General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDU'ers defending this! WTF is wrong with you people?
This discussion thread was locked as off-topic by pintobean (a host of the General Discussion forum).

http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1014&pid=1243490
LuvNewcastle
(17,821 posts)I guess he has the hickory stick?
erlewyne
(1,115 posts)I'll bet if the police officer had it to do over
this would not have happened. I cannot
understand physical abuse.
He will have to live with this the rest of his life.
Bettie
(19,704 posts)and yet, every cop who does something like this comes up with justification as to why it "had" to happen. Why he had no choice, it was all his victim's fault, after all.
"Live with it the rest of his life"? Yeah, that would indicate a conscience. People who do this kind of thing don't seem to have that.
PatSeg
(53,214 posts)will tell you the same thing - the abuser will try and justify what he's done and blame the victim. "Why do you make me hit you?" mentality.
Bettie
(19,704 posts)when I was a child, I heard all the time "if you didn't do X, I wouldn't need to hit you, you deserve this".
Oh and, "well, you are the only girl around now that your mother left and it is up to you to fill her place since she left because you are such a brat". (Yeah, that means what it sounds like.)
PatSeg
(53,214 posts)they are reading from the same script. It is difficult to forgive violent behavior, if the abuser continues to blame the victim.
awoke_in_2003
(34,582 posts)Even if the prick gets fired, he will be working for another PD somewhere. The pig should be in jail.
Madmiddle
(459 posts)yuiyoshida
(45,409 posts)This is the kind of world Donald Trump wants!
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10027291206
Beausoir
(7,540 posts)randys1
(16,286 posts)all cops will almost ALWAYS cover for those who are.
denbot
(9,950 posts)If this happened to their own kid I'd imagine the song would change.
Vinca
(53,992 posts)Please tell me this guy has been arrested.
Glimmer of Hope
(5,823 posts)Lee-Lee
(6,324 posts)And you know what? There is no defending this. Scumbag shouldn't have a badge and Damm sure never shouldn't have ever been made an SRO.
Some departments see the SRO job as a place to dump the problem officers nobody wants to work with instead of doing the right thing and getting rid of them. I ponder if that is the case here.
There could have come a point in the interaction where the use of force was justified in order to get the girl into compliance. Based on all I saw this wasn't the case at this point by a long shot, there should have been a lot more verbal commands, followed by use of "soft hands" to move the student. Jumping straight to that level of violence is in no way justified.
Fire him, prosecute him. SC seems to have been doing well prosecuting bad cops, let's hope they keep up the trend here.
Mariana
(15,624 posts)My high school had a "resource officer" back in the 1980's. We plagued that man on purpose, teased him. baited him, pranked him. He remained level and calm, as he should have done. There were real crimes taking place at my school, and he was there to deal with those. It was not his job to enforce routine discipline or breaking of minor school rules.
Lee-Lee
(6,324 posts)They more and more often in many schools see the SRO as the default go-to disciplinarian. They intentionally hand off issues and cases to the SRO that have no business being handled in any way by the cops- but they do it because of a combination of laziness, unwillingness to deal with problems, and a fear of actually disciplining kids.
Hell, we saw that with the issue in Texas with the kid with the clock. The teachers and admin knew it wasn't a bomb. They had no worries it was a danger- so why the hell did they call the cops? Because they were lazy and didn't want to actually handle the issue themselves like adults but wanted somone else to do the hard part for them and make the hard decisions.
It's sad- instead of using the SRO's to handle issues that are legitimate law enforcement issues and to provide security school administrators and teachers are dumping every tiny discipline problem to the cops because they don't want to do their job like responsible adults. By shoving it to the cops they can avoid the responsibility for having to discipline the students.
It's actually what led to me leaving law enforcement- we had a new Sheriff elected and he reorganized everything and told me I could either be a SRO in a school where they did just that or I didn't have a job. I left and took a voluntary Army Reserve tour in Afghanistan and had another department holding my certifcation as a part timer. Well the chief of the small department died suddenly, and the new one got rid of all part time officers and that made me go over a year without being employed and all my credentials went dead- so I would have had to start all over from the beginning.
Xyzse
(8,217 posts)I actually needed that piece of information.
Mariana
(15,624 posts)They absolutely are in the wrong when they call in police for this kind of thing. The officers assigned to schools should be able (and willing) to refuse to handle stuff like this, and their departments should back them up. With the exception of some child-haters who get a charge out of seeing "bratty" kids being beat up, I don't think many people really want the police being called in to use force to deal with minor discipline issues.
