Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

MIButterfly

(1,784 posts)
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 05:44 PM Sep 29

My thought about Zohran Mamdani and the Democratic Party.

My opinion and nobody has to agree with it, but here's what I think. The people of New York City chose Zohran Mamdani to be their candidate for mayor and the Democratic Party should, to a person, back the one CHOSEN BY THE PEOPLE for the general election. That's who they want. It shouldn't be who the establishment wants it to be or who they think it should be or whose turn it is; let the PEOPLE decide and then back whoever they choose. It may be a simple solution and maybe I'm simple, but that's how I see it.

This nitpicking between the factions in the Democratic Party has not gotten us anywhere and I don't understand why the Powers That Be continue to do it. United we stand and all that. Let's fight the Republicans, not each other.

91 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
My thought about Zohran Mamdani and the Democratic Party. (Original Post) MIButterfly Sep 29 OP
Yeah. mr715 Sep 29 #1
"We have a Democratic nominee. Are we a party who rallies behind our nominee or not?," Emile Sep 29 #2
YES! InAbLuEsTaTe Sep 29 #58
Unfortunately and some times it's wrong, but Democrats do have different opinions especially ....... Lovie777 Sep 29 #3
I am with you. Cuomo's term, like Bloomberg's had much that was awful in it, and much that Scrivener7 Sep 29 #5
there is always the least bad choice . just be grateful for any vote he gets no matter how begrudging msongs Sep 29 #24
It really is that simple. sdfernando Sep 29 #4
I don't think endorsements should be automatic newdeal2 Sep 29 #6
How about, if you can't, in good conscience, endorse the candidate, then don't say anything? MIButterfly Sep 29 #9
I'm not a New Yorker... the people will make the final decision, soon. WarGamer Sep 29 #7
What exactly is the "establishment" doing to harm Mamdani? SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #8
Mamdani is not taking any harm mr715 Sep 29 #10
How? SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #12
I'll do my best, I'll try to be logical. mr715 Sep 29 #14
Most endorsements in 21 SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #15
How about Cuomo? mr715 Sep 29 #16
F*ck Cuomo SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #18
Ha! mr715 Sep 29 #19
Then what is the "establishment" doing? SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #21
You say fuck Cuomo mr715 Sep 29 #23
Cuomo is not part of the establishment SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #27
I've done my best to articulate my reasoning. mr715 Sep 29 #30
And I've asked you to cite SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #36
Cuomo was establishment Democrat until he declared himself himself IND after losing the Dem primary. thesquanderer Sep 29 #62
Cuomo sucks SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #64
While they may not be withholding funds, I doubt the party machinery under Jacobs is working to elect him, either. thesquanderer Sep 29 #67
That's supposition SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #68
I still think he's part of the establishment since he didn't resign and disappear Tribetime Sep 30 #81
That's an opinion SocialDemocrat61 Sep 30 #83
Excellent reply! I believe this is a leadership test. Emile Sep 29 #20
No, it's a purity test. SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #22
Who is looking for purity? mr715 Sep 29 #25
Sure they could SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #29
What is your definition of establishment? nt mr715 Sep 29 #33
National and state party officials SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #37
It isn't just me. mr715 Sep 29 #38
Again I couldn't care less SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #42
