Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:24 PM Nov 2024

Madness everywhere! I'm in an Irish pub in Atlanta and newspaper cuttings on the wall show they celebrate the IRA!

Last edited Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:44 PM - Edit history (1)

Yes, they support what was a terrorist organization here, a terrorist organization that killed 1800 people.


EDIT TO ADD THIS:

To be clear, they also had a "Remembering the hunger strikers" poster, paying tribute to Bobby Sands and other hunger strikers.
That wasn't old. It was a "40 years later" tribute to them dated 2021. Yes, that is celebrating terrorists.

97 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Madness everywhere! I'm in an Irish pub in Atlanta and newspaper cuttings on the wall show they celebrate the IRA! (Original Post) Doodley Nov 2024 OP
I was once at a St. Patrick's party at a bar in New York where it turned out they were raising money Scrivener7 Nov 2024 #1
wow... i had no idea. BlueWaveNeverEnd Nov 2024 #20
In the late 90's Docreed2003 Nov 2024 #63
My ex's mother, a 5th generation Irish American, wnylib Nov 2024 #89
lol WhiskeyGrinder Nov 2024 #2
What Pub and what Neighrhood? Raine1967 Nov 2024 #3
Not joking. I thought maybe this is just America! I lived in England most my life. I know many Americans Doodley Nov 2024 #6
Senator Joe Biden soandso Nov 2024 #35
I was in County Down the day in 1981 when Bobby Sands died visiting relatives for the 1st and only time. PufPuf23 Nov 2024 #52
What a story! I bet it there were some scary moments. Thanks for sharing. Doodley Nov 2024 #59
That could be troubles.ome. Abolishinist Nov 2024 #4
I guess you've never spent much time in Boston or NYC's most traditional Irish pubs. hlthe2b Nov 2024 #5
As I said in another reply, they have a "Remembering the hunger strikers" poster among newspaper cuttings that Doodley Nov 2024 #8
The support for the ira, a terrorist organization Meowmee Nov 2024 #12
Thank you. The support seems to be here on this thread! I am "naive" because I am shocked to see sympathizers. Doodley Nov 2024 #43
You will almost never get through to this type of person Meowmee Nov 2024 #45
That is the difference between American media, even back then, and the British media. Even though the UK has Doodley Nov 2024 #50
I don't like the BBC or the Guardian anymore Meowmee Nov 2024 #75
Who is sympathizing? I think that people are just commenting on wnylib Nov 2024 #90
I certainly did not intend to imply you were a sympathizer, but there are the "both sides" type posts here, Doodley Nov 2024 #91
In fact, I just read a post that says the IRA were freedom fighters, not terrorists. Pretty disgusting. Doodley Nov 2024 #92
The violence was generally rejected; the cause of the IRA, not so much except by Protestants and English. hlthe2b Nov 2024 #14
And "Black 47" wasn't just a bar on Second Avenue. Scrivener7 Nov 2024 #19
No. Indeed. hlthe2b Nov 2024 #21
Stop stirring up s*hit OutNow Nov 2024 #7
Please read my previous reply, and please don't accuse me of stirring any pots. I don't support the IRA. Do you? Doodley Nov 2024 #10
Do you really think the IRA is widely & actively operating today 30 years after the Peace Accords were signed? hlthe2b Nov 2024 #16
I'm happy to answer your questions. Doodley Nov 2024 #22
One of my two masters degrees before I went into medicine was in history and I did hlthe2b Nov 2024 #27
What have I written that is inaccurate according to your superior knowledge? Could you be more patronizing? Doodley Nov 2024 #31
I get that you are defensive. I will leave the thread--hoping you WILL hlthe2b Nov 2024 #34
You can't answer my question. You basically claimed I don't know what I'm talking about. You Doodley Nov 2024 #36
You've shown no inclinication to listen. So, at a later date if you would like to have a constructive discourse, sure. hlthe2b Nov 2024 #39
Listen to what? I'm waiting for you to provide one fact that you claim I got wrong. Again you insult me. Apology please. Doodley Nov 2024 #41
First time in an Irish American pub then? meadowlander Nov 2024 #9
No the first, but don't frequent them! Doodley Nov 2024 #23
Seriously. H2O Man Nov 2024 #60
LOL n/t leftstreet Nov 2024 #11
Where? Lithos Nov 2024 #13
O'Reilly's, Sandy Springs (not auto parts!) Doodley Nov 2024 #24
Nice Lithos Nov 2024 #32
I'd be interested to hear what you think. You might get a lot of insults like I have had if you take issue though! Doodley Nov 2024 #69
Freedom fighters Arazi Nov 2024 #15
Sorry, but Sinn Fein never got much more than 13% of the Northern Ireland vote during the troubles. The IRA was a Doodley Nov 2024 #26