GOLGO 13
(1,681 posts)Most just know & deal accordingly.
mercuryblues
(16,411 posts)in your scenario is calling the kid's parent? When have schools stopped doing that? In all these cases I have not heard where the parents were called, before the abuse and arrest.
riversedge
(80,808 posts)in dealing with people. She was not armed and the classroom should have been cleared and the officer should have called for help. No excuses for his behavior.
hobbit709
(41,694 posts)trumad
(41,692 posts)I'm like huh?
n2doc
(47,953 posts)Really wonder why they stay here.
JackInGreen
(2,975 posts)The ones that stay still have hearts, might be smallish, but they have em.
I know a few IRL that have come here and a couple that stayed. We tend to consider ourselves mutually so far left and right we smoke around the back.
OneGrassRoot
(23,953 posts)Bettie
(19,704 posts)None whatsoever.
trumad
(41,692 posts)She should have complied.
Bettie
(19,704 posts)because we're all supposed to comply at all times.
Isn't that how a bunch of women got raped by cops in Texas? By complying?
I used to argue that there are good cops. I don't make that argument anymore because the 'good' cops allow the ones who would do this continue and cover for them. They encourage this kind of thing by never saying a word about it.
randys1
(16,286 posts)Bettie
(19,704 posts)are in the cop's corner.
And people always look for reasons to blame the victim. I swear, victim blaming is a hobby for many, they search for reasons why the cop or vigilante is not at fault, but the victim practically harmed him or herself.
Chan790
(20,176 posts)the only things that comply mindlessly to authority are sheep. So that's how I'm interpreting defenders of this...they think we should be compliant sheep that quake at the authority of the state.
I wonder how many of them comprehend that we are the state, not the elected officials and "peacekeepers" (irony quotes because that officer surely was not keeping the peace) we empower.
BeanMusical
(4,389 posts)malthaussen
(18,567 posts)... is the apparent belief that, when there is no compliance, there is no limit to the means used to coerce it. Arguing about whether or not she should "obey orders" is an interesting screen to the deeper question of appropriateness of response.
-- Mal
PatSeg
(53,214 posts)It seems there are no degrees in the response to noncompliance with today's law enforcement, it is just "off" and "on".
w0nderer
(1,937 posts)winning the hearts and minds of people everywhere
way over response unless she actually pulled a weapon of some sort
Response to trumad (Original post)
NCTraveler This message was self-deleted by its author.
Mariana
(15,624 posts)if this had been done to a 40 year old woman who had refused to leave, let's say, a public library. I think some of them just hate young people and enjoy seeing them "put in their place".
justiceischeap
(14,040 posts)there wouldn't be all this police violence.
The one question I haven't seen answered about this is why the student was asked to leave the class in the first place. What had she "done" to deserve this level of violence? Of course, I don't think there's an excuse for this level of violence unless the student is brandishing a weapon and threatening others around her.
Mariana
(15,624 posts)that they thought she deserved it because she was being a "brat" in school. I suspect they would be just fine with white kids who are "brats" being beat up, too.
RedRocco
(454 posts)justiceischeap
(14,040 posts)Still not a valid reason for that level of violence but at least now my curiousity is sated.
mnhtnbb
(33,348 posts)Then an administrator was called to the room to get her to come out of class.
She refused.
It certainly doesn't seem like the school officials have a reasonable plan when a student
resists complying with teacher/administrator requests, if their next step is forcible
removal of a student by an officer.
randys1
(16,286 posts)have to beat 98% of all kids in America who do the exact same thing ALL the fucking time.
justiceischeap
(14,040 posts)She just goes on working, so the excuse of disrupting the class is a moot point. What's more disruptive, sitting in a chair, refusing to leave a room or throwing a child into another child's desk as she studies?
Mariana
(15,624 posts)than the student ever could have been. How much learning went on after that incident? I bet not much, and not just in that classroom during that class period, but in the whole school, once word began to spread about the assault.
randys1
(16,286 posts)when Cpt Hunnicutt shows up to replace Trapper John in Season 4, they get back to the unit and are in Rosie's bar and a fight breaks out. Hawkeye and Radar react like it isnt happening at all, the new guy, Hunnicutt is all freaked out.
NCTraveler
(30,481 posts)It is domestic terrorism. I truly don't think that is hyperbole.
geek tragedy
(68,868 posts)Ed Suspicious
(8,879 posts)randome
(34,845 posts)Cop already has a lawsuit pending against him.
[hr][font color="blue"][center]"The whole world is a circus if you know how to look at it."