Even if endorsements are not important... thesquanderer Sep 29 #63
Endorsements are bs SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #65
Populists use the label Establishment to identify and demonize imaginary corrupt enemies out to get them. betsuni Sep 30 #74
re: "a disgraced former governor who was forced to resign and is now running as an independent." thesquanderer Oct 12 #88
Endorsments: Mamdani vs Cuomo SocialDemocrat61 Oct 12 #89
Good link, ty. But there is this perception that the big players in the party are not enthusaistic about him... thesquanderer Oct 12 #90
It's coming from the corporate media SocialDemocrat61 Oct 12 #91
Are we a party who rallies behind our nominee or not? Emile Sep 29 #40
We should be SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #43
As I said, it's a leadership test! Emile Sep 29 #44
And as I said SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #45
Gillibrand lives in N.Y. Booker does not. There is no reason for Booker to endorse candidates for another state. 3Hotdogs Sep 29 #46
Gillibrand lives in upstate New York SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #48
Moynihan had a term, "Benign neglect." 3Hotdogs Sep 29 #49
Yes he did SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #52
gotta wait 'till February fund raiser. 3Hotdogs Sep 29 #54
Well I'll still give a heart now ❤️ SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #56
Now I want a heart. nt mr715 Sep 29 #57
Ok here you go ❤️ SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #59
Just a respectful, thought provoking discussion. And a heart. NT mr715 Sep 29 #60
I am not a New Yorker and have no ball in this game. sheshe2 Sep 29 #11
It's a purity test SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #17
You are correct. sheshe2 Sep 29 #28
I've asked for SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #34
Why is anyone obligated to answer questions you ask? Violet_Crumble Sep 29 #66
They are not SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #69
Conspiracy theory that Democrats are corrupted by donors, oligarchs, billionaires, corporations, lobbyists, betsuni Sep 30 #75
I'm not from New York, I simply don't care about this election. tritsofme Sep 29 #13
We're the greatest city in the world mr715 Sep 29 #26
Also a strong democratic socialist movement may convince applegrove Sep 29 #31
Either way the Democrat Party wins Glen Livid Sep 29 #32
Democratic not Democrat. nt BWdem4life Sep 29 #41
George Carlin has already told us why. aeromanKC Sep 29 #35
We need to support the new guard Chicagogrl1 Sep 29 #39
Amen LilElf70 Sep 29 #51
"We need to support the new guard" sheshe2 Sep 29 #53
In the movie Logan"s Run SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #55
Dayum, fifty could be the new old and in the way. sheshe2 Sep 29 #61
Then "new guard" gets same "disappointment" complaints, into the Status Quo Establishment binder they go. betsuni Sep 30 #79
Herding Democrats can be harder than herding cats. pat_k Sep 29 #47
Well said Cirsium Sep 29 #50
re: " It shouldn't be who the establishment wants it to be or who they think it should be or whose turn it is" thesquanderer Sep 29 #70
He should become a Democrat LyfeTimeDem Sep 29 #71
Mamdani is a democrat SocialDemocrat61 Sep 29 #72
he is a self-identified Socialist LyfeTimeDem Sep 30 #73
He's a member of the Democratic Party SocialDemocrat61 Sep 30 #80
Yep Coumo & Adams shouldnt be running IbogaProject Sep 30 #76
The old Democrats have to step aside bob4460 Sep 30 #77
How do you define old? SocialDemocrat61 Sep 30 #85
Sanders doesn't identify as a Democrat n/t MichMan Sep 30 #86
True SocialDemocrat61 Sep 30 #87
Post removed Post removed Sep 30 #78
He is a Democrat. It's time to show support for the democratic nominee. Emile Sep 30 #84
Post removed Post removed Sep 30 #82

