Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

EarlG

(23,485 posts)
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 01:08 PM Jan 24

The photo seems to disprove DHS's narrative

This is the man who was shot. This is a screengrab from a video that was taken by someone driving past in a car moments before the shooting. This was right as they were starting to take the guy down. You can see that he has a phone in his right hand and is (likely) filming.

I do not have the video available, although I have seen the video that this still comes from. This photo came from Reddit.



DHS said:

"At 9:05 AM CT, as DHS law enforcement officers were conducting a targeted operation in Minneapolis against an illegal alien wanted for violent assault, an individual approached US Border Patrol officers with a 9 mm semi-automatic handgun. The officers attempted to disarm the suspect but the armed suspect violently resisted."

https://abc7news.com/post/minneapolis-shooting-today-federal-agent-reportedly-involved-gov-tim-walz-says/18463609/

https://www.foxnews.com/us/border-patrol-involved-shooting-reported-minneapolis

DHS also said that he had no ID (which is not a crime). Meanwhile local officials report that the man had a legal permit to carry. So he may have been "with" a 9mm handgun, but the the photo above, taken moments before the altercation which led to the shooting, does not show the man brandishing a weapon.

Edited again to add: The video has now been posted and can be seen on Bluesky (DU link here):

https://democraticunderground.com/100220965013

This is another screengrab from the video. Watch the video and you can clearly see that the man had nothing in his left hand as officers started to shove him, prior to wrestling him to the ground. This was not about trying to disarm somebody who was threatening them.