A genocide Doodley. 600 years of monstrous occupation Arazi Nov 2024 #30
What was the "horrific oppression" or "genocide" during the troubles? Doodley Nov 2024 #70
Disenfranchisement of Catholics meadowlander Nov 2024 #78
Every Irish bar in NYC collected money for the IRA Prairie Gates Nov 2024 #17
Up the rebels! Hassin Bin Sober Nov 2024 #18
This post comes across as terribly naive Maeve Nov 2024 #25
The IRA were terrorists and were supported by a small percentage of people in Northern Ireland. I am naive if I'm not Doodley Nov 2024 #29
Are we not talking about old, yellowed newspaper clippings? Xavier Breath Nov 2024 #37
No. They are not yellowed. Would it be okay to put Nazi symbolism up in a public place, or conferate flags, or support Doodley Nov 2024 #56
Wow, overreact much? Xavier Breath Nov 2024 #66
The Unionists were also terrorists and the British government was oppressive Maeve Nov 2024 #49
Which bit justifies the IRA killing and maiming innocent people? Which bit of history don't I understand as well as you? Doodley Nov 2024 #53
The part where Unionists and Brit gov. also killed innocents Maeve Nov 2024 #55
And locked Catholics out of jobs, housing and the political process for decades. meadowlander Nov 2024 #74
You are kinder than me. H2O Man Nov 2024 #62
I've spent 20 years studying the issues Maeve Nov 2024 #65
I have family H2O Man Nov 2024 #81
I wish we could sit down and talk...your family history is fascinating Maeve Nov 2024 #85
1 person's terrorist is another person's freedom fighter. mopinko Nov 2024 #28
Don't pretend that the British government didn't bear some responsibility for the violence dflprincess Nov 2024 #33
... yonder Nov 2024 #38
That's my signature line. greatauntoftriplets Nov 2024 #48
It's as fine a seal as the promise it bears. yonder Nov 2024 #87
One mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter. Xolodno Nov 2024 #40
I hope you left. Now, never go back there. Iggo Nov 2024 #42
One could always tell what side the bar was by the whiskey they sold Historic NY Nov 2024 #44
In the 1990's, both were bought by a FRENCH company Maeve Nov 2024 #51
Nothing surprising about that Cirsium Nov 2024 #46
They had a "Remembering the hunger strikers" poster, paying tribute to Bobby Sands and other hunger strikers. Doodley Nov 2024 #47
You should've put that in the OP. Iggo Nov 2024 #54
I will do it now. Thanks! Doodley Nov 2024 #61
And the Brits were angels. And the Black and Tan were choir boys. NoRethugFriends Nov 2024 #57
My bet - Someone at the pub has friends or relatives who are in the IRA. SupportSanity Nov 2024 #58
Is this The Onion? H2O Man Nov 2024 #64
My mother's side of the family came from Ireland soandso Nov 2024 #67
Extremely common DetroitLegalBeagle Nov 2024 #68
Thanks for sharing. Good story about your friend's cousin! The Brits heard that funding for the IRA came from US. Doodley Nov 2024 #71
I worked for a property management company at that time soandso Nov 2024 #73
Soandso, I said I would remember your name when you were so courteous on another thread. You mix Doodley Nov 2024 #77
Wouldn't go that far, lol soandso Nov 2024 #79
I dunno, I cheered when they rocketed 10 Downing Street. Voltaire2 Nov 2024 #72
And the next year, ten percent of those who voted in Northern Ireland, voted for Sinn Fein. It was an act of terrorism. Doodley Nov 2024 #76
I have a friend who went into a bar to get a pop and he evidently ordered the *right* Irish whiskey. LudwigPastorius Nov 2024 #80
Many people, including some in her own government, whathehell Nov 2024 #82
I'm delighted with the responses to your hostility to Irish unity OutNow Nov 2024 #83
these were not unity, these were murderous terror: Celerity Nov 2024 #84
My late husband was from Ireland CountAllVotes Nov 2024 #86
This isn't a new thing re Irish Pubs in the U.S. especially the ones that were started up by IRA and supporters. msfiddlestix Nov 2024 #88
I wonder if I ever saw you play at the pubs in S.F. CountAllVotes Nov 2024 #93
Mostly at the Plough. I think I did play Ireland's 32 once, but usually was always the Plough, or at the Star and Plough msfiddlestix Nov 2024 #94
Lots of great memories from your post CountAllVotes Nov 2024 #95
There were great memories, did you play? msfiddlestix Nov 2024 #96
Yes, I am a musician CountAllVotes Nov 2024 #97

Scrivener7

(59,520 posts)
1. I was once at a St. Patrick's party at a bar in New York where it turned out they were raising money
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:26 PM
Nov 2024

Last edited Sun Nov 24, 2024, 09:53 PM - Edit history (1)

to buy guns "for the cause."