mr715

(2,522 posts)
1. Yeah.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 05:45 PM
Sep 29

Run in a Democratic primary and win, you get Democratic support.

Run and lose, you don't get that.

Lovie777

(21,395 posts)
3. Unfortunately and some times it's wrong, but Democrats do have different opinions especially .......
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 06:00 PM
Sep 29

about candidates. Cuomo is well known, his father was a prominent Democrat I believe the Governor of New York as well. Heck, Cuomo helped me through COVID, every morning I would tune in to hear him give status and information concerning NYC.

I'm from California, and that said, I do have respect for him, and I realized he may have crossed over to the dark side.

I do support Mamdani.

Scrivener7

(58,012 posts)
5. I am with you. Cuomo's term, like Bloomberg's had much that was awful in it, and much that
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 06:09 PM
Sep 29

was very welcomed. He kept me sane, too, when the sirens were running all night long here and the big tent hospital in the local mall parking lot was full. It was terrifying, and even knowing the bad things he did, I will always be grateful for that. And I don't think Cankles would dare to put military on the streets of NYC if he was the mayor.

BUT the people have spoken. Democrats have chosen Mamdani. Backing anyone but Mamdani is nothing but rank disrespect for New York's voters.

NO Democrat, when asked, should be giving ANYTHING but full-throated support to Mamdani. This avoidance disrespects all Democratic constituents.

msongs

(72,942 posts)
24. there is always the least bad choice . just be grateful for any vote he gets no matter how begrudging
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:46 PM
Sep 29

sdfernando

(5,986 posts)
4. It really is that simple.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 06:04 PM
Sep 29

Granted, I don't follow New York City politics and I am not very familiar with Zohran Mamdani....but the people have spoken....you know, the people in "WE THE PEOPLE". If we are going to have political parties, then once a candidate is chosen during a primary, every single person in that party, to a tee, should be working 100% get get that nominee elected....FULL STOP!

Not doing this is what is causing democratic voter registrations to decline. If the people don't feel their voice is heard and listened to, they will go somewhere else to be heard, or just entirely pull back. Either of those is not a good thing.

newdeal2

(4,610 posts)
6. I don't think endorsements should be automatic
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 06:11 PM
Sep 29

If that’s what you mean by back him.

If you endorse someone, it should authentic and done enthusiastically. You’re putting your name and reputation on the line so you better be damn sure.

MIButterfly

(1,784 posts)
9. How about, if you can't, in good conscience, endorse the candidate, then don't say anything?
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 06:31 PM
Sep 29

I've voted for Democratic candidates in the general election that I didn't vote for in the primary because, like my mother always said, the worst Democrat is better than the best Republican and that's never been truer than it is now.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
8. What exactly is the "establishment" doing to harm Mamdani?
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 06:25 PM
Sep 29

Is the DNC withholding funding and data that he is entitled to? Are any major democrats working to elect one of his opponents? If you’re talking about endorsements, it should be noted in 24 that Hochal and Schumer didn’t endorse Adams until late October, the weekend before the election. Other Democrats such as Gillibrand and Booker didn’t make any endorsement 4 years ago. Most likely because they don’t live in New York. Plus members of the same party endorsing each other is just political incest anyway.

mr715

(2,522 posts)
14. I'll do my best, I'll try to be logical.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:09 PM
Sep 29

I think Mamdani is extremely likely to win, and that his electoral success is the result of an energetic style of campaign and policies that are popular (and will work). The policies he communicates are simple, straightforward, and relatable to the majority of NYers.

To your question of what actions have "they" (leadership) taken - it is that they have not endorsed and allowed the cultivation of a narrative that the politics Mamdani advocates are way out there. Free buses, amirite?

It boils down to Jeffries, a NYer in leadership has not endorsed. Gillibrand levied some pretty Islamophobic attacks and yes, apologized, but that she went there in the first place provides fuel for the GOP to conflate good governance with extremist policy.

I think that in their failure to recognize Mamdani's success and cultivate the energy he is bringing, they are showing themselves (again, the establishment is hurting themselves) to be unwilling to adapt to new models of politics. This is problematic because the narrative of them being out of touch and disconnected from the people that invest in them the authority to govern is already there, and this reinforces it. It, at least to me, has a tang of cowardice and I find distasteful.

I will admit to you to be completely transparent: Cuomo lost me. Mamdani won me.

My hope is that this at least clarifies my thinking, even if it isn't clear. Apologies for having a mind as clear as mud.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
15. Most endorsements in 21
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:24 PM
Sep 29

Didn’t come until the end of October. And endorsements are bs anyway. But are there any substantial actions that the “establishment” has taken against Mamdani?

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
18. F*ck Cuomo
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:28 PM
Sep 29

He’s not “establishment” Are any of the “establishment” democrats supporting him?

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
21. Then what is the "establishment" doing?
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:36 PM
Sep 29

Are the national or state party organizations withholding data or funding that the Mamdani campaign is entitled to?

mr715

(2,522 posts)
23. You say fuck Cuomo
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:42 PM
Sep 29

I say he is part of the establishment. As I said before, I think this is less of an active harm thing than a demonstration of feckless leadership.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
27. Cuomo is not part of the establishment
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:49 PM
Sep 29

He holds no office and isn't a member of the DNC. And the only fecklessness here is criticism of the "establishment" without being able to state one actual action taken against Mamdani.

mr715

(2,522 posts)
30. I've done my best to articulate my reasoning.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:53 PM
Sep 29

I don't know why we have to tie ourselves in knots to support the Democratic nominee.

