General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIf we unfairly denigrate Democratic leaders, such as Thom
Hartmann, the most popular progressive radio personality, we are making our sides weaker and engaging in circular firing squad.
We are also violating DU Terms of Service such as:
********
No divisive group attacks
Do not smear, insult, vilify, bait, maliciously caricature, or give disrespectful nicknames to any groups of people that are part of the Democratic coalition, or that hold viewpoints commonly held by Democrats, or that support particular Democratic public figures. Do not imply that they are fake Democrats, fake progressives, conservatives, right-wingers, Republicans, or the like.
Why we have this rule: Substantive disagreement on important issues is always welcome on this website, but our members should not be made to feel unwelcome simply because they hold a different point of view. Democratic Underground welcomes all people who are members of the Democratic coalition, including the full range of center-to-left viewpoints and supporters of all Democratic public figures.
*********
The personal attacks against Thom clearly violate the above guidelines and I look forward to DU administrators enforcing the common sense guidelines to promote civility and help bring about a stronger Democratic party.
boston bean
(36,951 posts)Freethinker65
(11,203 posts)George II
(67,782 posts)NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)alcibiades_mystery
(36,437 posts)R B Garr
(18,073 posts)Blue_true
(31,261 posts)Me.
(35,454 posts)elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)But more like a repeater. Maybe the Republicans take their marching orders from whatever dip shit shows up on the radio dial but we don't.
scheming daemons
(25,487 posts).....
If Thom doesn't want to get "denigrated", he should quit touting the RT/Sputnik/Zerohedge Putin line.
Freethinker65
(11,203 posts)MrsCoffee
(5,825 posts)NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)
Maven
(10,533 posts)uponit7771
(93,532 posts)obnoxiousdrunk
(3,117 posts)NightWatcher
(39,379 posts)Thom's not a democratic figure that is protected by the TOS here. Your repetitive posts about him are suspicious at best.
HE GETS PAID BY PUTIN'S STATE RUN PROPAGANDA MEDIA. HE'S NO FRIEND OF OURS.
Miles Archer
(23,976 posts)...if I were going to post my thoughts on the subject, you could very well turn around and sue me for plagiarism. We're on the same page here.
I've seen the "what seems like daily" pro-Hartmann posts, and largely ignore them.
I choose to not get my news from RT. End of story.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)... but now that I think about it, I wonder if that person was really joking.
MrsCoffee
(5,825 posts)You are violating the terms yourself right now. You should hop off that high horse and stop putting Hartmann on a pedestal. He is a nobody who collects a check from Putin's propaganda machine.
He is not a Democratic leader, he is merely a public media personality who is open to criticism here. If you want the admins input, you should address that in the ATA forum instead of embarrassing both yourself and him.
moonscape
(5,791 posts)It's getting silly.
Orrex
(67,313 posts)ProfessorGAC
(77,106 posts)Then he got back to really big issues.
berni_mccoy
(23,018 posts)Many of the Hillary Supporters focus on that. However, once Hillary won the Primary, Thom supported her. He was even supporting her before the primary was over, so not sure why there is so much hate here for him.
Thom has also been a long-time member of DU. So attacks against him could be considered uncivil attacks against other DUers.
boston bean
(36,951 posts)berni_mccoy
(23,018 posts)Thom's show is syndicated and RT is one of the channels. Trying to imply he's in cahoots with the Russians against Hillary is FUD.
Weekend Warrior
(1,301 posts)Hekate
(100,133 posts)R B Garr
(18,073 posts)There is no coming back from that.
pnwmom
(110,313 posts)And I'm sure I wasn't the only one.
Thom has a choice. He doesn't have to sell his syndicated show to RT, but he does. He's lending his name and viewership to RT.
Plucketeer
(12,882 posts)This would explain A LOT! I never have put two 'n two twogether! See, every time I listen to Thom, I have this intense craving for a bowl of Borscht and a bottle of cheap vodka. DAMN you, Thom Hartmann! Wonder how often Putin dials him up to give instructions?
DU is eating itself. The reason I once found here has turned to a Jim Jones mindset. You'll forgive me if I pass on that cup of kool-ade.
PatSeg
(53,360 posts)I started listening to his radio show years ago and found him to be intelligent and reasonable. I just wish he would separate himself from RT. He is still a great progressive voice, but I will not watch RT.
nini
(16,832 posts)ANYONE who is sympathetic to anything Russian right now after recent events is suspect to me
burrowowl
(18,494 posts)Adrahil
(13,340 posts)I do give a shit that he is willing to take Putin's paycheck. And if I get hidden for that, then there is something very wrong.
berni_mccoy
(23,018 posts)the DNC has as little hope as the GOP.
