Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

fizzgig

(24,146 posts)
Tue May 14, 2013, 01:30 AM May 2013

Star Trek’s History of Progressive Values — And Why It Faltered on LGBT Crew Members

In 2009, director J.J. Abrams transformed Star Trek into a true mainstream hit with his blockbuster movie reboot, earning $385 in worldwide box office and shattered the opening weekend IMAX record; with Star Trek Into Darkness about to hit theaters this Friday, he seems poised to do it again.

But long before the 47-year-old franchise was breaking box office records, it was breaking ground as one of the most forward-thinking franchises in television and film history. Thanks largely to the (at the time) radical philosophy of creator Gene Roddenberry, the show attracted audiences with its adventure stories, but it kept them with its utopian optimism: the idea that the raging intolerance of the day would someday become a thing of the past, and anyone could explore the stars if they wanted.

In the future, Roddenberry envisioned race and gender as non-issues. He put Japanese-American George Takei, as Lt. Hikaru Sulu, at the helm; African-American Nichelle Nichols, as Lt. Nyota Uhura, in the communications chair; and even attempted to make the Enterprise’s first officer a woman (studio executives rejected that unsavory idea, so the alien Spock took the job). The equality on the U.S.S. Enterprise’s bridge was a watershed moment, both in television history and in Americans’ understanding of social equality.

“Most television shows, at best, follow cultural trends. Star Trek had clear-cut ideals of its own,” wrote Joan Winston, Jacqueline Lichtenberg and Sondra Marshak in their 1975 book Star Trek Lives!, the first and most definitive chronicle of the early years of Trek fandom. “No one would claim that Star Trek was the cause of all the improvement [we've made with problems like racism and sexism]. But it is still harder to believe that it had no effect, when twenty million people tuned in to Star Trek and saw Mr. Spock being treated as friend and brother by Captain Kirk, saw the black and the Russian and the Oriental [sic] and the Southerner and the others treating each other with respect and love.”


from wired

cross posted in lgbt
30 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Star Trek’s History of Progressive Values — And Why It Faltered on LGBT Crew Members (Original Post) fizzgig May 2013 OP
Long read, but well worth it! Behind the Aegis May 2013 #1
Of course, the crew member in the red shirt, no matter what his race, always MADem May 2013 #2
yup fizzgig May 2013 #3
Yeah, whatever. Megalo_Man May 2013 #4
Care to elaborate? Behind the Aegis May 2013 #5
I seem to recall a lesbian scene.. AsahinaKimi May 2013 #18
I agree, it's out-dated, though to be fair they wrote that in 1975. arcane1 May 2013 #26
remember when Kirk's brain was swapped with a woman's brain Skittles May 2013 #6
The philosophy that dare not speak its name in US media- cprise May 2013 #7
By TNG and the movies, I started to get the definite impression that Klingons were black yurbud May 2013 #13
The impression I got was Klingons were like Vikings cprise May 2013 #15
the original series Klingons were more like Arabs yurbud May 2013 #16
I am a BIG I Love Lucy fan FunkyLeprechaun May 2013 #8
I had no idea dsc May 2013 #12
Extensive Roddenberry interview cprise May 2013 #9
Sexuality of crew members wasn't really a subject of exploration mainer May 2013 #10
It mostly certainly has been in the many incarnations since the original. Behind the Aegis May 2013 #11
Not a single gay character? AsahinaKimi May 2013 #19
That doesn't sound like a gay character. Behind the Aegis May 2013 #20
so that kiss was a transgender kiss on tv? AsahinaKimi May 2013 #21
You don't seem to understand sexual orientation. Behind the Aegis May 2013 #22
True there have be no RELATIONSHIPS of this manner.. AsahinaKimi May 2013 #23
That was the premise of the entire article and what I was putting forth. Behind the Aegis May 2013 #24
Wow.. you must be tough.. AsahinaKimi May 2013 #25
I am tough. Behind the Aegis May 2013 #29
Just for your information... AsahinaKimi May 2013 #30
Star Trek actually broke ground by showing the least talked about sexual orientation-- yurbud May 2013 #14
Had Roddenberry lived a bit longer, we would have seen the integration. Gormy Cuss May 2013 #17
not to mention... nlomb269 May 2013 #27
and also nlomb269 May 2013 #28
 

Megalo_Man

(88 posts)
4. Yeah, whatever.
Tue May 14, 2013, 03:39 AM
May 2013

Somebody hasn't watched TNG, DS9, or Voyager if they say that "star trek has failed LGBT."

AsahinaKimi

(20,776 posts)
18. I seem to recall a lesbian scene..
Sun May 19, 2013, 02:40 PM
May 2013

I think it was DAX who kissed another woman on DS9. As for an aside comment, directed at the article, I wish they hadn't used the word Oriental, as its OUT DATED. "Asian" is what we prefer these days.

found it

 

arcane1

(38,613 posts)
26. I agree, it's out-dated, though to be fair they wrote that in 1975.
Sun May 19, 2013, 07:31 PM
May 2013

I'm surprised it's the 47th year of Trek and they aren't commemorating that magic number. Or maybe they are and I missed it

Skittles

(153,111 posts)
6. remember when Kirk's brain was swapped with a woman's brain
Tue May 14, 2013, 05:21 AM
May 2013

he fell apart emotionally and could not handle commanding!!!

cprise

(8,445 posts)
7. The philosophy that dare not speak its name in US media-
Tue May 14, 2013, 05:27 AM
May 2013

Roddenberry was an avowed secular humanist.

