Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Fire Walk With Me

(38,893 posts)
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 04:54 PM Aug 2013

People Who Got Shorter Sentences Than Chelsea Manning: Spies Selling Secrets To Russians etc...

Last edited Fri Aug 23, 2013, 05:43 PM - Edit history (1)

techdirt ‏@techdirt

People Who Got Shorter Sentences Than Bradley Manning: Spies Selling Secrets To Russians & Active Terrorists
http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130821/18434224275/people-who-got-shorter-sentences-than-bradley-manning-spies-selling-secrets-to-russians-active-terrorists.shtml


Take, for example, the case of David Henry Barnett, a CIA agent who directly sold secrets to the Russians, including but not limited to outing around 30 active CIA agents to the KGB. Oh, and at the urging of the KGB, he also tried to get a job on Capitol Hill in order to get access to more secrets. He was eventually caught and charged with espionage in 1980... and received an 18 year sentence. Got that? Directly sell the identity of CIA agents to the KGB and you get about half the time that Manning got, not for revealing the identity of any intelligence agents, but basically for embarrassing the State Department and the military. That doesn't seem right.

Okay. And how about people, including Americans, who actively tried to hurt America? Remember, Manning made it quite clear his goal was to help America. But that's not true for these five people who joined the Taliban or teamed up with terrorists working on plans to attack America. Those people actively wanted to harm America. And they got shorter sentences.

David Hicks: An Australian national who was captured fighting alongside the Taliban and sent to Guantanamo Bay prison in 2002, Hicks plead guilty to material support for terrorism in a Gitmo military commission in 2007 and was sentenced to seven years confinement. That sentence was reduced to nine months given time already served.

John Walker Lindh: Lindh was convicted of a slew of terrorism and conspiracy charges in 2003 for fighting with the Taliban against the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan. He was sentenced to 20 years in prison.


(More at the link.)

35 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
People Who Got Shorter Sentences Than Chelsea Manning: Spies Selling Secrets To Russians etc... (Original Post) Fire Walk With Me Aug 2013 OP
Can there be any doubt now that the Manning trial was simply our Vinnie From Indy Aug 2013 #1
I fully agree with you gopiscrap Aug 2013 #19
k&r for the truth, however depressing it may be. n/t Laelth Aug 2013 #2
How many of those were serving members of the armed forces subject to the UCMJ? Spider Jerusalem Aug 2013 #3
Good point, and a good reason to stay out of the armed services! n/t Fire Walk With Me Aug 2013 #4
The people responsible for the abuses at Abu Ghraib got shorter sentences. backscatter712 Aug 2013 #9
The people actually responsible for Abu Ghraib were never tried at all. N/T Just Saying Aug 2013 #27
As we called it in my day-The Uniform Code Of Marsupial Justice hobbit709 Aug 2013 #13
Let's see, we have William Calley .. I won't go into it but you can read it yourself YOHABLO Aug 2013 #25
Jonathan Pollard was sentenced to life without parole. NaturalHigh Aug 2013 #5
Manning didn't pass secrets to the enemy for profit, though. KoKo Aug 2013 #30
He released over 700,000 documents... NaturalHigh Aug 2013 #34
He didn't "consort" to spy on us for another country or take money." eom. KoKo Aug 2013 #35
Most get life zipplewrath Aug 2013 #6
The Marine Haditha murderers. Catherina Aug 2013 #7
But they were Amur-kens! Fighting for our raht... burnodo Aug 2013 #16
Recommend....that was horrendous...and it should have gotten attention and KoKo Aug 2013 #31
That's because it isn't about justice, JoeyT Aug 2013 #8
Ding, ding, ding. We have a winner. Scuba Aug 2013 #11
I personally wonder if Hicks and Lindh were simply victims of politics: they may both just have been struggle4progress Aug 2013 #10
This isn't about justice, this is about sending an intimidating and punitive message myrna minx Aug 2013 #12
It's even more chilling to see those that applaud it. hobbit709 Aug 2013 #14
Pssst... It's Chelsea Manning. KamaAina Aug 2013 #15
Oh bloody hell. Cut-and-pasted the title and obviously wasn't thinking. Will edit. Fire Walk With Me Aug 2013 #21
^ Wilms Aug 2013 #17
Geez people, FairWinds Aug 2013 #18
Outed a CIA Agent..but, he's part of the "Ruling Class." n/t KoKo Aug 2013 #32
Then there were the Rosenbergs... classof56 Aug 2013 #20
Rebel "Prez" Jefferson Davis got 2 yrs... charlives Aug 2013 #22
The US Government has made out that Manning's was ''the Largest Loss of Secrets Evah'' Octafish Aug 2013 #23
POLICE STATES generally don't like law-abiding citizens or whistleblowers. blkmusclmachine Aug 2013 #24
Couldn't agree more. You play by their twisted rules .. or you're squashed. YOHABLO Aug 2013 #26
Its almost as if there is some kind of order... napoleon_in_rags Aug 2013 #28
k&r toby jo Aug 2013 #29
Lt. Calley served 1 day in Leavenworth and 3 years house arrest. Tierra_y_Libertad Aug 2013 #33

