General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsRussia to the rescue?
Last edited Fri Jan 30, 2015, 04:15 PM - Edit history (1)
The Russian Federation is offering to loan Greece the cash it needs to hold off international creditors and prevent yet worse "austerity" as demanded by the European Central Bank and International Monetary Fund. This injection of Russian money could halt some long feared actions, such as wholesale sell-off of properties owned by the Greek government. "But how can Russia afford that," one may ask, "aren't the Russians broke because of our sanctions?" No, actually they are nothing of the sort; in fact, the Russian government still holds one of the largest reserves of foreign currency in the World. It's everyone else in Europe who is suffering losses due to anti-Russian sanctions.
Russian Finance Minister Anton Siluanov. (RIA Novosti)
Russia might bailout Greece finance minister
Greece hasnt outright asked Russia for a loan, but Russian Finance Minister Anton Siluanov said Moscow wouldn't rule it out. His statement comes days after Greece openly opposed further economic sanctions against Russia.
"Well, we can imagine any situation, so if such [a] petition is submitted to the Russian government, we will definitely consider it, but we will take into account all the factors of our bilateral relationships between Russia and Greece, so that is all I can say. If it is submitted we will consider it," Siluanov told CNBC in an interview in Moscow on Thursday.
The new left-wing Syriza government in Greece won a majority at last Sundays election on the promise to renegotiate the countrys 317 billion debt and end austerity. Greece needs to negotiate with EU policymakers by February 28 in order to receive the next tranche of bailout funds. If Athens doesnt get the money it will have difficulty servicing its debt. Two bailouts were paid in 2010 and 2014 totaling 240 billion. The new government was quick to show support for Moscow, and has openly called for an end to Russian sanctions, and may veto any future sanctions.
Siluanov applauded Greeces stance on sanctions as pragmatic and economically justified. On Thursday the European Commission decided to extend sanctions against Russia through September 2015, but did not add any broader economic measures. A spokesperson for the new PM Alexis Tsipras said Greece didnt approve of any further restrictive measures. Between announcing it doesnt intend to pay off its 317 billion debt in full and blocking Russia sanctions, Greece has emerged as a wild card among the 29 countries of the EU.
(snip)
Read more at: http://rt.com/business/227751-russia-greece-financial-aid/
Update:
Greece wont cooperate with troika, rejects aid extension
The new left-wing Greek government has said that it will not cooperate with the troika of international lenders, and does not plan to seek an extension for its aid package which is set to expire at the end of February.
Without the aid, Greek banks could face being shut off from European Central Bank funding.
This position enabled us to win the trust of the Greek people, Greek Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis said Friday during a joint press conference with Jeroen Dijsselbloem, head of the eurozone finance ministers group.
The meeting between Varoufakis and Dijsselbloem is to lay the groundwork for visits by newly-elected Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras and the finance minister to London, Paris, and Rome next week. The new Greek leadership has voiced its intention to attempt to loosen the terms of the massive 240 billion (US$271 billion) bailout.
Read more at: http://rt.com/news/228031-greece-troika-varoufakis-bailout/
Adrahil
(13,340 posts)Another chance for Russia to drive a wedge between EU nations, and have another state under their thumb?
Oh yeah....they are "rescuing" them. There will be many strings....
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Since they have already have spent five years "under" the European Union's "thumb," perhaps they see the alternative as a less damaging course for their austerity battered nation?
After all, Russia was offering far more lenient terms to the Ukrainian government before our State Department organized President Yanukovich's overthrow and precluded such a funding option.
myohmy2
(3,721 posts)....what has Greece got to lose, but the yoke of European corporate domination....
....let Greece go back to printing their own currency and let the new bi-polar world continue....
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)With our mega-bankers and energy barons being the overlords of everything? That does not appeal to me.
Adrahil
(13,340 posts)But having another pole lead by a kleptocracy of Oligarchs isn't an improvement, IMO. Especially not one willing to do what they are doing to their former imperial possessions.
I understand your resistance to the finance-centric west. I do NOT understand your support of an even MORE corrupt east.
And don't say you don't support them. Your actions here speak to your sympathies.
Cayenne
(480 posts)Adrahil
(13,340 posts)It's not that I think 'Murica is the bestest in the world.
But Russia is at least as bad, and IMO, far worse. To sort of prop it up as a just counterweight to the evil West is just disingenuous.
Art_from_Ark
(27,247 posts)since the Cyrillic alphabet is based in large part on the Greek alphabet.
Adrahil
(13,340 posts)Agreeing to restrictions on who they can and can't have trade deals with? And so forth?
