Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

no_hypocrisy

(54,906 posts)
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 07:15 AM Feb 2025

'Very dangerous': Trump dumps billions of gallons of water farmers were counting on for summer

https://www.alternet.org/trump-california-water/

President Donald Trump recently ordered the release of massive amounts of water from two California dams, and now local farmers are scrambling to preserve precious freshwater resources needed for dry summer months.

-snip-

However, water managers in Tulare County told Bakersfield, California-based news site SJV Water — which covers water issues in the San Joaquin Valley – that there are multiple physical and legal barriers that prevent the valley's water from getting to Southern California. SJV Water reported that the water would have to be "pumped at great expense" across the valley to the California Aqueduct, where it would still need to travel hundreds of miles to make it to the Los Angeles area.

“Every drop belongs to someone,” Kaweah River Watermaster Victor Hernandez told SJV Water. “The reservoir may belong to the federal government, but the water is ours. If someone’s playing political games with this water, it’s wrong.”

-snip-

"A decision to take summer water from local farmers and dump it out of these reservoirs shows a complete lack of understanding of how the system works and sets a very dangerous precedent," Vink said. "This decision was clearly made by someone with no understanding of the system or the impacts that come from knee-jerk political actions."

62 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
'Very dangerous': Trump dumps billions of gallons of water farmers were counting on for summer (Original Post) no_hypocrisy Feb 2025 OP
Most of these farmers probably voted for Trump. Irish_Dem Feb 2025 #1
Absolutely, and it will be the liberal 'tree huggers' and smelt that did it. travelingthrulife Feb 2025 #41
Hillary's emails in the pizza parlor did it. Irish_Dem Feb 2025 #48
To whom you can say with evidence... Grins Feb 2025 #55
Famine and food shortages Blue Full Moon Feb 2025 #2
And not enough water come summer Attilatheblond Feb 2025 #13
Redistribution of Wealth, possibly to foreign powers delisen Feb 2025 #29
I suspect that is what Trump and Musk are doing. Blue Full Moon Feb 2025 #39
I called it... 2naSalit Feb 2025 #36
Correct Blue Full Moon Feb 2025 #40
G.O.P. is forcing farmers out of business with this Stupid Stunt BoRaGard Feb 2025 #3
Immigration round up as well............... Lovie777 Feb 2025 #6
Won't make eggs cheaper. But big Money bros can buy more farms & further consolidate factory food. . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Feb 2025 #9
Yep. It's all about taking ALL the resources and land Attilatheblond Feb 2025 #14
Don't remember who said it- I think maybe it was Alliepoo Feb 2025 #16
The Orange Addickt wants to control the flow of Spice. . . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Feb 2025 #19
He and Musk love their spice... too much. ananda Feb 2025 #26
They voted for him so this is what they want travelingthrulife Feb 2025 #42
Not just this one. Tariffs last time killed trade with China NickB79 Feb 2025 #50
This is a big deal. jeffreyi Feb 2025 #4
Before this, the issue was the theft of California water to transfer to no_hypocrisy Feb 2025 #5
shithole's revenge................ Lovie777 Feb 2025 #7
It's a criminal big deal. . . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Feb 2025 #8
Water is a third rail issue in the west Strelnikov_ Feb 2025 #54
Trump screwed over farmers in his first administration... perdita9 Feb 2025 #10
In his first term kkmarie Feb 2025 #25
TSF is unfit and unqualified. Not only that he doesn't consult with the domain specific iluvtennis Feb 2025 #11
Remember when Notre Dame was burning and Trump insisted they just needed to dump water on it? Lonestarblue Feb 2025 #12
Did he do this on purpose to fuck with California? Or to screw with Newsom? IcyPeas Feb 2025 #15
Absolutely. Order will be traceable to cabinet level lackey (acting) who may or may not fall on own sword. . nt Bernardo de La Paz Feb 2025 #18
He's screwing his own people. paleotn Feb 2025 #23
Those are not mutually exclusive. PunkinPi Feb 2025 #33
It's a flippant grandstanding inconsiderate stupid decision underpants Feb 2025 #35
All of the above. He also wants to act like a hero to the farmers. They will suck it travelingthrulife Feb 2025 #44
He did it to own the libs Diraven Feb 2025 #52
So long fresh fruits and vegetables. Guess there's no one to pick them anyway. Vinca Feb 2025 #17
The dairy farmers in that area will take a hit too. hunter Feb 2025 #32
That's what... 2naSalit Feb 2025 #38
Soon there will be lots of former federal workers to pick those fruits and vegetables. travelingthrulife Feb 2025 #45
He obviously likes seeing people suffer and die. twodogsbarking Feb 2025 #20
Red farmers lost their water. Awwww. paleotn Feb 2025 #21
But it will be Newsome's fault. travelingthrulife Feb 2025 #46
Not hardly. paleotn Feb 2025 #61
His grudge against California is incredibly stupid and dangerous and this is just an assault on the people of CA LymphocyteLover Feb 2025 #22
It's an assault on all of us since we get so much food AllyCat Feb 2025 #28
It was pure spite orangecrush Feb 2025 #24
He had to find a faucet to turn on since everyone ragged him about that stupidity. travelingthrulife Feb 2025 #47
"a complete lack of understanding of how the system works" Danascot Feb 2025 #27
No common sense, no understanding how things actually work TommieMommy Feb 2025 #30
Brilliant! I suppose this could help push the price of Mike 03 Feb 2025 #31
isn't this akin to a terrorist attack on one of our states? This is civil war shit LymphocyteLover Feb 2025 #34
trmp knows more about water than anybody.... spanone Feb 2025 #37
I posted on the DU Gardening Forum in November about re-planning my gardens post-election NickB79 Feb 2025 #43
Sounds gorgeous, but you really have to have large gardens to actually survive on them. travelingthrulife Feb 2025 #49
Indeed. I'm under no illusion I can go off-grid NickB79 Feb 2025 #53
No crops means no need for migrant workers whopis01 Feb 2025 #51
"Forget it Jake, it's Chinatown" DBoon Feb 2025 #56
So, they won't have water for their crops, or workers to tend and harvest them. patphil Feb 2025 #57
Update: Officials have backed off on the largest release Qutzupalotl Feb 2025 #58
I think we should EndlessWire Feb 2025 #59
What a colossal A-hole republicon to do that to the farmers BoRaGard Feb 2025 #60
Folks elected a bombastic clown who doesn't know what he's doing Hitorque Feb 2025 #62