I had no idea until months later.

It was pretty common in the US. Forever.

Docreed2003

(18,714 posts)
63. In the late 90's
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:41 PM
Nov 2024

I was in an Irish pub in Chicago & an older Irish gentleman struck up a conversation, asked me my family connections to Ireland, and ask me if I'd ever considered "contributing to the cause". The conversation went from charming to unsettling quickly

wnylib

(26,009 posts)
89. My ex's mother, a 5th generation Irish American,
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 10:13 PM
Nov 2024

used to donate regularly for guns for "the cause." She told me once that there were visitors to her church who privately collected money for the IRA. Don't know if that was true. She was not the most honest person.

Raine1967

(11,676 posts)
3. What Pub and what Neighrhood?
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:31 PM
Nov 2024

Are you being sarcastic?

Seriously, if you are not joking, call the place out.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
6. Not joking. I thought maybe this is just America! I lived in England most my life. I know many Americans
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:44 PM
Nov 2024

supported the IRA. For example they have a framed poster here saying "Remembering the Hunger Strikers," specifically mentioning Bobby Sands. These were IRA terrorists who were imprisoned and went on Hunger Strike. Bobby Sands died and made himself a martyr.

 

soandso

(1,631 posts)
35. Senator Joe Biden
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:37 PM
Nov 2024

Tried to change an extradition treaty with the UK to prevent IRA in the US from being extradited. I don't recall if he was successful.

PufPuf23

(9,852 posts)
52. I was in County Down the day in 1981 when Bobby Sands died visiting relatives for the 1st and only time.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:23 PM
Nov 2024

Found out one branch of Irish family was Catholic (3/8s Irish and the rest Western European mutt); and that my great grandfather had sold the family store and gone to California in 1880 with intent to bring family to the USA. Great grandfather abandoned family. Grandfather came to California in 1888 looking and finding his father. I knew of the existence because father's oldest brother had kept written contact with a 1st cousin.

Had no idea great grandfather came to California before grandfather and was lacking in personal knowledge that family was Catholic or specifics of the Troubles. My Jewish now exe-wife played fiddle in a band that played Irish music was my level of awareness though Irish surnamed. We had driven a rental car from Rosslare to Galway to County Down and stayed on a farm where my great grandfather and grandfather had lived as a child. I have a tile from the of their childhood home here in my office.

Bobby Sands died that first night. Northern Ireland went on strike. Relatives from Belfast and elsewhere came to the farm because of the strike and the oddity of my visit. There was a picture of JFK on the wall in the dining room. The countryside as quiet with UK military checkpoints. We went to the parish and met the priest and visited the ruins of a flax mill ruin on the River Mourne where family had worked. We were pulled over in the empty countryside by a group from a military helicopter that landed in the field in front of us after tailing us by air.

That evening part of the family took us to a pub in the small, largely Catholic, village. We went in quietly through a back door as the village was subject to the general strike. The pub was owned by a woman who had re-immigrated back to the village of her family after owning a bar in Brooklyn. Lots of singing. Some folks had taken temperance pledges. All were hardcore supporters of the IRA, singing IRA songs. One of the family members, my 2nd cousin, that lived on the farm was an IRA widow with a teen son. While we were in the pub the IRA came through the village, hung banners and spray-painted slogans on buildings. We went on some hikes but stayed the next several days on the farm.

Our schedule was to go to Dublin the day that turned out to be the day of Bobby Sands' funeral. Family dove with us to border where there was a military checkpoint. Every town and village on the highway to Dublin had funeral parades. We had a hotel booked and the car drop in downtown Dublin, got near, parked the car on a sidewalk and walked to planned destination with luggage. Caught an airport shuttle and flew to London on first plane seats available.

hlthe2b

(113,954 posts)
5. I guess you've never spent much time in Boston or NYC's most traditional Irish pubs.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:43 PM
Nov 2024

This is not that rare. But, in the decades since the peace accords (Good Friday Agreement, 1998), I think it might be time to consider this merely a historical artifact.

I assume the OP is being sarcastic, but I honestly can't tell if a couple of others on the thread are as well.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
8. As I said in another reply, they have a "Remembering the hunger strikers" poster among newspaper cuttings that
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:51 PM
Nov 2024

are supportive. No, I've not been to many Irish pubs here, but coming from England, I remember the terrorism well, and that the IRA and its objectives were overwhelmingly rejected in every election by the people of Northern Ireland.

