"The Four Percent Solution" by Paul Krugman at the NY Times
The Four Percent Solution
by Paul Krugman at the NY Times
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/24/the-four-percent-solution/
"SNIP......................
Larry Ball makes the case that we would be a lot better off with a 4 percent inflation target rather than the 2 percent that is now central bank orthodoxy. Intellectually, this position is hardly outlandish; indeed, Balls case is very similar to the case Olivier Blanchard made three years ago, just stated more forcefully and with more evidence.
The basic point is that a higher baseline for inflation would make liquidity traps, in which conventional monetary policy is up against the zero lower bound, less likely and less costly when they happen. Ball estimates that if we had come into this crisis with an underlying inflation rate of 4 percent, average unemployment over the past three years would have been two percentage points lower. Thats huge it amounts to millions of jobs and trillions of dollars of extra output.
There are two main arguments against a higher inflation target. One is that events like the current crisis almost never happen. My view would be that the costs of this crisis are so large and the difficulties weve had in responding so grotesque that even if they were once-in-75-year events, that should be enough to warrant different policies. But Ball also argues that the risk of liquidity-trap events is much greater than conventional wisdom would have you believe. Just looking at US experience, the last three recessions were all postmodern recessions caused by private-sector overreach, not Fed tightening and in each case the Fed had a very hard time getting traction. Both 1990-91 and 2001 were near misses in terms of the liquidity trap; 2007 onwards was actually in line with what had become the normal pattern, not a bizarre exception.
By the way, one point Ball doesnt mention is that to the extent that we consider Japans issues partly demographic, thats becoming the norm too: low fertility and, perhaps, low resulting investment returns are also becoming standard among advanced countries. Again, this calls for a higher inflation target.
......................SNIP"