General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Ivy League, Mental Illness, and the Meaning of Life
The former Yale English professor William Deresiewicz stirred up quite a storm earlier this month with his New Republic essay Dont Send Your Kid to the Ivy Leaguea damning critique of the nations most revered and wealthy educational institutions, and the flawed meritocracy they represent. He takes these arguments even further in his upcoming book, Excellent Sheep: The Miseducation of the American Elite and the Way to a Meaningful Life.
Deresiewicz, who is also the author of A Jane Austen Education: How Six Novels Taught Me About Love, Friendship and the Things That Really Matter, spoke to me on the phone from his home in Portland, Oregon.
How does the phrase excellent sheep describe the typical student at an elite college today?
The most interesting thing about that phrase is that I didnt write it myself. It came out of the mouth of a student of mine, and just seemed perfect. Theyre excellent because they have fulfilled all the requirements for getting into an elite college, but its very narrow excellence. These are kids who will perform to the specifications you define, and they will do that without particularly thinking about why theyre doing it. They just know that they will jump the next hoop.
Youve observed that Ivy League students have an internal struggle with both grandiosity and depression. Can you explain this further?
Alice Miller wrote about this 30 plus years ago in the classic The Drama of the Gifted Child, but I had to experience it to see it for myself. The grandiosity is that sense of youre the greatest, youre the best, youre the brightest. This kind of praise and reinforcement all the time makes students feel theyre the greatest kid in the world. And I would say that this is even worse than when I was a kid. Now theres a whole culture of parenting around this positive reinforcement.
These kids were always the best of their class, and their teachers were always praising them, inflating their ego. But its a false self-esteem. Its not real self-possession, where you are measuring yourself against your own internal standards and having a sense that youre working towards something. Its totally conditional, and constantly has to be pumped up by the next grade, the next A, or gold star. "
http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2014/08/qa-the-miseducation-of-our-college-elite/377524/
flamingdem
(39,313 posts)but I chose a progressive college with no grades.
This article brings me a slight sense of glee.
woolldog
(8,791 posts)That's too bad.