General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe little Spanish Bushbot Ambassador who offered Pres. Morales *coffee* as he violated his rights
Last edited Mon Jul 8, 2013, 09:37 AM - Edit history (1)
For God's sake, find your fucking ignore and trash thread buttons if you're so sick of my posts about how we fucked up. It's funny how those who complain the loudest can't find the tools to make DU just the little bubble they need. Use a MAP if you can't find your ignore and trash thread buttons.Meet Alberto Carnero Fernández, the coffee boy

BushAznar memo
The memo provided insight into the run-up to the 2003 invasion of Iraq. It revealed that Saddam Hussein had offered to step down and leave Iraq if he were allowed to keep $1 billion. Some have suggested that this indicates that the war was avoidable. According to the account in El País, the memo also gives details on how Bush tried to coerce members of the United Nations Security Council into supporting US policy: he tells Aznar how he can cut Angola's foreign aid from the Millennium Challenge Account and how he can torpedo the free trade agreement with Chile (awaiting ratification in the United States Senate at the time) if the two countries did not back US policy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush%E2%80%93Aznar_memo
(Video in Spanish, no subtitles, the quote below is at minute 5:15 where President Morales states what happened after we were told "we could not enter French territory, we were very surprised and decided to make an emergency landing in Vienna Austria"
On July 4, President Evo Morales related how Ambassador Alberto Carnero tried to commandeer his plane to check whether the former U.S. agent Edward Snowden was on the flight.
When Morales's plane landed on Austrian soil emergency, "suddenly appears the Spanish Ambassador to Vienna, Austria (Alberto Carnero) with two individuals from the Embassy of Spain. The first (the ambassador) tells me that we need to check the presidential airplane. I replied: 'Why do you need to check?'. (He answers me) "I've been in constant contact with the vice Vice-Chancellor of Spain". I replied that 'I do not know this gentlemen, I heard on the news reports that he is American agent'.
I told him that 'we are very respectful of international conventions, international agreements. Therefore I am not transporting anyone to Bolivia' I replied to his insinuations that I was transporting Snowden. Then, when I said that, he replied "I will go ask my Vice-Chancellor". He gets up, and leaves his little office where we were at the airport in Vienna, Austria. He returned and said, "No, we have an agreement among "Foreign Ministers to check your airplane". I told him that 'his chancellor had never informed me of this'. I said: 'You can NOT check. If you do not believe me, you are telling me that President Evo is a liar'. I said that '(our) presidents do not lie, and you know, brothers and sisters, that our ancestors cosmic law is now constitutionalized: Ama Sua (do not steal), Ama Llulla (do not lie) and Ama Quella (do not be idle), I not going to lie to anyone.'
(Minute 7:45) The ambassador comes back from asking his Vice Chancellor, and repeats, "you have to invite us into your plane to have a cup of coffee, to have a little coffee so we can check". I said, 'You're treating me like a criminal, only criminals can be checked, and I'm no criminal. And you are not going to inspect the Presidential airplane'. I mean, brothers and sisters, in this time, for them to control us, for them to check our plane ... I could not understand the colonialist mentality'. 'We had no defense (resistance) whatsoever, it was just me and the pilots. If you want to check, you can do so but only by force, we can offer no resistance. It's clear, how could we resist a military or police operation, but the only way to do so is to do it by force. He got scared and did not dare to check by force and then told me he's going to call his Vice-Chancellor again. He came back and said "Would you speak with my Vice-Chancellor?". I said 'no I have nothing to discuss with the Vice-Chancellor. If you want, call your president (Mariano Rajoy) and not his Vice-Chancellor'. And then finally he tells me, after speaking with (his Vice-Chancellor) another time, he tells me at 9 in the morning, " I can't tell you yet if you can leave or not, because we need talk to our friends." Who are these friends of Spain? Well, they have the right to speak their friends but I asked 'who are these friends? Portugal? France? Italy?' He did not say anything. I wonder who these *friends* are. Then, at 9 and 30, or 10 in the morning, he returned and said to me, a little worried, scared and nervous 'You are free to go" and stopped insisting to check (the plane).
