The difference? Biden returned files willingly
By Noah Feldman / Bloomberg Opinion
We still dont know a lot of important facts about President Bidens retention of classified documents at his Penn-Biden center office and Delaware home. For that matter, theres a lot we still dont know about former president Donald Trumps retention of classified documents at Mar-a-Lago. What is certain is the legal concept that prosecutors will have to use to determine whether to prosecute either president: intent.
The relevant provision of the Espionage Act is fairly clear. Its a crime if you both willfully retain classified documents and also fail to deliver them on demand to the government official entitled to receive them.
The adverb willfully is standard legal language, a close cousin to knowingly. To act willfully, in the legal sense, is to act intentionally, consciously and voluntarily. As the Department of Justice has put it, relying on judicial interpretation of statutes, An act is done willfully if done voluntarily and intentionally and with the specific intent to do something the law forbids.
In practice, this requirement of willfulness could very well mean that Trump committed a crime with respect to the classified material he retained, while Biden did not. Consider that Trump, through representatives, allegedly refused for months to return more than 30 boxes of documents sought by the National Archives; a refusal that eventually prompted the FBI to show up at Mar-a-Lago and seize the material. That refusal sounds very much like it matches the language of the Espionage Act, which requires both unauthorized retention of classified documents and the refusal to hand them over.
https://www.heraldnet.com/opinion/comment-the-difference-biden-returned-files-willingly/
bullimiami
(13,105 posts)law to the letter and the intent of the law better describes.
hildegaard28
(391 posts)don't understand why the FBI hasn't raided all of his properties. His assistant testified that he was ordered by Trump to move them. And he did so. Every Trump property needs to be torn to shreds to search for those documents.