General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsRest in Peace Phil Donahue
https://www.today.com/popculture/news/phil-donahue-dies-rcna167132...Donahue died at his home surrounded by his family, including his wife of 44 years, Marlo Thomas, his sister, his children, grandchildren and his beloved golden retriever, Charlie, his family said in a statement to TODAY.
Donahue's family requested that donations be made to St. Jude Childrens Research Hospital or the Phil Donahue/Notre Dame Scholarship Fund in lieu of flowers, according to the statement...
I need to process this news. I'm not sure I' up for it.
a kennedy
(35,995 posts)COL Mustard
(8,226 posts)Unfortunately it morphed into Jerry Springer and the other odious versions.
Wednesdays
(22,605 posts)Jerry Springer's show morphed into Jerry Springer.
WheelWalker
(9,402 posts)rainin
(3,246 posts)allegorical oracle
(6,480 posts)Children's Hospital has taken in more than 170 injured children from Gaza. Have missed him over these many years.
Auggie
(33,151 posts)His was the best
Solly Mack
(96,943 posts)snowybirdie
(6,687 posts)Saying his show was similar to Jerry Springer's. Damn. He discussed serious topics in his early days and had intelligent guests. It wasn't until his last days on air that this was lowered because of the Springers etal. on tv. Loved him
Tom_Foolery
(4,728 posts)Always a fighter for liberal causes.
sinkingfeeling
(57,835 posts)bullimiami
(14,075 posts)Tribetime
(7,145 posts)With him ..My dad introduced me to him in 1968 when I was 8 in Columbus just before he started his first TV show in Columbus. RiP
underpants
(196,502 posts)As I posted on another thread
The St. Jude (Fed Ex) golf tournament was this weekend. The Thomases have made a gigantic difference in a lot of lives over a lot of years. Free care for kids with cancer. Im getting a little teary eyed.
tetedur
(1,418 posts)interviewing people who argued against the war for good reasons.
That is how I remember him. He was the top ranking cable show for MSNBC and they fired him.
KS Toronado
(23,727 posts)And it was the pressure from the Bush administration that got his show canceled. reQublicans don't
like people asking questions about their shenanigans.
Clouds Passing
(7,934 posts)Jerry Springer was awesome too when his show was on Air America, in the early days of hurricane katrina.
BonnieJW
(3,124 posts)for him to come back to tv, but it never happened. Maybe black listed?
willamette
(182 posts)CatWoman
(80,290 posts)during the prelude to the Iraq War, he was the only news program that made common sense.
progressoid
(53,179 posts)CatWoman
(80,290 posts)he refused to jump on the pro war band wagon
Dennis Donovan
(31,059 posts)I'll always remember his daytime TV show as well as his MSNBC show they unceremoniously yanked off the air on the eve of the Iraq War because he spoke out against it.
Alice Kramden
(2,951 posts)Fla Dem
(27,633 posts)StarryNite
(12,116 posts)You will be dearly missed.
TNNurse
(7,541 posts)helps to accept it was for the best.
unblock
(56,198 posts)how i didn't recognize him, well,.. that's my autism i guess, or something...
one year, my wife roped me into going to the new york times' annual crossword puzzle championship.
i used to do their crossword puzzles daily on my commute into the city, but once it became a driving commute, i got out of practice. i wasn't keen on going, but my wife knew i would enjoy it, so she signed me up anyway.
well, i've spoiled the punchline, but phil donahue was also there, as just another contestant, and i happened to get sat at his table. honestly, i didn't recognize him and to this day i can't remember which of us sat down first. i would have just looked for any open seat.
anyway, aside from the quiet periods doing the actual puzzle tests, we had plenty of time for table chat. people came up to him to shake his hand, thank him for everything he's done, take selfies, and get autographs. i get the hint that he was someone of note, but still had no clue who he was. i thought he was some retired local mayor or something.
toward the end of the 3 hours, i was able to talk to my wife (she wasn't allowed in the playing area) and she was shocked to fine i couldn't recognize him and clued me in. as soon as she said it, i was, duh, of course!
anyway, real nice guy and obviously very down-to-earth and normal guy other than having been on tv a ton.
willamette
(182 posts)RANDYWILDMAN
(3,163 posts)Not many of them on the tele.
Rip Phil
Kid Berwyn
(24,399 posts)Still waiting for MSNBC as well as the rest of ABCNNBCBSFakeNoiseNutworks to apologize for their roles in helping Poppy Bush and later his idiot son Smirko McCokespoon to LIE America into two illegal, unnecessary and disastrous wars on countries that posed no threat to the United States.
mjvpi
(1,931 posts)If you took all of the voices that have been kicked off of MSNBC at critical moments, you would have a good news and opinion channel. Check out Mehdi Hassans new documentary.
iluvtennis
(21,497 posts)AllaN01Bear
(29,498 posts)Attilatheblond
(8,880 posts)Sending strength to his widow, Marlo Thomas. It will be a huge lose to her.