Grins

(9,459 posts)
55. To whom you can say with evidence...
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 11:19 AM
Feb 2025
“So sorry. We tried to help. But you voted Republican.”

The silver lining? Even if they had the water they don’t have the workers, all courtesy of the same guy and his Party.

Blue Full Moon

(3,484 posts)
39. I suspect that is what Trump and Musk are doing.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:26 AM
Feb 2025

Taking away women's rights. Fake religious piety. That also would fit China, India or Russia too. Highest bidder.

2naSalit

(102,791 posts)
36. I called it...
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:04 AM
Feb 2025

A year ago, that there would be the start of a global famine within 18 - 24 months. There are about 8 - 10 months left in that window.

If it isn't environmental collapse, it's political obstruction. We will kill ourselves and everything else on the planet just to be the last ones to stand on top of the trash heap we've collectively created and wave one big weenie at the universe and all the trash we've made.

I give us till the middle of 2026 before undeniable signs of entropy on a grand scale show up.

Bernardo de La Paz

(60,320 posts)
9. Won't make eggs cheaper. But big Money bros can buy more farms & further consolidate factory food. . . . . nt
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 08:19 AM
Feb 2025

Alliepoo

(2,832 posts)
16. Don't remember who said it- I think maybe it was
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 08:58 AM
Feb 2025

Bernie Sanders- “whoever owns the water owns the world.” And that’s the absolute truth. We could maybe add ‘who controls the water’ too.

ananda

(35,144 posts)
26. He and Musk love their spice... too much.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:40 AM
Feb 2025

What interests me the most is all the repercussions
for themselves, this country, and the world ... which
they, in their narrow greed and hate-filled lives,
haven't considered.

All the disasters alone will not be avoidable, and a
country with no functioning government and idiots
at the helm will end up totally out of their control,
and their lives will go to hell as well.

NickB79

(20,356 posts)
50. Not just this one. Tariffs last time killed trade with China
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:43 AM
Feb 2025

My dad's side of the family lost a lot of money when China stopped buying our soybeans. And the $30 billion in farm aid Trump sent out to compensate mostly went to big farmers. The little guys like my uncles running 200-300 acres barely saw a dime. And yes, that's little; you aren't a "real" farmer this days unless you're plowing 500+ acres.