Billy Graham used to rail against secular humanism in the 70s and 80s, and apparently the American media are averse to naming it (like "socialism", in America its a term that is mostly reserved for use by conservatives in demonizing people).

--

Speaking as a gay guy, I wasn't disappointed that TNG lacked a regular cast member; I never thought we were populous enough to warrant representation on any particular show (TV and movies in general being another matter). I was more perplexed that Worf and Geordi were obscured by heavy prosthetics... out of an aversion to black males IMHO. The Gennai episode did impress me in how forceful yet equivocal it was, and I was mostly disappointed especially in how a lot of people back then chose to interpret it as a warning against rampant feminism or androgyny.

It was soon after that I realized Hollywood Liberals had bought into ambiguity as an absolute rule when dealing with issues (or worse, using the Liberal label as a cover for making reactionary and authoritarian impressions, such as those on the show COPS). For a long time since the mid-90s, solidly progressive messages were left to cartoons (e.g. The Simpsons).

yurbud

(39,405 posts)
13. By TNG and the movies, I started to get the definite impression that Klingons were black
Thu May 16, 2013, 12:55 PM
May 2013

sort of the way some people thought Ferengi were based on Jewish stereotypes only with big ears instead of big noses.

I half expected to hear rap and black Muslim names along with Klang, Karg, Worf, and the like:

"Shaq! Jamal! Kill the Federation scum!"

yurbud

(39,405 posts)
16. the original series Klingons were more like Arabs
Thu May 16, 2013, 02:01 PM
May 2013

I never watched DS9, so I can't comment on the Bajorans, though their earrings have really caught on.

 

FunkyLeprechaun

(2,383 posts)
8. I am a BIG I Love Lucy fan
Tue May 14, 2013, 06:35 AM
May 2013

and my husband is a borderline Trekkie, I keep reminding him that it was Lucille Ball that approved Star Trek in the first place (she was the only one to give Roddenberry a chance), despite the disapproval of other board members. She was the first female president of a production company, Desilu, at the time.

dsc

(52,152 posts)
12. I had no idea
Tue May 14, 2013, 05:57 PM
May 2013

what an interesting connection. Lucille Ball was every bit the revolutionary as Rodenberry.

mainer

(12,018 posts)
10. Sexuality of crew members wasn't really a subject of exploration
Tue May 14, 2013, 03:38 PM
May 2013

with the exception of Kirk (who was always getting it on with the ladies) and Spock (who had to go through that mating ritual). I don't think we ever learned whether Scotty or Sulu or Chekhov were straight, because it just didn't come up as subject matter. So if they did introduce an LGBT character, might it have required a complete change in focus? Suddenly we'd have to find out about the crew's sexual conduct, which was supposed to be verboten anyway aboard a ship full of professional crew members.

Behind the Aegis

(53,921 posts)
11. It mostly certainly has been in the many incarnations since the original.
Tue May 14, 2013, 05:20 PM
May 2013

Data and Tasha Yar. Ricker and Troi (among hundreds of others). Janeway and her husband she left behind. Tom and B'lana Torres. I could go on and on, and among them, not a single gay character. There have been a few episodes with gender changing aliens.

AsahinaKimi

(20,776 posts)
19. Not a single gay character?
Sun May 19, 2013, 02:44 PM
May 2013

Dax had been both male and female in her past. Dax ALSO had a scene where she kissed a woman. I don't recall the episode but I remember reading how pissed off a few people were about it. Mostly Born again Christians.. I thought it was a great scene.


found it

Behind the Aegis

(53,921 posts)
20. That doesn't sound like a gay character.
Sun May 19, 2013, 03:27 PM
May 2013

It could possibly be a transgender character, if one stretches a bit, but not gay, lesbian, or bisexual.

AsahinaKimi

(20,776 posts)
21. so that kiss was a transgender kiss on tv?
Sun May 19, 2013, 03:43 PM
May 2013

There was several episodes I remember in the Star Trek universe where there was woman on women kisses. One with the alternate universe Kira with the Ezri Dax. There was also an episode where an alien was of a third gender, kissing Riker in the Next Generation. This idea has been in Star Trek episodes, though rare I am sure. Still, it was not ignored as you would have everyone believe.

Behind the Aegis

(53,921 posts)
22. You don't seem to understand sexual orientation.
Sun May 19, 2013, 03:47 PM
May 2013

Kissing someone of the same sex, especially the ones you are describing, are not examples of gay and lesbian, or even bisexual characters. They have been completely ignored, despite your valiant efforts to put forth claims they were/are not ignored.

AsahinaKimi

(20,776 posts)
23. True there have be no RELATIONSHIPS of this manner..
Sun May 19, 2013, 03:57 PM
May 2013

But Kissing same gender on Star Trek has happened, and you don't do that unless you are Inclined to.