"If I had accepted the inspection, we would have been out of there in an hour or two after landing, but we would not give pleasure to Spain, even more so to the the United States, to inspect our plane so we could leave quickly. We have dignity, sovereignty and we are proud of our country, of the Patria Grande and we will never submit to these forms of blackmail sisters and brothers.
He then goes on to how President Rafael Correa told the US to take its preferential trade deal and stuff it (cheers). and how Latin America is on the rise while the US is on the decline. They don't need this he says. Then he mentions how the US had the nerve to deliver an extradition request for Edward Snowden after he landed in Bolivia. It's all to intimidate. "Our real sin is to have an indigenous President, and to be anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist. That's our sin sisters and brothers. They can't accept that we can govern better than the neoliberals. They can't understand that. What I understood is that they used their agents to intimidate us, to shut us up, to badger, to chastise Latin America and the Caribbean . They do not want this liberation of the people led by anti-capitalist presidents, governments, parties"
I can't go on lol. You get the idea. Besides, I just wanted to point out Alberto Carnero, then I got into the whole speech because it's the first time I listened to it but it took over an hour just to translate/transcribe less than half of his speech.
If our media was worth anything at all, that speech should already have been translated and published so we can understand what's going on in the world, and how the world reacts to our actions. Instead we get a vapid bubble.
I thought you might like to hear a few more details of what happened that night. It's the same global 1% running things. This also explains why they dragged Bush and the Lord of Bats himself, Dick Darth Vader Cheney, out to defend this illegal surveillance.
HooptieWagon
(17,064 posts)cyclezealot
(4,802 posts)Bush's Buddy now sits on the board of News Corporation. He had wanted a slot at the World Bank , but Bush gave that to old pal , Paul Wolfowitz.. We know how that went.. So , Rupert Murdock had to give the X Spanish PM something in exchange for Wolfowitz slot at the World Bank..
backscatter712
(26,357 posts)dawg
(10,777 posts)I would hazard that almost none of us think President Obama is as bad as Bush, but we elected him to be the opposite of Bush, not the kinder, gentler version who tries to come us with vaguely plausible legal cover.
magellan
(13,257 posts)The Ambassador was low on caffeine!
Seriously -- the fuel gauge/level excuse would only be plausible if the Austrians had come right out and said that was why Morales's plane had landed in Vienna. All the reporters would have gone home. Non-story. But that isn't what happened.
struggle4progress
(126,150 posts)Rubén Saavedra Soto: Nadie requisó el avión FAB 001
07 de Julio de 2013
http://www.eldeber.com.bo/ruben-saavedra-soto-nadie-requiso-el-avion-fab-001/130706215201
... How was permission to land in Vienna requested?
We asked for an emergency landing as a precaution against lack of fuel ...
JAbuchan08
(3,046 posts)against running out of fuel? I suppose you could stretch that into a fuel gauge problem, as in "the fuel gauge is showing that we will have less than we need" and that sort of thing will happen if you are denied the ability to land at your original refueling stop.
cali
(114,904 posts)and good morning to you. can't offer you coffee, alas.
Catherina
(35,568 posts)Can you believe their nerve?
This story, that part of it, has offended me from day one. Reporters stated that little jerk never made it past the front door of the plane which confirms what Morales is saying here about the condescending, let's have a cup of coffee, master to servant attitude.
Thanks my dear conscientious and humanity-loving Cali
magellan
(13,257 posts)Catherina
(35,568 posts)It takes a long time to transcribe/translate these but as Edward Snowden put it,
"This country is worth dying for"
I have so many other more selfish things to do with my time, such as getting my fading eyes checked, or taking my lovely dogs out for walks, or dying my graying hair but this, THIS, is TOO important.
Thank you for appreciating and being part of our collective efforts.
Mojorabbit
(16,020 posts)Tanuki
(16,447 posts)posting on an internet forum to "dying for your country"....did you?
truebluegreen
(9,033 posts)I hope this "incident" casts a long shadow on relations with Latin America and the rest of the world. Our rogue status needs to be addressed.
treestar
(82,383 posts)ForeignandDomestic
(190 posts)A peek into the mindset that we are dealing with!!
treestar
(82,383 posts)mere ad hominem and you have failed to see the issue.
