Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:21 AM 6 hrs ago

"Melania' is car rides and cold silences

By Amy Nicholson | The Los Angeles Times
PUBLISHED: February 8, 2026 at 5:48 AM CST

LOS ANGELES — I’m hesitant to call “Melania” propaganda because I can’t imagine anyone watching this movie and thinking that Melania Trump comes off well. If this vapid, airless, mindless time-waster had subversive designs of being a satire about the first lady of the United States, there’s not much it would have changed. Yet somehow, “Melania” is exactly the film that the first lady wanted to make — her company was paid $40 million for the rights to this self-greenlit production — and no one around her warned that it was a very expensive bad idea.

“Melania” didn’t screen for critics and, of the dozen people in my AMC theater on opening day last Friday, half of us were journalists paying to play catch-up. Introducing “Melania” at its Kennedy Center premiere the night before, the lead herself insisted that it is not a documentary but a “very deliberate act of authorship inviting you to witness events and emotions through a window of rich imagery.” Mostly, it’s B-roll of Melania stepping in and out of SUVs. My best guess is her pay rate is a million dollars an hour.

The president is effusive the first time that he greets his wife on an airplane tarmac alongside the film crew. “A movie star!” Trump says with a grin. He has a couple reasons to sound happy. For one, he’s getting to actually make public eye contact with his wife. As a bonus, she even offers up her cheek for a peck, which is as affectionate as things get between them.

With the same queenly beneficence she grants her husband, Melania has allowed the long-out-of-work director Brett Ratner (this is his first film since six women accused him of sexual assault in 2017) access to film her in tightly constrained snippets until the day after her return to the White House. It is 2025 and Trump will be sworn back into office as the 47th president of the U.S. in 20 days — or is it 13? One attempts to measure the passage of time in her outfit changes — a white jacket, shiny black leggings, a tight leather pencil skirt — although the exact numbers blur when Melania attempts to count them ...

https://www.twincities.com/2026/02/08/review-made-of-car-rides-and-cold-silences-melania-is-so-polished-it-slips-out-of-the-first-ladys-hands/

9 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
"Melania' is car rides and cold silences (Original Post) struggle4progress 6 hrs ago OP
Not a single person in the theater struggle4progress 6 hrs ago #1
8% from Critics while Rotten Tomatoes Claims 99% from Audience struggle4progress 6 hrs ago #2
So, so, so bad struggle4progress 6 hrs ago #3
They deserve each other SO much. Maru Kitteh 5 hrs ago #7
Michelle sees 13,000% viewing spike as Melania debuts struggle4progress 6 hrs ago #4
Nothing To See Here struggle4progress 6 hrs ago #5
Horror Film Poised to Outshine Melania struggle4progress 6 hrs ago #6
Multi-million dollar infomercial struggle4progress 5 hrs ago #8
Giving bribery a bad name struggle4progress 5 hrs ago #9

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
1. Not a single person in the theater
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:23 AM
6 hrs ago

David McAfee
February 7, 2026 8:08PM ET

... "Friends, I wandered into a ‘Melania’ screening in Culver tonight after seeing ‘The Secret Agent.’ Not single person in the theater. Watched 10 minutes. I found myself with tears streaming down my face," she wrote on X. But those weren't tears from a moving documentary, she noted.

"Watching Trump take the oath to defend the Constitution, as he tears it down. The dissonance of Melania saying her husband would be a 'unifier,' and all the pomp and circumstance for someone so venal," she wrote on X. "So beneath the great office - and wishing we could turn the clock back" ...

https://www.rawstory.com/melania-2675108961/#

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
2. 8% from Critics while Rotten Tomatoes Claims 99% from Audience
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:27 AM
6 hrs ago

By Paloma Chavez
Published on February 6, 2026 04:52PM EST

Melania, which hit theaters on Jan. 30, has a staggering 8% approval rating among critics on Rotten Tomatoes as of Friday afternoon, up slightly from its previous 6% rating.

The general audience seemed to have enjoyed the documentary more, with 99% of verified Rotten Tomatoes users rating the film positively. (The number plummets to 29% approval when you incorporate unverified ratings.)

The divide marks the movie review site’s biggest critic versus audience split in history, a spokesperson for Rotten Tomatoes tells PEOPLE ...

https://people.com/melania-documentary-rotten-tomatoes-rating-11901508

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
3. So, so, so bad
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:34 AM
6 hrs ago

By Drew Magary,
Feb 6, 2026

... I’d just seen “Melania” the day before this. For work, mind you. I’d never actually go see this film of my own accord, although a handful of our most gullible Americans did just that over the weekend. The first lady’s self-produced “documentary” made $7 million at the box office over that period, defeating initial expectations that it would gross $0 million. Like Jimmy Kimmel, I’m not convinced that everyone who bought a ticket to “Melania” actually bothered to attend “Melania.” But honestly, you and I have bigger lies to debunk right now. The only important thing here is that “Melania” exists, even if barely so. It’s the least essential movie I’ve ever seen. That it exists at all is a damning indictment of all the backroom deals that went into its production and of all the people involved in those deals, the first lady included ...

