General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Empire Strikes Back
THE BAFFLER
The Empire Strikes Back
Scott Beauchamp May 14, 2015
The story itself has a dreamlike aura.
Seymour Hersh is a pioneer of investigative journalism, the modern iteration of which he fashioned almost singlehandedly by uncovering the 1968 My Lai massacre, during the Vietnam War. Americans had opposed the war before My Laieveryone knew what the American government was capable of, and many suspected that it was concealing the true extent of the horrors in Vietnambut Hershs 1969 dispatches gave them coordinates to navigate their outrage by. Hersh presented the facts in black and white. After Hershs revelations, skeptics on the left didnt have to feel like paranoids anymore. It turned out they had been right all along.
Hershs work in the aughts had much the same effect. In 2004, he exposed torture at Abu Ghraib. In 2008, he found that U.S. Special Forces were operating in Iran. The list goes on, with each discovery providing a single fleck of color. Take a step back to widen your field of vision, and youll be able to make out Hershs pointillist masterpiece: a painting of the lies the American elite have told to mask the lawless violence of pursuing their imperial ambitions.
Because of the penetration and scope of Hershs work, it is as much an indictment of the American medias coverage of elites as it is one of the American government. To engage with Hersh properly, even to criticise him, the media would necessarily have to break from its day-to-day reporting of political horse races and its slavish echoing of official narratives. It would have to expose the government to shrewd interrogation in the process. That being the case, Hershs work is important, even if parts of it do turn out to be inaccurate...
SNIP
...Predictably, many in the media have rushed to the governments defense. Hershs anonymous sources rankle them. The story itself, which is so far removed from the official narrative and implicates corruption at the highest levels of government, has a dreamlike aura. Never mind that the account the government gave has been deteriorating from the start, and the glaring contradictions between the official versions as related by the Pakistani and American governments. Put aside the fact that someone else using different sources reported a version of Hershs story in 2011, or that NBC, within a day, had already confirmed a key point of Hershs narrative. If Hershs critics actually did submerge themselves in a detailed re-reporting of his allegations, the process would subjugate the American ruling class to deeper scrutiny than usual...
http://www.thebaffler.com/blog/empire-strikes-back/
Enthusiast
(50,983 posts)FourScore
(9,704 posts)I bet Seymour Hersh knows a thing or two about that as well.
I'm surprised the man hasn't been killed.
MisterP
(23,730 posts)the "admission" that Iraq intel was "faulty" isn't just softpedaling their crimes, it seems almost nugatory, obvious, after over a million dead--the reaction from both the perps and the public is "yeah, and?"
MohRokTah
(15,429 posts)Octafish
(55,745 posts)No, wait, that was a Bush.
G_j
(40,366 posts)lawless violence of pursuing their imperial ambitions."