Let's not talk in circles - I think we both know where we stand here.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
36. And I've asked you to cite
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:58 PM
Sep 29

actual actions that have been taken against Mamdani. Any else is just spin and grievance shopping.

thesquanderer

(12,872 posts)
62. Cuomo was establishment Democrat until he declared himself himself IND after losing the Dem primary.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 09:23 PM
Sep 29

Last edited Mon Sep 29, 2025, 10:07 PM - Edit history (1)

And it's one thing not to endorse the person who beat you (or at least not right away), but another thing entirely to actually run against him. Some states actually have laws against that. Whether you agree with those laws or not, this behavior is not good for the party, especially from someone who was not on the fringe of the party to begin with, but was practically the definition of party establishment, which Cuomo was. Even with the scandals that brought him down, he was still pretty much the poster boy for New York Democrat over his career, and presented himself as Dem right up until he lost to Mamdami.

Adams didn't have Cuomo's long and high profile career, but nonetheless, as mayor of NYC, he was NY Dem establishment until he, too, went independent after declining to run in the Dem primary after determining that he could not win it.

Interesting contrast referenced here, about how the biggest national establishment Dems Pelosi and Biden welcomed Adams 4 years ago, and now even establishment Dems from his own home state (Schumer and Jeffries) are keeping him at arm's length:

https://www.axios.com/2025/07/21/zohran-mamdani-new-york-democrats-wary

And since you wanted examples, besides those, the New York State Democratic Chair (Jay Jacobs) has refused to endorse him.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
64. Cuomo sucks
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 09:42 PM
Sep 29

I completely agree. But he hasn’t been been part of the “establishment” since he resigned as Governor in disgrace.

You’re right about Jacobs, as chair of the state party, he should endorse the nominee, although I doubt his endorsement would change a single vote.

But my question was what actions has the “establishment” taken against Mamdani? Has party funds or voter.data been withheld from him?

thesquanderer

(12,872 posts)
67. While they may not be withholding funds, I doubt the party machinery under Jacobs is working to elect him, either.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 09:53 PM
Sep 29

Fundraising, GOTV, etc.... How can you inspire your organization to work to elect someone you refuse to endorse? It's not just damaging if the party takes actions against him, as you suggest. It's also damaging if the party does not take action to support him.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
68. That's supposition
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 10:02 PM
Sep 29

And as a life long new Yorker, the state party doesn't get involved in NYC campaigns other than providing some funding and data. They don't bus people down from upstairs new York to work in city campaigns.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
83. That's an opinion
Tue Sep 30, 2025, 04:28 AM
Sep 30

And it doesn't reflect reality. He holds no post in the party on either a state or national level. So is anyone who has ever been elected to office as a democrat automatically a member of the "establishment"? If so that means Mamdani who is an elected democratic assemblyman is establishment too.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
22. No, it's a purity test.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:38 PM
Sep 29

And that’s the last thing democrats need right now. Purity tests didn’t serve democrats well in 2000, 04, 16 or 24.

mr715

(2,522 posts)
25. Who is looking for purity?
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:46 PM
Sep 29

I am not. But my lying eyes tell me that Mamdani has stumbled on a campaign that others could learn from.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
29. Sure they could
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:52 PM
Sep 29

But that's not the issue
The issue is the unsupported accusations that the "establishment" is taking actions against Mamdani.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
37. National and state party officials
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:01 PM
Sep 29

and elected office holders. Not a disgraced former governor who was forced to resign and is now running as an independent.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
42. Again I couldn't care less
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:10 PM
Sep 29

about endorsements. They are nothing but political incest. I never heard of anyone who based their vote on an endorsement
I've asked several to cite actual actions taken by the "establishment" against Mamdani and haven't heard a single one.

thesquanderer

(12,872 posts)
63. Even if endorsements are not important...
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 09:36 PM
Sep 29

...having major party figures not only fail to endorse you, but actually work *against* you, is damaging to the party. As I said in the other post, it's not just that NY Dem establishment figures Cuomo and Adams didn't endorse him when he won, but actually chose to leave the party and run against him and put lots of time and money (esp. Cuomo) into telling New Yorkers how terrible Mamdani is, is definietly an action against him by someone the NY public still sees very much as an establishment Democratic figure (even if you do not).

