Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 01:03 PM Thursday

So I watched the entire CA Dem Governor debate last night

Here's my takeaway: The R candidates are cartoon characters, although the British one was more likeable than the sheriff guy. More importantly, all of the Dem candidates were qualified, serious, and able to lead the largest state in the union. I would vote for any of them without hesitation.

Matt Mahon: I went into the debate with more knowledge about him than some of the others, since I live in Silicon Valley and he is the mayor of the largest city in SV. He played that up, was relaxed and camera ready, and said he would stand up to "big tech" when he was called on it. However, his efforts to "both sides" issues was not appealing to me. He did seem knowledgeable about addressing homelessness and had a record of addressing it in San Jose.

Xavier Becerra: He was calm, knowledgeable, and low key, as one would expect. But he was not afraid to speak his mind and play up his experience. One of my favorite parts was when he was challenged about the California Highway Patrol stopping truck drivers and giving them "English proficiency" tests. He spoke to that in a way tha I think will appeal to our huge Hispanic population here as well as other Democratic voters. He also spoke about his own impressive biography (something I wish he would do more) and how he was the first in his family to graduate from college.

Tom Steyer: He seemed to be presenting himself as the front runner. I'm not saying he was cocky, but he did not waste time attacking other candidates. He defended himself and his billionaire status, saying he would be glad to pay more taxes and he and his wife had agreed to give away all their money in their lifetimes. His demeanor was energetic and passionate about progressive causes, including ending homelessness and taxation.

Katie Porter: Put on the defensive at the beginning about her treatment of an aide that went viral, she apologized and tried to put it behind her. After that, she played up her "professor" persona and made many good points. I was reminded of why she was so good in congressional hearings. Teaching experience definitely translates to good communication skills.

Bottom line I am still supporting Becerra. However, I will vote for the Dem candidate no matter who it is. And so will the candidates. They were asked to pledge to support the eventual candidtate of their party and all the Dems agreed to do so.

41 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
So I watched the entire CA Dem Governor debate last night (Original Post) senseandsensibility Thursday OP
Mahan is not a Democrat obamanut2012 Thursday #1
I don't really know how to respond to that since you didn't provide senseandsensibility Thursday #2
He's running as a Dem, but is a spoiler for the elites FoggyLake Thursday #8
You don't ahve to respond, it's fine -- we can agree to disagree obamanut2012 Thursday #9
Anyone talk about non profit healthcare? ICE? leftstreet Thursday #3
It was, unfortunately, a very controlled debate with strict time limits senseandsensibility Thursday #4
Oh, wow. 30 seconds! leftstreet Thursday #5
You know I hope I got that right senseandsensibility Thursday #6
Well, there are 61 candidates on the ballot Retrograde Thursday #14
Totally agree Lifeafter70 Thursday #19
My Granny did the Depression in South Dakota... BurnDoubt Yesterday #35
I think Porter's a bit out of her depth... OhioBack2Blue Yesterday #36
To me it's about who can manage a large state bucolic_frolic Thursday #7
Good luck CA. Icanthinkformyself Thursday #10
Snark appreciated senseandsensibility Thursday #12
You could start by doing some research on Steyer before commenting. Sibelius Fan Thursday #20
Yes he deserves a lot of credit for Prop 50 senseandsensibility Thursday #22
Youtube link for the full debate ... aggiesal Thursday #11
Yes, I watched it live on our local KRON station. senseandsensibility Thursday #13
I watched the entire debate as well... ultralite001 Thursday #15
Such is the nature of competition senseandsensibility Thursday #17
Thanks for watching Lifeafter70 Thursday #16
Hope your son is okay! senseandsensibility Thursday #18
He is in Hospice Lifeafter70 Thursday #28
Well, that certainly puts things in perspective. senseandsensibility Thursday #29
Promises to support the eventual Democratic candidate ring hollow Bobstandard Thursday #21
I guess I have a little more patience senseandsensibility Thursday #23
I have a sense of impending doom Bobstandard Thursday #24
More people are waking up senseandsensibility Thursday #26
Thanks. 🙏 Bobstandard Thursday #32
Thanks senseandsensibility for this post, I didn't watch the debate and appreciate your summary. ShazamIam Thursday #25
Steyer, Becerra, Porter............. Lovie777 Thursday #27
Best case scenario relayerbob Thursday #30
That would be a hoot! senseandsensibility Thursday #31
I support Becerra too..... State the Obvious Thursday #33
I have liked Becerra ever since I first heard of him! n/t oldsoldierfadingfast Thursday #34
Becerra or Steyer would be fine Sympthsical Yesterday #37
No such thing as a good billionaire. AllyCat Yesterday #38
Thanks for the summary DFW 21 hrs ago #39
Interesting senseandsensibility 20 hrs ago #40
I'm less excited with Becerra, had higher expectations in rexponses. msfiddlestix 18 hrs ago #41

obamanut2012

(29,447 posts)
1. Mahan is not a Democrat
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 02:02 PM
Thursday

He is a literal Trojan Horse candidate funded by SV tech bros. For real. This isn't me bashing Dems, it's a known fact here. He is a spoiler.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
2. I don't really know how to respond to that since you didn't provide
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 02:13 PM
Thursday

any source for your assertion. However, Mahon ran for mayor as a D, is running for Governor as a D, and recently told a a local newspaper that he is a lifelong Dem. He is not progressive enough for me, but I think he is still a Dem.