Adrahil
(13,340 posts)FFS man, the whole purpose of RT is manipulate US opinion to Moscow's advantage? RT America is NOT a private Russian venture, it's a Russian government propaganda tool. Can you not see it?
JHan
(10,173 posts)muriel_volestrangler
(106,476 posts)which will be why they boast about winning awards for it:
https://www.rt.com/about-us/press-releases/annual-telly-awards-winners/
And why "RT" appears in the user name used for it on YouTube. And why 'RT' and its chyron are on all the YouTube videos of it.
It seems ironic for someone with a signature depicting Trump as a Russian to be complaining about people pointing out Hartmann's business relationship with the Russian state TV company.
emulatorloo
(46,155 posts)because it isn't good for his reputation.
I've been giving him solid recommendations about how to produce the show inexpensively with great production values. And recommended alternative ways to distribute such as YouTube. That's been very successful for the TYT and would no doubt be successful for Thom.
Of course, Thom's intern never replies. (Does not reply to any DU'er btw)
Your theory is incorrect and non-factual, and smearing your fellow DU'ers the way you've done is uncivil. You're also refighting the primary in the very worst way. I supporter Bernie in the primary so your assertions are way off base.
Response to Akamai (Original post)
Post removed
karynnj
(61,063 posts)He has a radio show, leans left, but radio personalities aRe NOT our leaders.
tazkcmo
(7,419 posts)And I didn't even know he was a candidate for something! Gratz Thom! Your first legaslative item should be to join us little people and drop the "h". The optics scream "entitled"!
MineralMan
(151,478 posts)Maybe I'm wrong, though.
MrsCoffee
(5,825 posts)Fla Dem
(27,737 posts)Stop telling DU'ers what they can and cannot do. I personally do not like TH. I think he is an egotistical showman whose main mission in life is selling his books and proving how intelligent he is. I do not like that he's broadcasting on RT. Doesn't matter if he is paying them for the air time, or they are paying him. RT is a Russian propaganda outlet and his presence only enhances their credibility.
Maybe if you'd stop bringing the subject up, people would stop making comments about him. Since Monday you've made over 20 posts about TH. I would call that obsessive and provocative.
But in the end, people get to make their own decisions on who they like or dislike.
MineralMan
(151,478 posts)and this thread has to do with moderation, perhaps it would be better posted in the Ask the Adminstrators forum. I'm sure they'll have an answer for you in due time.
Akamai
(1,779 posts)I didn't know that should have been the first step.
FSogol
(47,650 posts)MineralMan
(151,478 posts)Akamai
(1,779 posts)forum and also to the administrators.
The vilification of Bernie Sanders lasted far too long and disheartened many of his supporters while emboldening his detractors.
Fresh_Start
(11,366 posts)while emboldening her detractors AND resulted in the election of Donald Trump.
mcar
(46,253 posts)Hekate
(100,133 posts)He just got FFRd. Just a little vacay to cool off.
Now about those people demanding a military coup d'etat in the US...
MineralMan
(151,478 posts)Too many removed posts, I guess.
leftynyc
(26,060 posts)doesn't mean the rest of us agree.
berni_mccoy
(23,018 posts)Cary
(11,746 posts)leftynyc
(26,060 posts)98% of Democrats never heard of him. And plenty of the rest don't respect anyone paid by RT. Sell it to someone who cares.
Foamfollower
(1,097 posts)Fuck Russian propagandists like Hartmann.
Squinch
(59,967 posts)pnwmom
(110,313 posts)BannonsLiver
(20,770 posts)I feel like someone is trying to sell me life insurance or a time share. It's quite bizarre.
leftynyc
(26,060 posts)anyone who collects a check from RT is beyond me. He's discredited himself and to call someone who more than 95% of Democrats never heard of a leader is imbecilic.
Hekate
(100,133 posts)PragmaticLiberal
(932 posts)We get it. You like/respect Thom. Nothing wrong with that.
Obviously, some people disagree with you...and THAT'S OK too.
No need to create thread after thread basically repeating yourself.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)(And I'll just leave it at that.)
bluepen
(620 posts)Akamai
(1,779 posts)unsupported attacks on his character. Sure reminds me of the earlier attacks on Bernie Sanders, some of which the DU administrators here said were also inappropriate.
George II
(67,782 posts)kacekwl
(9,233 posts)are attacking his character. I don't get all the grief regarding Hartmann. I listen to him about 45 min a day and have for about 6-7 years and don't recall a time he was "shilling" for Russia. Don't always agree with him but so what.
Squinch
(59,967 posts)from Putin.
George II
(67,782 posts)kacekwl
(9,233 posts)above. Not only character attacks but questioning his patriotism. I still don't get it.
uponit7771
(93,532 posts)Funtatlaguy
(11,887 posts)Is it correct that his show is carried on RT?