And the New York State party leader making a point of not endorsing him was significant as well. I agree, that endorsement wouldn't have meant anything. Even if endorsements mattered (I agree, generally debatable), everyone expects the party leader to endorse their candidate. But in this case his specific NON-endorsement also telegraphs what the NY Democratic establishment thinks of Mamdami.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
65. Endorsements are bs
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 09:51 PM
Sep 29

In 21 most of the few that happened didn’t until late October. And the only major party figures were ones from NYC. Cuomo hasn’t been “establishment” for years. Adams didn’t run in the primary so it’s not fair to say he was “establishment” too. As far as the NYS chair not endorsing Mamdani, that is wrong. But that’s only one person. And other than the endorsement has he taken any other action against the Mamdani campaign?

betsuni

(28,600 posts)
74. Populists use the label Establishment to identify and demonize imaginary corrupt enemies out to get them.
Tue Sep 30, 2025, 12:43 AM
Sep 30

Endorsements are a purity test, those who fail are part of the evil Establishment plotting and rigging to stop progress. How Planned Parenthood ended up on the Establishment enemies list about ten years ago.

Evidently endorsements are so tremendously morally important that Democratic voters carefully keep track and flee the party, disgusted, if an endorsement is not made promptly enough in one mayoral election somewhere in the United States.

thesquanderer

(12,872 posts)
88. re: "a disgraced former governor who was forced to resign and is now running as an independent."
Sun Oct 12, 2025, 05:53 AM
Oct 12

Despite not being on the party line on the ballot, he is still campaigning as a Democrat.

In an interview with NBC News' "Meet the Press NOW" earlier this month, Cuomo said that he and Mamdani are like "apples and oranges" and described the Democratic mayoral nominee as "fringe."

"You know, it’s apples and oranges. We couldn’t be more different. I’m a mainstream Democrat. He’s a fringe Democrat,” Cuomo said.


(from https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/elections/democratic-national-committee-zohran-mamdani-endorsement-nyc-mayor-rcna237025 )

He is still seen by people as a Democrat, running against another Democrat, and as that quote shows, that's how he wants it to be seen. And I do think the average voter-on-the-street sees Cuomo as "establishment."

The (correct) perception out there is that a lot of well known people in the party are hesitant to support the Democratic nominee, and one of the best-known Dems in NY is actively campaigning against him.

And while I agree with you that, in general, endorsements don't matter much, I think people's expectations are that the usual public Democratic supporters will support the Democratic nominee. So while no individual endorsement may carry much weight, I think the sum of all the NON-endorsements from those who normally would whole-heartedly endorse the Dem nominee does send a message, i.e. that there's a lot of hesitation about him from within the Democratic establishment. It gives Mamdani another hurdle to overcome.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
89. Endorsments: Mamdani vs Cuomo
Sun Oct 12, 2025, 06:12 AM
Oct 12
ZOHRAN MAMDANI (Democrat)

Elected officials: Gov. Kathy Hochul, Lt. Gov. Antonio Delgado, state Attorney General Letitia James, Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Jerrold Nadler, Nydia Velázquez, Adriano Espaillat, Pat Ryan and Yvette Clarke, state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli, New York City Comptroller Brad Lander, Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, state Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins, Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, state Sens. Brad Hoylman-Sigal, John Liu, Julia Salazar, Jabari Brisport, Kristen Gonzalez, Gustavo Rivera, Michael Gianaris, Zellnor Myrie, Luis Sepúlveda, José Serrano, Nathalia Fernandez, Liz Krueger and Andrew Gounardes, Bronx Democratic Party Chair and state Sen. Jamaal Bailey, Brooklyn Democratic Party Chair and Assembly Member Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn, Assembly Members Micah Lasher, Emily Gallagher, Phara Souffrant Forest, Marcela Mitaynes, Karines Reyes, Claire Valdez, Sarahana Shrestha, Khaleel Anderson, Robert Carroll, Jessica González-Rojas, Brian Cunningham, Steven Raga, Manny De Los Santos, Khaleel Anderson, Bobby Carroll, George Alvarez, Jordan Wright, Harvey Epstein, Al Taylor, Tony Simone, Emerita Torres, Landon Dais, Alex Bores, Maritza Davila and Monique Chandler-Waterman, Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine, Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso, Queens Borough President Donovan Richards, Bronx Borough President Vanessa Gibson, City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, City Council Members Chi Ossé, Justin Brannan, Shaun Abreu, Carmen De La Rosa, Pierina Sanchez, Jennifer Gutiérrez, Sandy Nurse, Lincoln Restler, Alexa Avilés, Tiffany Cabán, Shahana Hanif, Erik Bottcher, Crystal Hudson, Rita Joseph, Julie Won, Oswald Feliz, Diana Ayala, Kevin Riley and Chris Marte

