Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(129,591 posts)
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 09:58 AM Jun 2022

Omicron booster candidate shows 'superiority' against variant, Moderna says

Source: Washington Post

Preliminary data on Moderna’s omicron-targeting coronavirus vaccine booster candidate showed that the shot gives recipients a “superior” antibody response against the variant, Moderna announced Wednesday, expressing hope that the company can make the new shots available by late summer. The booster candidate, which provided an eightfold rise in immunization against omicron, also increased antibodies against the alpha, beta, gamma and delta variants.

Soon after omicron’s discovery last year, Moderna said it was developing shots specifically designed to fight the variant. Rivals Pfizer and BioNTech announced the same. In April, Moderna released data that showed a booster shot that the company began working on in February 2021, tailored to fight the original version of the virus and the beta variant, increased the level of virus-blocking antibodies against several variants, including omicron, better than a regular booster.

Data from the recent clinical trial, which involved 437 participants, showed that Moderna’s omicron-targeting booster would probably provide longer protection against variants a month after administration when compared with earlier versions of its coronavirus vaccine, Moderna said, making it the company’s “lead candidate for a Fall 2022 booster.” It will submit the data to regulators in the coming weeks. The booster “was generally well-tolerated,” with side effects comparable to earlier boosters, the company said.

New daily coronavirus infections are slowly climbing in the United States. The country recorded a 38 percent uptick in new cases during the past week, according to figures compiled by The Washington Post, as protection from booster shots and previous infections wanes and as more people go about their lives without masks.

Read more: https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2022/06/08/moderna-booster-omicron-coronavirus-trial/



I had my 2nd booster of Moderna on May 12 (about 6 months after my first one November 15, 2021), where I was trying to time it for the October/November 2022 time frame (as a "5/6-month" boost), with the hope that a new booster would be ready by then.

I will say that the 2nd Moderna booster that I got surprisingly elicited zero side effects - i.e., it was like when I have gotten annual flu shots. I guess my body was like yeah...yeah...yeah...whatever...

17 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

Hugin

(33,222 posts)
1. It will be good to have in the Fall.
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 10:33 AM
Jun 2022

My reaction to my fourth booster was interesting.

Some things were absent that I observed in the initial two shots of the m-RNA vaccines and others were consistent with any vaccination (flu, etc) I've received over the last dozen years.

So, I guess that indicates I'm gradually building up an immunity to that particular virus and adapting to the m-RNA vaccines. It is difficult to make any personal conclusions because I did switch brands.

progree

(10,920 posts)
3. What does 8 fold rise in immunization mean? ... and ugh, looks like case levels rising again
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 10:54 AM
Jun 2022
The booster candidate, which provided an eightfold rise in immunization against omicron, also increased antibodies against the alpha, beta, gamma and delta variants.


What does 8 fold rise in immunization mean? That I can go to 8 times as many crowded bars before catching Covid? Or does it increase antibodies level 8-fold and compared to what?

Data from the recent clinical trial, which involved 437 participants, showed that Moderna’s omicron-targeting booster would probably provide longer protection against variants a month after administration when compared with earlier versions of its coronavirus vaccine, Moderna said,


That's a pretty weak statement, kind of almost at odds with the wundervax that it sounds like in the first paragraph.

New daily coronavirus infections are slowly climbing in the United States.


I was going to contest that one, like I did yesterday, but just now I went over to the NY Times site (which has the wonderful "Last 90 days" button)
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/us/covid-cases.html

and egads, its right according to the NYT data (yes yes everybody I know, it doesn't count at-home tests which have been an increasing share of all tests and blah blah. And yes I know that the smartest people in the room tell us case levels don't matter any more)

The 7 day case average had a local mini-peak of 110,614 on May 25, then it went down a bit, then went flat. Well, the last 2 days show a rise of the 7 day average to 112,771, the highest level since February 17, when it was coming down from the winter super-peak (803,730 on January 14).

The 14 day new cases average is up 4% (comparing 7 day average ending June 7 to the 7 day average ending May 24).

14 day average up 12% for hospitalization and 13% for ICUs, reflecting, at a lag, the case rises that had been occurring for 2 months before May 25.

14 day average deaths down 2% .

BumRushDaShow

(129,591 posts)
7. I was trying to do a quick search to find their data submissions
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 11:37 AM
Jun 2022

and found a link for a pre-print in an earlier article from April - https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-1555201/v1

I went through 50+ pages of data but found a graph that might be showing this visually but my brain is fried this morning so I haven't actually calculated anything using it yet...