Tony Randall, 7 Faces of Dr. Lao (1964)[/center][/font][hr]
deutsey
(20,166 posts)Why couldn't Officer Weightlifter, as you say, just pick the girl and the desk up and carry her out into the hallway? He was supposed to remove her from the room from what I understand. I doubt the order was to fling her to floor and drag her around like a rag doll.
mnhtnbb
(33,348 posts)JackInGreen
(2,975 posts)"You're such a Bobby badass there cheif, carry her out desk n all....with a smile." No instead it's a choke slam and scene from a horror movie.
trumad
(41,692 posts)Cause I got juried.
DocMac
(1,628 posts)list yesterday. It was long overdue.
SwankyXomb
(2,030 posts)when you call them out over their authoritarian bullshit.
sinkingfeeling
(57,835 posts)shouldn't be allowed near a school or anybody under the age of 21!
Ed Suspicious
(8,879 posts)Prople defending that cop's actions long for fascism.
get the red out
(14,031 posts)One would hope the school could call a parent if a student was too disruptive and refused to leave the class as requested.
Mariana
(15,624 posts)My daughter developed a behavior problem in elementary school, one she never displayed at home. The teacher finally called me, but only after it had been going on for months. I was not pleased.
get the red out
(14,031 posts)I don't have kids, but it only seems right to keep parents informed.
Mariana
(15,624 posts)I know lots of people like to blame the parents for any misbehavior by their children, but when it happens at school, we don't see it and can't correct it if we aren't told about it. Most kids, even very young kids, are plenty smart enough to figure out that they can get away with different behaviors with different people. Hell, my cat knows that much.
mountain grammy
(29,035 posts)It's an assault on a young girl, in broad daylight, in front of witnesses, who are getting the message. You could be next. Sickening.
abelenkpe
(9,933 posts)I cannot believe anyone would defend or justify that. Especially here on DU.
Photographer
(1,142 posts)SharonAnn
(14,173 posts)That helps solve a lot of discipline in their school. Not so much in the public schools where the child was then sent.
bullwinkle428
(20,662 posts)K&R.
Volaris
(11,703 posts)Because of course cops in SCHOOLS should have firearms. . .
1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)should we wait for all the facts to come out? The girl could've said something really bad about the cops mother!
{Do I need to put this:
, here?}
JustAnotherGen
(38,054 posts)SmittynMo
(3,544 posts)We don't know all the facts. We've seen it over and over before. People refuse to do as requested, and you see the results. If a cop tells me to get out of the chair and leave, that's exactly what I would have done. I'm guessing here, the student refused to participate.
However, there is no way I could support the officer and his actions here. Was he threatened? I didn't see that at all. Even if the student refused to listen, this should not have been the result. There are other ways to deal with uncooperative people.
SmittynMo
(3,544 posts)You are right. We don't know all the facts. We've seen it over and over before. People refuse to do as requested, and you see the results. If a cop tells me to get out of the chair and leave, that's exactly what I would have done. I'm guessing here, the student refused to participate.
However, there is no way I could support the officer and his actions here. Was he threatened? I didn't see that at all. Even if the student refused to listen, this should not have been the result. There are other ways to deal with uncooperative people.
1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)There is nothing, short of that student producing a weapon, that would justify what this cop did ... NOTHING!
Yes. We have seen this over and over again ... People refuse to do as DEMANDED and we see the results ... cops forcing compliance of kids using excessive force.
I suspect that maybe because you life's relationship with law enforcement, and authority, is markedly difference from that of the average Black person ... compliance, means little to those bound and determined to escalate any resistance, whether real or perceived. And society, until very recently, has it that for some people, acing on other people ... it's no big deal.
trumad
(41,692 posts)Not one.
TheKentuckian
(26,314 posts)dorkzilla
(5,141 posts)I saw the video of him lifting...this guy is a walking roid rage.
They really need to start testing cops for this shit.
LWolf
(46,179 posts)posted to a teachers' group on FB. Not a single teacher was defending that assault on the student. Every single one was calling for the removal of that "officer" from public school grounds and from his job.
malthaussen
(18,567 posts)I suppose if she had been injured, it would have been written off as "collateral damage."
What I like is the people who justify this because a whole class period might be lost if the situation were dealt with more rationally. You know, because every second of a student's life is critical to his mastering the material.
-- Mal
alcibiades_mystery
(36,437 posts)Submission, violence, white supremacy, meekness in the face of abuse.
These were the lessons in class that day, taught with fist and muscle. Anyone who justifies this behavior of this SRO on educational grounds is a psychotic.
bonniebgood
(958 posts)is pure violence being accepted and condoned by our Government. I really would like to know the family makeup of this officer? I would love to hear what sort of person he really is.
ladyVet
(1,587 posts)It's uncalled for. Not only could he have seriously injured this student, but what about that poor kid whose desk got rammed? Jeebus.