Vinnie From Indy

(10,820 posts)
1. Can there be any doubt now that the Manning trial was simply our
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 04:58 PM
Aug 2013

version of a "show trial"?

The sentence was insanely unfair and this post proves it!

Good post and off to the Greatest with it!

Cheers!

gopiscrap

(24,754 posts)
19. I fully agree with you
Fri Aug 23, 2013, 11:56 AM
Aug 2013

and that is why we need to keep the heat and spotlight on this issue!

 

Spider Jerusalem

(21,786 posts)
3. How many of those were serving members of the armed forces subject to the UCMJ?
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 05:12 PM
Aug 2013

Apparently, none of them. Military and civilian justice are not the same thing; in the case of a serving member of the armed forces convicted of espionage, the sentence is in part exemplary, pour encourager les autres. Discouraging the wilful disobedience of orders and disclosure of classified information by showing what happens to those who do is in the interests of military discipline.

It would be a fairer comparison to look at members of the armed forces convicted by court-martial of espionage and compare their sentences with Manning's.

backscatter712

(26,357 posts)
9. The people responsible for the abuses at Abu Ghraib got shorter sentences.
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 06:19 PM
Aug 2013
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abu_Ghraib_torture_and_prisoner_abuse

The United States Department of Defense removed seventeen soldiers and officers from duty, and eleven soldiers were charged with dereliction of duty, maltreatment, aggravated assault and battery. Between May 2004 and March 2006, eleven soldiers were convicted in courts-martial, sentenced to military prison, and dishonorably discharged from service. Two soldiers, Specialist Charles Graner, and his former fiancée, Specialist Lynndie England, were sentenced to ten years and three years in prison, respectively, in trials ending on January 14, 2005 and September 26, 2005. The commanding officer of all Iraq detention facilities, Brigadier General Janis Karpinski, was reprimanded for dereliction of duty and demoted to the rank of Colonel on May 5, 2005. Col. Karpinski has denied knowledge of the abuses, claiming that the interrogations were authorized by her superiors and performed by subcontractors, and that she was not allowed entry into the interrogation rooms.
 

YOHABLO

(7,358 posts)
25. Let's see, we have William Calley .. I won't go into it but you can read it yourself
Sat Aug 24, 2013, 09:29 PM
Aug 2013

William Laws Calley[1] (William Laws Calley, Jr.) (born June 8, 1943) is a convicted American war criminal and a former U.S. Army officer found guilty of murder for his role in the My Lai Massacre on March 16, 1968, during the Vietnam War

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Calley

NaturalHigh

(12,778 posts)
5. Jonathan Pollard was sentenced to life without parole.
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 05:28 PM
Aug 2013

Manning only got 35 years. In my opinion, Manning got a fairly light sentence considering the charges of which he was convicted.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
30. Manning didn't pass secrets to the enemy for profit, though.
Sun Aug 25, 2013, 11:19 AM
Aug 2013

That's a huge difference.