Each quadrant in the above represents a variant - the "original" ( "Wuhan" ), the "Beta", the "Omicron", and the "Delta" (and as a note, "Beta" never really took hold here in the U.S., the first big variant after the original was "Alpha", which was also prevalent in Europe).

For each bar graph in a quadrant, there are 6 bars and the first 3 bars for each graph (which are plots over time), represent the results using the original vax entity (mRNA-1273) and the second 3 represent (again over time), the results from the new "Omicron-specific" entity (mRNA-1273.211). The time plots are for 0 months, about 1 month, and the "181" days is just about 26 weeks or 6 months.

So I think that "8-fold" reference may be how much better the new vax entity protects against Omicron compared to the original.

progree

(10,920 posts)
10. Thanks much for putting this together.
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 12:09 PM
Jun 2022

I looked up the word "titer" and it means concentration.
Looking at the Omicron Variant graph

.................... MRNA-1273 mRNA-1273.211
Prebooster ........... 38 ......... 38
Day 29 ............ 529 ......... 1408
Day 181 ............146 ......... 317



Day 29
So just taking MRNA-1273, the original Moderna, the antibody concentration increased 13.9 fold by day 29 (edit: correction made)

Whereas with mRNA-1273.211 it increased 37 fold by day 29 -- to a level 2.67 times that of MRNA-1273

Day 181
So just taking MRNA-1273, the original Moderna, the antibody concentration increased 3.8 fold by day 181

Whereas with mRNA-1273.211 it increased 8.34 fold by day 181 -- to a level 2.17 times that of MRNA-1273

I bold-faced the "8.34" since it matches 8 fold when rounded... Then I bold-faced 3.8 fold above since its the comparable number for original Moderna.

In sum, at day 181, original Moderna increased the antibody concentration 3.8 fold while the new Moderna increased it by 8.3 fold. It seems to me to be saying?

BumRushDaShow

(129,591 posts)
13. Thank you because although it would be easy to do some subtraction and division
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 12:38 PM
Jun 2022

to get the delta between vaccine entities, just scrolling through those pre-print pages of data looking for some kind of chart or graph, caused my brain to do this --

I think the graph showed up around pg 53 out of 55 or something

And yes, I believe those values for the titer are the quantity of antibodies per unit/volume (could be per ?l or whatever).

In sum, at day 181, original Moderna increased the antibody concentration 3.8 fold while the new Moderna increased it by 8.3 fold. It seems to me to be saying?


I think they are just comparing the Day 181 (for your purposes of picking that date point) using mRNA-1273 to Day 181 using mRNA-1273.211 (the latter being the new one, and doing that across 4 different variants).

BumRushDaShow

(129,591 posts)
14. This is preliminary - they haven't released this "bivalent" vaccine yet but I expect by the fall.
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 12:42 PM
Jun 2022

Will be monitoring for if/when it gets approved!

tavernier

(12,407 posts)
11. Same
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 12:13 PM
Jun 2022

I’m glad I started and ended with Moderna because I’m the only person that I personally know that hasn’t been sick with one of the variants.

BumRushDaShow

(129,591 posts)
15. Both Pfizer and Moderna have been working on combo shots
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 12:47 PM
Jun 2022

using a traditional platform flu + mRNA COVID combo and having a mRNA flu and mRNA COVID combo, and neither have been ready to go with those yet... but I think were looking at 2023 (probably because they have been focusing on children and then variant-specific types the past year).

bullimiami

(13,105 posts)
16. I delayed my 2nd Pfizer hoping they would release the update. Went ahead anyway.
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 03:07 PM
Jun 2022

4x Pfizer. Only side effect was a sore arm.

salin

(48,955 posts)
17. I had 3 phizers (2 plus boosts), and asked my dr
Wed Jun 8, 2022, 03:14 PM
Jun 2022

at an appointment if I should get moderna for booster two (when boosters first rolled out, there was a lot of talk about the possible value of having had both Mrna type of shots, but after that, not much discussion.) She said - we have it here, why don't you get it now? So 4th boost, unplanned, with Moderna. No side effects. Just in time for the Omicron varient to escalate regionally. And so far, no covid.

Am glad to hear a more targeted (to the omicron varients) is moving along well. Maybe in time for the next shot in the fall.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Omicron booster candidate...