Meowmee

(9,212 posts)
12. The support for the ira, a terrorist organization
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:57 PM
Nov 2024

which was also aligned with and trained by another terrorist organization, the plo, and its supporters, has been here for forever sadly and is hypocritical at the least. I also lived in England when they were blowing up innocent people with bombs in London. It was a terrifying time that I will never forget nor forgive.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
43. Thank you. The support seems to be here on this thread! I am "naive" because I am shocked to see sympathizers.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:53 PM
Nov 2024

Meowmee

(9,212 posts)
45. You will almost never get through to this type of person
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:58 PM
Nov 2024

I learned that long ago. But keep stating what you believe anyway. Also thanks for this post because it alerted to me to how many people here on DU have these views- it’s not shocking to me because I was attacked by similar types a while back. It’s important to note that the ira were not only butchers of innocents in those bombings but also of many of their own who they also murdered.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
50. That is the difference between American media, even back then, and the British media. Even though the UK has
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:21 PM
Nov 2024

the gutter press, there are decent broadsheets like the Guardian, broadcasting standards, and the BBC, that is the gold standard in journalism, even if it isn't perfect. Look at Robert Kilroy Silk, shamed for attacking Muslims, and forced to resign. That is an everyday thing by an American president (Trump) and he is never held to account. The media can't even do that. It is just a different standard. There is no real debate of the issues. Shows like Newsnight don't exist. That's not to say there isn't a lot of Democrats that can't see through the propaganda asking them to support a terrorist organization. Anyway that's my thought FWIW.

Meowmee

(9,212 posts)
75. I don't like the BBC or the Guardian anymore
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:21 AM
Nov 2024

But the G still have some good articles. I can’t remember the coverage on the IRA at the time we were living there which was a long time ago. I remember being terrified when we sometimes went to London, and hearing the details of the terrorist attacks. We were caught in delays/ traffic for hours once due to a suspected bomb in a mailbox there.

I have not read about what happened with Silk, good for them for speaking out against him at least. Some of the media here have spoken against the orange psycho but it has come to nothing, and they mostly enabled him tragically.

wnylib

(26,009 posts)
90. Who is sympathizing? I think that people are just commenting on
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 10:26 PM
Nov 2024

people and situations that they have seen or heard.

For example, I mentioned in an earlier post that my ex MIL used to tell me about donating to the IRA through "visitors" to her church. That was in the 1970s. I have no idea if she was telling the truth. I definitely did not sympathize.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
91. I certainly did not intend to imply you were a sympathizer, but there are the "both sides" type posts here,
Tue Nov 26, 2024, 04:10 AM
Nov 2024

and attacks on me personally as I have called out the pub for sympathizing. I appreciated your response and apologize if it seemed I was suggesting otherwise.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
92. In fact, I just read a post that says the IRA were freedom fighters, not terrorists. Pretty disgusting.
Tue Nov 26, 2024, 04:15 AM
Nov 2024

hlthe2b

(113,954 posts)
14. The violence was generally rejected; the cause of the IRA, not so much except by Protestants and English.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 09:14 PM
Nov 2024

There was a very big difference between the Catholics and Protestants in terms of their beliefs vis-a-vis " the Troubles" which underlies the very issue. Those differences likewise were prominent among Irish in Boston, Chicago, NYC, and other areas of the US with large populations. You might do some reading on the horrible deadly consequences that came from BOTH sides during the troubles. It was NOT all one-sided. "Sunday, Bloody Sunday" was not just a catchy U2 song...

Regardless, I don't see why after 30 years you want to dredge this up again as though those Pub owners were somehow plotting to reestablish the IRA again. If, so I frankly think that is ridiculous. It was their heritage, but nonetheless, I'm guessing they aren't wanting to celebrate that which we all abhor.

Have you studied the history of this episode of history for England and Northern Ireland? I'm surprised a bit at the comments if so. I must be much older than some on this thread who don't seem to know much about it.

OutNow

(916 posts)
7. Stop stirring up s*hit
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:50 PM
Nov 2024

The Good Friday agreement was signed in 1998 and brought peace to both Irish countries. Sein Fein is the most popular political party in both sides of the border.

The struggle for a united Ireland is closer to victory than any time in the last 200 years. You shouldn't be shocked that many Irish Americans have always supported the goals of the IRA.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
10. Please read my previous reply, and please don't accuse me of stirring any pots. I don't support the IRA. Do you?
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 08:54 PM
Nov 2024

hlthe2b

(113,954 posts)
16. Do you really think the IRA is widely & actively operating today 30 years after the Peace Accords were signed?
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 09:20 PM
Nov 2024

Do you think the area is rampant with violence?

Honestly, Doodley, this surprises me. I don't want to annoy or anger you. But, I think you need to do some historical reading on this as well as to educate yourself on the status of Northern Ireland today. The main area of political conflict has to do with Brexit in recent years. Yes, I get that you spent time in England. But the issues are far broader than a single perspective.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
22. I'm happy to answer your questions.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:08 PM
Nov 2024

Do you really think the IRA is widely & actively operating today 30 years after the Peace Accords were signed?
Reply to hlthe2b (Reply #16)


No. I never said I do.