NaturalHigh

(12,778 posts)
34. He released over 700,000 documents...
Sun Aug 25, 2013, 12:56 PM
Aug 2013

knowing that many would end up in the hands of the enemy. His motivations aren't particularly important to me. He signed a non-disclosure agreement, and he (like anyone who graduated from basic training) was well-educated about the consequences of disclosing classified information.

zipplewrath

(16,698 posts)
6. Most get life
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 05:39 PM
Aug 2013

Most people of this type get life. Of course that can come with an opportunity for parole. Manning may be out in 9 years or so, because of time already served. John Walker is scheduled to get out after 30.

Catherina

(35,568 posts)
7. The Marine Haditha murderers.
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 05:48 PM
Aug 2013

You can massacre 24 innocent Iraqis, including women, children, a baby and a man in a wheelchair and walk away scot-free.

On November 19, 2005, US Marines from Kilo Company, Third Battalion, First Marine Division killed 24 unarmed civilians in Haditha, Iraq, execution-style, in a three to five hour rampage. One victim was a 76-year-old amputee in a wheelchair holding a Koran. A mother and child bent over as if in prayer were also among the fallen. “I pretended that I was dead when my brother’s body fell on me and he was bleeding like a faucet,” said Safa Younis Salim, a 13-year-old girl who survived by faking her death. Other victims included six children ranging in age from 1 to 14. Citing doctors at Haditha’s hospital, The Washington Post reported, “Most of the shots … were fired at such close range that they went through the bodies of the family members and plowed into walls or the floor.”

...

(There) were blatant attempts to cover up the atrocity, disguised as “collateral damage.” Congressman John Murtha, a former Marine, was briefed on the Haditha investigation by Marine Corps Commandant Michael Hagee. Murtha said, “The reports I have from the highest level: No firing at all. No interaction. No military action at all in this particular incident. It was an explosive device, which killed a Marine. From then on, it was purely shooting people.” Marine Corps officials told Murtha that troops shot a woman “in cold blood” as she was bending over her child begging for mercy. Women and children were in their nightclothes when they were killed.

After the massacre, Briones was ordered to take photographs of the victims and help carry their bodies out of their homes. He is still haunted by what he had to do that day. Briones picked up a young girl who was shot in the head. “I held her out like this,” he said, extending his arms, “but her head was bobbing up and down and the insides fell on my legs.” “I used to be one of those Marines who said that post-traumatic stress is a bunch of bull,” said Briones, who has gotten into serious trouble since he returned home. “But all this stuff that keeps going through my head is eating me up. I need immediate help.”

Murtha told ABC there was “no question” the US military tried to “cover up” the Haditha incident, which Murtha called “worse than Abu Ghraib.” His high-level briefings indicated to him that the cover-up went “right up the chain of command.”

...

The 24 Haditha victims are buried in a cemetery called Martyrs’ Graveyard. Graffiti on the deserted house of one of the families reads, “Democracy assassinated the family that was here.”

http://www.counterpunch.org/2012/01/31/the-haditha-massacre/

The US Press wouldn't even publish the pictures AFP took, they were that bad.

All charges dismissed and 1 acquitted. BUT MANNING IS THE ONE IN JAIL!

 

burnodo

(2,017 posts)
16. But they were Amur-kens! Fighting for our raht...
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 07:48 PM
Aug 2013

to be ignorant of our own government, unless they wanna take are guns!

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
31. Recommend....that was horrendous...and it should have gotten attention and
Sun Aug 25, 2013, 11:24 AM
Aug 2013

follow up outrage. But, the Media/MIC and the People only cared about "9/11" and used that excuse to cover it up. We were lied to for that Invasion and the tragic costs will be with us and Iraq and Middle East for decades.