77 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The photo seems to disprove DHS's narrative (Original Post) EarlG Jan 24 OP
The guy's armed with a camera phone. Kid Berwyn Jan 24 #1
The more they try to silence us, the more we speak up and stand up. n/t yellow dahlia Jan 24 #16
EXACTLY!!!!!! IT WAS A FAWKING PHONE!!!!! a kennedy Jan 24 #57
Has his name been released? MagickMuffin Jan 24 #2
Alex Pretti. ShazzieB Jan 25 #62
Yeah, I already know the details MagickMuffin Jan 25 #63
Camera as Deadly Weapon leftstreet Jan 24 #3
I know. He was just being a rigorous citizen, and now he is dead. yellow dahlia Jan 24 #14
MPD Chief confirmed that he was a lawful gun owner with a permit to carry Prairie Gates Jan 24 #4
Yup. He was exercising his 2A rights. herding cats Jan 24 #5
Exactly. yellow dahlia Jan 24 #11
Trump: "HE HAD A GUN, ONLY CRIMINALS CARRY GUNS ON OUR STREETS, WE NEED LAW AND ORDER." Ol Janx Spirit Jan 25 #67
NRA is too busy licking boots to be alarmed by such things quakerboy Jan 25 #70
That's not actually true. And I think it has the potential to wake up some of these 2A groups... Ol Janx Spirit Jan 25 #76
Good Guy RobinA Jan 24 #22
We see no gun in either hand... Camera in right hand and left hand is empty (see bluesky video below) liberalla Jan 24 #34
DHS is claiming he walked up to agents with weapon drawn. Per MS NOW. Solly Mack Jan 24 #6
Don't believe your lying eyes. yellow dahlia Jan 24 #10
Damn eyes. Solly Mack Jan 24 #13
He had a gun that he was wearing a holster at the time. ShazzieB Jan 25 #64
Disgusting people. Solly Mack Jan 25 #66
Those fuckers at MSN censor every comment I make wolfie001 Jan 24 #25
It's a digital pocket camera. People have been using these so as not to risk their phones. SunSeeker Jan 24 #32
Oooo, thanks for the reminder, I think I have 2 of those lil oldies but goodies around here. Attilatheblond Jan 24 #35
Thanks! Either way, not "brandishing" a gun. Solly Mack Jan 24 #36
The benefit to using a phone is being able to upload to the cloud as you record EdmondDantes_ Jan 24 #38
Download the SD card files in your phone via an adaptor dongle, when you are safely at home or in your car. nt SunSeeker Jan 24 #41
FAWK DHS!!!!!! IT WAS A FAWKING PHONE!!!!! a kennedy Jan 24 #58
Yeah, because everyone knows swearing bothers me. lol Solly Mack Jan 24 #61
It's a Rebl2 Jan 24 #59
It's a weapon to the thugs because it exposes their actions. Solly Mack Jan 24 #60
Oh, man Lulu KC Jan 24 #7
Ill fitting child sized ballistic vest... Hugin Jan 24 #8
So it appears this guy was attacked and beaten for the crime of exercising his First Amendment rights. yellow dahlia Jan 24 #9
Blocking the door to the Donut Shop? leftstreet Jan 24 #18
He was on the other side of the street from the donut shop JHB Jan 24 #44
DHS is not to be trusted for one second. spanone Jan 24 #12
Kick dalton99a Jan 24 #15
I posted the video in an OP 10 minutes ago - see highplainsdem Jan 24 #17
Here.- found another Bluesky post with it: highplainsdem Jan 24 #19
The truth will come out. orangecrush Jan 24 #20
Why are these f-ers permitted to wear the word POLICE on their vests Hope22 Jan 24 #21
This is the first time I noticed that electric_blue68 Jan 24 #56
They were everywhere! Nt Hope22 Jan 25 #68
I saw the various vids.... electric_blue68 Jan 25 #69
Sorry for the misunderstanding. Hope22 Jan 25 #72
Nazis wolfie001 Jan 24 #23
Do NOT assume that the victim was brandishing a weapon. ICE lies, Safe as Milk Jan 24 #24
Asking my DU colleagues: AverageOldGuy Jan 24 #26
Exact. Justice matters. Jan 24 #37
How about Jackboots? Or Figarosmom Jan 24 #47
How about Rebl2 Jan 25 #74
Bovino is fucking lying his ass off now on MSNOW. LuckyCharms Jan 24 #27
Good God! James48 Jan 24 #29
That wee little fuck needs to be shuttled... LuckyCharms Jan 24 #30
And now they'll get the ammo they need to declare all-out war on us?... buzzycrumbhunger Jan 24 #28
Peacefully watching and recording ICE is a death sentence IronLionZion Jan 24 #31
Trump and his new Gestapo were in danger because he was brandishing a phone... ashredux Jan 24 #33
... littlemissmartypants Jan 24 #39
These Individuals Voted In Favor Of Continuing To Fund These ICE Murderers MayReasonRule Jan 24 #40
And every Republicans but one. creeksneakers2 Jan 24 #48
I Expect It Of The Wholly Fascist Ongoing Criminal Enterprise That Is The GOP MayReasonRule Jan 24 #49
I want to remind everyone creeksneakers2 Jan 24 #52
I Hold To Account Those That Commit The Offenses MayReasonRule Jan 25 #71
There is more video of them pulling the gun out of the victims holster before the shot him Historic NY Jan 24 #42
Another video, apparently from the woman in the pink coat. The man was helping people, no gun in hand. SunSeeker Jan 24 #43
I'd bet they didnt even know Figarosmom Jan 24 #45
Footage from The Guardian that shows the murder -- at least ten shots fired by my count. ancianita Jan 24 #46
k&r nt orleans Jan 24 #50
When do we start calling out the credibility gap? EnergizedLib Jan 24 #51
Minnesota Gun Owners Law Center is skeptical of official narrative regarding shooting CROW50 Jan 24 #53
there are at least 2 videos circulating barbtries Jan 24 #54
Kick electric_blue68 Jan 24 #55
Seems like the agent who took Pretti's gun Blue Full Moon Jan 25 #65
Fox lying their asses off. Yeah...they were pursuing a 'dangerous illegal' travelingthrulife Jan 25 #73
Cold blooded murderers. They're American Brownshirts Joinfortmill Jan 25 #75
There is a white vehicle where someone gets in and closes the door. Ellipsis Jan 25 #77

MagickMuffin

(18,206 posts)
2. Has his name been released?
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 01:11 PM
Jan 24


Murdering people is going to become the norm, because this maladministration wants us dead.




herding cats

(19,994 posts)
5. Yup. He was exercising his 2A rights.
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 01:19 PM
Jan 24

I dearly hope the firearm enthusiasts take note of just how fucking fast those rights flew out the window here.

It appears ICE twisted his constitutional rights into a valid reason to assault and murder him.

Ol Janx Spirit

(826 posts)
67. Trump: "HE HAD A GUN, ONLY CRIMINALS CARRY GUNS ON OUR STREETS, WE NEED LAW AND ORDER."
Sun Jan 25, 2026, 01:13 AM
Jan 25

That's going to be news to the 2A MAGA-heads.