Do you think the area is rampant with violence?

No. I never said I do.

Honestly, Doodley, this surprises me. I don't want to annoy or anger you. But, I think you need to do some historical reading on this as well as to educate yourself on the status of Northern Ireland today.


Oh really? You think you know better than me, do you? I don't anger easily. Just as well, because you are assuming a lot about me and are coming across as very patronizing.

hlthe2b

(113,954 posts)
27. One of my two masters degrees before I went into medicine was in history and I did
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:17 PM
Nov 2024

study the history of Ireland, England, Scotland, and yes, "the Troubles" with comparisons to the Middle East-- publishing findings in a Master's Degree dissertation, so yes. I do probably know a bit more unless you have studied it systematically. I'm sorry if you find that patronizing, as it is not my desire to insult you. But based on your reactions and assessments, I have to think you are not as well-read on the history---more recent and preceded by previous centuries--or at least very limited in your perspective. If that isn't the case, perhaps you want to reread what you actually wrote and perhaps clarify. I note several on this thread arriving at the same conclusion, so, while I stress that I don't wish to embarrass or as you say, "be patronizing" to you, you do come across as very limited in your knowledge and perspective.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
31. What have I written that is inaccurate according to your superior knowledge? Could you be more patronizing?
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:25 PM
Nov 2024

hlthe2b

(113,954 posts)
34. I get that you are defensive. I will leave the thread--hoping you WILL
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:34 PM
Nov 2024

do some more reading on the issues and get a broader view of the complexities of the issues that continue to echo to this day. People don't forget and may have reasons to feel sympathy for those who were victimized or persecuted in years past--but that does not mean they are latter-day "terrorists" as you proclaim.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
36. You can't answer my question. You basically claimed I don't know what I'm talking about. You
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:39 PM
Nov 2024

insulted me, and instead of giving examples when asked, you say you will leave the thread. You could apologise, but you choose to patronize me again.

hlthe2b

(113,954 posts)
39. You've shown no inclinication to listen. So, at a later date if you would like to have a constructive discourse, sure.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:43 PM
Nov 2024

But, this has escalated beyond that. Have a good evening.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
41. Listen to what? I'm waiting for you to provide one fact that you claim I got wrong. Again you insult me. Apology please.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:46 PM
Nov 2024

Lithos

(26,638 posts)
13. Where?
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 09:05 PM
Nov 2024

I've been to a few in the Atlanta area and do not recall much other than Football and other sports being posted.

L-

Lithos

(26,638 posts)
32. Nice
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:32 PM
Nov 2024

I know of it, though have never gone to it. I spend more of my time either around Vinings over to Buckhead and over to Downtown. Will check it out next time if I have a spare evening.

L-

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
69. I'd be interested to hear what you think. You might get a lot of insults like I have had if you take issue though!
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:57 PM
Nov 2024

Arazi

(8,887 posts)
15. Freedom fighters
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 09:19 PM
Nov 2024

After 600 years of brutal oppression by the British including an actual genocide with the potato famine, the Irish finally fought back.

Over a million dead and another million displaced in the famine - at least 25% of the entire Irish population at the time. That history isn’t going to be forgotten - ever

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
26. Sorry, but Sinn Fein never got much more than 13% of the Northern Ireland vote during the troubles. The IRA was a
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:16 PM
Nov 2024

terrorist organization that killed many innocent people and didn't have the support of the people of NI.

Arazi

(8,887 posts)
30. A genocide Doodley. 600 years of monstrous occupation
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:24 PM
Nov 2024

The IRA were freedom fighters finally fighting back against horrific oppression.

Innocent Brits were killed but it’s a tiny fraction compared to the torture, slaughter and displacement of millions of innocent Irish before they finally got tough and overthrew the British occupation.

Edited to add that Northern Ireland is part of the UK. You know that right?

meadowlander

(5,133 posts)
78. Disenfranchisement of Catholics
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:32 AM
Nov 2024

who were not allowed to vote unless they owned property until 1969. Reduced provision of essential services to Catholic areas like water supply, sewer lines and public transport by disproportionately Protestant local government bodies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_man,_one_vote#Northern_Ireland

The RUC could detain people indefinitely without cause and used torture on suspects.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Demetrius

Shooting unarmed civilians in the street at a peaceful protest march.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Sunday_(1972)

Discrimination in housing and employment forcing Catholics into poverty and ghettos or homelessness

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Segregation_in_Northern_Ireland

Economic violence is violence. If you make it impossible for people to feed and house their families and take away their vote, they become desperate and have few options but to descend into physical violence.

I don't condone political violence but I understand there are conditions under which it probably becomes inevitable.

