General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSupreme Court Halts Historic Hawaiian Election
by Chris D'Angelo, Associate Editor, HuffPost Hawaii
The U.S. Supreme Court has temporarily blocked a historic and controversial election from moving forward in Hawaii.
Native Hawaiians are currently nearing the end of a month-long election to select delegates for a constitutional convention, but on Friday, Justice Anthony Kennedy issued an order blocking both the counting of votes and the certification of any winners "pending further order" by the court.
The election is seen by many as a first step for Native Hawaiian self-determination. The elected delegates would attend a constitutional convention and recommend a form of self-government, deciding what -- if any -- relationship that government should have with the United States.
But opponents of the election say the process is unconstitutional and racially exclusive.
A group of native and non-native residents is challenging the election, arguing Hawaii residents who don't have Native Hawaiian ancestry are being excluded from a vote that affects the state. They also argue that the election is racially exclusive and therefore unconstitutional.
Attorneys representing Hawaii have argued that the state isn't involved in the election -- an argument that a federal judge agreed with last month. In October, U.S. District Court Judge J. Michael Seabright said the election was legal since it was a private poll being conducted by the private nonprofit Nai Aupuni.
Nai Aupuni said in a statement Friday that Native Hawaiian self-governance has been discussed for over two hundred years without tangible results. And despite the recent ruling, the group remains confident that the election will ultimately be ruled legal.
"Reorganizing a government is not easy and it takes the courage and will of the candidates to take the first step in this historic process," Nai Aupuni said.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/supreme-court-halts-hawaiian-election_5658c6e8e4b08e945feb3ecc
CincyDem
(6,351 posts)I'm sure they're basking in the success of their last foray into the realm of electoral politics.
Sheesh
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)Only people born in Pennsylvania could vote in Pennsylvania for example. Or only Irish can vote in Massachusetts. The Supreme Court got this one right so far.
Nye Bevan
(25,406 posts)No thanks. I'm glad the SCOTUS stopped it.
Democat
(11,617 posts)There are enough problems without going back to the past.
GGJohn
(9,951 posts)An election based on ancestry or skin color has no place in America.
uawchild
(2,208 posts)The issue is that native ethnic Hawaiians are just trying to get rights similar to those of other Native Americans, like the Navajo tribal nation for example. Currently, they are the only aboriginal group of people in the US denied those rights and benefits, I believe.
The election is question is about ethnic Hawaiians organizing themselves and selecting representatives to argue their case with the US Federal government. People complaining it's some how racist are missing the point, that would be akin to saying non-Navajo's should be allowed to vote in Navajo tribal elections.
EndElectoral
(4,213 posts)2naSalit
(86,528 posts)gladium et scutum
(806 posts)But only Navajo tribal members on the Navajo reservations vote in their elections. Does a person of Navajo ancestry get to vote in Reservation elections if they reside in New York City? Is there a reservation for Native Hawaiians or an Island populated exclusively by them, I don't know. If there is a type of reservation, by all means all who reside there should be eligible should be able to vote. From the way this issue sounds the election was to be across all of the islands, regardless of residency, but restricted to those claiming native status.
yuiyoshida
(41,831 posts)I just viewed a video documentary about How Hawaiians came to Hawaii, and the history about Hawaii up and until statehood, in 1959. I am part native Hawaiian.. so this is very interesting to me, thanks for posting.