FoggyLake

(315 posts)
8. He's running as a Dem, but is a spoiler for the elites
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:00 PM
Thursday

$12 million donations from Silicon Valley billionaires. He is currently polling at around 5%, which smells like spoiler to me. Republicans will do anything to game the jungle primary. But I guess if he says he's a Dem, then he must be because politicians never lie.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
4. It was, unfortunately, a very controlled debate with strict time limits
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 02:20 PM
Thursday

All of the candidates were cut off after 30 seconds and they had to answer the questions presented and stay on topic. I do think that most of them referred disparagingly to Trump's immigration policies and healthcare in general but I wish more questions had been asked on those topics.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
6. You know I hope I got that right
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 02:31 PM
Thursday

I'm going by memory since I didn't take notes or anything during the debate. I thought that's what they said, but I can confirm that it was a very short time period and the questions were very concise, so if candidates were not asked specifically about something it was hard to work it in.

Retrograde

(11,434 posts)
14. Well, there are 61 candidates on the ballot
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:18 PM
Thursday

Got my sample ballot yesterday - not the longest list I've seen, but substantial. I assume the debate just picked the top pollers (LivingForGodAndCountry DeMott probably doesn't stand a chance). I'm leaning towards Becerra: several terms in Congress, California Attorney General (he was Kamala Harris's replacement), and Secretary of Heath and Human Services under Biden - a long and diversified history. I got, tired of Steyer's incessant ads months ago. I think Porter's a bit out of her depth, and Mahan needs to finish his first term as mayor of San Jose (and do more than show up on the local news on a regular basis). And the Republican candidates are right out: my grandfather told me to never vote for a Republican and I still heed his advice.

Lifeafter70

(1,157 posts)
19. Totally agree
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:41 PM
Thursday

I only looked into the top three. Steyer has some creds but really disliked his campaign style.
Bercerra adds are just now showing up.
I'm in the Reno area right now caring for my son so don't get too many of their tv campaign adds. I have been looking into their public service and Bercerra comes out on top for me.
I get home one week out of the month and really disliked the Steyer's TV adds.

BurnDoubt

(1,829 posts)
35. My Granny did the Depression in South Dakota...
Fri Apr 24, 2026, 02:01 AM
Yesterday

and she told me she would NEVER vote for a Republican. She never missed an Election in her ninety years. I’m following in her footsteps and I always think of her when I vote. I’m so glad she didn’t have to watch our descent into madness.

OhioBack2Blue

(159 posts)
36. I think Porter's a bit out of her depth...
Fri Apr 24, 2026, 02:51 AM
Yesterday

Really dude? You couldn't come up with something more specifically performance based...just sexism/ misogyny. (I stand by my comment even if you are afab or trans female).

bucolic_frolic

(55,491 posts)
7. To me it's about who can manage a large state
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 02:57 PM
Thursday

What on their resume indicates such experience or ability.

Icanthinkformyself

(408 posts)
10. Good luck CA.
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:09 PM
Thursday

Choose wisely. If Steyer is serious about what he and his wife will do with their wealth they could start by funding non-profit progressive media. I am aware that he supports the CA billionaire tax proposal. What number would he and his billionaire friends be comfy with? We don't want to over stress them and force them to make empty threats. like leaving.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
12. Snark appreciated
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:11 PM
Thursday

And I mean that sincerely. Billionaires can take it. I will say that he made a fairly good impression on me. He seemed sincere and enthusiastic about progressive causes. I'm not supporting him, but I would definitely vote for him if he was the nominee.

Sibelius Fan

(24,848 posts)
20. You could start by doing some research on Steyer before commenting.
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:48 PM
Thursday

Funding progressive issues? Steyer was the main funder that got Prop 50 on the ballot and passed. He spent $87-million in one election funding D candidates who were not him. He has a long history of writing the check for progressive issues. I understand he was one of Obama’s primary funders.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
22. Yes he deserves a lot of credit for Prop 50
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 04:35 PM
Thursday

I usually remember to say that when I write about him so thanks for the reminder. Didn't know about funding Obama. I think he's been pretty solidly and demonstrably progressive for the past couple of decades at least. He's not some fly by night Dem who just swooped in for the Governor's race.

aggiesal

(10,867 posts)
11. Youtube link for the full debate ...
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:10 PM
Thursday

Unfortunately it's from NewsNation, which is a RQ rag
There is a KTLA broadcast, but they are using the NewsNation feed.

https://www.youtube.com/live/Xd8xdLbbADw?si=n8QLijzVDu1FVg7o

ultralite001

(2,601 posts)
15. I watched the entire debate as well...
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:20 PM
Thursday

Becerra comported himself well.