And today, we just put tariffs on China, Mexico and Canada. Trump was just talking about EU tariffs yesterday as the next step, and tariffs on any BRICS nations as well.

At this rate my uncles won't have farms to pass on to their kids 4 yr from now. It will be nothing but mega-farm conglomerates in charge, hiring my cousins to drive the tractors instead.

jeffreyi

(2,571 posts)
4. This is a big deal.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 07:59 AM
Feb 2025

Another article:
https://sjvwater.org/trumps-emergency-water-order-responsible-for-water-dump-from-tulare-county-lakes/

*snip*
“A decision to take summer water from local farmers and dump it out of these reservoirs shows a complete lack of understanding of how the system works and sets a very dangerous precedent,” said Dan Vink, a longtime Tulare County water manager and principal partner at Six-33 Solutions, a water and natural resource firm in Visalia.

“This decision was clearly made by someone with no understanding of the system or the impacts that come from knee-jerk political actions.”
*end of snip*

no_hypocrisy

(54,906 posts)
5. Before this, the issue was the theft of California water to transfer to
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 08:02 AM
Feb 2025

parched areas like Las Vegas for their casinos' mega water fountains.

Strelnikov_

(8,170 posts)
54. Water is a third rail issue in the west
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 11:11 AM
Feb 2025

And as noted in the article “Every drop belongs to someone”.

Nearly all of the water storage and major distribution infrastructure (canals, tunnels) is owned and/or managed by the Feds on some manner.

The fourth rail is access to public land for fishing hunting and recreation.

Whole load of FAFO coming down.

perdita9

(1,352 posts)
10. Trump screwed over farmers in his first administration...
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 08:20 AM
Feb 2025

...with tariffs which cost them billions in sales and they couldn't line up fast enough to vote for him again.

Facts and reasoning isn't going to work with this demographic. They're going to have to suffer harsh consequences before they'll be able to see Trump for what he really is.

kkmarie

(340 posts)
25. In his first term
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:33 AM
Feb 2025

After his tariffs bankrupted the farmers he bailed them out. They lost nothing. They learned nothing. And voted again for tariffs because tariffs don't impact them.
https://www.cfr.org/blog/92-percent-trumps-china-tariff-proceeds-has-gone-bail-out-angry-farmers

iluvtennis

(21,497 posts)
11. TSF is unfit and unqualified. Not only that he doesn't consult with the domain specific
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 08:25 AM
Feb 2025

experts to understand the process & procedures and constraints. He’s a fkn fool.

Lonestarblue

(13,480 posts)
12. Remember when Notre Dame was burning and Trump insisted they just needed to dump water on it?
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 08:36 AM
Feb 2025

His ignorant solution most likely would have destroyed the whole edifice. Thankfully, French authorities ignored him and Notre Dame has been rebuilt and is once again open to the public. If a hammer is needed to fix a problem, Trump will send a bulldozer. He has no real life experience because he has been pampered by his millions all his life.

Bernardo de La Paz

(60,320 posts)
18. Absolutely. Order will be traceable to cabinet level lackey (acting) who may or may not fall on own sword. . nt
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:05 AM
Feb 2025

paleotn

(22,212 posts)
23. He's screwing his own people.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:14 AM
Feb 2025

Those farming communities are very red. CA and all other states, are not monoliths. That's simplistic thinking he's guilty of and many around here as well.

underpants

(196,494 posts)
35. It's a flippant grandstanding inconsiderate stupid decision
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:59 AM
Feb 2025

They have no consideration of what one move has not just on people but on other moves they make. No planning. No cohesive process.

travelingthrulife

(5,179 posts)
44. All of the above. He also wants to act like a hero to the farmers. They will suck it
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:34 AM
Feb 2025

right up.

Diraven

(1,898 posts)
52. He did it to own the libs
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:49 AM
Feb 2025

It was a power move to show that no one could stop him and he could mean tweet about it. None of that water made it to anywhere it was actually needed, it was a total waste.

hunter

(40,690 posts)
32. The dairy farmers in that area will take a hit too.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:52 AM
Feb 2025

I wonder if they'll take down their Trump flags.

