General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMorgan J Freeman: "Anthem Blue Shield Blue Cross -- just denied cancer follow-up MRI to check spread was deeme
My insurance -- Anthem Blue Shield Blue Cross -- just informed me that my cancer follow-up MRI to check spread was deemed "not a medical necessity" and therefore not authorized.
— Morgan J Freeman (@mjfree.bsky.social) 2025-02-10T21:19:42.881Z
Morgan J Freeman
My insurance -- Anthem Blue Shield Blue Cross -- just informed me that my cancer follow-up MRI to check spread was deemed "not a medical necessity" and therefore not authorized.
February 10, 2025 at 3:19 PM
=====
My own comments
GOD DAMN US medical insurance companies are PREDATORY KILLING MACHINES DENYING
NECESSARY MEDICAL TESTS TO STAY ALIVE.
AMERICANS ARE BEING KILLED BY PREDATORS, US CORPORATE PROFITS COME FIRST BEFORE LIFESAVING TESTING
America is a fricken joke.
Americans are getting killed for profiting
Response to IrishBubbaLiberal (Original post)
Post removed
Skittles
(172,204 posts)FUCK that
IrishBubbaLiberal
(2,561 posts)Jury Nullification
drmeow
(6,000 posts)believes in jury nullification (a bullshit practice that the Supreme Court should not have allowed but did) and would probably declare a mistrial if he was found not guilty!
I might find him guilty but insist that his punishment be time served and not a second more.
Jersey Devil
(10,842 posts)Judges can do nothing to prevent jury nullification if jurors do not disclose their beliefs during voir dire.
THE MAN IS A GUN HUMPING PYSCHO KILLER COWARD
HE FUCKING AMBUSHED SOMEONE AND SHOT THEM IN THE BACK
are you SERIOUSLY saying people should be able to act as judge, jury and executioner? WTF!!!!
Farmer-Rick
(12,726 posts)I understand what you're saying. It's just more complicated than that.
Some people who have lost their spouse or children because they couldn't get them the medical attention needed to keep them alive, would say that the dead CEO acted as judge, jury and exectioner. The CEO just did it through paperwork and scams.
So if someone had managed to assassinate Hitler or Stalin, or Jeffrey Dahmer would they be psycho killer cowards too?
I understand 2 wrongs don't make a right but sometimes it does provide real justice when nation's justice system has failed.
In normal times I would be 100% behind you. Now that we have an American dictator, who allows oligarchs to subvert justice for profit, I think there is more to the story than just a psycho murderer hunting down an innocent man.
Skittles
(172,204 posts)we don't do this kind of SHIT in a CIVILIZED SOCIETY
Mangione didn't even CONFRONT the guy - just shot him in the back - what if he had missed and killed someone else? Would that be OK because well he had GOOD INTENTIONS!
JFC
DONE here
Skittles
(172,204 posts)not just UHC
B.See
(8,608 posts)my wife has another and they're both fucking policy holders, moreso this year than last.
And Donnie "price of eggs Trump" (btw, how's that going for ya?) who just killed Biden's caps on prescription drugs isn't going to do shit about it.
Besides, he's too busy trying to import Afrikaners and GUTTING consumer protections.
The Madcap
(1,947 posts)plastic straws.
Ms. Toad
(38,730 posts)He didn't kill those.
What he killed was Biden's negotiations with drug companies for lower prices on a few drugs a year.
B.See
(8,608 posts)I'd read about it, but off the top of me head misstated what really had occurred . Thanks for the clarification.
bluestarone
(22,325 posts)LeftInTX
(34,560 posts)bluestarone
(22,325 posts)Ms. Toad
(38,730 posts)MRI is not one of the few things that require a pre-approval on traditional Medicare.
LeftInTX
(34,560 posts)Ms. Toad
(38,730 posts)Meowmee
(9,212 posts)They have escaped accountability for poor care, denied care and what amounts to murder etc. It will only get worse.
LeftInTX
(34,560 posts)Oops. I thought this was the Morgan Freeman. But apparently there is another one.
But it's this guy: 
Marcuse
(9,060 posts)Though Im sure he gets the wait staff excited after making a dinner reservation.
LeftInTX
(34,560 posts)Freeman produced the MTV reality TV show Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County. In 2007, he created and executive produced the television series Maui Fever, another MTV reality series. He also produced the MTV reality shows 16 and Pregnant, Teen Mom and Teen Mom 2.[7]
Marcuse
(9,060 posts)unblock
(56,231 posts)Most of their game is to delay treatment.
