General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNew Details Revealed About the Nearly 2 Dozen Young Girls Confirmed Missing from Christian Camp After Devastating Texas
Last edited Sat Jul 5, 2025, 11:01 AM - Edit history (1)
This is too sad
https://people.com/new-details-revealed-about-young-girls-missing-from-texas-christian-camp-11766988
Adding important link
It did not predict this amount of rain - blame Slibby
https://www.democraticunderground.com/100220461156
pfitz59
(12,704 posts)'Christian summer camp' sounds like a brain-washing camp. Justpoints out that 'god' doesn't care.
malaise
(296,101 posts)These are lil babies who didnt send themselves to this summer camp
FarPoint
(14,765 posts)You rock!
FarPoint
(14,765 posts)let's not change the details/facts...
malaise
(296,101 posts)This is horrific.
FarPoint
(14,765 posts)It could just be a start....
malaise
(296,101 posts)vanlassie
(6,248 posts)But I DO hope youre right.
Skittles
(171,710 posts)yeah, OK
Layzeebeaver
(2,286 posts)And from that same experience I can say that its either god doesnt care or there is no god.
Obviously, everyones experience is different. Im only speaking about my own.
Bluetus
(2,795 posts)"These weren't some inner-city gang members. These were good Christian girls, baptised and everything (which is ironic)"
Funny how Christians and atheists both die from cancer, Alzheimer's, ALS, lightning strikes, tornadoes, and floods at the same rate. It is almost as if there really aren't any invisible guardian angels after all.
And here's the thing: Atheists and agnostics have no trouble having sympathy for the children (and everyone else) lost in this disaster, whether their parents believe in bearded guys in the sky or not. It is just as sad either way, and doubly so, considering it happened in a state that consistently votes for a government that welcomes climate change, hates science, and just voted to cripple the very agency that could have helped spare all the souls that were lost here.
If I believed in holy ghosts, I would ask God to damn every Republican.
Retrograde
(11,419 posts)weren't inner-city gang members either, and I don't think they got as much sympathy from the Texas establishment.
I hope that against the odds most if not all of the missing girls are found alive and safe. And I also hope that their families see the dangers in what Donnie;s reckless actions have done and is doing to this country in less than six months and do something to stop further damage to the US and its residents.
Bluetus
(2,795 posts)instead play the "It is God's will" card.
That is, IMHO, a fundamentally immoral position. If one is in a position to take some actions (even simply voting) to make the children safer from gun violence, weather events, or any other tragedy, and doesn't --- then one has no moral authority on ANY subject.
And this goes for the clergy who stand aside silently when these things happen.
And for those who do instinctively go to the "God's will" card, maybe we should confront them to explain why God drowned all these children the day after the President signed the legislation that shut down most efforts at combating climate change and gutted the NWS and FEMA.
Melon
(1,525 posts)Are Christians. What is it to you that they find solace is god in praying for their loved ones lives?
Bluetus
(2,795 posts)if they don't act for the protection of lives when they have the chance. That is as un-Christian as one can possibly be.
But I know, it is too soon. But I don't think it is too soon to ask what any of them have done to make Texas children safer from gun violence, such as we saw in El Paso and Uvalde. Sorry, it is not acceptable to say those things are "God's will" when there are things we can do about it.
mucifer
(25,667 posts)Bluetus
(2,795 posts)and use that as the basis for the kind of crap legislation and bullshit SCOTUS decisions that have only been possible by this Christian dominionist activism.
We are where we are as a nation as a direct result of Christian extremism. These "camps" are part of a systematic, madras-style indoctrination that continues to reinforce the stranglehold that Christian extremists have on our society even though practicing Christians represent only 40% of the country and the extremists may be more like 20% of the country. While these parents may feel no personal connection with the climate catastrophe that took these babies, there is a very direct connection.
It was not "God's will". It was a direct result of decades of ACTIVE denial of the damage we are doing to our planet, and Christian extremists have been at the very center of all of that. These things need to be said out loud if we are ever going to reverse the damage.
mucifer
(25,667 posts)Bluetus
(2,795 posts)The point I'm trying to make is that what happened is a DIRECT result of climate change, and Christians in general have been the primary enablers of the Republicans who have fought every attempt deal with the climate crisis. The news coverage should make the obvious connection.
Religious freedom means that anybody can have camps like this. But there is a direct connection between the climate change that took these lives and the political activism of Christians in our politics, and that should be stated out loud.