... “Melania” isn’t really a movie, and it certainly doesn’t qualify as a documentary. It has no journalistic value and even less entertainment value. It reveals nothing about its subject, and makes no effort to. To watch “Melania” is to watch Mrs. Trump glide through a meticulously curated existence, with designers and chefs and aides welcoming the first lady with smiles every time she walks into a room. Unless you count the stagehands who wave to Mrs. Trump as she walks through an arena concourse, you will not see her interact with actual Americans. And instead of seeing the first lady volunteer in times of crisis (during the LA wildfires, for instance), you’ll see her solemnly watch those events unfold on TV. You’ll get to watch her attend memorial services for fallen servicemembers, and you’ll hear her voiceover — read with about as much conviction as a fifth grader delivering an oral book report — tell you that their deaths make her sad. None of it will move you ...

... see Melania meet and greet with other members of this cloistered ruling class: her husband, her 9-foot-tall son Barron, her loser stepkids, vice president JD Vance, Tesla Nazi Elon Musk, Apple CEO Tim Cook and, hold your surprise, Jeff Bezos. All of these members of the Trump circle are busy living the high life, and none of them have time for the problems of the little people, even if they happen to be the root cause of those problems ...

“Everyone wants to know,” Melania tells the audience at the beginning of the movie, “so here it is.” No, ma’am. No one wanted to know about this. YOU GUYS WERE ALREADY INAUGURATED. And I didn’t watch that ceremony either, because I don’t like having to vomit. So what am I dying to know about a f—king rerun of this thing? How you picked your dress? The fact that you were the first person to get a look at the invites for the ball? That every dinner guest got an amuse-bouche featuring a gold leaf-coated egg topped with a generous dollop of caviar? That you and your husband interact with each other like he’s your grandpa? That you sound like Derek Zoolander if Derek Zoolander was a real person? No. No, I don’t want any of that garbage. I would have preferred you make something USEFUL out of the suffering that you and your friends have caused, instead of spending $75 million on the celluloid equivalent of a 108-minute ad for a perfume sold at Macy’s ...

https://www.sfgate.com/sf-culture/article/melania-film-review-21338044.php

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
4. Michelle sees 13,000% viewing spike as Melania debuts
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:37 AM
6 hrs ago

By Glory Moralidad
Published 06 February 2026, 4:11 PM GMT

... The release of Amazon's 'Melania' sent Netflix viewership for Michelle Obama's 'Becoming' through the roof at 13,000%, sending the former first lady's documentary back into the Top 10.

Over the weekend of 30th of January and 1st of February, 'Becoming' experienced a dramatic increase from 354,000 minutes watched to 47.5 million - a 13,000% increase.

The jump was sufficient to send the film back to Netflix's 'Top 10' charts ...

https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/michelle-obama-sees-13000-viewing-spike-melania-debuts-poor-reviews-soft-sales-1776931

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
5. Nothing To See Here
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:40 AM
6 hrs ago

Ken Jones, OnScreen Blog Chief Film Critic

I’ll be honest, I was never ever planning to see Melania, the $75 million '‘documentary” that was produced by Amazon Studios and seemingly doubled as a gift to the Trump grift syndicate in return for (I’m guessing) not having the screws put to Jeff Bezos’ finances and curry favor for the next four years.

However, my editors thought it would be useful and entertaining for someone very much anti-MAGA to review this piece of propaganda, if for no other reason than to answer a few questions:

Could non-MAGA audiences at least watch this to make fun of it in an MST3K-style way?

Is there anything of substance in this vanity project?

What is my actual threshold for self-flagellation and loathing? ...

https://www.onstageblog.com/onscreenblog/2026/2/1/melania-review-nothing-to-see-here

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
6. Horror Film Poised to Outshine Melania
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:45 AM
6 hrs ago

Morgan Winslow
Published: February 6, 2026 5:54 AM ET

... *Send Help* debuted alongside Melania, a film directed by Brett Ratner that is expected to disappoint at the box office. In *Send Help*, Linda, an awkward employee in the strategy and planning department, faces challenges when her work credit is usurped by her colleague ...

https://www.filmogaz.com/136360

So if you really like horror films, "Send Help" is bettefr than "Melania"

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
8. Multi-million dollar infomercial
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:52 AM
5 hrs ago

February 6, 20263:00 AM ET

...So what word would each of you use to describe the Melania documentary as a whole?

ALISON WILLMORE: I would say airless ...

WILLMORE: It is an incredibly manicured production that gives you very little that looks like an authentic beat of people, like, not being intensely aware that the cameras are there and what they're there for ...

WILLMORE: ... she does not appear on camera at all, like, without the full face of makeup and the hair. So she is sitting on this sofa watching the news, and it's very clearly arranged. But also, at a certain point, Brett Ratner's camera, like, zooms in very close to her eyes. And it's like he's trying really hard to find emotion there, you know, while she says some kind of platitudes about all the destruction, to be horrified at the loss with no emotion, you know, in the voiceover. And I feel like that best embodies the airlessness of this movie to me, which is that you have this scene of, like, real destruction that was unfolding at the time ...
'
https://www.npr.org/transcripts/nx-s1-5703364

struggle4progress

(125,697 posts)
9. Giving bribery a bad name
Mon Feb 9, 2026, 12:55 AM
5 hrs ago

By Don Morton
February 6, 2026

~snip~

“Even if you watch this on an airliner, you may walk out.”

“Outtakes from an innocuous reality show.”

“Trance-inducing screen saver.”

“Might go watch Melania at a theater so I can spend some time alone.”

~snip~

https://metropolisjapan.com/movies/melania/

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»"Melania' is car rides an...