2024/03/03/aipac-israel-spending-democratic-primaries-00144552
A California Democrat running for Rep. Katie Porters seat suddenly became the target of an unexpected barrage of negative ads from the nations premier pro-Israel group this year. So he emailed a former Michigan representative, Andy Levin, for advice. Levin was ousted from his House seat in 2022, after the American Israel Public Affairs Committee spent $4 million against him. Levin was one of a handful of Democrats targeted by AIPAC last cycle, when the group went after a range of progressive candidates in mostly open House primaries over their criticism of Israel.
He told Dave Min, who has not called for a permanent cease-fire in Gaza but has privately criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, to reach out to progressive Jewish groups for help. Thats what Levin had done. But, he acknowledged, we were simply swamped by outside spending in his own primary, and Dave Min might face a similar fate. Most candidates wont be able to survive that spending barrage, Levin said in an interview with POLITICO, and Im afraid that they can be quite successful in wiping them out.
This cycle, they are going even bigger. AIPAC is expected to spend $100 million across its political entities in 2024, taking aim at candidates they deem insufficiently supportive of Israel, according to three people with direct knowledge of the figure, who were granted anonymity to discuss private meetings. The strategy has taken on new urgency this election season from donors animated by the Israel-Hamas war.
AIPACs biggest targets are members of the so-called Squad of progressive House Democrats who have been openly pressuring the administration to call for a cease-fire. But AIPACs ambitions are broader. United Democracy Project, the groups super PAC, is monitoring 15 to 20 House races and polling in many of those districts, according to a person directly familiar with UDPs strategy and granted anonymity to discuss the approach. Theyll have so much money, wherever theres an opportunity, they will take it, said one Democratic donor adviser who is involved in the effort and was granted anonymity to speak candidly about the organizations plans.
snip
brooklynite
(96,882 posts)All of the members of The Squad won by defeating other Democrats. Were you equally offended by groups that supported them?
Celerity
(54,407 posts)AIPAC Super Pac money being spent this election.
That AIPAC related spend comes to a significant degree from RW billionaires, and also some of it will go to RW treasonous election denier Rethugs, same as 2022.
Also, you often bring up Hakeem Jeffries.
Well, he endorsed Bowman.
So did Katherine Clark, who is the House Minority Whip. She previously served as Assistant Speaker from 2021 to 2023 and Vice Chair of the House Democratic Caucus from 2019 to 2021.
Nixie
(17,984 posts)dividing the left. Thanks for pointing it out.
RandySF
(84,274 posts)Doc Sportello
(7,964 posts)An organization that is willing to put anti-democracy repubs in charge of Congress. So there's that.
RandySF
(84,274 posts)Doc Sportello
(7,964 posts)For you to respond to what was actually posted instead of responding with some flaccid non sequitur?
betsuni
(29,078 posts)Very dramatic!
tritsofme
(19,900 posts)Danmel
(5,778 posts)Propaganda.
He needs to go.
Elessar Zappa
(16,385 posts)Is there a chance Republicans can win that district in November? I want a Democrat in the seat, whoever it is.
DinahMoeHum
(23,606 posts)to take this seat.
And I say this as a resident of the 16th district.
Alls well as long as a Democrat retains that seat.
Historic NY
(40,037 posts)The people who he purportedly represents.
Cha
(319,074 posts)Geore Latimer for Congress.. A Pres Biden Dem!