Vox and the False Consensus of ‘Most Economists Agree’
Source: FAIR (Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting)
When it launched in 2014, new media outlet Vox prided itself on having an analysis-driven approach, explaining the news to its readers in a clear and concise way. A rhetorical tic appearing in much of their reporting, however, belies those noble motives: the reliance on phantom economic and expert consensus.
Given that Vox does little original reporting, much of their selling point is quick, easy-to-understand analysis. A meaningful amount of this analysis, however, pivots on the toxic cliche, most economists agree/think/say/believe, and its equally toxic cousin, most experts agree/think/say/believe. This cliche is frequently used without a shred of evidence for said consensus.
Vox is by no means alone. This is a common trope found at the The Economist and other wonky neoliberal outlets. The problem with the refrain, aside from the fact that its a weasel phrase that wouldnt pass muster in a 10th grade rhetoric class, is that its designed to posture, to aggrandize an argument based solely on the insertion of an entirely made-up consensus of bespectacled, important men hovering over data and dispassionately reaching conclusions that happen to dovetail with the authors own positions.
Read more:
http://fair.org/home/vox-and-the-false-consensus-of-most-economists-agree/