There's no excuse for a grown man to assault a child. Even if this student was threatening others, there are ways to calm down a situation without throwing them across the room and dragging them out like a rabid dog.
I do wonder, if this had been a white student, would this have happened? I hate to think so, but probably not.
gollygee
(22,336 posts)and some who will always find African Americans "deserved it."
bread_and_roses
(6,335 posts)Years ago, now. On this site - a story about a five year old girl handcuffed and arrested in class ... there was a photo of the child, mouth agape in the kind of full out terrified cry that only very little children do ... handcuffed and arrested for misbehaving in kindergarden .... She was - of course - a little black girl ... it might have been in Florida. madfloridian would remember it, I think.
and people here defending and justifying that.
Authoritarians come in red AND blue. Child-haters too.
JackInGreen
(2,975 posts)that swine still deserves a full gutting and roasting for that shit.
blackspade
(10,056 posts)It's pathetic.
RKP5637
(67,112 posts)cwydro
(51,308 posts)It's been reported that he's a powerlifter.
Big tough guy beating up a little girl.
WDIM
(1,662 posts)Prosecuted. If she us under 18 that is battery of a minor. Cops do not have a right to lay their hands on a person sitting in a chair. They are not above the law the only way officers are going to learn is to prosecute!
brush
(61,033 posts)Aren't women officers supposed to be brought if hands have to be put on a female?
WDIM
(1,662 posts)Bet he felt real tough.
Our police officers need mental evaluations to determine how prone they are towards violence and aggression and if they are they should be fired.
jtuck004
(15,882 posts)Thats because a recent study suggests motorists are less likely to stop for an African American pedestrian in a crosswalk. A black pedestrians wait time at the curb was about 32 percent longer than a white persons. Black pedestrians were about twice as likely as white pedestrians to be passed by multiple vehicles.
The small but provocative study conducted by researchers at Portland State University in Oregon and the University of Arizona suggests that biases just outside peoples conscious awareness can make them less likely to yield to minority pedestrians. And that could put those pedestrians at risk, said Kimberly B. Kahn, an assistant professor of social psychology at Portland State University.
Put another way: Not only do black men have to worry about being hassled and possibly shot by police for simply being black, they have to worry about being run over by motorists. Kahn said a follow-up study is underway to see whether drivers also discriminate based on gender and whether crosswalk design and signage might change driver behavior.
But can it change deep-rooted stereotypes? Ralph Ellison devoted a novel to the profound invisibility of African Americans. Researchers have shown the same thing. Taxi drivers roll past black people hailing taxis. Doctors miss telltale signs of critical medical conditions. Teachers fail to see a minority childs gifts.
...
http://field-negro.blogspot.com/2015/10/while-black.html
That officer treated her like she was some kind of less-than-human object. Too common occurrence. And now we can add sitting.
KeepItReal
(7,770 posts)Police know who they can mess with.
Or rather *used* to know who they could mess with.
Social media gives the formerly powerless a way to show the world how differently people of color or the poor are policed and administered.
d_r
(6,908 posts)I'm too angry and sad to be able to write this very eloquently, but this is just a reflection of a deeper problem. A problem we've always had in this country. A problem before Brown vs. Board of ed, a problem when the mobs were wanting to lynch the little rock 9, a problem of white flight and bussing in the 70s, a problem of the achievement gap in the 2000s.
Look at how the rest of those kids in that class are keeping their heads down trying not to look or be noticed.
Look at the administrator there to observe the situation.
They run schools like they are damn military prison camps.
Look, corporal punishment is legal in 19 states. Black kids and poor kids are more likely to receive it than other kids. In those and other states black kids and poor kids are more likely to get in school and out of school suspension.
And then we wonder why the drop out rate is higher for black kids. We wonder why there is an achievement gap for black kids and poor kids.
Its because school isn't a safe place to be for many kids. Its because it is a place run like a prison boot camp where you are assumed guilty until proven innocent which you will never be because you have no right to talk back. You are only digging your hole deeper and I advise you to stop digging. You have no rights.
We do this. Our society is what does this.
TBF
(36,667 posts)There is absolutely no excuse for this.
just based on the comments in the related articles...it seems that the school district wants him out of the schools but the Sheriff thinks there is nothing wrong with his conduct...so that's going to come down to a fight of whose authority is bigger: the school district to bar him from the school vs. the sheriff who seems committed to going to bat for his guy and will probably refuse to assign a different deputy to the school...and most places with SROs require the school to have one, so if the sheriff says "You've got no choice but this guy"...this could get messy.