Yes, the velvet fist of Putin will be so much better.
We'll see how this works out for them the first time they dare to counteract what their new master demands of them.
Having said that, I think the EU had better play its cards right here. Austerity has not proven to be effective. It's an intellectually bankrupt economic plan.
oberliner
(58,724 posts)I can't believe that site is taken seriously by anyone here.
It is the Fox News of Russia, to put it kindly.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Or write your own. Thanks.
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)You post Russian propaganda... the topic of the thread is the fact that you've (again) posted Russian propaganda.
But I will disagree with oberliner...
They're worse than Fox.
malaise
(295,832 posts)Name one thing Fox has been correct on?
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)and being the propaganda arm of a foreign government.
The President can't just call up Fox and ask them to run a story that they know to be false... Putin can do that.
Art_from_Ark
(27,247 posts)certainly seemed to have no problems getting news organizations to run a story they knew was false.
Yellow cake and weapons of mass destruction, anyone?
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)They have a political affiliation, not direct ownership by the government.
malaise
(295,832 posts)Guess that's why CBS fired Dan Rather - who fired Maher again?
FFS - they all manufacture consent - they all control the media.
They all have their intelligence agencies all over all media.
JonLP24
(29,919 posts)I have watched hours of coverage and the tell the truth about America that a lot of the corporate media doesn't.
AverageJoe90
(10,745 posts)Russia Today may be perfectly fine with bashing U.S. corruption, but they're loath to talk about their own right-wing at home, namely Putin's United Russia party......
JonLP24
(29,919 posts)There are so many news & sources out there. The EU & its Western Allies are against Russia in this Ukranian civil war. All these allegations against Russia Today come from Western state department officials & very little of what they is substantiated. In fact, they don't even point to examples. There is an information war going on but contrary to Hillary Clinton's claims, the west isn't losing it judging by the lack of understanding by the knee jerk hatred going on.
I always verify with multiple sources, if there is a lone wolf claiming this is going on that isn't backed up I reject it. Russia Today does serve a purpose in what is their perception? How do they see things, being lined up against by the EU, IMF, & Western allies. Though when it comes to this conflict, I stay away from sourcing RT since it will be distracted & you can easily find other sources backing up specific claims. But it helps to see their perception when so many people are lining up & discrediting them.
zappaman
(20,627 posts)You celebrities did not go to medical school!: Fox News medical correspondent chides anti-vaxxers
http://www.salon.com/2015/01/22/you_celebrities_did_not_go_to_medical_school_fox_news_medical_correspondent_chides_anti_vaxxers/
So, I guess that's one thing...
Cha
(318,868 posts)Rupert Murdoch owned outlet.
LOL.. one thing they have in common.. they both hate President Obama.
FBaggins
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)In this case, for instance, Russia is supporting a government well to the left of ours. That's hardly "rw" with the US political range.
JonLP24
(29,919 posts)oberliner
(58,724 posts)It is important for anyone reading the article to be fully aware of that - in case they might not be familiar with "RT".
This source regularly makes excuses for Russia (especially vis-a-vis Ukraine) and for Putin, in particular.
This is their usual "hooray for Russia" nonsense and should be treated as such.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Nor are you required to reply to them.
If you do, however, please address any such replies to the topic offered. Thanks again.
LanternWaste
(37,748 posts)Posters may respond to an OPs as each poster sees fit to. If you have a problem with comments that don't validate a bias, you may wish to alert on it, or (as you said) simply not respond to them.
Thanks again...
mythology
(9,527 posts)It's not a valid news source and yet you treat it as if it came down the mountain carved in stone.
This isn't Russia where disagreeing with your hero Putin will result in somebody being jailed or killed.
aquart
(69,014 posts)And it only prints what Putin okays?
Sounds like a source for Putin's plays.
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)It's obvious why you would want readers to just accept the propaganda without question and restrict their replies to those that assume that the claims are unbiased and accurate...
What's missing is why anyone should listen to such ridiculous demands.
Here's a hint for the next time: The validity of a source is always in order.
HERVEPA
(6,107 posts)You're not in Russia.
love_me_some_pickles
(35 posts)This poster seems only to post pro Russian articles, Mostly from Russia Today, which is the even more evil equivalent to Faux Noise.
One should be skeptical of anything posted from Russia Today, or another liberal.
uppityperson
(116,017 posts)it happens so rarely. How's the snow, or were you in that heat wave?
snooper2
(30,151 posts)Hey, did you ever see this Putin greatness LOL
HERVEPA
(6,107 posts)You don't own the thread.