It is a tragedy that anybody had to die in these flash floods, but I'd wager the vast majority who were affected have consistently voted for politicians who have blocked all attempts to deal with climate change. We cannot let the RW continue to bully us into not stating these obvious connections.
Consequences. Just like Uvalde and el Paso.
Skittles
(171,710 posts)if they kept it to themselves
I have a HUGE problem with sanctimonious repukes using their crap religion in government.
Do you REALLY think anyone rooting for rounding up people to deport and cutting off medical help and food assistance truly "believes in Jesus"???
Classic example of a "thought terminating cliche".
Vogon_Glory
(10,297 posts)marble falls
(71,924 posts)... rise 18 feet in a few hours. They say 15 boats washed down it and disappeared. Two teens raced their jeep in front of the crest down at another creek and still haven't been found.
Flashflooding is a real problem here in Central Texas.
malaise
(296,101 posts)They said homes, tents, vehicles x everything is gone.
Even the camp director is dead
https://www.bbc.com/news/live/c15np18yy24t
Prairie Gates
(8,156 posts)NJCher
(43,165 posts)I had no idea something like that could happen in such a short time.
Rec
marble falls
(71,924 posts)... away will whip thru the arroyos 10 feet deep in an instant.
Nasruddin
(1,258 posts)I happened to be in NM - Albuquerque - many years ago during monsoon season for a conference.
Every day on the 5pm news, there would be a report of someone rescued or drowned from a flooding arroyo somewhere around town after the afternoon scattered rain in the area. Every day. People who lived there, who still didn't get it.
One day it was a dog.
NJCher
(43,165 posts)OK, now I understand. I didn't know what an arroyo was.
This is kind of like the blizzards that come out of nowhere in the Midwest. People get caught in them and some of us stay why didn't you just stay home. They are often predicted too late or not at all.
womanofthehills
(10,988 posts)There are two ways in and out of my place and both have arroyos that cross roads. I keep a blanket, pillow and water in my car because during super heavy rains, I have not been able to cross arroyos that go from 4 to 8. I just basically sleep in my car till its about a foot and passable.
I have gone to an exercise class in town - sun shining & no rain - hour and a half later coming home -get to the arroyo and its not passable. Big rain north of me I was unaware of.
The arroyos are often 4 to 8 ft deep - last year we had a 4 inch rainfall in a very short time and the arroyos are now filled to the top with rocks they washed down. So instead of the arroyos when empty being an average of 6 ft deep - they are now a half a foot deep because they are filled with huge rocks. Im curious to see how this affects how they run this year.
mwmisses4289
(4,186 posts)especially in the hill country and along the gulf coast.
Melon
(1,525 posts)Bluetus
(2,795 posts)It can't happen everywhere. It really depends on the topology and how it drains.
It is hard to fathom it happening this quickly, especially considering that these events were much less common even 20 years ago. Our hotter climate holds vastly more water in vapor form, and we are now seeing crazy amounts of rainfall that were almost unprecedented a generation ago.
I once was in a camper van in New Zealand where we got 12 inches of rain in 12 hours. I never experienced anything like that. But it was normal in that area. Many roads were washed out, but crews were out early the next morning laying new gravel and asphalt. We knew about the storm in advance and the locals gave good instructions about where the big flash flood risks were. But still, that was soooooo much rain, it was scary.
Melon
(1,525 posts)that occurred. If someone tells you 3 inches of rain so they know the river will rise a foot or two, you dont need to evacuate anything. Its been a drought so lakes and rivers are low. It rained 15 and the river rose 20 foot in the middle of the night. Nobody saw this coming. Nobody.
Mossfern
(4,716 posts)flash flood.
It comes up as quick as a flash. (I think)
Again, we get warnings way ahead of time.
Bluetus
(2,795 posts)and dumped 12" instead of the expected 3"
That can happen, and I have been seeing these huge, unexpected rainfall events much more frequently in the past decade. I doubt the NWS would have had any better information, considering tat most of that is computerized and runs nonstop.
But if it is known flash flood area, maybe this isn't the best place for a camp, even a Christian one, where Jesus would presumably try to save his followers.
marble falls
(71,924 posts)Skittles
(171,710 posts)harped on him until they all got lessons - you're right, it's a chronic danger in Texas, there are SOOO many low water crossings
LudwigPastorius
(14,725 posts)the Guadalupe rose 26 feet in 45 minutes.