Ol Janx Spirit

(826 posts)
76. That's not actually true. And I think it has the potential to wake up some of these 2A groups...
Sun Jan 25, 2026, 11:45 AM
Jan 25

...to the fact that the current Administration is now going down a road they always decried but never believed that a Republican administration would perpetrate: shooting legally armed citizens in the street and lying about it.

https://www.axios.com/2026/01/25/gun-groups-challenge-minneapolis-shooting-pretti

I think they sat up and took notice.

I especially like the swift response from the Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus quoted in the Axios article:

The Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus demanded a "full and transparent investigation" and noted "there has been no evidence produced indicating an intent to harm the officers."

The group warned: "Every peaceable Minnesotan has the right to keep and bear arms—including while attending protests, acting as observers, or exercising their First Amendment rights. These rights do not disappear when someone is lawfully armed, and they must be respected and protected at all times."


I was always amused by the Reich-wingers that claimed they would rather live in Putin's Russia than in Biden's America.

Some of the gun laws in Russia:
Age: Minimum 21 years old for most firearms, raised from 18 in 2021.
Safety: Complete gun safety courses and pass a federal test.
Background Checks: Must pass background checks, including for drug use or mental health issues.
Storage: Must have a secure gun safe, inspected by police.
Medical: Need certificates from doctors, including a psychiatrist and ophthalmologist.
Initial Purchases: Typically limited to smooth-bore long guns and pneumatic weapons.
Rifles: After five years of shotgun ownership, rifles may be purchased.
Handguns: Allowed for sport/competition and self-defense on private property, but live-ammo handguns cannot be concealed carried in public; only traumatic (rubber bullet) handguns are permitted for public self-defense.
Prohibited Areas: Carrying is banned at mass gatherings, protests, educational/night entertainment venues, and by intoxicated individuals.

But when you need to control the population you really can't let them have guns like we do in America.

It is going to be interesting to watch the current Administration start trying to make the argument that America should not be awash in private citizens bearing arms if they truly intend to control us.


liberalla

(10,921 posts)
34. We see no gun in either hand... Camera in right hand and left hand is empty (see bluesky video below)
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:36 PM
Jan 24

Need to find out if he was right or left handed.
He may have had a gun on him, but it wasn't visible (at least while he was standing up recording)

This is so so so fucked up!

Solly Mack

(96,640 posts)
6. DHS is claiming he walked up to agents with weapon drawn. Per MS NOW.
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 01:20 PM
Jan 24

That looks like a phone to me, but my eyes could be lying to me.

ShazzieB

(22,333 posts)
64. He had a gun that he was wearing a holster at the time.
Sun Jan 25, 2026, 12:18 AM
Jan 25

He had a concealed carry permit and was exercising his second amendment rights that Repubs claim are so sacred. He never took the gun out of its holster; The ICEholes saw if when they were dragging him into the road. They shot him 3 times and then took the gun, which they have kept and have refused to let local authorities examine.

Crusty Gnome and Co have been using the gun to claim he was a "domestic terrorist" who was planning to massacre as many people as possible. Because they're despicable.


wolfie001

(7,358 posts)
25. Those fuckers at MSN censor every comment I make
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:10 PM
Jan 24

Yet every horse-with-wings comment by a racist redneck is posted. FUCK MSN!!!

SunSeeker

(57,884 posts)
32. It's a digital pocket camera. People have been using these so as not to risk their phones.
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:29 PM
Jan 24

Looks like a $30 PopSnap pocket camera by Vivitar from Target or Walmart.

I bought a cheap $30 Vivitar PopSnap pocket camera for my son for travel, and found it can record really good video, so long as you insert a 32GB or 64GB SD card in it so it has the memory to record the video(s). Very handy for recording ICE. And it is super compact, it will easily fit in a shirt pocket, under a hat, etc. I am sure there are similar cameras on Amazon as well.

That way, you don't risk your phone. My whole world is on my phone. No way would I want Trump’s Nazis taking my phone. They can have my PopSnap.

Attilatheblond

(8,514 posts)
35. Oooo, thanks for the reminder, I think I have 2 of those lil oldies but goodies around here.
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:36 PM
Jan 24

Might have to dig them outta my old tech drawer, charge 'em up and check 'em out for serviceability.

