General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNew Yorker: We ask babies to have more courage facing guns than politicians facing gun lobby
Last edited Fri Dec 14, 2012, 11:04 PM - Edit history (1)
http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/closeread/2012/12/the-newtown-shooting-kindergarteners-and-courage.htmlSome of the info is wrong here as to the father being shot, but Amy Davidson asks an important question:
"The contrast here is not only between the civility of the children and the cruelty of the shooter, but between what was asked of them at this moment and how little the public and elected officials ask of themselves when it comes to doing something about gun violence. *snip* How do we find ourselves asking kindergarteners to be more courageous in the face of a gunman than politicians are in the face of the gun lobby?"
From Reuters Michelle McLoughlin
Young Children wait outside Sandy Hook Elementary School after a shooting in Newtown.
Amy Davidson: you hit the nail on the head.
Skittles
(153,226 posts)the gun lobby represents cowards
bettyellen
(47,209 posts)Tsiyu
(18,186 posts)been doing research for a book on dysfunctional "preppers" and arsenal owners.
They are scared chicken littles, petrified of the world, and I'm amazed how honest many of them are in admitting online how often they pee their pants while hunting or out in the woods because they "hear something scary." Honestly, the ones who claim to have the most weapons are the most timid and freaked out by the world.
Yet they have no problem when kindergarten students have to brave their way out of a gunman's sights. All they care about is they might not get to keep their security blankets - also known as arsenals big enough to take down small cities.
They are lily-livered chicken shit scum, and the politicians who fellate them are cowardly PIGS.
Small children are braver than the cowering, simpering NRA-licking politicians, who should all be ashamed to even show their poltroonish faces.
UndahCovah
(125 posts)to take back what you said about preppers. The world is a very dangerous, unpredictable place. Have you ever been to a third world country? Well guess what, I have.
Look at all the shit going down all over the world. Do you think America is impervious, protected, magically-untouchable? This country is headed for a fall. In my opinion, the foolish ones are the people who are unable or unwilling to see that, and refuse to make provisions for their safety.
Prepare, then prepare again. Don't stick your head in the sand and pretend that you are somehow going to be protected; protect yourself. I'm not referring to guns in particular, BTW.
SunSeeker
(51,755 posts)You're 43 times more likely to be killed by your own gun than by an intruder's. You are unlikely to have an intruder. But you are very likely to get drunk, get depressed, get in a fight with someone in your house, or have your kid find your gun. That's how people get killed. Having a gun in the house makes it far more likely that you'll get your own head blown off.
That's why it is so crazy to suggest you should buy a gun for your own protection. I would imagine this woman knew her son had mental issues. Ironically, maybe she thought those guns would protect her from him.
http://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/more-guns-more-suicides/
UndahCovah
(125 posts)I'm NOT particularly referring to guns. General prepping for any kind of emergency is a wise choice, not a dysfunctional one. The truth is, this world IS a scary place to live, and a lot of bad shit can happen to a person. You can minimize or avert at least some of it by being prepared.
tblue37
(65,502 posts)SunSeeker
(51,755 posts)But an earthquake kit ain't gonna kill me or anyone else. A gun, on the other hand, will make it more likely I or someone close to me will die.
themandylion
(6 posts)I'm not trying to kill intruders. I'm trying to persuade them to disengage and leave after filling their underwear, when they see and/or hear I am not a helpless victim.
There are thousands upon thousands of instances annually of home invaders leaving in a hurry when a gun is presented against them. No one dies BECAUSE of that firearm.
I'm not about to sit for several minutes "hoping" the police get to me before the home-invading goon makes it to my children or I.
AllyCat
(16,239 posts)And require some actual testing and licensing to drive them. Cars and guns are not even close in argument.
SunSeeker
(51,755 posts)Did you join DU just to tell us "cars kill too"?
Surgery kills people too, but like cars, the vast majority of the time, except for accidents, it serves its purpose of aiding us in living our lives. Guns are only built to kill. Guns don't help us live our lives. On the contrary, most of the time, a gun kills its owner rather than anyone else.
ananda
(28,887 posts)Guns are designed for only one thing: to kill.
Sheldon Cooper
(3,724 posts)'leave after filling their underwear'. Do you realize how ridiculous that sounds? It's not enough that you have to scare off an intruder, you HAVE to include that you've made him shit his pants. So macho.
magical thyme
(14,881 posts)Enjoy your visit. Keep it short, Mr. Cars Kill People Too.
RetroLounge
(37,250 posts)RL
UndahCovah
(125 posts)I hope you never have to weather any kind of disaster.
RetroLounge
(37,250 posts)_!_
RL
smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)UndahCovah
(125 posts)Cerridwen
(13,260 posts)I would speculate...no.
I'd also speculate you made a wrong turn.
I'm weird that way.
Yannow, going under cover means not saying so. I'm just sayin'.
lsewpershad
(2,620 posts)are you talking about? Do you which country in the world has killed more people in the world?
DainBramaged
(39,191 posts)War on Christmas? FAUX news lies and people die?
What is this prepare you are so enamored with?
Remember, a vote for Romney was a wasted vote.
_ed_
(1,734 posts)Wow, you need help.
Tsiyu
(18,186 posts)I have no problem with those who prep, but the arguments some of them have over SHTF are absolutely stunning.
If I have to live in a world where I shoot a small child who comes to my door hungry, and live inside a bunker like a dog, and absolutely hate my fellow human beings over "stuff" I think I'd rather "die with the stupid masses" as some preppers might say.
There's a life to live right here and now, and people who need help right here and now, and stickpiling shit just pales in importance to that.
YMMV.
myrna minx
(22,772 posts)Iris
(15,673 posts)riverwalker
(8,694 posts)Ilsa
(61,709 posts)ask kindergartners to face the real boogeyman.
horsedoc
(81 posts)Our leaders have failed us time and again.
DallasNE
(7,404 posts)Here is how Amy Davidson concluded her article. It is so moving it needs to be repeated here.
Guns make it easier for a killer. They make it impossibly hard for parents who arrive, dazed and pleading, at the firehouse in Connecticut where the surviving schoolchildren were taken, and dont find the one they were looking for there.
That would be sheer, unimaginable terror.
Tsiyu
(18,186 posts)There wil be arms aching to hold those little ones, aching to tell them how much they love them, and there will be courageous family and friends who must carry on with excrucuiating knowledge of the terror in those childrens' last moments.
But that's a worthy sacrifice the gun lobby doesn't have to make, nor the politicians who quake and quiver at their feet.
They want the babies and their families to be the brave ones.
forestpath
(3,102 posts)Response to Tsiyu (Original post)
Post removed
fightthegoodfightnow
(7,042 posts).
fightthegoodfightnow
(7,042 posts)SunSeeker
(51,755 posts)It takes a helluva lot longer to chase someone down and stab them to death than to shoot them. If that mentally ill nutbag in China had a gun or assault rifle, many more...probably many dozens...of kids would have been killed in the China incident--like that gun nut in Norway who mowed down 77 kids with his assault rifle.
My family were victims of both Stalin and Hitler as well. A gun did not protect my family and it would not have protected your family from Hitler and Stalin's bombs and tanks.
Take your bullshit somewhere else.
Cha
(297,831 posts)What a compelling pic that is..
Thank you Tsiyu