Fair winds, Mr. Donahue. And many thanks for opening an avenue for regular people to ask questions and be heard.
True Dough
(26,674 posts)but he made it to 88. I'm always grateful when the good guys and gals live a long, full life.
Easterncedar
(6,269 posts)I had a friend, gone now, whose crusty, blustery, difficult and sometimes aggressive husband told her one day that he had been watching a Phil Donahue show about it and suddenly understood that he had been verbally abusive to her and wanted to mend his ways.
lastlib
(28,277 posts)I had to send it back to them because Marlo signed it in the wrong place. (They did very well that year--income was in the very low eight digits.....)
RIP, Phil. Condolences to Marlo.
lostnfound
(17,520 posts)When I was in college. An exploration of human behavior, based on interviews with more than fifty scientists, including Stephen Jay Gould.
SpankMe
(3,720 posts)bdamomma
(69,532 posts)RIP Phil Donahue and sympathy to his family. I used to watch his show many many years ago.
Beringia
(5,507 posts)Jacson6
(2,014 posts)I learned the importance of listening to both sides and to be skeptical about what people said.
willamette
(182 posts)Xavier Breath
(6,640 posts)at our local NBC affiliate WDTN (WLWD at the time). He broadcast from Dayton for the first seven years of his program, so folks here tend to think of him as 'ours,' though he belonged to everyone. RIP, Phil
mdbl
(8,658 posts)RIP Phil. Thanks for everything.
llmart
(17,623 posts)I was a stay at home mother back in the day and looked forward to sitting down and watching his show each day. I learned an awful lot from it. He was one of the first male TV personalities who was all in for the ERA and feminists.
I don't know why, but for some reason I remember one particular show of his. He interviewed people who had worked for Pan Am (I think it was that company) who had been cheated out of their pensions because of the GOP and Reagan's policies.
There's no one quite like him these days.
Figarosmom
(12,002 posts)I'm glad he found a good life with Marlo and lived long. Living a good life is the best way to stop all the haters from getting to you.
Baitball Blogger
(52,350 posts)wolfie001
(7,667 posts)I saw his show throughout the '80s and he's the biggest reason why I support the Democratic Party!!! Always understanding and empathetic. Opposite of repukes. RIP Bill!!!
UTUSN
(77,795 posts)That said, here I go mixing in something unpleasant into a topic: I hope Tweety made amends to DONAHUE for how he treated him during Tweety's rah-rah support of W.Shrub's Iraq Attack. I notice that Tweety is being rehabilitated by the Morning Scab show. Tweety is who recruited Joe SCABS by frequently hosting him, then Scabs got his shows, later new marriage, whole new life of more ranting and raving. This is what I saw on t.v. live, from my notes of monitoring Tweety for a decade:
****** How Tweety "Executed" DONAHUE on MSNBC. Tweety was on his book tour for another one of his "books" (large type, wide spaces between lines, blank half-pages). It was in the jingoistic hysteria in the run-up to the illegal Iraq attack. The book was about supposed "Americanism" -- an American Civ 101 ripoff about books and movies and cultural stuff that are essentially American (think, "The Great Gatsby" ). So Phil welcomed him as a colleague and peer on Phil's MSNBC show for the full hour to plug the book. From the moment he appeared, there was a strange, deadly snake look in Tweety's snake eyes. Phil was walking around the audience, apparently not sensing anything, while Tweety was motionless, following him only with his eyes. Phil brought up something or other questioning blind, kneejerk jingoism, and Tweety STRUCK! He started out with venom dripping, "You see, THIS is EXACTLY what's wrong with YOU Liberals: You are NEGATIVE about this country, you find NOTHING good about it," and on and on. It took awhile before Phil figured out what was happening. Later, Phil, devastated and spent, was sitting at the table with Tweety and, weaker and weaker, did some of his trademark shoulder shrugging and arm waving. Tweety delivered the coup de grace, "What's THIS (mimicking the movements)??!! What's with the --APE-- movements???!" Days or a week or two later, Phil's cancellation was announced and took effect.
Native
(7,359 posts)UTUSN
(77,795 posts)
Plus, "Tweety" sounded too affectionate.