EdmondDantes_

(1,522 posts)
38. The benefit to using a phone is being able to upload to the cloud as you record
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:48 PM
Jan 24

The strict camera devices don't let you do that without connecting to another device.

Hugin

(37,610 posts)
8. Ill fitting child sized ballistic vest...
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 01:24 PM
Jan 24

I can’t quite make out what the cosplay toy says below “POLICE”. The alt-klan member would be better off without it. Any shot would bounce around in there like a golf ball in a hurricane.

yellow dahlia

(5,202 posts)
9. So it appears this guy was attacked and beaten for the crime of exercising his First Amendment rights.
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 01:27 PM
Jan 24

And perhaps he was executed for exercising his Second Amendment right to carry a gun.

JHB

(38,057 posts)
44. He was on the other side of the street from the donut shop
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 03:12 PM
Jan 24

But in a world where cameras are counted as guns, I guess you can "block" an entrance from 10 yards away.

highplainsdem

(60,791 posts)
17. I posted the video in an OP 10 minutes ago - see
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 01:37 PM
Jan 24
https://democraticunderground.com/100220965013

- but you have to click on the part of the video saying it can't appear off Bluesky to reach the Bluesky post with the video.

highplainsdem

(60,791 posts)
19. Here.- found another Bluesky post with it:
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 01:46 PM
Jan 24

Video before it happens is showing this guy they shot in the head in Minneapolis was just standing there videoing them before and they got out to push him back and then murder him.

Democratic Women of South Orange County (@dwsoc.bsky.social) 2026-01-24T17:24:14.392Z

Safe as Milk

(220 posts)
24. Do NOT assume that the victim was brandishing a weapon. ICE lies,
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:07 PM
Jan 24

just like Diddling Donny.

If there was a weapon "found" on his person, find the registration data, confirm ownership. Even so, gun ownership does NOT demand that the owner be shot and killed.

AverageOldGuy

(3,554 posts)
26. Asking my DU colleagues:
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:11 PM
Jan 24

From this moment on, when referring to the organization formerly known as "ICE," refer to them only as "Gestapo." No more "ICE." And if you wish to refer to Stephen Miller as "Hermann Göring" . . .

Not familiar with the Gestapo, here is the Wikipedia article (footnotes and references are in the Wikipedia article).


The Geheime Staatspolizei ([ɡəˈhaɪmə ˈʃtaːtspoliˌtsaɪ] ⓘ, lit. 'Secret State Police', abbreviated Gestapo [ɡəˈstaːpo] ⓘ ,[3] was the official secret police of Nazi Germany and in German-occupied Europe.

The force was created by Hermann Göring in 1933 by combining the various political police agencies of Prussia into one organisation. On 20 April 1934, oversight of the Gestapo passed to the head of the Schutzstaffel (SS), Heinrich Himmler, who was also appointed Chief of German Police by Hitler in 1936. Instead of being exclusively a Prussian state agency, the Gestapo became a national one as a sub-office of the Sicherheitspolizei (SiPo; Security Police). From 27 September 1939, it was administered by the Reich Security Main Office (RSHA). It became known as Amt (Dept) 4 of the RSHA and was considered a sister organisation to the Sicherheitsdienst (SD; Security Service).

The Gestapo committed widespread atrocities during its existence. The power of the Gestapo was used to focus upon political opponents, ideological dissenters (clergy and religious organisations), career criminals, the Sinti and Roma population, handicapped persons, homosexuals, and, above all, the Jews.[4] Those arrested by the Gestapo were often held without judicial process, and political prisoners throughout Germany—and from 1941, throughout the occupied territories under the Night and Fog Decree (German: Nacht und Nebel)—simply disappeared while in Gestapo custody.[5] Contrary to popular perception, the Gestapo was actually a relatively small organization with limited surveillance capability; still it proved extremely effective due to the willingness of ordinary Germans to report on fellow citizens. During World War II, the Gestapo played a key role in the Holocaust. After the war ended, the Gestapo was declared a criminal organisation by the International Military Tribunal (IMT) at the Nuremberg trials, and several top Gestapo members were sentenced to death.[6]

Justice matters.

(9,553 posts)
37. Exact.
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:45 PM
Jan 24

But, but, but... "Nazis, Nazis, Nazis... the "Nazi card" when they use "Nazi methods" in plain sights.

Living in Canada, Cuba, Panama, Columbia and Greenland in 2026 Feels like living in Poland in early 1939.

