The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsWhat is the best tv or movie version of Dicken's "A Christmas Carol"
Asking for a friend.
Adsos Letter
(19,459 posts)And the Muppet one was always a hit around here.
Sinistrous
(4,249 posts)however Patrick Stewart is also magnificent in the role of Scrooge.
Paladin
(28,246 posts)No other version comes close, as far as I'm concerned; we watch it every year.
trc
(823 posts)And, if you watch carefully you will spot a man in dark glasses in the mirror when Scrooge is looking at himself in the morning. I think he is wearing a sport coat and carrying a clip board... but it has been a long time since I watched the film.
pressbox69
(2,252 posts)our favorite too
solara
(3,836 posts)The moment when he realizes he isn't dead after all and starts to giggle..well, that is one of the best acting moments ever..
SoCalMusicLover
(3,194 posts)aka-chmeee
(1,132 posts)As a confused Santa, I always watch "Polar Express" and Alastair Sim's "Scrooge" before my first outing. Polar Express to reinforce my conviction that Santa doesn't have to be a buffoon and Scrooge to set the mood.
(confused is wife's description....Says I look like Santa but act like Scrooge. But what the hell? I'm atheist!)
rurallib
(62,401 posts)JenniferJuniper
(4,510 posts)anyone else is a poser.
stopbush
(24,393 posts)IMO, the George C Scott version is the worst.
GoneOffShore
(17,339 posts)Well, with the exception of the 20th century sound man who shows up in the mirror on Christmas morning.
no_hypocrisy
(46,060 posts)irisblue
(32,950 posts)I love this one.
Lindsay
(3,276 posts)The music is Broadway quality.
I started a tiny business making Christmas ornaments, and called it "Razzleberry Dressing," of course.
Freddie
(9,258 posts)Saw it first when I was a little kid and was not familiar with the story. Mr. Magoo is still the real Christmas Carol for me. And the one with George C. Scott.
Dave Starsky
(5,914 posts)But the 1982 George C. Scott version is right up there, too.
irisblue
(32,950 posts)Phentex
(16,334 posts)Thanks for posting it.
Dave Starsky
(5,914 posts)Is that you can watch it with the little kids in your family and you will ALL love it. The adults in the room get more out of it than the kids do, but everyone benefits, overall.
Kermit the Frog plays Bob Cratchit. And as ridiculous as it sounds, that puppet's performance will break your heart.
muntrv
(14,505 posts)Mz Pip
(27,434 posts)rainy
(6,089 posts)jpak
(41,757 posts)Floyd R. Turbo
(26,546 posts)FSogol
(45,464 posts)Murray totally phoned it in and the director decided that Murry was so funny that he should just ad-lib it.
The late Roger Ebert said it best:
Finally, he demands a miracle, and his secretarys little tyke is dragged forward to demonstrate that he can actually speak at last. Then the entire cast and crew line up behind Murray to sing of Christmas cheer, and I cant remember when Ive seen anything along these lines that was more forced and depressing.
What went wrong here? I have no idea. The chemistry must have been bad from the start. Or perhaps the material was simply intractable. One problem is that Murray frequently interjects one-liners that are at right-angles to the material, blocking the flow of the story. He gives the impression, at those moments, that he is seeking to distance himself from the film, but a story like this works only if it seems to believe in itself.
You cant bad-mouth A Christmas Carol all the way through and then expect us to believe the good cheer at the end. In his studies of Dickens in preparation for this role, Murray seems to have read only as far as Bah! Humbug!
Ebert's entire review here:
https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/scrooged-1988
Floyd R. Turbo
(26,546 posts)FSogol
(45,464 posts)irisblue
(32,950 posts)LanternWaste
(37,748 posts)Scrooge (1970) starring Albert Finney is my favorite.
Paladin
(28,246 posts)Very well done.
Docreed2003
(16,855 posts)Not because I think its the best, although its nostolgic for me because I remember when it aired originally and it seemed like such a big deal as a kid, but because no one else has mentioned it!
FSogol
(45,464 posts)version.
Glorfindel
(9,725 posts)followed closely by "Scrooged" with Bill Murray. The first one I remember seeing was the Alastair Sims version when I was a little boy. That one scared me!
Phoenix61
(16,999 posts)Especially enjoy when he sings "Thank you very much."
50 Shades Of Blue
(9,954 posts)I love Roland Young in anything.
Close second is a tie among the Mr. Magoo, Alistair Sims, and Muppets versions.
NNadir
(33,509 posts)Lovely music, quite beautiful.
As a child, I recorded the songs on a cheap tape recorder (using the microphone held up to the black and white tv speaker) and listened to that tape all year long.
After many decades decades I still remember it.
"Winter was warm, summer soft that year, the winter was warm...
...and all my dreams are there, wrapped up somewhere, in summer dreams..."
pressbox69
(2,252 posts)Jane Kean from the Honeymooners. Jack Cassidy played Cratchit.
mia
(8,360 posts)Storyline
In 1843, the celebrated British novelist, Charles Dickens, is at a low point in his career with three flops behind him and his family expenses piling up at home. Determined to recover, Dickens decides to write a Christmas story and self-publish it in less than two months. As Dickens labors writing on such short notice, his estranged father and mother come to bunk with him. Still haunted by painful memories of his father ruining his childhood by his financial irresponsibly, Dickens develops a writer's block which seems to have no solution. As such, Dickens must face his personal demons epitomized through his characters, especially in his imagined conversations with Ebenezer Scrooge. Now with a looming deadline, Dickens struggles for inspiration against his frustrations and his characters' opinions in a literary challenge creating a classic tale that would define the essential soul of modern Christmas.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt6225520/
FSogol
(45,464 posts)The owner of our local book store helped to make it happen. Hope it's a great success!
https://www.npr.org/2017/11/27/566005492/booksellers-foray-into-hollywood-is-a-dickens-of-a-tale
pressbox69
(2,252 posts)is the best and Magoo is the best musical version. I wish someone would try to turn it into a live staged musical. Part of the reason I love the 1951 version is because my Dad had to watch it every year. He swore that when it was first released, Scrooged bumped down his stairs one at a time on Christmas morning but that scene was cut on TV. I can't find anything about such a scene although I've searched for years. Has anyone else heard of this deleted scene?