His Misogyny. Then M-TV held its 20th or 25th or whatever anniversary, and all the cable echo chambers were doing segments of Britney shedding her duds down to almost nothing. Not to be left behind, Tweety followed suit, with a guest "culture" commentator from Time Mag, the young humor columnist, Joel STEIN. The staff kept re-running the Britney clip, and Tweety was clearly DROOLING disgustingly. STEIN said, "You're beginning to creep me out." Tweety responded, "Yeah, well, wait till YOU're 50." This led to the suggestion that "Tweety" be modified to "Tweezer" to retain the hair reference while canceling out the affection factor and also adding the (dirty old) "geezer" angle.
Back when, misogyny was a wink-wink/smirk-smirk thing among the old style flunkies like him, there were many examples of his, with HRC being his prime target for years until she was becoming a real contender, when he yearned to host her, but the bridges had been burned.
But here's a vignette from back in the day, regarding his wife Kathleen. He deigned to host her or let her co-host a segment or so, this time with him and another recycled miscreant Mike BARNICLE. She was standing like at the front of a class and they two were sitting like the smirking, spit-balling, Catholic schoolboy-jerks that they really are. She trudged through her presentation, taking her subject seriously while the two of them smirked, giggled, and mocked all the way. But regarding Kathleen, he exemplifies one signature characteristic of misogynists: Despite the obviously hostile behaviors, they claim to adore, honor, put-on-a-pedestal women. And Tweety frequently does that over-compensating, protests-too-much thing by referring to her as, "MY QUEEN."
*************So flash forward decades to the TWITLER atrocious era, specifically calling Senator WARREN Pocahontas. Tweety hosted her soon after a TWITLER episode of it, besides a manic outburst of his sputtering interrupting, almost giggling every time he said that name, catching himself each time then protesting that it was a horrible thing, like Beavis/Butthead giggling at a dirty word. So WARREN kept to the high road and that TWITLER was not going to silence her. So then he struck, like when he lashed out at DONAHUE. He was in bursting giggle mode and said, "So, for you 'Pocahontas' will be like a clarion call for you to come charging out!1" and he busted his gut. WARREN looked sucker punched.
Darrell HAMMOND "Doing" Tweety on SNL. Tweety's ego was massively stroked after the debut of HAMMOND's impersonation of him, either in 2001 or 2002. He said, "I am now an ICON: I have been 'done' on Saturday Night Live'." The funniest line in the debut was HAMMOND as Tweety, cracking himself up with, "For the ... FIFTY ... people who watch this show... (Hardball, not SNL). In the first few times HAMMOND featured him, the target was Tweety himself -- manically interrupting, spitting, and drooling. However, the characterization evolved, not true to the original, where Tweety became the "rational" character surrounded by oddball, extremist "guests", with HAMMOND-Tweety shaking his head in disbelief at their partisan spin.
"Turning" from Being a Democrat. He (like G.E.RUSSERT and Pat CADDELL) still trades on having been a Democrat in the CARTER/O'NEILL era. In the hothouse of big time political flunkydom, STATUS and POWER come from the SUCCESS of your boss. RAYGUN kicked Tweety's bosses' rears, and Tweety gravitated to admiring that "success". When he started up his media career he was mentored by G.E. RUSSERT, who had himself already started "turning" by "reaching out" to LIMBOsevic and expending his formerly-Lib-bleeding-heart on those poor wingnuts who had been maligned and marginalized by the Liberal Elite, lo those many years. Tweety started doing video valentines to RAYGUN, promenading arm in arm with Nancy. He might have tapped into the frenzy of the FAKE impeachment, but "hatred of the CLINTONs" isn't what made him turn. The last time he was identifiably a Democrat was sometime around 1988 when Hardball (the book) was published. Throughout the year of Campaign 2000 he savaged the Dem candidate daily and went on to years of bromance over Shrub, renouncing any Democratic heritage. He said his parents were cloth coat" (Rethugs), and that basically what first drew him to the Dem side was Irish-Catholic pride over JFK. Not ideology, not idealism. He said the reason he joined the Peace Corps was specifically to avoid going to Vietnam.
How Tweety "Executed" DONAHUE on MSNBC. Tweety was on his book tour for another one of his "books" (large type, wide spaces between lines, blank half-pages). It was in the jingoistic hysteria in the run-up to the illegal Iraq attack. The book was about supposed "Americanism" -- an American Civ 101 ripoff about books and movies and cultural stuff that are essentially American (think, "The Great Gatsby" ). So Phil welcomed him as a colleague and peer on Phil's MSNBC show for the full hour to plug the book. From the moment he appeared, there was a strange, deadly snake look in Tweety's snake eyes. Phil was walking around the audience, apparently not sensing anything, while Tweety was motionless, following him only with his eyes. Phil brought up something or other questioning blind, kneejerk jingoism, and Tweety STRUCK! He started out with venom dripping, "You see, THIS is EXACTLY what's wrong with YOU Liberals: You are NEGATIVE about this country, you find NOTHING good about it," and on and on. It took awhile before Phil figured out what was happening. Later, Phil, devastated and spent, was sitting at the table with Tweety and, weaker and weaker, did some of his trademark shoulder shrugging and arm waving. Tweety delivered the coup de grace, "What's THIS (mimicking the movements)??!! What's with the --APE-- movements???!" Days or a week or two later, Phil's cancellation was announced and took effect.