Prairie Gates

(8,152 posts)
17. Every Irish bar in NYC collected money for the IRA
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 09:28 PM
Nov 2024

And this was DURING the terror campaigns.

None of this was a secret.

Maeve

(43,456 posts)
25. This post comes across as terribly naive
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:15 PM
Nov 2024

How many were killed by the Unionist terrorists? Are we really going to play that game 20+ years later?
A lot of American Irish left their homeland because of laws and customs they found unjust and so became resistance from afar. Situations have changed. Thatcher is dead. Give it a rest.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
29. The IRA were terrorists and were supported by a small percentage of people in Northern Ireland. I am naive if I'm not
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:20 PM
Nov 2024

supposed to be shocked to see people now supporting the actions of the IRA.

Xavier Breath

(6,640 posts)
37. Are we not talking about old, yellowed newspaper clippings?
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:40 PM
Nov 2024

This conflict was resolved decades ago. The people who put the clippings up have probably long ago moved on to their final reward. The current owners probably keep them up because they're kitschy.

If you're still troubled by it, then why not have a dialogue about it with the barkeep? Get their read on things.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
56. No. They are not yellowed. Would it be okay to put Nazi symbolism up in a public place, or conferate flags, or support
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:29 PM
Nov 2024

for apartheid? This was a celebration of terrorists, some created a few years ago.

Xavier Breath

(6,640 posts)
66. Wow, overreact much?
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:50 PM
Nov 2024

What I wrote was reasonable and meant as part of a serious discourse, which you clearly don't want to have.



Maeve

(43,456 posts)
49. The Unionists were also terrorists and the British government was oppressive
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:14 PM
Nov 2024

Learn some history

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
53. Which bit justifies the IRA killing and maiming innocent people? Which bit of history don't I understand as well as you?
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:25 PM
Nov 2024

meadowlander

(5,133 posts)
74. And locked Catholics out of jobs, housing and the political process for decades.
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:14 AM
Nov 2024

Only landowners got to vote in Northern Ireland until 1969 which incentivized the Protestant minority to make it almost impossible for Catholics to buy property which led to mass unemployment and homelessness with no spending on social services approved by politicians who were basically all Protestants.

"One person, one vote" was what the IRA was fighting for. Something I would hope seems like a no-brainer to people living in modern democracies.

Maeve

(43,456 posts)
65. I've spent 20 years studying the issues
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:48 PM
Nov 2024

I side with the Nationalists, but some made bad choices. War is messy and always involves evil, neither side has clean hands. Ever.
I think you are a realist, so we agree more than not.

H2O Man

(79,048 posts)
81. I have family
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:43 AM
Nov 2024

that was actively involved in the struggle for hundreds of years. I have poetry written in the 1700s, of a grandfather in a dungeon, sentenced to death. My father's father's cousin fought with The Big Guy in the early 1900s, and served time with Collins, and became the second Secretary of Finance. Grandpa gave his grandchildren bills with his cousin's signature. I had a distant cousin who I was told delivered supplies to Bobby Sands.

The thing about wars is that everyone gets hurt. The combined totals of those dead from each side is the tip of the iceberg. The damage done continues to show up. I talk with cousins in Ireland frequently, and some of the hateful things I hear suggest they are not much different from the maga population.

Maeve

(43,456 posts)
85. I wish we could sit down and talk...your family history is fascinating
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 08:52 AM
Nov 2024

Yes, the divide continues and the one time we were in No. Ireland was only a day trip; Hubby wouldn't spend the night there. But I did want to see the Causeway and Carrick-A-Rede.

mopinko

(73,724 posts)
28. 1 person's terrorist is another person's freedom fighter.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:17 PM
Nov 2024

up the ra.
u rly shd read up on the troubles. it wasnt irish v irish, it was irish v the brits, arming and stoking the udf.

find the doc- the miami show band massacre. was on netflix.

dflprincess

(29,341 posts)
33. Don't pretend that the British government didn't bear some responsibility for the violence
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:34 PM
Nov 2024

Bloody Sunday (1972) ring a bell?

Xolodno

(7,349 posts)
40. One mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:46 PM
Nov 2024

Nothing is black and white, it's usually varying shades of grey depending on who you talk to. One person may take an absolutist view on one side, likewise, someone else will do the opposite. Sad to say, often both sides have valid reasons for it.

It's easy to force our own morality on a subject, but far harder to understand and come to the altar of compromise.

Historic NY

(40,037 posts)
44. One could always tell what side the bar was by the whiskey they sold
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:55 PM
Nov 2024

Catholic based wouldn't sell Bushmills whiskey only Jameson Whiskey

My family was from both areas in Ireland

Maeve

(43,456 posts)
51. In the 1990's, both were bought by a FRENCH company
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:22 PM
Nov 2024

And later sold to international conglomerates. The company who owns Bushmills also owns Guinness. The war is over and money won. Drink what you like.