Find an excuse to deny it, drag hells, but eventually approve.
They profit because the patient might give up or die(!) before disputed test or procedure and even if they do eventually get it, they earn interest on the money just because of the delay.
Insurance companies have a freeroll to deny and delay. It costs them nothing and they might save money.
Of course sometimes they do deny, not just delay. They have little incentive to be decent human beings.
Tickle
(4,131 posts)aeromanKC
(3,929 posts)lastlib
(28,409 posts)LiberalArkie
(19,869 posts)Evolve Dammit
(21,802 posts)Blue Full Moon
(3,563 posts)Farmer-Rick
(12,726 posts)Yup, they are murdering people by preventing access to healthcare in a timely manner. But it's legal murder. The government has deligated it's authority to execute citizens to the health insurance corporations.
Blue Full Moon
(3,563 posts)Farmer-Rick
(12,726 posts)Sarah Palin would be proud....if she's still alive.
dlk
(13,289 posts)The entire apeals process has legal timelines for responses and an attorney isnt required. although in certain circumstances, one may be called for.
Appeal every single claim denial for reconsideration, as many times is allowed.
Insurance companies play a numbers game.
KewlKat
(5,810 posts)dlk
(13,289 posts)KPN
(17,441 posts)notices about claim disputes or specific medical care denials. Its important to appeal timely and per specifics required in appeal.
Skittles
(172,204 posts)the American for profit system is DISGUSTING
KPN
(17,441 posts)Last edited Tue Feb 11, 2025, 02:03 PM - Edit history (1)
My opinion: we could use a few more Luigi's.
Callous and, some would say, irresponsible on my part -- I know, but I feel quite certain we won't see meaningful relief from our the current health care system and, more generally, the parasitic capitalism we currently endure through entirely peaceful means. It would be wonderful and thrilling if we could, but I just don't see it -- not in our lifetimes at least.
In fact, it is obviously getting worse, not better. When the instigator and principle preparer behind Project 2025 (Vought) is head of the OMB, and the Secretary of Defense (Hegseth) hold and have openly expressed opinions that "political violence is inevitable", "a struggle of good versus evil", and the left poses an existential threat, it's hard for me to see a happy peaceful ending.
Skittles
(172,204 posts)JFC
Response to KPN (Reply #71)
Skittles This message was self-deleted by its author.
Ms. Toad
(38,730 posts)I refuse to be shunted off to the appeal process until all direct avenues of informal appeal is exhausted. I just keep asking for supervisor after supervisor after supervisor until I get the straight story about the denial. Normally, it is something stupid that is easily fixed. A step therapy medication - where they lost the documentation that the first line meds had already been tried; coding errors - where an out-of-network care that had received in-network authorization was still being coded as out-of-network, etc. Those kinds of errors aren't really suited for appeal, since it takes actual conversations with real people to sort out what actually happened and resolve it. If it gets sent to appeal, without a conversation to sort it out, it just gets denied on the same basis as the original.
As to the coding error - it took 200 hours of my time, because every new claim on the approval number required calls to two corporate entities and convincing one of them to call the third to get the bill re-coded, the payment sucked back, and a new payment sent. I got to the point where I could walk the customer assistance agent through a computer system I had never seen - because in my prior conversations I learned exactly what was happening and why it was repeatedly mis-coded (the initial authorization or out-of-network care was for a second opinion only; it was converted to authorization for care - but instead of assigning a new number, they just tacked the new authorization pages into a long .pdf document under the original number, so the people doing the coding saw treatment - and only authorization for a second opinion because they didn't bother to scroll down in the .pdf). Ultimately, I insisted that they open a new number for the third go-round (multiple surgeries), and that solved the problem. Had I just appealed, that would never have happened. I probably would have gotten each bill resolved - at the cost of a ton of paperwork each and every time, and I never would have know that I needed to insist on a new case number being assigned. I have also successfully had an insurance company rewrite their nationwide software system because their software didn't match a kind of policy they sold.
If working informally doesn't work, then I appeal - I've probably done it only once or twice, and I'm far less successful at winning appeals than I am at working through customer service. By the time I file a formal appeal, it requires a doctor's cooperation (and the few who don't cooperate quickly become my ex-doctor).