Mojorabbit
(16,020 posts)He had all the perks that a head of state is supposed to have.
reusrename
(1,716 posts)What's worse is that the question itself, if asked in good faith, is not that unreasonable.
One can tell by the reaction to reasoned responses that this question is only asked for one purpose, to disrupt the board with a whole 'nuther load of bullshit.
Why are these folks here?
eShirl
(20,257 posts)ForeignandDomestic
(190 posts)nt
treestar
(82,383 posts)But they sure enjoy hitching on to Evo's victimhood!
xtraxritical
(3,576 posts)treestar
(82,383 posts)And you still risk, when going into a foreign country, that they not respect those rights. With much greater risk than that the US will violate your rights.
Mojorabbit
(16,020 posts)HooptieWagon
(17,064 posts)you'd find your answer in front of your nose. International law, treaties, and protocol. The US alone has the FSIA law, which immunizes foreign heads of state from detention or arrest while in office. Google Foreign Sovereign Immunity Act
pocoloco
(3,180 posts)Got bloodstained hands??
JEB
(4,748 posts)Or....
SaveOurDemocracy
(4,566 posts)The Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations of 1961 is an international treaty that defines a framework for diplomatic relations between independent countries. It specifies the privileges of a diplomatic mission that enable diplomats to perform their function without fear of coercion or harassment by the host country. This forms the legal basis for diplomatic immunity. Its articles are considered a cornerstone of modern international relations. As of June 2013, it has been ratified by 189 states. The 1961 UN Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations marked its 50th anniversary in April 2011.[1]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vienna_Convention_on_Diplomatic_Relations
itsrobert
(14,157 posts)The same rules should apply to all the people.
SaveOurDemocracy
(4,566 posts)SaveOurDemocracy
(4,566 posts)... leader of a sovereign nation having his flight interrupted and being pressured to allow a search of his plane? Guess that same attitude extends to Obama and AF1??
treestar
(82,383 posts)MannyGoldstein
(34,589 posts)you'll give it a shrug?
Pretty impressive.
Cleita
(75,480 posts)from the World Court for their arrest on war crimes. I don't think Obama has any yet, so I know I would object.
MannyGoldstein
(34,589 posts)while there, Snowden releases documents indicating that the US massively spied on Brazil and Obama signed off on it.
Brazil immediately issues a warrant for Obama's arrest. He's grabbed and tossed into a Brazilian jail.
Seems like that's OK with some folks?
Cleita
(75,480 posts)immunity, an immunity that we and our allies violated with Morales. The warrants from the Hague are a whole different matter and Bush or Cheney should be arrested. However, it seems Bush was in Africa last week and left scot free. Now I know it would have been difficult to arrest him especially with not only the SS protecting him but Obama's SS in proximity as well. It's probably the only reason the weasel dared step off USA soil that time because he knew there would be a large security contingent accompanying them.
MannyGoldstein
(34,589 posts)apparently disagrees with us. He claims local law trumps all others.
Cleita
(75,480 posts)formercia
(18,479 posts)I feel a disturbance in the Force.
Cleita
(75,480 posts)busterbrown
(8,515 posts)Im always amazed at how some of us at D.U. are so adept at putting a thread together which is rather complex.. unfortunately I am not one of those Duers.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)When he was told he was "free to go" that says it all.
SwissTony
(2,560 posts)Surely, he's got as much right to do this as I have. Absolutely F_All.
Catherina
(35,568 posts)mazzarro
(3,450 posts)Or there are no Austrians who can speak fluent Spanish and have conversation with Pres. Morales - hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm!
suffragette
(12,232 posts)Such a little thing to ask.
Seriously, thank you for your time, energy and skill in following up on this and presenting the additional translated info.
pa28
(6,145 posts)Cute. I'm glad Morales stayed firm because those "friends" really ought to be exposed.
broiles
(1,455 posts)A Simple Game
(9,214 posts)This:
HooptieWagon
(17,064 posts)OK, not only was his plane forced down, but thats an admission he was physically detained. Obama has brokwn several US and International laws and treaties.
gtar100
(4,192 posts)Worker's rights, unions, fair trade, open elections, and individual rights, equal justice, etc. These are the ideals of the Left that conservative/corporatist/right-wing people fight against. And Latin America has no shortage of those types of people. So they've got a long road to travel before they can feel safely out of harms way.
