General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsCanada should invite Minnesota to become its 11th province
Yes or no?
| 42 votes, 0 passes | Time left: Unlimited | |
| YES! | |
38 (90%) |
|
| NO! | |
4 (10%) |
|
| 0 DU members did not wish to select any of the options provided. | |
| Show usernames
Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll |
|
Chasstev365
(7,227 posts)Irish_Dem
(80,150 posts)Lars39
(26,498 posts)Sogo
(6,994 posts)nt
paleotn
(21,694 posts)paleotn
(21,694 posts)Vermont came close to rejoining the UK over the territorial fight with NY. Had the timing been different, Yorktown surrender and NY hadn't agreed to compromise, we might have ended up as Canada's strange little appendage. Lots of Quebec ties as it is, particularly in the NEK and the Champlain Valley. And there was that whole thumbing their nose at Jefferson and continuing to trade illicitly with British Canada. Smuggler's Notch isn't called that because it's a cutsie name for the tourist trade.
DavidDvorkin
(20,506 posts)Polybius
(21,561 posts)But it was illegal in 1776 too.
DavidDvorkin
(20,506 posts)Do we want that again?
Polybius
(21,561 posts)But the next one doesn't have to be.
carpetbagger
(5,428 posts)This is 159 years later. The great empires in Europe shed independent nations behind them from Ireland to Moldova, and there's a judo move in that the red hats have been having erotic dreams about secession and the CSA for a generation.
I could see California doing it. The GOP would be enticed by potential electoral dominance for a generation, and the red hats think CA is a drain on the nation. Then comes VT, which would join Canada, followed by MA (Ind or Canada)and HI (In some loose association with CA, minus military land).
Minnesota isn't strongly Democratic. I don't see a 50+1 vote, and I don't see the 60-70 percent support needed to convince the US government not to fight it.
Dave says
(5,335 posts)Ping Tung
(4,159 posts)NotASurfer
(2,364 posts)I'd think I'd write that into the treaty somewhere if I were Canada