Working through customer service, I've won every appeal I've chosen to fight. There were two out of perhaps 50 that I chose not to fight (small dollar amounts, not likely to be repeated).
But - yes - they count on us not challenging them, whether informally (as I do most of the time) or formally. Virtually no one challenges the system, so they win on those, and others give up too soon - so they win those by attrition.
dlk
(13,289 posts)Insurance companies count on their customers being passive and just accepting poor service.
Farmer-Rick
(12,726 posts)But you got to wonder why our supposed democratic government put statutes of limitations, so to speak, on murder by denial?
LittleGirl
(8,999 posts)and I've been denied multiple things including an ultrasound for my dense breasts. It took me 4 months to get the insurance, Medicare! to pay for an ultrasound last week and I was told, I'll probably have to pay for it. God damn it. I've paid into Medicare since 1976. I want my healthcare!
wryter2000
(47,940 posts)Thats not Medicare
LittleGirl
(8,999 posts)RicROC
(1,249 posts)When I first turned age 65, I went to a local insurance broker who sold me a BC/BS Medicare plan. A couple years later I went to a 2nd broker, friend of the family, who recommended Anthem Medicare. I'm never sick so really didn't have many claims. After listening to Thom Hartmann radio on authentic Medicare, I called the 1st broker to tell her I would like to go back on the original Medicare plan. Her response, "you've never been on traditional Medicare, you've always been on Advantage"
What an eye-opener! These brokers will steer clients into Advantage and never explain the difference. Fortunately, I live in NY State so as one of 3 states where one can switch easily back and forth, I am now on traditional Medicare.
===> If I lived in other 47 states, (after 1 year on Advantage) Medicare is allowed to audit and decide whether to accept the potential patient. They have the option to bar one from Medicare.
wryter2000
(47,940 posts)The ads are so deceptive.
dlk
(13,289 posts)Last edited Mon Feb 10, 2025, 09:34 PM - Edit history (1)
If you are already enrolled in an Advantage plan, you can change to different Advantage Plan or return to original Medicare
All of the Medicare Advantage plans in your zip code are s listed on Medicare.gov. They will all have star ratings. I would recommend checking out the 5-star plans, if theyre available in your zip code.
You also have the option of returning to original Medicare. If you want to enroll in. Supplement, you will be subject to medical underwriting, unless your state has special rules, like the birthday rule, or year round guaranteed issue, such as NY or CT.
Also please note, whatever you decide to do, Medicare requires you to have creditable prescription drug coverage (Part D), either with an Advantage Plan or a standalone Part D plan.
Otherwise, Socisl Security will assess a lifetime penalty of 1% per month of an average national premium established.by CMS.
I noticed for 2025, Advantage plans greatly reduced benefits, as well as greatly increased premiums, copays and coinsurance.
Good luck!
LittleGirl
(8,999 posts)dlk
(13,289 posts)You may want to follow up on that.
LittleGirl
(8,999 posts)but I had to appeal the first denial of coverage for my thyroid drugs already. They have a 500+ deductible and raised the premium from 40 cents (yes, cents) to 17.40. Can you believe that? Ugh.
dlk
(13,289 posts)n/t
HereForTheParty
(915 posts)You can switch between MA plans, but to get a medigap policy to go with original Medicare you have to pass a screening process. If you have cancer, for example, forget it. You're stuck with MA.
dlk
(13,289 posts)You can also change an Advantage plan:
1. If its during your trial right (12 months) you can return to original Medicare and either return to or enroll in a
Medigap (supplement) plan with guaranteed issue or return to your previous Medigap plan.
2. If your Advantage plan ends or makes significant changes, you can return to original Medicare and have guaranteed issue if you decide to enroll in a Medigap plan.
If you move out of your service area and your Advantage plan isnt offered in your new area, you can enroll in a Medigap plan in your new area with guaranteed issue.
Just be sure to have Part D coverage to avoid the lifetime penalty.
HereForTheParty
(915 posts)I just wanted to emphasize once you are in MA, most often you can't switch to traditional Medicare with a medigap plan without underwriting. Original Medicare without a medigap policy is untenable.
dlk
(13,289 posts)There are exceptions, depending on where you live.
New York and Connecticut have guaranteed issue year-round.
Some states have adopted a birthday rule, where someone can enroll in a Medigap policy, with guaranteed issue (no medical underwriting) within in a specific time frame around their birthday.