That's almost 7 inches a minute!
Kid Berwyn
(24,395 posts)Those poor little girls experienced a horrific death. My heart is broken today.
malaise
(296,101 posts)From the BBC link
While large parts of Texas recorded about two inches (50mm) of rain, the wettest areas recorded a torrential deluge of 14.98 inches (380mm) that led to catastrophic flash flooding as rivers burst their banks rapidly.
-
Thats a lot of rain
Kid Berwyn
(24,395 posts)Excerpt
Texas Lt-Gov Dan Patrick said the potential for heavy rain and flooding covered a large area.
Everything was done to give them a heads up that you could have heavy rain, and were not exactly sure where its going to land, Patrick said.
Obviously as it got dark last night, we got into the wee morning of the hours, thats when the storm started to zero in.
Kerr county judge Rob Kelly, the countys chief elected official, said: We do not have a warning system.
When pushed on why more precautions werent taken, Kelly said no one knew this kind of flood was coming.
Continues
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2025/jul/05/texas-flooding-latest-news-updates-guadalupe-river-flood-camp-mystic
PS: There was a warning system the NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE pee-residunce Trump cut its funding.
which is why he suddenly found his mouth
Kid Berwyn
(24,395 posts)Half a century ago, I worked at a summer camp north of Detroit. I was the Assistant Waterfront Director, a glorified life guard in charge of fishing poles, life jackets and canoes.
The place was founded for rich kids from the suburbs, but every few weeks, wed host city kids whose families were of limited economic means. In exchange for their experience, theyd spend part of each day as labor.
Wed clean up the camp, but that would take less than half an hour. The rest of the work day, about two hours, was spent driving around in a big four-wheel pick up truck the woods and camp perimeter picking up big rocks.
The camp architect a great guy who refused to support military madness and used his skills to build a small amphitheater, walls, and other stuff. The kids felt like they were part of these structures.
I know they today are thinking of those poor little girls 1,000 miles away in Texas.
malaise
(296,101 posts)Bluetus
(2,795 posts)Uhhh, radar works at night.
This is the state that doesn't see any reason to be on the national electric grid, because the electric utilities are governed by the railroad commission !?
WTF? Even without the National Weather Service, the information was out there.
This is what happens when you believe that government is the work of the devil.
Melon
(1,525 posts)The flood alert came out at 5:30am. Some areas were swimming by then. Peoples houses were inundated while they were in bed. The river rose a foot a minute at its peak.
Bluetus
(2,795 posts)These things can change quickly. The alert systems are mainly local. Evacuation orders in hurricanes, or example, are usually issued at the county level. We have an emergency siren network that is activated by county personnel. The NWS stuff is mostly computerized. I'm not saying it was smart to fire a bunch of NWS workers, but it might not have made much difference in this case.
And look for Texas to beg for FEMA money in 3 --- 2 --- 1.
Ms. Toad
(38,637 posts)The actual rainfall was double that 12-15"
Melon
(1,525 posts)Ms. Toad
(38,637 posts)Last edited Sat Jul 5, 2025, 03:46 PM - Edit history (1)
Here's one reference for 6". https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/death-toll-in-texas-floods-rises-to-at-least-27-as-search-continues-for-many-missing-officials-say
I know the only article I could find which gave me definitive numbers for what rain fell (rather than how much the river rose) also included the forecast of 6-8" I'll keep looking.
Here is an article focused on tracking predictions and analyzing the flooding.
The HREF model on Thursday morning, a tool developed from NOAA research also indicated the risk of 10" or more in spots, using the "probability matched mean" product which can identify higher risk areas for heavy rainfall. I've used this in Houston many times, often with considerable forecast success ahead of flooding events. It has a knack for cutting through some of these higher end events and highlighting those risks.
https://theeyewall.substack.com/p/making-sense-of-the-weather-that
Bluetus
(2,795 posts)there is no chance they slept through that. It is a horrible thing.
Norbert
(7,765 posts)Damn.
Coolgoober
(334 posts)About young girls dying. Just like he hasn't said anything about service members dying since he became president. It's disgraceful. He's disgraceful.