2naSalit

(102,791 posts)
38. That's what...
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:08 AM
Feb 2025

The slaves inmates of the prison camps are for, forced labor producing food.

paleotn

(22,212 posts)
21. Red farmers lost their water. Awwww.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:12 AM
Feb 2025

That's not going to play well in the long, scorching hot, central valley summer.

paleotn

(22,212 posts)
61. Not hardly.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 08:45 PM
Feb 2025

Typical Amurkin response. Always negative. Jeebers, dude, it must suck to go through life like that.

LymphocyteLover

(9,847 posts)
22. His grudge against California is incredibly stupid and dangerous and this is just an assault on the people of CA
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:13 AM
Feb 2025

AllyCat

(18,842 posts)
28. It's an assault on all of us since we get so much food
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:44 AM
Feb 2025

From California. He is trying to blow us all up.

Danascot

(5,232 posts)
27. "a complete lack of understanding of how the system works"
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:41 AM
Feb 2025

is the hallmark of this administration.

TommieMommy

(2,900 posts)
30. No common sense, no understanding how things actually work
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:45 AM
Feb 2025

And 💩 for brains. Lots of shortages coming up 😡

Mike 03

(18,690 posts)
31. Brilliant! I suppose this could help push the price of
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 09:45 AM
Feb 2025

almonds and almond butter up again, back when a jar of almond butter could cost you $15 or $20. (Almonds are a crop that requires enormous amounts of water and have historically suffered during drought years.) I'm sure the irony of Trump's constant inflation-spiking fuckups won't be lost on anyone here, but I hope the dumbshits who voted for him will eventually get it.

NickB79

(20,356 posts)
43. I posted on the DU Gardening Forum in November about re-planning my gardens post-election
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:34 AM
Feb 2025

I'm lucky enough to have 1.5 acres in southeast Minnesota, absolutely gorgeous soil, my own well, lots of chicken manure for composting.

In the past, I've grown a lot of plants just for fun. Lots of experimenting with unusual, "pretty" crops that don't really produce as much as tried-and-true varieties. But following the election, I decided that had to change. Between tariffs, deportations and the dismantling of environmental laws, the risk of food being expensive or simply unavailable is too great to ignore.

I grew up poor on a family farm in central MN, so we grew a lot of our own food. I learned from my dad and my grandma how to garden, raise livestock, hunt, fish, butcher, make sausage, etc. I still have the skills, and now I have to put them to use again.

Doubling the size of my gardens to 2000 sq ft. My wife and teenage daughter, who aren't really into gardening like me, know they'll have to help out a lot more this year. Lots of basic crops. Peas, spinach, lettuce, carrots, cabbage, potatoes, garlic, corn, beans, tomatoes, banana peppers (they outproduce ANY other pepper in the Midwest), and so much squash. Squash everywhere. I can store piles of winter squash for months in my unheated garage, and in a pinch I can use it for supplemental chicken feed. My basement is unfinished, and I'll be converting the NW corner with a small window into a cold storage room by walling it off, so it stays 50F all winter. I'll also be burying metal trash cans in the backyard, where when filled with straw and covered with bags of leaves, will keep produce like carrots and potatoes insulated and fresh deep into winter. Thankfully I've been planting fruit trees and berry bushes for years now, so I'm set on apples, plums, pears, peaches, apricots and aronias (you can use them like blueberries).

My daughter wants a beehive. I've been hesitant to put one in, because a quarter acre of my property is prairie wildflower and native grass restoration, and honeybees are non-native and compete with native bumblebees for flowers. But now I'm debating, because a steady supply of honey would be nice. A few friends from high school and college have successful hives, so I can pick their brains on Facebook about it.

We needed a new stove right before Christmas, and I convinced my wife to go back to a coil-top model instead of a glass-top. Why? Because you can't pressure can vegetables on a glass-top; the weight of the big canner can crack the glass. A coil top can support it. I already have 50 jars of canned tomatoes, 50 jars of salsa, 50 jars of chili base, 50 jars of applesauce, and 25 jars of pickles in the basement from last summer's harvest. Now that I can pressure can, I'll be adding jarred green beans, sweet corn, carrots, etc.