But, that is just one media outlet where it is carried, correct?
Have people noticed a change in the show since it started airing on RT?
berni_mccoy
(23,018 posts)and was on RT for more than a year before the election. No one complained about this when Thom shifted his support for Hillary even before the Primary was over.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)The full extent, and consequences of Russian election tampering and coordinating with the Trump campaign wasn't yet obvious. At that point in time, RT was just a joke... a punch-line... a gadfly. We rolled our eyes and chuckled at Hartmann... wondering what he was thinking, why the lack of judgement, why the low standards, etc.
The "attack on Thom" isn't BS... but the defense certainly is.
berni_mccoy
(23,018 posts)Maybe you'll dig all the way to Russia.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)
berni_mccoy
(23,018 posts)
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)
BannonsLiver
(20,770 posts)uponit7771
(93,532 posts)... elections
SunSeeker
(58,358 posts)Coventina
(29,865 posts)ETA: Dupe.
dembotoz
(16,922 posts)Maybe we need an emoticon for circular firing squad
Du sure loves to do it
FSogol
(47,650 posts)Thom Hartman isn't a Democratic Leader or even a credible pundit.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)... or before he even posts another one of these divisive threads. That user may or may not be allowed to return, but for now, it appears that someone has been sent to stand the corner to think about what they've done.

FSogol
(47,650 posts)Bradshaw3
(7,964 posts)how it is you know this. Is there a list or something where this info is published?
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)Each user has a visible public "profile" page.
Bradshaw3
(7,964 posts)Maven
(10,533 posts)It's not going to happen
dawg
(10,777 posts)DemocratSinceBirth
(101,975 posts)leftstreet
(41,171 posts)Squinch
(59,967 posts)hatrack
(65,040 posts)Which is pretty much required if you're branding yourself as a "Democratic leader".
get the red out
(14,064 posts)Isn't denigrating him.
Foamfollower
(1,097 posts)Please, just stop this nonsense support of a Putin Puppet on this Democratic site.
BainsBane
(57,775 posts)What an absurd claim.
Response to BainsBane (Reply #56)
Post removed
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)
LanternWaste
(37,748 posts)"Seems pretty clear to me..."
The unashamed worship of sacred cows are pretty clear as well. However, I completely understand our biases will often do their utmost to defend these cows from criticism, and pretend that criticism is against the rules.
BainsBane
(57,775 posts)He's one man. How do you not know the difference between one man and a group?
Your admiration for autocracy is touching, but we are still trying to maintain a democratic system in this country. Yes, it's a struggle, but hell will freeze over before I put any one person, no matter how wealthy or popular, above the rights of citizens, and there is absolutely nothing in TOS that enforces obedience to the media.
This is fucking bizarre.
DesertRat
(27,995 posts)Cary
(11,746 posts)I was totally unaware that he was on Putin's payroll.
Sunlight is the best disinfectant.
Historic NY
(40,112 posts)he toots his own horn on RT to make a living.
OnDoutside
(20,868 posts)This isn't difficult.
Let Hartmann leave RT and apologise for being associated with the Enemy of the USA, then you can have the conversation.
nini
(16,832 posts)We've definitely moved into total bizarro world.
OnDoutside
(20,868 posts)stevenleser
(32,886 posts)I'm most curious to hear this since folks who tend to be fans of Tom are folks who have tended to attack me.
BainsBane
(57,775 posts)You're just not measuring up.
stevenleser
(32,886 posts)mcar
(46,253 posts)Really good question. I eagerly await the responses.
BannonsLiver
(20,770 posts)R B Garr
(18,073 posts)Scruffy1
(3,540 posts)He is not a leader, but a radio guy. He makes his living selling books and advertising on his shows. this is all fine with me and I don't care if he works with RT, after all he wants to make a living. The real leaders are the people who volunteer to do the phone calls andd the canvasses. The ones who talk to their friends and neighbors and are respected in their community. Everyone is looking for a quick cure for Democratic failure. There is no panancea. it will happen one vote at a time. House by house, block by block, city by city, county by county and state by state. People like Hartmann are only preaching to the choir anyhow.
BainsBane
(57,775 posts)nini
(16,832 posts)Really?????
Is Stephanie Miller ad Democratic LEADER too? We must have different understandings of the word Leader
Damn..this one is quite the stretch.
betsuni
(29,214 posts)We certainly don't want to make our sides weaker.
Though Shalt not Take thy Rodent's name in vain!