DoBW
(3,223 posts)how can he benefit ....
malaise
(296,101 posts)That is all
Norrrm
(5,054 posts)TommieMommy
(2,900 posts)malaise
(296,101 posts)marble falls
(71,924 posts)hay rick
(9,605 posts)Since America no longer believes in science, it's time to shift blame to where it really belongs. Maybe the Big Guy's sharpie ran out of ink.
Response to malaise (Original post)
ZDU This message was self-deleted by its author.
ZDU
(1,264 posts)"Gee Bob, let's go with, 'What is Extreme Weather' for 1,000 points." Folks we are in a new era of weather and climate. Prepare yourselves.
mjvpi
(1,931 posts)China is getting creamed by flash flooding, too much rain.
electricmonk
(2,015 posts)I watched one yesterday on a channel called China Observer showing floods from the Yangtze River valley but the way they edit their videos it's hard to tell where and when it happened. Would love a good source to watch.
Side note I saw that Russia is also getting some major floods in the St Petersburg for the first time in July since 1865.
Nigrum Cattus
(1,317 posts)it's Anthropocentric Climate Destruction -
https://arctic-news.blogspot.com/
ZDU
(1,264 posts)Thank you, thank you! It's greatly appreciated. .
Ping Tung
(4,370 posts)(e) all of the above
JHB
(38,213 posts)You don't even need to account for Trump to make that call, it's standard Republican playbook:
Rail about government being the problem and not working
Get into power
Ensure that government doesn't work
dalton99a
(94,115 posts)Ping Tung
(4,370 posts)Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?
Epicurus
Thank you. It needed to be said. It needed to be repeated. It needed to be posted. Thank you.
Duncan Grant
(8,920 posts)Skittles
(171,710 posts)sickening
Ms. Toad
(38,637 posts)malaise
(296,101 posts)keep_left
(3,210 posts)...(the Guadalupe River). Here is a link to a short movie (The Awesome Power, from the late '80s) about flash floods where the incident is discussed. An architect built a house on tall pilings near the headwaters of the Guadalupe. The house was raised 16 feet (three feet above the 100-year flood plain). Nonetheless, a severe thunderstorm caused the river to rise 22 feet in four hours, overflowing its banks and causing most of the house to collapse into the river. A school bus convoy from a church camp was capsized by the same flash flood; 10 drowned.
Here's the link (see 5:33-8:48): https://archive.org/details/gov.ntis.ava17096vnb1
malaise
(296,101 posts)Thanks for posting
dalton99a
(94,115 posts)keep_left
(3,210 posts)...of getting old--you remember obscure things like this from years past. (Well, at least until you get really old, and then you have trouble remembering anything!). I last recall seeing that film on a public-access cable channel back in the late '90s.
malaise
(296,101 posts)Latest - 43 dead including fifteen children and 27 girls from Camp Mystic are still missing. I feel for those parents.
Melon
(1,525 posts)Right before the storm.
Thursday: Flood watches were issued. By late afternoon, a Slight Risk of excessive rain (WPC 2/4) was highlightedwhich in hindsight may have underplayed the potential.
DSandra
(1,719 posts)And Texas is where 10,000 people got killed in a single hurricane in 1900 (the Great Galveston Hurricane.)
Melon
(1,525 posts)And WTF does 1900 Galveston have to do with anything?
Skittles
(171,710 posts)and I have KNOWN people who sound that ignant
Melon
(1,525 posts)This online community is not the same in my eyes after the last 2 days. Ignorance I once attributed to one side of the spectrum has a home here as well.
Skittles
(171,710 posts)THIS TRAGEDY WAS ENTIRELY PREVENTABLE - and THAT makes it SO MUCH FUCKING WORSE
DONE HERE, UGH
Melon
(1,525 posts)DSandra
(1,719 posts)And look at how they deregulated electricity that led to the deaths of hundreds of people during a snowstorm in 2021.
AccuWeather said the private forecasting company and the National Weather Service sent warnings about potential flash flooding hours beforehand.
These warnings should have provided officials with ample time to evacuate camps such as Camp Mystic and get people to safety, AccuWeather said in a statement. It called the Hill Country one of the most flash-flood-prone areas of the U.S. because of its terrain and many water crossings.
At the Mo-Ranch Camp in the community of Hunt, officials had been monitoring the weather and opted to move several hundred campers and attendees at a church youth conference to higher ground. At nearby Camps Rio Vista and Sierra Vista, organizers also had mentioned on social media that they were watching the weather the day before wrapping up their second summer session Thursday.