The Real Tragedy: Ecological ruin stems from what happens to--not what is caused by--the commons
from OnTheCommons.org:
The Real Tragedy
Ecological ruin stems from what happens to--not what is caused by--the commons
By Jonathan Rowe
This is the from the new book Our Common Wealth: The Hidden Economy That Makes Everything Else Work, a collection of writings from Jonathan Rowe (1946-2011). Rowe was a co-founder of On the Commons and a co-editor of On the Commons.org.
In the belief system called economics, it is an article of faith that commons are inherently tragic. Almost by definition, they are tragic because they are prone to overuse. What belongs to all belongs to none, and only private or state ownership can rescue a commons from the sad fate that will otherwise befall it.
The standard reference for this belief is an article that appeared in Science in 1968 called The Tragedy of the Commons. Though the author, Garrett Hardin, was a biologist, his article was strangely lacking in scientific inquiry. It was more like economicsan extrapolation from assumptions rather than an investigation of reality.
Hardin assumed that all commons are free-for-alls. He bid his readers to picture a hypothetical pasture peopled with hypothetical herders. These herders existed outside of any social structure and lacked even a capacity to talk with one another. They all behaved according to what the economics texts call rationality: they let their herds loose in the pasture in a single-minded effort to maximize their own gain, with no thought for the future or for anybody else. Under those assumptions, tragedy is a foregone conclusion.
What Hardin overlooked is that people do not necessarily behave as economists assume they do. As historian E. P. Thompson observed, Hardin failed to grasp that commoners themselves were not without common sense. Thompson was referring specifically to the common-field agriculture of his own England. Households had their own plots but shared land for hunting, foraging, and grazing. They pooled their implements and labor for joint maintenance and combined their herds to fertilize their respective plots. The destruction Hardin declared to be inevitable simply did not happen. To the contrary, the system worked well for hundreds of years. ....................(more)
The complete piece is at:
http://onthecommons.org/magazine/real-tragedy