This episode was where this species that have both male and female parts. Soren wanted to be female.
http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/The_Outcast_%28episode%29

Behind the Aegis

(53,921 posts)
24. That was the premise of the entire article and what I was putting forth.
Sun May 19, 2013, 04:51 PM
May 2013

I completely disagree with your assertion on same-sex kissing; it is no different in many cases than kissing someone of the other gender. I am aware that a few of the "Star Trek"s have addressed, in an "Afterschool Special" type of way has addressed issues of gender. Think of the number of episodes of all the "Star Trek"s combined, it has to be well over a thousand, and not ONE gay, lesbian, or bisexual character...at least not one I can recall, and certainly not a regular.

AsahinaKimi

(20,776 posts)
25. Wow.. you must be tough..
Sun May 19, 2013, 07:25 PM
May 2013

NO...SAME SEX KISSING isn't off the table, just because a person may kiss (maybe someone like) their parents good night...THESE WERE PASSIONATE kisses. You don't do that unless you lean one way or the other..or both ways. I AGREE... THAT Star Trek never showed same sex marriages, or Same Sex couples. Maybe they should have tried harder, except that during this time period, many of the later shows were filmed, it was still difficult to put anything like that on Main Stream Television. Hell, it was probably just as difficult to have it on a Cable Network.

I remember while living here in San Francisco, during the time of these episodes aired, there were still NEWS stories of Gay Bashing in the Castro and on Folsom Street. Not by local people, but from people who were visiting the city, and were drunk or otherwise being hateful.

I wonder how many TV programs that are on today feature a main character that is gay.. and being loving relationship and kissing on Network TV? I don't have a TV so I would wager to guess not that many. During that time period.. (Was it the 80s?) this kind of thing was unheard of on many TV shows. In fact, before that on the original episodes, it was unheard of for a guy like James Kirk to kiss a woman like Uhura simply because she was black. That was the first racial kiss, as I recall hearing.

Maybe STAR TREK, representing the so called future, should have had many things acceptable that we would expect for the future, but Network TV, who had sponsors were not going to allow too much too fast. Shows that tried to push the envelope got shot down eventually because the sponsors were putting their commercials there as their a stamp of approval. No Commercials no air play.

Behind the Aegis

(53,921 posts)
29. I am tough.
Mon May 20, 2013, 01:41 AM
May 2013

I have endured, tolerated, overcome, and battled homophobia for years and years, and continue to do so. I don't know what angle you are going for, and quite frankly, I am starting to assume it is not a good one, so I will stop, but I will say this about your red herring arguments, there are a few gay characters on various shows, more so on cable shows, and given the ground-breaking work "Star Trek" and its franchise did for a number of issues, it is very disappointing it has not done the same for GLB people, which is the premise of the article, and the reason for my agreement with what was contained within it.

AsahinaKimi

(20,776 posts)
30. Just for your information...
Mon May 20, 2013, 06:49 AM
May 2013

I am bi.. not that should matter.. but as a fan of Star Trek..for years..I have loved that the show went as far as it did, during the times it was in. I don't even have a TV or cable and refuse to watch the garbage that is spewed out on television these days.. I don't have an agenda.. but one can imagine how difficult it was .. (I guess it was the 80's)for that kind of thing to be even hinted at on TV. Star Trek has broken a lot of barriers, but I guess some people have a problem with that..because in their mind, they didn't go far enough. I say consider the times... when it was aired. Back then, a show didn't get air time, if no one would would buy a time slot on their show. Later came syndication but still it required still, advertisements on TV to back that show. If a advertiser didn't like what was happening on a TV show, despite the ratings it would die out.

yurbud

(39,405 posts)
14. Star Trek actually broke ground by showing the least talked about sexual orientation--
Thu May 16, 2013, 12:58 PM
May 2013

Asexuality.

They are so far in the closet, I don't even know if any of my best friends are A.

Gormy Cuss

(30,884 posts)
17. Had Roddenberry lived a bit longer, we would have seen the integration.
Thu May 16, 2013, 03:02 PM
May 2013

Last edited Thu May 16, 2013, 05:46 PM - Edit history (1)

It's not necessary to add "sexual conduct" in order to present an LGBT character. Simply incorporating gender references to mates and as Whoopi apparently did, removing gender referencing when generalizing about relationships, would have been enough to establish the sexuality of some bridge characters.

Roddenberry was ready to address it over 20 years ago.

nlomb269

(11 posts)
27. not to mention...
Mon May 20, 2013, 01:30 AM
May 2013

The episode where the aliens with half-white, half black faces...where Frank Gorshin played the security officer after an racial activist, and Kirk says but you're the same! Gorshin replies no the left side of his face is white, and the right is black, and mine is the other way...a truly effective comment on the absurditiy of racism.

nlomb269

(11 posts)
28. and also
Mon May 20, 2013, 01:41 AM
May 2013

I like the one where they waged war by computer, and if you were in the zone of a strike, you had to be painlessly executed - a war without destruction very orderly that had been going on for centuries!

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Editorials & Other Articles»Star Trek’s History of Pr...