Also 5-star Advantage plans are an option, if theyre offered in a persons zip code.
More seniors could lobby.for a birthday rule in their state. It offers the best workaround at this point.
RobinA
(10,478 posts)That is impossible. Advantage haters on here keep telling me Medicare doesn't deny anything.
pandr32
(14,307 posts)Tree Lady
(13,331 posts)I never got before with medicare. I have Blueshield as my supplement bluecross was no longer a option. We have never paid a cent for going to the doctor, getting regular labs test and xrays.
Hubby was super sick with virus of some kind and bad chest cough. Went to doctor he gave him flu and covid test, they charged $200 a piece for those! Then chest xray to see if he had pneumonia. He had viral bronchitis.
After medicare and supplement they want almost $400 from us. I will be fighting this bill, scares me now to even go to doctor, what used to be covered is not now. And by a lot!
Auggie
(33,226 posts)Tree Lady
(13,331 posts)and supplement. My husband drove Bart in SF for 30 years so we have always had good medical. This is first time a regular doctor visit with tests not covered.
Response to Tree Lady (Reply #47)
Skittles This message was self-deleted by its author.
Auggie
(33,226 posts)Or was it part of the yearly deductible? I have a Plan G with a minimum yearly deductible of $257, so I do receive an invoice for up to that amount every year.
Fullduplexxx
(8,631 posts)riversedge
(81,196 posts)Bluethroughu
(7,215 posts)Cf402
(3 posts)During my wife's final cancer, BCBS deemed the follow-up MRIs as unnecessary and uncovered, although they were required to gauge treatment effectiveness against the cancer's spread. After months of playing the idiotic game of appeal, they were finally approved, only to have the final hope treatment denied two weeks prior to her passing, but gleefully informing us that we could appeal -- a process that would take up to two months. Yes, I know this is just another story, but goddamn American insurance.
waterwatcher123
(518 posts)IronLionZion
(51,436 posts)they make more profit if we die faster. Don't like it? What are we going to do about it?
JoseBalow
(9,609 posts)The judges have chosen
ALBliberal
(3,364 posts)same insurance! Age 28. He is under supervision scans blood tests for five years.
Dear god! Now he has to worry about this!
Works at HP. For three years now.
No one is safe from these sick predators.
I hope this guy takes it to the streets!!!!
OMGWTF
(5,173 posts)Racygrandma
(195 posts)So I have a pet scan in May. I have Medicare and never had any problems. When I was on bamacare I signed onto to united. So they never took my premium out of bank account. I called and they said three times well we have your payment. Uh no, well then they dropped me because didnt pay premium . No kidding. I am a cancer survivor so insurance is a big deal. Yeah I had to call the insurance commissioner herein KS to get it straightened out. Yep they want us dead. We cost to much.
DFW
(60,318 posts)My employer in the USA provides Blue Cross plus some Dental with an immense deductible. In practical terms, that means nothing. Fortunately, you can deduct unreimbursed medical expenses from taxable German income, so it really only costs me half.
NGeorgian
(135 posts)The Sickest Patients Are Fleeing Private Medicare PlansCosting Taxpayers Billions
Skittles
(172,204 posts)works great when you don't need it - then when you do, it's a crap shoot and the taxpayers end up spending even more money
madamesilverspurs
(16,516 posts)that insurance companies exist to make money for their investors. Period.
It's still a painful memory: We attended all those contentious healthcare town halls, we were heartened by the busloads and planeloads of medical professionals going to DC to testify to congress, we watched the discussions in congress as though our lives depended on the outcome (yes, that was a bit of sarcasm), and we were jolted when the congressional conversations changed from healthCARE reform to health INSURANCE reform. We did get the Affordable Care Act, which the GOP stupidly dubbed Obamacare; and for his manipulations on behalf of the insurance industry, Max Baucus was assigned to a diplomatic post in the ass end of China. Short version: Medical provision is the come-on, but money is the purpose.
.
4catsmom
(667 posts)'cause no country for poor men
Maeve
(43,478 posts)A refused service and get your doctor involved. Insurance companies back down at a much higher rate than expected.
calimary
(90,371 posts)ESPECIALLY this.
SheltieLover
(81,271 posts)Kablooie
(19,115 posts)And Ive never had them refuse anything a doctor wanted. They are a non profit and the doctors dont make more if a patient gets more tests.