Cirsium

(3,942 posts)
46. Nothing surprising about that
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 10:58 PM
Nov 2024

Irish pubs in the Midwest routinely collected money for the IRA. The clippings you saw are probably old.

Your post is ill informed.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
47. They had a "Remembering the hunger strikers" poster, paying tribute to Bobby Sands and other hunger strikers.
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:03 PM
Nov 2024

That wasn't old. It was a tribute to them dated 2021. Yes, that is celebrating a terrorist.

 

soandso

(1,631 posts)
67. My mother's side of the family came from Ireland
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:55 PM
Nov 2024

Irish Catholic. Then my stepfather, who she married I was 12, also came from Irish stock. St Patrick's day was a big deal to them, as well as everything Irish. I never got the bug and don't identify with the place, at all. I'm glad my ancestors left. It looks like a dreary, miserable place with a bunch of boozers.

DetroitLegalBeagle

(2,504 posts)
68. Extremely common
Sun Nov 24, 2024, 11:55 PM
Nov 2024

Many Irish bars openly raised money for the IRA. Some sent donated guns from the US and smuggled them into Ireland. A high school friend of mine had an older cousin and uncle who traveled over there to help train their snipers, supposedly at least. He told us this in high school so he could have been full of shit.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
71. Thanks for sharing. Good story about your friend's cousin! The Brits heard that funding for the IRA came from US.
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:05 AM
Nov 2024
 

soandso

(1,631 posts)
73. I worked for a property management company at that time
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:13 AM
Nov 2024

and had a guy come in about some work on driveways. We became fairly friendly, lunching together, and he was involved with the IRA and getting guns and money to them. He had an Irish surname and was as Irish looking as it gets (big ginger with freckles). He was really into what was going on over there (which wasn't of much interest to me, more a curiosity).

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
77. Soandso, I said I would remember your name when you were so courteous on another thread. You mix
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:28 AM
Nov 2024

with some interesting folks!

 

soandso

(1,631 posts)
79. Wouldn't go that far, lol
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:35 AM
Nov 2024

He had an engineering company and I hired him to fix the driveways of an apartment complex. We liked each other but were not friends outside of a professional relationship. I didn't know enough about what was happening in Ireland to ask him a whole lot about it, other than they were fighting over there.

Doodley

(11,912 posts)
76. And the next year, ten percent of those who voted in Northern Ireland, voted for Sinn Fein. It was an act of terrorism.
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:21 AM
Nov 2024

LudwigPastorius

(14,723 posts)
80. I have a friend who went into a bar to get a pop and he evidently ordered the *right* Irish whiskey.
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:39 AM
Nov 2024

He thought nothing of it when a couple of guys started chatting him up, asking him what his name was (an Irish name) if he was Catholic (he was).

They then proceeded to try and recruit him for the IRA, saying, "ya know, we could use a strong, tall fella sooch as yerself".

(This was quite some time ago, so hopefully, all that shit will stay in the past.)

whathehell

(30,468 posts)
82. Many people, including some in her own government,
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 12:59 AM
Nov 2024

did not like the way Margaret Thatcher handled the Hunger Strike and would hesitate to call those partaking in it "terrorists".

The British were not neutral in the way they handled the two sides of the supposedly "sectarian" conflict. One way in which they demonstrated this was to label only the Catholic IRA as "terrorists", while refusing to characterize the equally violent Protestant "loyalists" in the same way, referring to them merely as "militants" or other morally neutral terms.

OutNow

(916 posts)
83. I'm delighted with the responses to your hostility to Irish unity
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 07:08 AM
Nov 2024

Your posts read like you're channeling Ian Paisley, the most reactionary of the Irish DUP terrorists. You might not be aware, but Bobby Sands is viewed as an Irish hero by many folks on both side of the border. The mural of Bobby Sands in Belfast is world famous and it honestly brought tears to my eyes when I visited it remembering the torture he endured in H block prison before he died in 1981.

I am delighted with the dozens of posts following your screed that supported the Irish struggle for a united Ireland, a goal that is closer every day.

CountAllVotes

(22,215 posts)
86. My late husband was from Ireland
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 10:35 AM
Nov 2024

He left Ireland in 1956 to come to this country.

He never talked a whole lot about the fact that the 10 brothers and sisters he had all grew up in extreme poverty as it was shameful to him.

His father died in 1939 and was involved with the resistance. It left a widow with 10 kids and no one to support the family other than the children which is what my husband had to do; drop out of school and work the farm which was far more important than education.

He worked at many different Irish pubs in San Francisco over the years. They all had a jar on the bar saying it was for "Northern Aid".

I don't know if the money in that jar actually went for Northern Aid but it was always full of contributions.

