This Is How Universities Can Escape Trump's Trap, If They Dare - by M. Gessen

[Tactical Peek]

This Is How Universities Can Escape Trump’s Trap, If They Dare

April 14, 2025, 5:02 a.m. ET

By M. Gessen

Almost three months into the Trump administration’s war on universities, and a year and a half into the Republican Party’s organized campaign against the presidents of top colleges, it is clear that antisemitism and D.E.I. are mere pretexts for these attacks. Like much of what this administration does, the war on higher education is driven by anti-intellectualism and greed. Trump is building a mafia state, in which the don distributes both money and power. Universities are independent centers of intellectual and, to some extent, political power. He is trying to destroy that independence.

There is a way for universities to fight back. It requires more than refusing to bend to Trump’s will, and it requires more than forming a united front. They must abandon all the concerns — rankings, donors, campus amenities — that preoccupy and distract them, and focus on their core mission: the production and dissemination of knowledge. Intellectuals have adopted this strategy to fight against autocrats in other countries. It works.

Because Trump views everything as transactional and assumes everyone to be driven by profit, he has approached universities the same way he approached law firms and, arguably, countries: by deploying devastating financial threats against each one individually, to compel compliance and prevent coalitions. Trump could have started by imposing a tax on universities’ endowments, a move that almost certainly would enjoy broad popular support. That, however, would presumably affect every major university, which could prompt them to band together. Research grants, which are specific to each university, are an ideal instrument to divide and weaken them.

His first target, Columbia University, acceded to his demands within two weeks of losing $400 million in grants and contracts. When Columbia’s first sacrifice didn’t bring back the money, the university made another: its interim president, Katrina Armstrong. That didn’t satisfy Trump, who now reportedly wants Columbia to agree to direct government oversight. He is also brandishing financial threats, separately, at the University of Pennsylvania, Harvard, Cornell, Brown, Johns Hopkins and Northwestern — and still there is no sign of organized resistance on the part of universities. There is not even a joint statement in defense of academic freedom or an assertion of universities’ value to society. (Even people who have no use for the humanities may see value in medical schools and hospitals.)

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/14/opinion/trump-higher-education.html?unlocked_article_code=1._k4.6ueE.nAatfDmbGgPn&smid=url-share

[creon]

1. Good advice

It would work.

[WhiskeyGrinder]

2. The fact that they haven't indicates to me that they do not, in fact, dare.

They must abandon all the concerns — rankings, donors, campus amenities — that preoccupy and distract them, and focus on their core mission: the production and dissemination of knowledge.

The production and dissemination of knowledge has been on the back burner for so long, there are many institutions that will find it difficult to focus on it.

[maxrandb]

3. I have an easier solution

Fire about 100-200 white males employed by the university, and explain that they were removed to comply with the order ensuring "no one shall be hired due to their race, or privilege".

You could also cancel thousands of white males acceptance status, because they were based on "racial preference".

I am tired of nibbling around the edges on this racist shit. It's time to play hardball.

[Iamscrewed]

4. 1930s

First they came for? Who's next.

[Martin68]

5. The lesson I draw from this post is that appeasing Trump is like appeasing Hitler. If you give him Poland,

he'll ask for Czechoslovakia next, and so on. It is better to stick to principles and take the punishment. Columbia and Harvard are strong enough to survive the loss of grants and federal funding until Trump is out of office.

[AverageOldGuy]

6. Don't expect universities to take this advice

To do this would require the University Board of Trustees to approve the action and you have to figure that a lot of trustees are super-wealthy MAGAts who are perfectly happy with Trump.

[moonshinegnomie]

7. columbia is no longer a top tier university

its no better than trump university...