So here's a toast - with fair trade coffee - to the rise of people's rights in Latin America and the inevitable humbling of the rich there and everywhere.
And the good thing for the US is that nothing ever stands still. This downfall of the US is clearly the result of embracing conservative policies and values. Seeing how much of an utter failure they are is unfortunately the only way of changing stubborn minds, it seems.
xtraxritical
(3,576 posts)Catherina
(35,568 posts)Latin America Rising under the leadership of great men/women who listen to their people.
While in the US workers are scrambling for pennies to keep a roof over their heads, Latin America is building 100,000s of thousands of roofs while providing healthcare, shelters, meals, education, transportation.
Wake up America
If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing. - Malcolm X
HooptieWagon
(17,064 posts)I guess US and EU are abandoning those trade partners to the Russians and Chinese. Pretty stupid of Obama.
ohheckyeah
(9,314 posts)When the US stock market tanked, I took what we had left and put it into stocks in companies in South America. We recouped our losses in about a year with a return of 26%.
Starry Messenger
(32,381 posts)Such a pretty coffee boy, huh? It's amazing how these sociopaths look like such nice professional people.
I'll repeat it again: You go, Evo!
As for the naysayers on DU, they don't like your cyber investigative journalism. What does it say about someone who turns their head to investigative journalism? I'll tell you what it says about them: They are trolls of obfuscation, of misinformation. Hell, I'll go as far to say they are spooks themselves, and always have been no matter HOW long they have been a DUer. If one cannot see the truth, even when being led straight to the water and dunking their head in it, they are not lovers of democracy, of facts, of truth.
Thanks for the translation. All I know is conversational, and not much of that.
snappyturtle
(14,656 posts)Wouldn't you just love to hear the evening "news" lead off with this? That would put an end to all the fabrications of the event.
temmer
(358 posts)courtesy of reorg:
Lieutenant-Colonel Omar Haijawi-Pirchner, head of Referat III of the airport police, which is in charge of alien and border control:
"The airport police had nothing to do with the plane of Evo Morales, it was immediately approached by the colleagues of the BVT, the Federal Agency for State Protection and Counter Terrorism (Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz und Terrorismusbekämpfung).
http://diepresse.com/home/panorama/welt/1427309/Staatenlos_Endstation-Flughafen?direct=1416110&_vl_backlink=/home/politik/index.do&selChannel=103
MannyGoldstein
(34,589 posts)awful, awful.
cantbeserious
(13,039 posts)eom
sabrina 1
(62,325 posts)kind we would tolerate over there.
BrainDrain
(244 posts)is turning into a fourth-world embarrassment when a country the elites here consider a third-world country has to get up and tell this country the truthful difference between right and wrong.
jeeeebus it makes the head explode.
EXCELLENT post Catherina
School Teacher
(71 posts)Unfortunately for them, the Spanish voted in the Right Wing Partido Popular. Now they are enjoying the benefits of a Neoliberal
Economy. So of course their ambassador is playing along with Obama's agenda. These PP people are so arrogant. They talk down to the Spanish public as if they were bad little children for complaining about austerity.
Mosaic
(1,451 posts)"little Spanish" is offensive to Latin Americans.
truth2power
(8,219 posts)"the little Spanish Bushbot". I would say he deserves the name.
hootinholler
(26,451 posts)The plane is forced to land in Austria, and Spain is demanding to search it? W.T.F.????