I remember the death of Bobby Sands and the hunger strikers. They had a reason for being hunger strikers, like my husband's dead father with 10 kids left behind with no support.

My husband referred to the history of Ireland as being 1100 years of resistance. He knew his history well. He had a good reason to feel the way he did. The family farm is still up and running and no British government was ever able to take away this ancient farm he grew up on and cared for. The farm was their mother after all. Without it, they would have all died during the Great Famine. Strangely, there are no records of this farm in Griffith's Valuation of Ireland, a record that is used by genealogists to trace their ancestors. The 15 people that lived in the thatched cottage were nowhere to be found according to Griffith's records.

More about Griffith's Valuation of Ireland here:
Ireland, Griffith’s Valuation, 1847-1864

https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/1269/

Forgotten perhaps, dead not. My husband left behind 40 nieces and nephews when he died. I wonder how many of them know the horror of what had occurred?

He was out in the fields working one day and found an old pipe buried near the family graveyard. It said on it "Ireland for the Irish" in Gaelic, a motto that he lived by.

My own family left Tipperary in the 1840s and came to New York and Boston. I still have a few distant relatives living in these place today as well as San Francisco. Again, dead but not forgotten!

Ireland has a long sad history.

May Bobby Sands rest in peace.

& recommend.

msfiddlestix

(8,178 posts)
88. This isn't a new thing re Irish Pubs in the U.S. especially the ones that were started up by IRA and supporters.
Mon Nov 25, 2024, 10:05 PM
Nov 2024

it's been going on since early twentieth century. in the U.S. Their weapons were/are largely smuggled from here for nearly a century. I was an Irish music for a number of years, and got the history right out of the pubs in San Francisco. it was kinda a weird wake up experience the first time I played. after that I just had to ignore those guys, I was there to play music.

CountAllVotes

(22,215 posts)
93. I wonder if I ever saw you play at the pubs in S.F.
Tue Nov 26, 2024, 12:30 PM
Nov 2024

There was Ireland's 32, The Plough and the Stars, The Abbey Tavern and The Blarney Stone.

Do any of these places ring a bell?

If you knew that whole scene at all, I bet you crossed paths with my late husband as his brother owned a pub in San Francisco!

Small world not!



msfiddlestix

(8,178 posts)
94. Mostly at the Plough. I think I did play Ireland's 32 once, but usually was always the Plough, or at the Star and Plough
Tue Nov 26, 2024, 05:07 PM
Nov 2024

in Berkeley. That was way back in the 90;s and early aughts. My trad music interests past several years though is Appalachian/Bluegrass, so I haven't been there in years.
But I'll never forget my first experience at the Plough and Stars When I learned the patrons wee IRA, I think the owner(s) not positive about that, but I have no reason to think he wasn't. Of course, I was fairly steeped in the Irish culture/history and certainly was sympathetic to a point.
I also learned along the way, how much organized smuggling with the exceedingly important help of law enforcers who were Irish and IRA family connected etc whether we're talking about New York, Boston, or San Francisco. etc.
Going on since long before I was born, and I Just turned 74. So, I was surprised to see this post I guess younger generations are not clued into this aspect of U.S. history.

CountAllVotes

(22,215 posts)
95. Lots of great memories from your post
Tue Nov 26, 2024, 06:12 PM
Nov 2024

The pubs in Berkeley were my father's hang-outs. He'd go into town once a year to celebrate St. Patrick's Day I remember.

I grew up saturated in the Irish culture needless to say and married into it as well.

Thanks for your post!



msfiddlestix

(8,178 posts)
96. There were great memories, did you play?
Tue Nov 26, 2024, 06:25 PM
Nov 2024

By the way, I meant to refer to the playing I did was in Sessions, not performances. But you would know that if you went to the sessions yourself!!

CountAllVotes

(22,215 posts)
97. Yes, I am a musician
Tue Nov 26, 2024, 06:44 PM
Nov 2024

I studied for years at the guitar, viola, clarinet and a bit of piano and violin.

I don't play much any more due to arthritis in my hands. Even typing is an effort now.

I think you are referring to traveling around from one pub to the next and hopefully you'd have a couple of others with you (?). You'd play for a length of time but who knows how long?

My brother-in-law played the accordion and used to play with other musicians when he could get them together. If you knew of any accordion players, it may have been him as I cannot think of any others.

This was indeed an aspect of history buried in the past. You got that right about how the law enforcement was in on it as well as many were Irish that supported the cause so to speak. It would make a great book I've often thought.

I know one pub still has an original owner in the Richmond, O'Keeffe's.

I suppose you might remember Harrington's? He had two pubs, one served lunch and the other one was in the Tenderloin. That was years ago. Great times indeed!

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Madness everywhere! I'm i...