Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
New Yorker: If Trump Goes Even Lower, We'd Better Be Prepared
If Trump Goes Even Lower, Wed Better Be PreparedThe New Yorker, by Bill McKibben, 6/3/2020
What Id like to talk about is civil disobedience, and its uses in authoritarian states. Im not talking about whats going on in this country this weekI have no more interest in telling people currently in the streets that they shouldnt be destroying property than they have in listening to me. If you live a life, as black Americans clearly do, in which a police officer could kill you for allegedly passing a counterfeit twenty-dollar bill, or if you live a life in which the incompetence of the nations leaders has helped precipitate an economic crisis that has left you with no job and no prospect of onewell, Ive been impressed with how peaceful the vast majority of the people in the streets have been. In fact, Tuesday night may turn out to have been significant. Unintimidated by Trumps heavy-handedness and local curfews, lots of people once again took to the streets, and a frequent chantWhy you got your riot gear? We dont see no riot herewas both a powerful taunt and accurate reporting.
What Im talking about is what happens if Trump, indeed, goes further still, and manages to make himself a full-on tyrant. It wouldnt take much. The Justice Department seems to have become his Justice Department. Congressional Republicans seem unwilling to stand up to him about anything; and, at the moment, some of them, such as Senator Tom Cotton and Representative Matt Gaetz, are egging him on. The courts are ever more packed, and the Pentagon seemed willing to funnel troops and materiel to D.C., then participate in Trumps political stunt on Monday, which is a bad sign. The Presidents constant shout-outs to the Second Amendment people are not a dog whistletheyre a clarion call. Even as Trump keeps escalating, one keeps hoping that hes merely trying to impress his basebut as we near an election in which he trails in the polls, the danger seems to mount. Its hard to know what, precisely, a coup looks like if the leader is already the President. Try to imagine troops ordered to use live rounds rather than rubber bullets, no social media on which to talk about it, and Fox News as the only sanctioned TV channel.
It seems a stretch, but such things are commonplace in many parts of the world. (Indeed, if youre black, facing live ammunition is already an outsize reality here.) If they came to pass, Americans would be in a difficult predicament: whether to submit to that rule or stand up to it. And thats where civil resistance comes in. Ive spent much of my adult life organizing a certain kind of nonviolent actionIve been in handcuffs more times than I might have imaginedand its had some real effect on the paths of pipelines and the flow of money. (As it happens, the first big civil-disobedience actions I helped organize were staged from Lafayette Park, the same place that Trump cleared for his photo-op stroll.) But the kind of civil disobedience that I know how to practice happens in the relatively open society that weve been living in (and is much harder for people of color). Other people in other places have worked with far less freedom, and accomplished far moreand their faithful chronicler was a man named Gene Sharp, who died two winters ago, at the age of ninety. I first wrote about him for this magazine thirty-six years ago, when he was already well into his lifes work of cataloguing and explaining all the methods of nonviolent action that people had used to stand up to authority.
What Im talking about is what happens if Trump, indeed, goes further still, and manages to make himself a full-on tyrant. It wouldnt take much. The Justice Department seems to have become his Justice Department. Congressional Republicans seem unwilling to stand up to him about anything; and, at the moment, some of them, such as Senator Tom Cotton and Representative Matt Gaetz, are egging him on. The courts are ever more packed, and the Pentagon seemed willing to funnel troops and materiel to D.C., then participate in Trumps political stunt on Monday, which is a bad sign. The Presidents constant shout-outs to the Second Amendment people are not a dog whistletheyre a clarion call. Even as Trump keeps escalating, one keeps hoping that hes merely trying to impress his basebut as we near an election in which he trails in the polls, the danger seems to mount. Its hard to know what, precisely, a coup looks like if the leader is already the President. Try to imagine troops ordered to use live rounds rather than rubber bullets, no social media on which to talk about it, and Fox News as the only sanctioned TV channel.
It seems a stretch, but such things are commonplace in many parts of the world. (Indeed, if youre black, facing live ammunition is already an outsize reality here.) If they came to pass, Americans would be in a difficult predicament: whether to submit to that rule or stand up to it. And thats where civil resistance comes in. Ive spent much of my adult life organizing a certain kind of nonviolent actionIve been in handcuffs more times than I might have imaginedand its had some real effect on the paths of pipelines and the flow of money. (As it happens, the first big civil-disobedience actions I helped organize were staged from Lafayette Park, the same place that Trump cleared for his photo-op stroll.) But the kind of civil disobedience that I know how to practice happens in the relatively open society that weve been living in (and is much harder for people of color). Other people in other places have worked with far less freedom, and accomplished far moreand their faithful chronicler was a man named Gene Sharp, who died two winters ago, at the age of ninety. I first wrote about him for this magazine thirty-six years ago, when he was already well into his lifes work of cataloguing and explaining all the methods of nonviolent action that people had used to stand up to authority.
More
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
4 replies, 2197 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (40)
ReplyReply to this post
4 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
New Yorker: If Trump Goes Even Lower, We'd Better Be Prepared (Original Post)
teach1st
Jun 2020
OP
C_U_L8R
(44,987 posts)1. When. Not if.
And it will be tomorrow if not today.
DinahMoeHum
(21,774 posts)2. The list of actions, per the article. . .
teach1st
(5,932 posts)3. Thanks, DinahMoeHum! N/T
Solly Mack
(90,758 posts)4. K&R