Doesn't matter if you say пожалуйста
nilesobek
(1,423 posts)Multiple posters point out that RT is a propaganda arm of the Russian Government.
Other posters thoughtfully point out that CBS, NBC, ABC, and FOX are merely propaganda arms of the American government.
Its being used as a tactic to disrupt threads. I have no more respect for Western news organizations than for Eastern ones.
It might set off some dopamine sector of the brain to make such repeated posts with graphics, multiple smiley faces, and the ritual of killing the messenger. Like gambling, drinking and drug abuse does.
muriel_volestrangler
(106,160 posts)another_liberal:
"The Russian Federation is offering to loan Greece the cash it needs to hold off international creditors and prevent yet worse "austerity" as demanded by the European Central Bank and International Monetary Fund. "
RT:
"Greece hasnt outright asked Russia for a loan, but Russian Finance Minister Anton Siluanov said Moscow wouldn't rule it out. "
Russian finance minister:
"Well, we can imagine any situation, so if such [a] petition is submitted to the Russian government, we will definitely consider it, but we will take into account all the factors of our bilateral relationships between Russia and Greece, so that is all I can say. If it is submitted we will consider it"
RT hasn't really pushed it much further than what the minister said. The false part is the "is offering to loan" bit that another_liberal wrote. He said they'd consider it, not that they will do it.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Let me refer you to the title of the article in my OP:
Russia might bailout Greece finance minister.
That would be the Russian Federation Finance Minister, by the way.
muriel_volestrangler
(106,160 posts)This is basic English that has been pointed out to you, and you still can't understand it. Or choose to pretend you don't understand.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Just as a "might" is an "offering."
Do you have a point, other than a desire to indulge in semantic hair splitting?
muriel_volestrangler
(106,160 posts)My point is that your paragraph is grossly misleading. The Russians have not offered a loan. You claim to not know the meaning of the word 'offer', or 'might', or perhaps it's even 'is' that you are unclear about. We are going to have to correct your English from now on, it seems.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)The difference in meaning, given this context though, is not that great. I think you are making a mountain out of a semantic mole hill.
Duckhunter935
(16,974 posts)aquart
(69,014 posts)
MattSh
(3,714 posts)Who do you choose to believe? Choose wisely or you choose ignorance.
SidDithers
(44,333 posts)Sid
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)Which... of course... is why the S&P just downgraded Russia's credit rating to "junk" status.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Only if they needed to borrow our money. It clearly looks like they don't.
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)They've had serious borrowing problems. Their bond auctions have failed multiple times as their borrowing costs reach new records.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Maybe someone is lying to you, or, at the very least, exaggerating greatly.
NCTraveler
(30,481 posts)Also, why do you think a country in economic turmoil is in a position to bail out another country?
"Yet they are offering to bail out Greece?"
Please show the offer as you have stated has happened. It is not in your op.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Now might be a good time to do so.
FSogol
(47,613 posts)another_liberal
(8,821 posts)(sigh)
FSogol
(47,613 posts)of that happening.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Or is it a strong "gut feeling?"
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)The EU bailed out Greece and they too have financial troubles.
Offering to bail out a MUCH smaller country is not evidence of financial strength.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)I'm sure they will soon be in touch with us, begging for mercy. If that happens we will all know it, though frankly, I wouldn't start holding my breath just yet.
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)Last edited Fri Jan 30, 2015, 11:10 AM - Edit history (1)
So the only two possibilities are that Russia is rock-solid economically or will declare bankruptcy tomorrow, eh?
You might... for instance... compare the strength of the dollar to the rubble (pun intended) over the last few months.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)I did not say any such thing.
No one knows how this economic warfare offensive will shake out in the end; however, to suggest Russia is currently being crippled by our economic sanctions is definitely what I would call "overly-simplistic."
FBaggins
(28,705 posts)You were the one (along with the Russian propaganda) that defended their economic strength by measuring whether or not they were bankrupt (and the ridiculous claim that if they could lend money to Greece, they must be in good shape). I was responding to the claim in the article that it was everyone else in Europe that was suffering.
* Russia is cutting the bulk of their budget by 10% this year and 5% for the next two years
* Predictions for their GDP this year are in the negative 5-6% range... with another 2-3% loss in 2016. That's a severe recession.
* Making things much worse, they've had to boost borrowing rates astronomically (from 10% to 17% in just the last month or so) to defend their currency from further collapse... yet they can't figure out which fate is worse - cut the rate to avoid economic collapse (but see the rubble continue to fall apart), or support the rubble, and watch the economy crumble. Putin apparently stong-armed their (supposedly ind.) dentral bank into lowering the rate by 2% today.
