Republican Medicare plan would be a gamble
This discussion thread was locked as off-topic by Rhiannon12866 (a host of the Latest Breaking News forum).
Source: LA Times
WASHINGTON — While Mitt Romney and Paul D. Ryan are campaigning on a promise to "preserve and protect" Medicare, their proposal to revamp the popular government health insurance program would be the plan's biggest gamble since it was created nearly half a century ago.
The members of the Republican presidential ticket argue that giving seniors vouchers to shop for a private insurance plan would spark competition among health insurers, holding down costs and ensuring the long-term viability of Medicare.
But several previous experiments with privatizing Medicare insurance coverage have ended up raising costs to taxpayers. And on the other side, there is little evidence that moving millions of elderly and disabled patients into commercial health plans will protect their coverage or tame the nation's skyrocketing healthcare tab.
"Doubling down on private insurers is a risky proposition," said University of North Carolina health policy professor Jonathan Oberlander, a leading Medicare historian. "Medicare has lost money on private plans for a long time."
Read more: http://www.latimes.com/health/la-na-medicare-20120819,0,7076443.story
This is a nice, though relatively rare article, that actually addesses the substances of Romney/Ryan's attacks and their proposed plans to turn Medicare into a voucher system in order to "save it" in a classic we needed to burn the village down in order to save it strategy. The article has a nice graphic illustrating the impact of Romney/Ryan's plan:
http://www.trbimg.com/img-503041fe/turbine/la-na-medicare-20120818-g/950
Finally, the article notes that by restoring the spending that was cut, Romney and Ryan would open a large deficit in Medicare, pushing the program's main trust fund into the red in just four years, rather than 12 under Obama's plan.
= new reply since forum marked as read
So much for the 'Protect & Strengthen' Medicare sign Paul Ryan stood behind in The Villages yesterday.
And, shame on Republicans, who use their mothers as props for their stealth efforts to destroy Medicare as a guaranteed benefit.
