Summary of Supreme Court health care Oral Argument,

[elleng]

Monday - Wednesday this week, issues Court will hear:

http://www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/294294/summary-supreme-court-health-care-oral-arguments-ammon-simon

Arguments will be recorded and made available each day.

Earlier post on the subject, without Supreme's 'summary.'

http://www.democraticunderground.com/1002464058

What's the likely outcome?

Nobody knows. It's clear that the court's four more liberal members, like almost all other liberal legal experts, will find the law constitutional in all respects. It's also clear that conservative Justice Clarence Thomas will vote to strike down much or all of the law. It's less clear what swing-voting Justice Anthony Kennedy and conservative Chief Justice John Roberts as well as Justices Antonin Scalia and Samuel Alito will do.

Kennedy, Roberts, Alito, and (especially) Scalia -- whom the government's brief quotes five times -- have all joined past decisions construing federal regulatory power very broadly. Two respected conservative federal appeals court judges, Laurence Silberman and Geoffrey Sutton, who is one of Scalia's favorite law clerks, have upheld the law.

http://www.kaiserhealthnews.org/stories/2012/march/15/supreme-court-curtain-raiser.aspx

[white_wolf]

1. Just wondering, isn't the National Review a very right wing magazine?

[elleng]

2. Yes, but

the Supremes themselves actually summarized the particular issues they were interested in hearing discussed, appointed counsel for some.
This article may somewhat mischaracterize the issues, but I wanted to provide the big picture for DUers.

Set out differently, this from Kaiser:

http://www.kaiserhealthnews.org/stories/2012/march/15/supreme-court-curtain-raiser.aspx

'What's the likely outcome?

Nobody knows. It's clear that the court's four more liberal members, like almost all other liberal legal experts, will find the law constitutional in all respects. It's also clear that conservative Justice Clarence Thomas will vote to strike down much or all of the law. It's less clear what swing-voting Justice Anthony Kennedy and conservative Chief Justice John Roberts as well as Justices Antonin Scalia and Samuel Alito will do.

Kennedy, Roberts, Alito, and (especially) Scalia -- whom the government's brief quotes five times -- have all joined past decisions construing federal regulatory power very broadly. Two respected conservative federal appeals court judges, Laurence Silberman and Geoffrey Sutton, who is one of Scalia's favorite law clerks, have upheld the law.'