* CBR is "encouraging" their banks to just accept (~40%) losses on their foreign-denominated mortgages and re-denominate them in rubbles... and not even at market rate.
* National debt cut to junk bond status, yet still has a negative ratings outlook
* The inflation outlook has climbed into the double digits
* And the one you obviously missed... they need to do something with their foreign currency reserves. The expectation was that the CBR would be selling dollars to help prop up the rubble... but there's no reason why they can't use it to impact foreign policy.
President Obama was correct. Russia's economy is "in tatters". Speculating that they might loan money to Greece doesn't change that at all. We can debate how much of it was poor policy on their part... how much was from sanctions... and how much was from OPEC oil moves (which may very well be part of the sanctions). What is beyond debate is that Russia's economy is in very bad shape right now.
?w=640
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)If the sanctions are truly bankrupting Russia, then undoubtedly they will soon come to us begging for mercy. I just don't believe that is likely to be the case.
malaise
(295,832 posts)Here come the BRICS
Ichingcarpenter
(36,988 posts)the saudis for one don't like the idea especially with their hands in the US banking system, whereas South America and some Asian countries are fightinng to get it started.
The US will pull out alll stops to damage the Bric.
malaise
(295,832 posts)Note the timing of certain global events and the announcement of the alternative bank to the IMF.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2014/12/22/brics-new-development-bank-threatens-hegemony-of-u-s-dollar/
BRICS New Development Bank Threatens Hegemony Of U.S. Dollar
<snip>
At the 2014 BRICS summit in Fortaleza, Brazil, the committee announced its impatience with failed reform within the International Monetary Fund: We remain disappointed and seriously concerned with the current non-implementation of the 2010 International Monetary Fund reforms, which negatively impacts on the IMFs legitimacy, credibility and effectiveness. Leaders of the emerging economies of Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa (BRICS) have expressed the need for reform in the Bretton Woods institutions. Collectively, BRICS account for nearly $16 trillion in GDP and 40% of the worlds population. These countries have drafted amendments to the IMFs voting policy and have yet to receive a sufficient number of votes. At the summit, Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff stated the BRICS nations are among the largest in the world and cannot content themselves in the middle of the 21st century with any kind of dependency. Last June, Sergey Glazyev, Vladimir Putins chief economic advisor, published an article outlining the need for an international anti-dollar alliance. He called upon allies to eliminate the dollar from international trade and trend toward depleting them from currency reserves. Recent dollar-less BRICS energy deals, currency swaps and foreign direct investment indicate that trend is taking place.
This years summit marks the establishment of a $100 billion dollar liquidity reserve and a $50 billion New Development Bank (NBD) in Shanghai. As each country acts to maximize its own utility, the emerging economies of the BRICS nations will create a paralleling international financial system ultimately challenging the hegemony of the current western-dominated system.
newfie11
(8,159 posts)Let's hope cooler minds prevail. I Fear if the IMF feels threatened wars will happen.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)And, as a consequence, war is happening.
DetlefK
(16,670 posts)They do support the sanctions. The new greek government is simply pissed that their support for the sanctions has been taken for granted without even asking them.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)That was a very bold move in itself. We'll see what happens next.
FLPanhandle
(7,107 posts)You don't immediately piss off the same people you want to borrow more money from and renegociate existing loans.
Once Greece did that it was only 1 of 2 things:
1) They are very stupid; or
2) They had already lined up another source of money.
Now they can default on the EU debt while living off the new Russian/Chinese loans and exit the EU completely.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)One thing is certain, if Syriza now decides to capitulate to the EU and international bankers by going back to austerity, they will not remain in power very long.
DetlefK
(16,670 posts)Greece's statement misinterpreted
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/01/29/us-ukraine-crisis-greece-idUSKBN0L214020150129
Greece supports sanctions but wants to delay decision
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/01/29/us-ukraine-crisis-idUSKBN0L22B720150129
Excerpt:
"He (new greek foreign minister Nikos Kotzias) signed up to a sharply worded statement that declared Moscow responsible for the violence in eastern Ukraine and demanded it halt its backing for the separatists.
While the Greeks did call for the decision on tighter sanctions to be delayed, they were not alone: other countries such as Italy and Austria also favored a delay, diplomats said, while Britain and the Baltic states wanted a clearer commitment to imposing new sanctions quickly."
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)As for what Greece will ultimately do: I'll wait to see what the Greek government decides. They will make the decision, not a pack of bought-and-sold Western media issue experts.
love_me_some_pickles
(35 posts)one of it's oligarchs? Russia has no money, flat -assed broke. Their criminal government has ceded all wealthy to Putin's friends and partners.