Others: U.S. Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders and Chris Van Hollen, Reps. Pramila Jayapal, Ro Khanna and Jamie Raskin, former Rep. Jamaal Bowman, former Mayor Bill de Blasio, former U.S. Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris

ANDREW CUOMO (Democrat running as an independent candidate)

Elected officials
: State Sen. Sam Sutton

Other: Jim Walden

https://www.cityandstateny.com/politics/2025/10/endorsements-2025-nyc-mayoral-general-election/406718/

thesquanderer

(12,872 posts)
90. Good link, ty. But there is this perception that the big players in the party are not enthusaistic about him...
Sun Oct 12, 2025, 06:25 AM
Oct 12

...so where do you think that is coming from?

Is it that some endorsements have been late and/or tepid?

Is it largely coming from Cuomo's own campaign?

Or something else?

You don't think that perception is wrong to begin with, do you?

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
91. It's coming from the corporate media
Sun Oct 12, 2025, 06:29 AM
Oct 12

who love the "dems in disarray" narrative and certain people who love to create purity tests. It's just bs for the most part.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
43. We should be
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:18 PM
Sep 29

But not every democrat rallied around Harris last year, and some worked against Biden after he won the primaries and many democrats worked against Clinton in 16 despite her being the nominee.
But we don't live in a perfect world. And I don't think democrats should require the same kind of fealty that Republicans do. As long as no one takes actual action against Mamdani, I don't have a problem.

3Hotdogs

(14,889 posts)
46. Gillibrand lives in N.Y. Booker does not. There is no reason for Booker to endorse candidates for another state.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:24 PM
Sep 29

Mandami is a Socialist Democrat. Bernie is a Democratic Socialist. I don't know what the difference is.

What I do know - Bernie and A.O.C. fill auditoriums.

I live in N.J. I attended. a presentation by Booker before he became mayor of N.J. It was an excellent speech to police officers about their contribution to society. Still, I wouldn't feel inspired to walk across the street to hear another speech by Booker. I will vote for him again, against a Republican, but that is the limit of my support for him.

Now back to Mamdani. The Dem "establishment" is afraid of being associated with the term, socialist. Instead of attacking the issue, they explain that the Democratic Party is not socialist and doesn't believe in socialism.

What they should be doing, is explaining what socialism can offer that would benefit all of us. They should define fascism and point out the characteristics of Republican leadership that are fascist.

Instead, we get ambiguous platform statements that end up in the bottom of the bird cage of those of us who still get newspapers.

--- and we will continue to lose elections.


Carry on.

P.S. I would drive hours to hear Bernie and/or A.O.C.

Oh. And I'm 83 years old.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
48. Gillibrand lives in upstate New York
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:32 PM
Sep 29

not in NYC. She has never endorsed a candidate for NYC Mayor before. And yes Booker is in another state but has gotten criticized for not endorsing Mamdani.

And you're entitled to your opinion of what you think the "establishment" should be doing. But my question was what actions has the "establishment" taken against Mamdani. Can you cite any?