How Tweety "Triggered" a Gun Incident (re: Kathleen WILLEY). At the height of the FAKE impeachment, Ms WILLEY claimed that a mystery jogger had threatened her or her cat or somebody, with the insinuation that there was a CLINTON connection. Several months later, there was gossip that the jogger had been identified. Tweety hosted her and it appeared they had discussed the identity off camera. He tried mightily to get her to say the name on the air, which she wouldn't do. Finally, he himself blurted it out, "Was it (Name/Surname)?" She wouldnt confirm it. Within days there was a bizarre incident, with the mentally disabled brother of Pat and Bay BUCHANAN going with a gun to the house of the supposed jogger named by Tweety, where there were only some foreign exchange students present. Later it was determined that the person Tweety named on the air had NOTHING to do with the supposed jogger incident.
"Heroes" Tweety and Tom DeLAY. In the aftermath of the 07-24-98 shooting of two Capitol police officers when the slain officers were duly eulogized and called heroes, Tweety latched on to this, the way we have seen him attempt to glorify himself in other instances: Like saying he was assigned to Africa in the Peace Corps and "WALKED THE SAME GROUND" THAT CHURCHILL had passed through. Or when he said, "I am an ICON! I have been 'done' by SNL!". So now that the Capitol policemen were being called heroes, Tweety came forward to say that HE had been a Capitol policemen, TOO, JUST LIKE THEM, when he was starting out. It turns out that he had worked a (temporary?) job for three months as that. In all the years before the officers were shot and eulogized, he probably NEVER referred to that job, most likely thinking of it as a rent-a-cop turn, until he could see in retrospect the glory that he had been DESTINED to from the beginning. But he is not the only glory hog. When that incident was happening, the news of the moment reported that Tom DELAY had hopped a plane out of town and immediately turned around in Houston when the incident was over. This show of courage is why he has been dubbed, "Tom-DePLANE!-DePLANE!-DELAY". But searches of countless news reports of that time show no mention of the hopping-the-plane. Only this is left: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm /... "...House members, many rushing out of town, did not have to remain behind. DeLay slipped out the main door of the Capitol less than 15 minutes after the shooting. He looked stricken. Asked if he'd seen anything, he said, "Did I ever. I don't want to talk about it." Aides rushed him into his waiting car. ...."
Native
(7,359 posts)Bengus81
(10,165 posts)Oh wait...they let him "retire" Got it....
But now they again let him show up here and there.
UTUSN
(77,795 posts)BaronChocula
(4,555 posts)BlueKota
(5,351 posts)My sympathies to Marlo and his children.
moonscape
(5,725 posts)liked him. He used to watch Phils show - late 80s - while making the beds in his and Moms room.
I was approached to be on the show but said no due to privacy concerns on a sensitive topic. The producer said they would put me in disguise and described the lengths they would go to, instances when they successfully had, etc,
Um, no. My father watches your show I told the producer and there is no disguise in the world that would fool him!
chowder66
(12,246 posts)He always reminded me of my dad.
Nanjeanne
(6,589 posts)oasis
(53,695 posts)R.I.P.
elocs
(24,486 posts)Or do we feel guilty that most of us likely haven't thought of Phil in awhile?
It says he passed away after a long illness and that should be a good thing because who would want to see him continue living with a long illness because it likely wasn't pleasant.
I don't get the RIP thing because the dead aren't resting, they're just dead.
Phil Donahue's body is certainly not alive and non-functioning, but he lives on in everybody who remembers him and respects who he was. All of us die, but some of us are never truly dead.
LilyBelle
(60 posts)with the 1992 Democratic candidates. Jerry Brown kept giving out his 1-800 number. TV has degraded. Phil was one of the greats. RIP.
Evolve Dammit
(21,777 posts)Skittles
(171,718 posts)he just seemed so even-handed, nice and very intelligent
Jack Valentino
(5,029 posts)and a favorite of my mother.
RIP, Phil....
I am quite sure that Phil Donahue's spirit will be standing in line with those
who wait to vote for Kamala Harris for President!
Bluethroughu
(7,215 posts)RIP
beemerphill
(599 posts)I liked his show and I liked the man. He was a gentleman and one of our nation's best, if not the best, talk show hosts. Whether you agreed with his politics or not, he was a person that you would be proud to call a friend.
RIP