BeanMusical
(4,389 posts)How can anyone defend this? Blaming the victim and approving what this maniac did is disgusting.
heaven05
(18,124 posts)DOES NOT SURPRISE ME IN THE LEAST. Disgusting how a child of color can be treated as such and the cop, ON HERE, can be defended as using appropriate behavior in getting compliance, from a person of color, to his demands. White kid? Never would have happened. But precedent has been set, Tamir Rice, Sandra Bland. Some DUer's love to see this type of violence against children and women OF COLOR. That's is a verifiable fact on here.
Madness but not surprising
KingCharlemagne
(7,908 posts)Copologists would have slunk back to their caves. Alas, you would be wrong.
freebrew
(1,917 posts)someone was saying the cops were right about Michael Brown.
I'm not sure what they meant by that and I was in no mood to give them the satisfaction of an audience.
We are citizens, we don't have to 'comply' to authority.
Every time something like this happens it drives this country further into
disintegration.
This needs to stop. It will stop when the people start fighting back en masse.
JustAnotherGen
(38,054 posts)I noticed on your thread the one or two mary mary quite contraries got sufficiently dragged by the site in general.
randome
(34,845 posts)[hr][font color="blue"][center]Stop looking for heroes. BE one.[/center][/font][hr]
BlueJazz
(25,348 posts)...there are times when their rude actions (cussing you out, throwing stuff at you), can certainly work on your nerves.
The thing is though: You can't act on ANY of your negative feelings. You're quite aware that these troubled people need help and YOU playing out some childish fantasy (like the cop did) is also childish and immature and certainly not the adult thing to do...plus helps no one.
I could never do what that cop pulled but I can understand that a small part of me slightly understands how someone who is unbalanced can do unspeakable things.
The Blue Flower
(6,490 posts)It's clear to me that this asshole has everyone in that school afraid of him. One can only imagine what would have happened to anyone who tried to stop him.
KittyWampus
(55,894 posts)A few agreed it was out of line but expressed their concern for the rest of the students and teachers losing valuable education time.
Apparently expressing two different opinions and seeing other larger issues instead of just reacting with outrage is verboten on DU.
trumad
(41,692 posts)1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)KittyWampus
(55,894 posts)What difference does that make to pointing out some DU'ers who voiced concern about the violent officer AND students losing education time needlessly got pilloried in that other thread?
1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)LanternWaste
(37,748 posts)It's an accurate study in contrasts... as one group is overwhelmingly concerned with abuse of a student, while another group minimizes that and voices an alleged concern with time being wasted.
Even the most sub-literate dullard recognizes the distinction between merely playing devil's advocate and rationalizing the absurd. And illustrating that is hardly a bad thing... unless of course, one believes that justifying the absurd is itself, hardly a bad thing.
tenderfoot
(8,982 posts)they should be PPR'd post haste.
Thespian2
(2,741 posts)perhaps they would like to replace the young girl and let the brute do the same to them...
womanofthehills
(10,988 posts)She could have died from injuries because she took her phone out - He is 300 lbs and she is 5'6.
Also arrested, a female student who stuck up for her.
http://www.wltx.com/story/news/local/2015/10/27/second-student-arrested-spring-valley-hs-speaks-out/74665360/
frizzled
(509 posts)nt
LiberalArkie
(19,803 posts)Look at the girl in the picture, she did not seem surprised at all except when the "peace officer" slammed the chair into her.
IDemo
(16,926 posts)Some threads seem to bring them in like moths to a flame.
IVoteDFL
(417 posts)There is zero defense for this. It's sick that some apparently tried.
BumRushDaShow
(169,745 posts)DU has been infested for some time and you see the ilk arise in thread after thread.
You had people defending this too -

They are no different than the leering slave master "Tom Moore" so elegantly portrayed by Chuck Connors in Roots.
tabasco
(22,974 posts)Sickening to see them here.
Solly Mack
(96,942 posts)There is no defense for it.
tenderfoot
(8,982 posts)Authoritarians are consistent in that way.
pintobean
(18,101 posts)Discuss politics, issues, and current events. Posts about Israel/Palestine, religion, guns, showbiz, or sports are restricted in this forum. Posts about the Democratic primaries, conspiracy theories and disruptive meta-discussion are forbidden.
And from Skinner's pinned thread
Positive threads about Democratic Underground or its members are are permitted.
Threads complaining about Democratic Underground or its members; threads complaining about jury decisions, locked threads, suspensions, bannings, or the like; and threads intended to disrupt or negatively influence the normal workings of Democratic Underground and its community moderating system are not permitted.