3Hotdogs

(14,889 posts)
49. Moynihan had a term, "Benign neglect."
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:42 PM
Sep 29

Oh, and it's kind of you to allow me my opinion. I'll remember to send you a Valentine's heart.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
52. Yes he did
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:53 PM
Sep 29

but that was about poor communities, not about elections so it really doesn't apply. My question was if there were any actions that the "establishment" has taken against Mamdani? I lived in NYC all my life and I've never seen the national party get involved in local elections. Or so many suddenly requiring that they should.
And you're welcome. Looking forward to the heart. ❤️

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
59. Ok here you go ❤️
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 09:08 PM
Sep 29

But if you want anything more, you'll have to buy me dinner first 😉

sheshe2

(95,249 posts)
11. I am not a New Yorker and have no ball in this game.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 06:50 PM
Sep 29

I don't understand all the angst about who endorses whom. He is a candidate for NYC alone. I doubt most would be able to even name the mayor of their own State Capital.

Sure, he was chosen by the people, the people of NYC. Let's let them decide.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
34. I've asked for
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:54 PM
Sep 29

actual action that has been taken against Mamdani and all I'm getting is double talk.

Violet_Crumble

(36,357 posts)
66. Why is anyone obligated to answer questions you ask?
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 09:52 PM
Sep 29

Or do you apply a different standard to yourself? You told me I was free to ask questions, but you had no obligation to answer them.

https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=20614079

I have no feelings about local elections in the US, apart from hoping the Democratic candidate wins, but if you think what yr getting from other DUers is 'double talk', then that's likely a you problem, as I can't see any double talk. I can see people saying things you clearly don't agree with, however.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
69. They are not
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 10:04 PM
Sep 29

But they are responding yet not answering my question. And most of the responses are double talk based on opinions not on facts.

betsuni

(28,600 posts)
75. Conspiracy theory that Democrats are corrupted by donors, oligarchs, billionaires, corporations, lobbyists,
Tue Sep 30, 2025, 12:56 AM
Sep 30

Satan, whatever the cat dragged in as long as they have ten dollars or so, and do nothing but plot and rig against the nice pure incorruptibles is taken as so obvious and everybody knows that it need not be explained or any evidence given.

tritsofme

(19,758 posts)
13. I'm not from New York, I simply don't care about this election.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 06:55 PM
Sep 29

I barely care about Chicago’s mayoral elections, and I live 30 minutes away, why would I give two shits about New York?

mr715

(2,522 posts)
26. We're the greatest city in the world
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:48 PM
Sep 29

Last edited Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:52 PM - Edit history (1)

And while our pizzas aren't as deep as Chicago's, they are much more portable.

applegrove

(129,613 posts)
31. Also a strong democratic socialist movement may convince
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:53 PM
Sep 29

Last edited Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:57 PM - Edit history (3)

oligarchs and the GOP to temper their policy platform. That is what happened to Canada and the US in the 1930s. Socialism was a threat so the capitalists, kick and screaming, had to move to the center. That is why Trump is going so strongly after Mamdani.

Glen Livid

(15 posts)
32. Either way the Democrat Party wins
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 07:54 PM
Sep 29

If Mamdani wins, it will be a great opportunity to see how his energy transforms the party. If the establishment Powers That Be get behind a candidate chosen by the people, it is an opportunity to move forward. If the establishment does not support the will of the people, they become the Powers That Had Been.

Chicagogrl1

(602 posts)
39. We need to support the new guard
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:05 PM
Sep 29

What worked in the past is no longer working. We need candidates that are young, articulate, not afraid to fight while hammering home their viewpoints using Tiktok. We need to capture the younger generation. We’ve got to rewrite the DNC playbook and support candidates that are supported by the people. In my opinion, as a direct response to the current wanna be facists, there’s no such thing as too far to the left.

LilElf70

(1,309 posts)
51. Amen
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:48 PM
Sep 29

I totally agree.

Now we need to find 90 million people that think you are 100% right. Let's take it one step further. What the hell is so bad about free tuition? Medicare PLUS for all?

sheshe2

(95,249 posts)
53. "We need to support the new guard"
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:53 PM
Sep 29

"We need candidates that are young, articulate, not afraid to fight....the new guard, young and articulate."

What is the new guard?

