General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhy Gutting the Filibuster Is a Huge Victory for Progressives
This is the best article I have read on the filibuster reform and its history.
===================
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2013/11/harry_reid_and_filibuster_reform_the_nuclear_option_is_a_huge_victory_for.single.html
<snip>
Republicans didnt try to convince Democrats otherwise. Their closing, baffled arguments against the filibuster reform (as recently as last week, Republican aides were confident the vote wouldnt happen) were a series of threats, varying in their politeness. When we have the majority, when we have a Republican president, we will put more people like Scalia on the court, said Grassley when asked to envision a post-nuclear world. Theres not a doubt in my mind that if the majority breaks the rules of the Senate to change the rules of the Senate with regard to nominations, the next majority will do it for everything, said McConnell.
Progressives know that. They expect that. They didnt demand the change because theyre ignorant about the 2014 polls. If they lose that election, theyll have given themselves a year to confirm judges and executive nominees. If they lose the presidency in 2016, theyll have empowered a Republican to put judicial robes on whichever Federalist Society member he wants. But they expected Republicans to break the filibuster anyway. I know that if there is a Republican president and a Republican majority, Sen. Merkley said this month, they will force up-and-down votes, because they demonstrated their commitment to that principle in 2005.
Merkleys opponents never really reckoned with his logic. Progressives did not consider filibuster reform a risk. They saw a way to kick over an impediment to majority rule, before Republicans took power and kicked it over themselves. Theyre trading something that might have brought consensus for something that empowers the party that wins elections. And theyre fine with that.
kentuck
(111,092 posts)So it can get a few more reads.