More Police Will Never Be a Solution to Black America’s Woes
http://www.thenation.com/blog/181505/more-police-will-never-be-solution-black-americas-woes
Police officers patrol in Brownsville, New York. (Reuters/Eric Thayer)
While riding the subway the other day, I overheard a mother and daughter discussing the police. The two of them had just boarded the train after witnessing an officer stop a young man whom the officer believed didnt pay the fare. Apparently, the young man had explained to the subway booth attendant that he didnt have any money, and the attendant took pity on him and let him through. The young man became defensive when the police officer didnt believe his story.
The mother, a black woman who looked to be in her 50s, was upset about the interaction she witnessed. As a police officer, you should be out trying to catch people doing murders and robberies, not things like hopping the turnstile, she kept saying. I feel like theyre just picking on these kids. The daughter, also black and probably in her 30s, had a different view: Theyre doing their job. They know enough to know which kids are the ones coming on the train stealing iPhones. Not paying the fare is the beginning of mischief. These kids are bad, she said.
These kids are bad isnt solely the opinion of that one woman I overheard on the train. And as such it wasnt surprising to read the findings of this Quinnipiac University poll that shows that 57 percent of black voters support broken windows policing. Its one reason why folks like President Obama and the Rev. Al Sharpton can go before black audiences and, as The Washington Posts Jonathan Capehart argues, air the dirty laundry of black America and receive rapturous applause. These kids are badand if we dont set them straight early on, the thinking goes, theyll be worse adults. Even given the adversarial (at best) relationship between black folks and the state, many black Americans still view police as part of the solution.
Its important to note, though, that this particular poll surveyed registered voters. As Kristen West Savali points out at The Root, Older black people are more likely to be registered voters than younger black people, and in populations most affected by police brutalitylow-income, black communitiesaccess to a landline or cellphone is not assured. She adds: When reading these results, one also has to take into consideration the disenfranchisement restrictions placed on black voters on parole. In other words, the people not as likely to face police harassment are the ones who support a crackdown on so-called quality-of-life crimes.