If I ran Greece, I'd sooner go to the Goti family for a loan. Better rates.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)They can bail Greece out several times over and still have some left.
love_me_some_pickles
(35 posts)Do you know any more?
Arcanetrance
(2,670 posts)But it doesn't seem like a good idea to me to take the position of trying to renegotiate debt and get out of austerity just to go to a different country and ask for money from another country with whatever strings attached they might add.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Moscow does badly need a friend in the EU right now. And they do have the money Greece so badly needs.
DCBob
(24,689 posts)The Greeks are in for a rough ride no matter what.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Russia needs a friend in Europe badly enough that they may just hand over the cash and tell Greece the first repayment will be due in five or ten years. Wink, wink, nudge, nudge.
Nuclear Unicorn
(19,497 posts)another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Anything's better than paying taxes to a gang of German bankers.
TooPragmatic
(50 posts)And it is not to German banks. Most of the debt is held by other EU governments so a Greek default would hit other countries.
Ps. Sorry that I'm not using RT as a source.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/11372369/Three-myths-about-Greeces-enormous-debt-mountain.html
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Meant as a kind of shorthand for the fact that Greece's government has been taking from its people so it can pay the interest demanded by foreign bankers. The "tranches" of money Greece receives are immediately paid to those creditor banks. The IMF and EUCB only give Greece money so they can pay their creditors and keep them in the black. The Greek people are left with nothing but the debt and growing interest owed. Hence, it is like "Paying taxes to the German banks."
TooPragmatic
(50 posts)As in my previous comment, 3% of Greek debt is held by Greek banks, 1% by foreign banks. Most of the Creditors are other European countries and IMF and the ECB. If Greece defaults, it is out from other European citizens, not banks.
And ALL governments take from it's people to pay for interest. That is part of the social contract. And Greece uses money mainly on other things since it servicing costs on its debt is about 2.6% of GDP. If you want to respond to my comment, at least check the links I post.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Last edited Sat Jan 31, 2015, 02:07 PM - Edit history (2)
It was largely their money the ECB loaned to Greece, and they will lose as the ECB loses if Greece can't, or won't, make its repayments on time. It might be noted that the German banks bought a great many of the German and other EU government bonds which gave them means to contribute to the ECB.
TooPragmatic
(50 posts)ECB holds 6% of the Greek debt, the Euro-zone states own 60%. And the ECB gets it's money from natinonal central bank, Germany being the biggest but it is proportional to the size of each State.
And most of the debt is held through the EFSF which is a fund managed by the ECB, but the money is backed by each state. So if Greece doesn't pay, other European governments will largely suffer and thereby ALL European citizens will pay the bill with cuts or tax increases.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)But it is the bankers' money, invested in government bonds, that the governments will lose. The bankers' holdings of government bonds will be worth less, so it is still in large part the bankers' loss.
The bankers exposed to the most of such losses are German bankers, right?
TooPragmatic
(50 posts)The money lost if Greece defaulted wouldn't cause the same avalanche anymore as in 2010. The markets have prepared for the risk. The sums would harm other governments, but wouldn't lead to any defaults. Therefore there wouldn't be a big change in the bond markets.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Why are German bankers so upset at the prospect of Greek non-payment or even complete default? It seems like every news article I read on the subject references German bankers threatening dire consequences for Greece (or the whole Eurozone) if such things do come to pass. Isn't it reasonable to assume they must have something big at stake in the outcome? Is it just Teutonic cultural outrage at Southern European fiscal untidiness that I'm seeing?
Response to another_liberal (Original post)
Corruption Inc This message was self-deleted by its author.
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)I've seen in updates that the head of the euro zone finance ministers' group was visibly "enraged" by the Greek Finance Minister's refusal to obey EU dictates. This could force the Eurozone countries to take a long look at themselves, and at how much of their national independence and sovereignty they have delegated to a few financial technocrats.
seveneyes
(4,631 posts)Punished for his written thoughts
Starving for his fame
Working blindly, building blocks
Number for a name his blood flows frozen to the snow
another_liberal
(8,821 posts)Last edited Mon Feb 2, 2015, 07:54 PM - Edit history (1)
I've read many of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's works (English translations) including A Day In The Life of Ivan Denisovich, Cancer Ward, The First Circle, August, 1914 and The Gulag Archipelago (volumes One and Two). I do have some notion of what repression of dissenters means in that culture and of the cruelty it can involve.
treestar
(82,383 posts)It's one thing to talk and another to do.