Is Austria that weak that it can be run over rough shod by other nations?
struggle4progress
(126,150 posts)It's not entirely clear to me what happened. The Spanish Foreign Minister and the Bolivian Minister of Defense both say that Spanish airspace was not denied. It's clear Morales believed France, Italy, Portugal, and Spain closed airspace due to suspicions Snowden was on-board; and he was on the phone with over Bolivian officials before the plane landed. So it's credible that somebody had complained to Spain before the plane was on the ground, which could explain why the Spanish ambassador hightailed it to the airport at the end of the day: he may merely have hoped to chat with Morales to smooth matters. According to the Bolivian Minister of Defense, the ambassador never mentioned Snowden and actually said something like he was tired and wondered if Morales would give him a cup of coffee on the plane, which Morales understood as a Spanish accusation that Morales was a liar and that Snowden was onboard.
... "Spain doesn't have to ask pardon in anyway because its airspace was never closed," said Spanish Foreign Minister Jose Manuel Garcia-Margallo ...
Spain says no reason to apologise to Bolivia in Snowden saga
MADRID, July 5 | Fri Jul 5, 2013 3:18am EDT
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/07/05/spain-bolivia-idUSE8N0CD01620130705
... Many hours before takeoff <from Moscow> the Government of Portugal notified the flight crew we could not land in Lisbon due to technical problems. So Spanish government authorization was obtained to stop in the Canary Islands ... At that time our use of airspace was not restricted. What we could not do was land ... The pilot himself had apparently heard a rumor that Mr Snowden was on-board ... We requested the emergency landing <in Vienna> as a precaution against a possible lack of fuel ... The President meanwhile telephoned the vice president and the chancellor to inform them what was happening ... They asked for our passports; we had no problem displaying them; ... they reviewed them quickly and returned ... After landing, the crew received notification of Portugal and Italy that they had canceled the overflight and landing permits in their territories ... The ambassador did not specifically mention Snowden. Our president said "Look, sir, we are not carrying anybody, not even Mr. Snowden". That unnerved the Spanish diplomat ... His response was confused ... The ambassador returned at 9:30 <AM>; President Morales told him it was all sorted out and thanked him ...
Rubén Saavedra Soto: Nadie requisó el avión FAB 001
El ministro de Defensa relata lo ocurrido en la nave presidencial cuando le bloquearon el vuelo en cuatro países de Europa. Cuenta los detalles de esos momentos tensos en Viena.
http://www.eldeber.com.bo/ruben-saavedra-soto-nadie-requiso-el-avion-fab-001/130706215201
Response to Catherina (Original post)
Name removed Message auto-removed
truth2power
(8,219 posts)to have someone continue to push back against all the obfuscation that goes on around here.
DeSwiss
(27,137 posts)Babel_17
(5,400 posts)pscot
(21,044 posts)Well done, Catherina. Remind me never to play hand grenades with you.
Catherina
(35,568 posts)There's a big wooden slab in my backyard with a painted bullseye and when I start feeling stressed, I throw knives. Sometimes I put names or pictures up as the target instead. It's surprising how good your aim gets in such a short amount of time lol.
I'm working on another translation right now.
reusrename
(1,716 posts)Of course we suspected that the shadow government was behind this and now we know the little bastard is a Bushbot.
Really, thanks for this.
Waiting For Everyman
(9,385 posts)This was an important stand that Morales took at that moment, and I respect him a lot for doing it. Thank you Catherina, for bringing us more depth on this. You do an awesome job of putting more light on these events.
And yes, what a nasty little sycophant the coffee boy is. There's such a striking contrast in character between the two sides in this story!
The revelations on the Iraq War are absolutely sickening. But then, being a Viet Nam era American, I knew a phoney war the first instant I heard of it (and Afganistan too). I saw to it that my neice who was on the verge of joining up at that time, did not do so. (My late husband was a case study in what the MIC does to soldiers and vets.) I could only shake my head at people who let their loved ones be sucked into it. It was nothing but VN2 on steroids, in a different climate. If we would only learn from our own past, and listen to people who were involved in those past events, these horrific mistakes would not repeat over and over again.
Laughing Mirror
(4,185 posts)"Our real sin is to have an indigenous President, and to be anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist. That's our sin sisters and brothers. They can't accept that we can govern better than the neoliberals. They can't understand that."
Bears repeating.
Pachamama
(17,564 posts)Speaking Truth to power....
And as a long time DUer who posts infrequently but knows the forum well: you are doing what needs to be done....you go girl....