Adrahil
(13,340 posts)Stop making excuses for this dope. He is willing to take that Russian paycheck after all they have done and are doing to fuck us over. WTF is wrong with him?
judesedit
(4,600 posts)working you up, keeping you distracted. We have to stick together on the important things if we want to accomplish anything. Just like the election was stolen under our noses because we were busy listening to bullshit. Use your time and energy to stick to the issues that need fixing. Treat the information you get from any source as a clue to help you get more information to use to help us get out of this very real American tragedy that's happening right now. You know what they say about opinions. Please ignore the negative comments, stay focused, and stick together. We have a duty to make things right for the future of our children/grandchildren, this country and the world. Thank you very much.
Iggo
(50,015 posts)No.
Binkie The Clown
(7,911 posts)will be met by a flood of replies speaking ill of fellow progressives.
Some people, (like Trump, for example) can't resist the opportunity to tell somebody else they are wrong.
But then, I suppose that's what the Internet is really all about, isn't it? People telling each other they are wrong.
Fresh_Start
(11,366 posts)is actually saying don't speak ill of my favored progressives while not recognizing that those favored progressives are speaking ill of other progressives or the poster conveniently doesn't recognize other democratic leaders as progressives as equally deserving of 'don't speak ill of'
Blue Ridge Virginia
(26 posts)to which the rest of us must be subjected forever and a day. Added a couple dozen to the ignore list thanks to this thread.
ucrdem
(15,720 posts)Bradical79
(4,490 posts)And they attacked our country and party directly. Don't tell peoole on a Democratic party forum that such a person is a Democratic leader. Really he would mostly fly under the radar if you didn't force him into every single thread you post in. You're intentionally baiting and disrupting conversation trying to get people to watch a Russian propaganda channel.
If you think responding to your dishonest posts promoting a man supporting Russian propaganda is a violation of the TOS, then take it up with them directly. There's an entire sub-forum for that. Otherwise you're violating the TOS yourself.
MadCrow
(155 posts)I have followed Thom Hartmann for years because he was the only figure on the radio that had views similar to my own. It was through his program that I first became aware of Bernie Sanders. I find Thom to be an intelligent and excellent spokesman for the overall Democratic point of view. During the entire campaign he did not denigrate Hillary.although he was openly for Bernie as was I. This divisiveness will cause hard feelings within DU and the Democratic Party. It is past time to move on, and look to the future. Much more of this intercinine fighting and I for one will find another forum that is more inclusive to my sentiments and probably to many others as well.
LongTomH
(8,636 posts)I follow Thom Hartmann here and on YouTube. I usually find myself in agreement with his views; but, then I'm a 'leftie.'
Squinch
(59,967 posts)with the best interests of the US at heart.
This isn't divisiveness. Anyone with a brain mistrusts Russia Times at this point. Why doesn't Thom?
LexVegas
(6,961 posts)Weekend Warrior
(1,301 posts)giving legitimacy to Russian State Run Media.
Dr Hobbitstein
(6,568 posts)
Also, fuck Thom Hartman.
MineralMan
(151,478 posts)at this time.
emulatorloo
(46,155 posts)"If we unfairly denigrate Democratic leaders, such as Katy Perry" something something something

JHB
(38,289 posts)...I'm a little perplexed as to how he can be characterized as a party leader.
Weekend Warrior
(1,301 posts)The Polack MSgt
(13,816 posts)I wanna wash my eyes out now.
Reading that thread with the knowledge of what August 2017 looks like, I honestly shook with anger.
Weekend Warrior
(1,301 posts)I didn't have much of a reference point so did a search. What a transformation this place seems to have made. Not when it comes to Thom but to posters in general.
R B Garr
(18,073 posts)was harvesting, and that is what Hartmann provided. Now look what we have.
Gothmog
(181,261 posts)The Russians are not our friends and RT is an arm of the Russian govt. I do not want to rely on sources that are controlled or related to the Russian government
Squinch
(59,967 posts)If he wants to be trusted, he should find another outlet.
The end.
JustAnotherGen
(38,087 posts)from his wiki:
He's never held office.
He's not running for office as a Democratic.
Also from his wiki:
Why doesn't he describe himself as a member of the Democratic Party?
emulatorloo
(46,155 posts)But even if it did, constructive criticism is encouraged here. There are no sacred cows on DU. Nor is DU a fan club.
Bottom line endless posts of yours are nothing but Flamebait designed to get DU's progressive members at each other's throats over meaningless stupidity. You've got your recs and lots of attention. Time to knock it off.
pnwmom
(110,313 posts)Lee-Lee
(6,324 posts)It is what leaders do.
Political punditry and infotainment is not leadership.
hrmjustin
(71,265 posts)Stand and Fight
(7,520 posts)burrowowl
(18,494 posts)I am tired of senseless attacks against Thom, Bernie, Harris, etc.