The biggest take away I had of the entire evening -- what a collection of interesting ideas + energies...
If these individuals could set aside their political personas + combine forces in a coalition / collaboration
focused on California's many problems... they could drive solutions that benefit all Californians + create a
robust model that could be game-changing for the rest of the nation.

There was a time when Americans worked together to solve problems... That focus needs to be resurrected
now... These folks could provide solutions our nation is craving -- much like Mandami is doing for New Yorkers...

At least this debate left me hopeful rather than depressed + shaking my head...

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
17. Such is the nature of competition
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:28 PM
Thursday

and probably the biggest reason I could never be a politician. They have no choice but to try to stand out. In this case, the stakes are extremely high. Whoever wins the D nomination is basically the next Governor. As Carville used to say, "politics ain't beanbag". At this point, we can only hope that they will come together and help each other once there's a nominee.

Lifeafter70

(1,157 posts)
16. Thanks for watching
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 03:27 PM
Thursday

Unfortunately I'm out of state caring for my son so was unable to do so.
I have been researching all but Mahon, and have the same take away as you.
I find Becerra to be the most qualified but will support whatever dem goes on ro the general.

Lifeafter70

(1,157 posts)
28. He is in Hospice
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 06:49 PM
Thursday

My grandso and I take turns caring for him.
We have good days and bad days but are grateful for whatever time we have with him.
His cancer (acc) is slow growing, he has been battling it since 2016.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
29. Well, that certainly puts things in perspective.
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 06:53 PM
Thursday

I am so sorry. You are really doing the work of angels.

Bobstandard

(2,339 posts)
21. Promises to support the eventual Democratic candidate ring hollow
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 04:31 PM
Thursday

By refusing to drop out of the race, lower polling candidates make it more likely that no Democrat will emerge from the primary. A two Republican general is frighteningly possible.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
23. I guess I have a little more patience
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 05:40 PM
Thursday

It seems to be down to three (I don't count Mahon in my calculation) finalists: Steyer, Becerra, and Porter. That's a lot more clarity than we had a few days ago. These are three strong candidates and I am willing to give them and the voters a little more time to sort it out.

Bobstandard

(2,339 posts)
24. I have a sense of impending doom
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 06:15 PM
Thursday

I used to be an inveterate optimist but recent events have disabused me of that.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
26. More people are waking up
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 06:36 PM
Thursday

That's reflected in the polls, so it's not just my wishful thinking. Even the media seems to be more skeptical in their coverage than they were a few months ago. I did feel like you did then, but I am gradually becoming more positive. I hope you are able to feel some of that as things evolve.

Lovie777

(23,299 posts)
27. Steyer, Becerra, Porter.............
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 06:41 PM
Thursday

the 3 to watch.

Who ever the top person is, California Dems will support.

relayerbob

(7,444 posts)
30. Best case scenario
Thu Apr 23, 2026, 07:31 PM
Thursday

Last edited Fri Apr 24, 2026, 01:46 PM - Edit history (1)

Both candidates end up Dems. I prefer Beccera, but a race between him and Steyer would be good.

Sympthsical

(11,044 posts)
37. Becerra or Steyer would be fine
Fri Apr 24, 2026, 05:16 AM
Yesterday

I'm still a little fence-sitting on it, but I think I'm going to go with Steyer. I just don't get the feeling Becerra will shake up Sacramento to any real, tangible degree. We need someone who will break the ball-grip lobbyists have in this state, and maybe he'll do it. Maybe not.

Becerra would be competent, though. So if it is him, that's fine. Just fine. Not amazing. But fine. It would just feel a little . . . stagnant, for lack of a better word. But the idea of a billionaire just waltzing in and throwing money down doesn't sit great with me, which is why I'm very, "Ehhhhh . . . ." about deciding.

Just going to hang on to my ballot until late May and see where we are with polling and things. Still plenty of time.

DFW

(60,332 posts)
39. Thanks for the summary
Fri Apr 24, 2026, 01:04 PM
21 hrs ago

I am not well versed in CA local politics, but I am in the USA for a few more days, and have talked with some colleagues from California, all of whom support Becerra--not what I would have guessed as an ignorant outsider.

senseandsensibility

(25,260 posts)
40. Interesting
Fri Apr 24, 2026, 02:08 PM
20 hrs ago

I am glad to hear that your colleagues support Becerra. I think his main problem is not enough exposure. I hope he rectifies that soon.

msfiddlestix

(8,181 posts)
41. I'm less excited with Becerra, had higher expectations in rexponses.
Fri Apr 24, 2026, 03:24 PM
18 hrs ago

I'm certainly not looking for perfection, but expect someone with his experience and background to be able to sharply articulate brief answers which actually answers directly. Instead, he seemed to think saying "I'm experienced" sufficed. If my instincts are on the mark Becerra is the party leaders favorite all the money and support will go to him. In which case he's got work ahead in this regard. A d step outside the bubble wouldn't hurt.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»So I watched the entire C...