JoeyT

(6,785 posts)
8. That's because it isn't about justice,
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 06:09 PM
Aug 2013

it's about making an example of him. Make sure any future whistleblowers know to keep their mouth shut and not embarrass the State Department.

struggle4progress

(126,447 posts)
10. I personally wonder if Hicks and Lindh were simply victims of politics: they may both just have been
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 06:22 PM
Aug 2013

in the wrong place at the wrong time, in which case zero time might have been more appropriate for them

myrna minx

(22,772 posts)
12. This isn't about justice, this is about sending an intimidating and punitive message
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 07:39 PM
Aug 2013

to future whistle blowers. The Miranda outrage at Heathrow is to send the same message to journalists and their spouses/loves ones. It's chilling and disturbing. It's equally disturbing that there are those who cheer this abuse of power.

hobbit709

(41,694 posts)
14. It's even more chilling to see those that applaud it.
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 07:43 PM
Aug 2013

The other you can expect from TPTB.

 

FairWinds

(1,717 posts)
18. Geez people,
Fri Aug 23, 2013, 11:46 AM
Aug 2013

how about Scooter Libby? He's a much better example.

Never served a day for being CONVICTED of involvement with leaking Top secret info.

The DC insiders leak more than Manning every week . .

classof56

(5,376 posts)
20. Then there were the Rosenbergs...
Fri Aug 23, 2013, 05:36 PM
Aug 2013

They were of course executed as "Enemies of Democracy". That was during the McCarthy Madness, rife with fear of evil Communism. I was old enough to remember that, and to this day I remain somewhat confused, but at the time it was generally accepted that as spies who sold our secrets to the Soviet Union, they got what was coming to them. Pretty sad, though.

Octafish

(55,745 posts)
23. The US Government has made out that Manning's was ''the Largest Loss of Secrets Evah''
Fri Aug 23, 2013, 06:11 PM
Aug 2013

I guess, if measured by how many corporations were using Uncle Sam to line their pockets.

If measured by what was lost, nothing of import, nothing that harmed U.S. security, nothing that harmed a human being -- other than the bastards who hide their loot offshore and the corporations that bribe Americans and foreign nationals to turn a buck any way possible.

 

YOHABLO

(7,358 posts)
26. Couldn't agree more. You play by their twisted rules .. or you're squashed.
Sat Aug 24, 2013, 09:34 PM
Aug 2013

Last edited Sun Aug 25, 2013, 09:11 PM - Edit history (1)

Even if it exposes the twisted antics of soldiers that kill innocent people for sport .. and their commanders are in full support of it and give the OK .. kill em.

napoleon_in_rags

(3,992 posts)
28. Its almost as if there is some kind of order...
Sat Aug 24, 2013, 09:46 PM
Aug 2013

You can almost picture, sometime back in the 60's, in South America a KGB agent and a CIA agent, both knowing what the other is, sitting down to drinks:

CIA: "You know, we don't have to live under the threat of nuclear destruction, what if we - I mean you and me, got along?"
KGB: "That true, most of people in Russia and the US live in blissful ignorance of the work we do. Should we treat each other as dogs?"
CIA: "Why do that, when we are the bravest and best in the world? What if people like us stopped being slaves of a public, in the US and Russia that doesn't care about us, and started standing up for ourselves?"
KGB: "Yes, what if people like us started to protect our own interests, and for once look at the stupid public as the 'other' in the situation?"

Long drinks.

CIA: "We'd stop forever the threat of nuclear war."
KGB: "But leaks to the public would become more severe in punishment than leaks to each other. Wouldn't the public notice?"
CIA: "Nah, they're all idiots".

 

Tierra_y_Libertad

(50,414 posts)
33. Lt. Calley served 1 day in Leavenworth and 3 years house arrest.
Sun Aug 25, 2013, 11:35 AM
Aug 2013

But, hell, he and the others at My Lai were only mass murderers not whistle blowers.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»People Who Got Shorter Se...