General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsPolitico: The Problem With Trump's Admiration of General Patton
http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/12/trump-general-patton-admiration-214545-snip-
Pattons rescue of cornered GIs at Bastogne erased his most famous blunder of the war, which occurred in two hospital tents in Sicily in 1943 when he infamously confronted two traumatized soldiers and slapped them. Patton had no concept of the disease that was then called shell shock, and we now know as Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. Wars were about winning and glory, and his subsequent apologies, ordered by his friend and superior, Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower, were entirely pro forma. He told colleagues that the soldiers were cowards and that the slappinghe also brandished a pistol at one of the soldiershad saved their souls. It is rather a commentary on justice when an Army commander has to soft-soap a skulker to placate the timidity of those above, Patton wrote in his diary.
-snip-
Disturbingly, Patton had zero sympathy for the Holocaust victims living in wretched, overcrowded collection camps under his command. He was unable to imagine that people living in such misery were not there because of their own flaws. The displaced Jews were locusts, lower than animals, lost to all decency. They were a subhuman species without any of the cultural or social refinements of our times, Patton wrote in his diary. A United Nations aid worker tried to explain that they were traumatized, but personally I doubt it. I have never looked at a group of people who seem to be more lacking in intelligence and spirit. (Patton was no friend to Arabs, either; in a 1943 letter, he called them the mixture of all the bad races on earth.)
-snip-
He saw journalists criticism of his handling of the Jews and the return of Nazis to high official positions as a result of Jewish and Communist plots. The New York Times and other publications were trying to do two things, he wrote, First, implement Communism, and second, see that all business men of German ancestry and non-Jewish antecedents are thrown out of their jobs.
As reports on the conditions in Bavaria began to alarm Truman, Eisenhower came down from Frankfurt on September 17 to join Patton on a tour of the camps where Jewish refugees were housed. He was horrified to find that some of the guards were former SS men. During the tour, Patton remarked that the camps had been clean and decent before the arrival of the Jewish DPs (displaced persons), who were pissing and crapping all over the place. Eisenhower told Patton to shut up, but he continued his diatribe, telling Eisenhower he planned to make a nearby German village a concentration camp for some of these goddam Jews.
While Eisenhower ordered him to stop mollycoddling Nazis, Patton lashed out at journalists and others he viewed as enemies. The noise against me is only the means by which the Jews and Communist are attempting and with good success to implement a further dismemberment of Germany, he said.
-snip-
To those whove studied Patton closely, Trumps view of the general as the ultimate winner is troubling. The headstrong gunslinger type can be effective in the right setting, and Patton was undeniably effective at the job he was sent to do. But he was even more plainly wrong about the big things, and represented a set of values that America had already left behind as it began to build its power on tolerance and engagement with the world, rather than nativist nationalism.
pangaia
(24,324 posts)Frightening is it not...
If trump thinks he is patton, he isn't far off, less the military smarts...if patton really had those even..
mountain grammy
(26,620 posts)Patton was a dirty word in our house, as was MacArthur.
safeinOhio
(32,675 posts)A decorated officer in the battle of the Bulge.
no_hypocrisy
(46,094 posts)yallerdawg
(16,104 posts)MADem
(135,425 posts)what PATTON was all about. In actual fact, he knows what George C. Scott as PATTON is all about.
He slapped the shit out of his kid, Diaper Don, the Wharton drunkard, so maybe he's a fan of Patton's famous slapping incident. Scott portrayed that to brilliant effect in the film.
He'd probably like PATTON a lot less (or George C. Scott as PATTON) if he remembered that George C. Scott never picked up his OSCAR for the role...as he said (a smart man, ahead of his time, really) "The ceremonies are a two-hour meat parade, a public display with contrived suspense for economic reasons."
http://mentalfloss.com/article/30074/8-academy-award-nominees-and-winners-who-snubbed-oscars
Cirque du So-What
(25,936 posts)'Our blood, his guts,' as many a GI observed.
lapucelle
(18,252 posts)of Patton's perspective.
Another part of the biography that Trump gets wrong is that he paints Patton as a "school of hard knocks" type. Patton came from a patrician and privileged background.