Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTrapped in the System: A Sick Doctor’s Story
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/22/upshot/trapped-in-the-system-a-sick-doctors-story.html
There is no bad guy here. I love the drug company that created this medication. The price is more than reasonable. I love the doctor who prescribed it to me. My insurance company has never refused to cover my care, and has always been honest with me. The laboratory personnel are professional and competent. Its the system the way all these things work, or fail to work, together thats the issue.
The Affordable Care Act, which seems so complicated to so many, was almost entirely about getting more people in the United States health insurance. That was just a first step, arguably an easy one, and were still fighting about it. Reforming the ways in which we actually deliver care and try to improve outcomes? Thats so much more important, and we barely talk about that at all. But thats what matters to the people who use the system, and its why so many of them are frustrated.
Because of my job, I probably know more about the health care system and how it works than most people in the United States. Yet if this is how much trouble I have navigating a simple refilling of my medication, I dont know how the rest of America does it, especially those with much more complicated issues than mine.
Answers to your questions about Trapped in the System: A Sick Doctors Story
http://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/answers-to-your-questions-about-trapped-in-the-system-a-sick-doctors-story/
I received more than my usual share of feedback from this weeks Upshot column. I thought I might answer some of the most common comments and questions here:
1. If we only had a single payer system. That would fix this, right?
Well, Im not sure. I understand your impulse, but that would only solve some of the insurance problems. Medicare for all wouldnt make it so that the lab, pharmacy, and doctors office shared an information system, or could even reliably share information. It wouldnt change the fact that I need to jump through the order hoops, or the authorization hoops. It might make things easier, but it wouldnt solve all of the problems. Ask people who have Medicare (which is much closer to single payer) if things are seamless. I doubt youll get a universally positive response.
http://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/answers-to-your-questions-about-trapped-in-the-system-a-sick-doctors-story/
I received more than my usual share of feedback from this weeks Upshot column. I thought I might answer some of the most common comments and questions here:
1. If we only had a single payer system. That would fix this, right?
Well, Im not sure. I understand your impulse, but that would only solve some of the insurance problems. Medicare for all wouldnt make it so that the lab, pharmacy, and doctors office shared an information system, or could even reliably share information. It wouldnt change the fact that I need to jump through the order hoops, or the authorization hoops. It might make things easier, but it wouldnt solve all of the problems. Ask people who have Medicare (which is much closer to single payer) if things are seamless. I doubt youll get a universally positive response.
Comment by Don McCanne of PNHP: Dr. Aaron Carrolls frank discussion of his chronic medical problem and the nuisances he faces in interacting with our health care system struck a chord with many - both for the empathy engendered because of his medical condition, and especially for the crying shame that this prominent physician has to go through hoops to make our health care system work for him, suggesting that it might not work well for any of us.
Of the over 700 responses that he received, a common theme was that he wouldnt have these problems if we had a single payer system. He responds that he is not sure. He suggests that people on Medicare, as a proxy for single payer, may find that their care is not so seamless either. Well, he hasnt experienced Medicare as a patient since he is still on his employer-sponsored plan, and he hasnt experienced Medicare directly as a physician either since he is a pediatrician.
I think that I can help him on this. I am a family physician, now retired from practice, and I never had the problems with my Medicare patients that I had with my managed care patients - problems similar to those he describes. I also have a few chronic disorders myself that require interaction with the health care system. I am covered under the traditional Medicare program with a Medigap supplement. I have had none of the problems that Dr. Carroll describes, except for nuisance requirements and limitations for my Part D drug coverage - but then Part D, by design, is much more like the managed care coverage that creates barriers to care (restrictive formularies, limited choice of pharmacies, logistical hurdles in filling prescriptions, etc.).
He is correct that interoperability of computer systems remains a problem, but that is a failure of George Bush and David Brailer in insisting that interoperability issues be left to the private sector to address. Players in the private sector strive for dominance and depend on a lack of interoperability to keep competitors out. The government is now encouraging improvements in interoperability, but how do you fix the mess that has been created? At any rate, the prospects for improving interoperability would be much greater under a single payer - improved Medicare for all - than they are under our fragmented, competitive multi-payer system.
Dr. Carroll says there is no bad guy here, but that Its the system the way all these things work, or fail to work, together thats the issue. But thats the point. Having our entire health care delivery system integrated under a well-designed single payer model would make the system work far better for all of us - patients and physicians alike.
(Aaron Carroll is a professor of pediatrics at Indiana University School of Medicine. He is a highly respected authority in health policy who blogs in The New York Times, The Incidental Economist, and JAMA. He is co-author of a widely-quoted study demonstrating that three-fifths of physicians "support government legislation to establish national health insurance."
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
0 replies, 800 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (5)
ReplyReply to this post