The chickens are laying eggs at a good pace again now that we're past the dead of winter. I'm getting 6 eggs per day from 14 hens; by summer it will be up to a dozen a day as more sunlight stimulates egg production. My flock is fairly young, and I'll be culling the three oldest girls for soup this spring. A neighbor down the road has a flock of 30+ birds, and I'll be trading fertilized eggs with her this spring to add genetic diversity and prevent inbreeding. I may build a new coop this year, and found some pretty interesting plans for building them out of recycled pallets. At the least, I can put up a smaller coop to sequester the broody mothers with their young chicks away from the other hens and rooster until they're big enough to reintroduce to the flock.

I've been knocking doors to find new hunting land locally so I don't have to drive 3 hr north to my family's land. It's hard to find deer permissions, but turkey, squirrel and rabbit are surprisingly easy to get an OK for. Too many trophy hunters chasing big bucks, but as they say, you can't eat antlers. And with the spread of chronic wasting disease here (a prion disorder like Mad Cow) I'm fine not eating venison anymore. And FYI, a big woodchuck tastes a lot like pork when seasoned up and cooked slow in a crockpot.

And this winter, I've actually managed to get out on the lakes a couple times and snag some nice meaty crappies and bluegills through the ice. I found a lake in the middle of some state land a few miles from me without a dock access, meaning you have to hike a few hundred yards from the nearest road to get to it. But that also means it's virtually unfished, so I have a 200 acre lake almost entirely to myself.

Trump is going to make preppers of us all at this rate.

travelingthrulife

(5,179 posts)
49. Sounds gorgeous, but you really have to have large gardens to actually survive on them.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:41 AM
Feb 2025

I garden but it only supplies a bit of the food we would need.

NickB79

(20,356 posts)
53. Indeed. I'm under no illusion I can go off-grid
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 10:53 AM
Feb 2025

I just laugh at the "hardcore" preppers I encounter on Facebook who think they can live off the land like the mountain men of the 1800's. It's a hard, unforgiving life that none of us would choose.

My goal is to lessen the blow to my household as best I can, get fresh food along with fresh air and exercise, and trade with my like-minded liberal friends and coworkers locally for goods and services I can't do myself. For example, my neighbor is a master electrician and I have given him lots of eggs in exchange for some rewiring help (I hate working with electricity, it scares me). Saved me a few hundred dollars vs calling someone. And now that they're expecting their first baby this spring, we've offered to help them as much as we can. I told his wife I'll grow her extra vegetable transplants this spring for her garden.

Establishing a solid, local friend group in times like this is often as valuable as money.

patphil

(9,067 posts)
57. So, they won't have water for their crops, or workers to tend and harvest them.
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 12:26 PM
Feb 2025

That will surely result in a drop in food prices.
Just a couple of idiotic decisions that could result in these farmers loosing millions of dollars; and possibly going bankrupt.
All part of the "tear it all down" process brought to you by the Republican party.

Qutzupalotl

(15,824 posts)
58. Update: Officials have backed off on the largest release
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 03:12 PM
Feb 2025

Water managers were relieved Thursday evening after the Army Corps of Engineers agreed to back off of a sudden decision earlier in the day to dump massive amounts of water from Kaweah and Success lakes.

Water managers said they got about an hour’s warning from the Army Corp’s Sacramento office to expect the Tule and Kaweah rivers to be at “channel capacity” by Thursday night.
….

“We were able to get them to back off that,” said Eric Limas, General Manager of the Lower Tule River and Pixley irrigation districts, of the Army Corps. “They’ll still be releasing water sometime tonight, but it will be a smaller amount, which will increase tomorrow.”
….

Some people interviewed for this story speculated that the move was political on the part of the new administration, a kind of water “flex,” but declined to elaborate.

https://sjvwater.org/decision-to-dump-water-from-tulare-county-lakes-altered-after-sending-locals-in-mad-scramble/

EndlessWire

(8,103 posts)
59. I think we should
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 03:45 PM
Feb 2025

cut off water to his golf course. You know, a kind of golf course "flex" because it will be hot in the summer, and we will need all that wasted greens water for the farmers in Central.

Do we have to let Trump visit California? He's a troublemaker.

BoRaGard

(7,591 posts)
60. What a colossal A-hole republicon to do that to the farmers
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 07:01 PM
Feb 2025

just pissing the water away.

How wasteful. How republicon is that?

 

Hitorque

(254 posts)
62. Folks elected a bombastic clown who doesn't know what he's doing
Sat Feb 1, 2025, 08:46 PM
Feb 2025

And they're shocked to see these kinds of headlines

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»'Very dangerous': Trump d...