Living in the US Feels like living in Germany in 1933.



James48

(5,126 posts)
29. Good God!
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:17 PM
Jan 24

Bovino needs to be fired.

Noem needs to be fired.

Stephen Miller needs to get fired.

Donald Trump needs to be fired.

IronLionZion

(50,994 posts)
31. Peacefully watching and recording ICE is a death sentence
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:27 PM
Jan 24

they don't want their murders recorded. Cruelty is the point. They want to discourage protestors.

ICE-holes are the violence.

ashredux

(2,894 posts)
33. Trump and his new Gestapo were in danger because he was brandishing a phone...
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 02:32 PM
Jan 24

This is most likely what happened….They wrestled him to a ground, one of the yahoo’s yelled “gun” and then they shot him… I bet a lot of money that’s how it was.

These guys are not trained, they’re just a bunch of assholes who used to be in prison because they storm the capital

MayReasonRule

(4,047 posts)
49. I Expect It Of The Wholly Fascist Ongoing Criminal Enterprise That Is The GOP
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 04:04 PM
Jan 24

The GOP is intent upon wholesale destruction of anyone or anything that dare oppose their boundless unbridled malevolent depravity.

creeksneakers2

(7,959 posts)
52. I want to remind everyone
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 04:35 PM
Jan 24

Because some here are in such a rush to blame all Democrats for what seven of them did that they forget to blame Republicans at all.

SunSeeker

(57,884 posts)
43. Another video, apparently from the woman in the pink coat. The man was helping people, no gun in hand.
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 03:09 PM
Jan 24


When ICE pushed another protestor wearing a red backpack to the ground, he appeared to try to help her up as ICE pepper sprayed him. ICE proceeded to beat on him and then shot him. The woman filming is sobbing. Horrific.

Video is on reddit, and being played on MSNBC now:
https://www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/1qluz6q/another_angle_of_the_minneapolis_shooting_taken/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Figarosmom

(10,427 posts)
45. I'd bet they didnt even know
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 03:29 PM
Jan 24

He had a gun until they started wrestling him to the ground. They originally were assaulting him because he was recording.

CROW50

(6 posts)
53. Minnesota Gun Owners Law Center is skeptical of official narrative regarding shooting
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 05:05 PM
Jan 24

Video at link from local Minneapolis Fox news affiliate features a representative of the Minnesota Gun Owners Law Center giving his response to today’s shooting. He’s being very measured with his responses, but there is no doubt he is skeptical of the narrative the Feds are pushing. Their mission statement notes that they are

“dedicated to challenging unlawlful restrictions and advancing the right to keep and bear arms”.

So, some of the Minnesota gun advocates are seeing through the BS being pushed by Fed leadership, which is good.

https://www.fox9.com/video/fmc-dg3fsrhu1zp2q7ab

barbtries

(31,215 posts)
54. there are at least 2 videos circulating
Sat Jan 24, 2026, 05:59 PM
Jan 24

that prove conclusively that Alex Pretti was disarmed, never drew, he was tear gassed and swarmed by multiple "agents" one of whom shot him, I would say at least 5 times.

what they're saying is pure propaganda and they're banking on the cult who won't look anywhere else to get information to believe it. NONE of what they say is true or offered in good faith. Pure, predictable, propaganda.

Can't wait to hear how Leavitt with pain this one.

emmett (@emmettroserose.bsky.social) 2026-01-24T16:11:27.685Z


i'm sure it will be we just made y'all safer by getting rid of a domestic terrorist. in other news, krasnov took another cognitive and he's the most cognitive human being alive. Everything is great. Great. Great.
Accuse her of lying and she'll act butt hurt but inside thinking you can't stop me haha

Democratic Barbara (@barbtries.bsky.social) 2026-01-24T16:18:28.732Z

Blue Full Moon

(3,289 posts)
65. Seems like the agent who took Pretti's gun
Sun Jan 25, 2026, 12:23 AM
Jan 25

Discharged it and the others murdered Pretti. This murder and the murder of Good and all the crime perpetrated by ICE was to extort voter data.

Ellipsis

(9,445 posts)
77. There is a white vehicle where someone gets in and closes the door.
Sun Jan 25, 2026, 12:10 PM
Jan 25

He was attempting to stop traffic so she could leave. That's why he was in the street.

If the grey vehicle had stopped this never would have happened.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The photo seems to dispro...