I am curious, at what age do we start the purge? At what age are they to old and inarticulate? When do we decide they are old and in the way.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
55. In the movie Logan"s Run
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:57 PM
Sep 29

everyone over 30 was killed. But that may be too young. Maybe 50? Poor Bernie Sanders 😢.

sheshe2

(95,249 posts)
61. Dayum, fifty could be the new old and in the way.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 09:11 PM
Sep 29

Oh no, AOC only has 14 years left and I will weep if Bern is tossed. Oh, wait he won and will be in office until 89.

betsuni

(28,600 posts)
79. Then "new guard" gets same "disappointment" complaints, into the Status Quo Establishment binder they go.
Tue Sep 30, 2025, 01:21 AM
Sep 30

It's "All About Eve," someone younger and outsider anti-establishment without a history so everyone can project whatever they want right behind you.

pat_k

(12,614 posts)
47. Herding Democrats can be harder than herding cats.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 08:28 PM
Sep 29

An end to the tendency to jump into circular firing squads would sure be nice, but I fear that such "arguments in the family" are a natural part of being a member of a very diverse party.

That said, I've actually been quite pleased that we are seeing an unusual level of unity in meeting the challenge of opposing the 47 regime. And while I'd love for the entire party to follow the sort of rule we have here (fight it out all you want in primary season, but come together behind the nominee), we don't have any party "enforcers." And I am very, very grateful we don't.



thesquanderer

(12,872 posts)
70. re: " It shouldn't be who the establishment wants it to be or who they think it should be or whose turn it is"
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 10:21 PM
Sep 29

Agreed. I think this bit us in the primaries in 2016 when the Dem establishment put its hand on the scale for Hillary over Bernie, and I'd even argue it bit us again in 2020. Yes, we won, but considering how the term ended and what it led to, it was arguably a pyrrhic victory.

I don't know if Sanders (our runner-up for the nomination both times) would have done better, but he couldn't have done much worse (certainly in 2016). I don't know that our nominee would have been Bernie if it weren't Biden in 2020, but whoever it was, it wouldn't have been Biden if the establishment wasn't pulling for him. Heck, his campaign was going nowhere until Clyburn got him SC. Whether you were a Biden fan or not, in the end, his presidency backfired on us, bigly. Despite its successes.

I live in the NY area, but not in the city, so I didn't have a horse in that primary race. I don't know that I would have voted for Mamdami (I only know I would not have voted for Cuomo). But the people have spoken, and I think the party establishment needs to get over its fear of giving the voters what they want. I at least think it's worth giving that approach a shot. You never know, it might work.

 

LyfeTimeDem

(252 posts)
73. he is a self-identified Socialist
Tue Sep 30, 2025, 12:36 AM
Sep 30

Someone who chose the moniker SocialDemocrat

Should understand the difference between a Democratic (adjective) Socialist (noun) and a Social(adjective) Democrat(noun)

According to Oxford:

Socialism:
An economic system in which the means of production are controlled by the state. Also known as socialist economy. Contrast capitalism. See also marxism.

Aka.... it's an economic system that opposes the private ownership of the means of production also known as Capitalism

We Democrats invented Regulated Capitalism starting with FDR, Social Democracies emulated that success ...including the Nordic ones

Social as an adjective doesnt mean the same when it is a noun...

Social Media
Social Personality
Social Club
Social Worker
Social Studies.

SocialDemocrat61

(6,580 posts)
80. He's a member of the Democratic Party
Tue Sep 30, 2025, 02:52 AM
Sep 30

Not the socialist party, if there is one. Anything else is just a label about ideology.

IbogaProject

(5,505 posts)
76. Yep Coumo & Adams shouldnt be running
Tue Sep 30, 2025, 01:05 AM
Sep 30

Unless we go jungle primary like California there shouldn't be extra Dems in the race. Coumo had neen allied with the turncoat IDC who ran as D but caucused with the GOP in the NY State Senate so his party loyalty has been weak for awhile.

bob4460

(372 posts)
77. The old Democrats have to step aside
Tue Sep 30, 2025, 01:07 AM
Sep 30

Or watch our party continue to lose! And I am a old fart but they need to pass the torch!

Response to MIButterfly (Original post)

Response to MIButterfly (Original post)

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»My thought about Zohran M...